Fred Miranda wrote:
I think the off-axis nervousness you refer to is just more DOF towards the corners due to higher optical vignetting. If it's more pleasant around the center area, that means the transition zone is actually smoother compared to the Leica.
I don't know this for sure because I've never tried the 28/2 cron.
I don't think it is as simple as that DoF is deeper with the Ultron in the sides and corners.
Check this comparison of center versus corner rendering of the Ultron II: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1WW1kMTwUafAxRWfn2ztywK9bOxCxyhkU/view
I have de-focused each shot to approximately the same degree of blur, in this case the transition zone, with the subject in the center and corner. Center crops look smooth, corner crops look nervous.
Here we have the Leica and Voigtländer side by side, center and side crops respectively. Focus is at about 12 feet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fuXvi3e6I97nCGKbJOA1xt5HKmg-T_LQ/view
Note that the Ultron has a bit of (regular) field curvature that makes the far background more blurry than the 'cron. I actually think the 'cron has a tiny bit of reverse field curvature, so the difference looks more pronounced. This means that in practice, the background rendering of the Ultron will look like it has a wider aperture than it actually has. When scrutinizing the leaves in the tree, I think the Ultron has some bokeh ball outlining that the 'cron doesn't. However, they aren't equally blurred, so not a definite result.
LarsHP wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI think the off-axis nervousness you refer to is just more DOF towards the corners due to higher optical vignetting. If it's more pleasant around the center area, that means the transition zone is actually smoother compared to the Leica.
I don't know this for sure because I've never tried the 28/2 cron.I don't think it is as simple as that DoF is deeper with the Ultron in the sides and corners.
Check this comparison of center versus corner rendering of the Ultron II: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1WW1kMTwUafAxRWfn2ztywK9bOxCxyhkU/view
I have de-focused each shot to approximately the same degree of blur, in this case the transition zone, with the subject in the center and corner. Center crops look smooth, corner crops look nervous.
Here we have the Leica and Voigtländer side by side, center and side crops respectively. Focus is at about 12 feet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fuXvi3e6I97nCGKbJOA1xt5HKmg-T_LQ/view
Note that the Ultron has a bit of (regular) field curvature that makes the far background more blurry than the 'cron. I actually think the 'cron has a tiny bit of reverse field curvature, so the difference looks more pronounced. This means that in practice, the background rendering of the Ultron will look like it has a wider aperture than it actually has. When scrutinizing the leaves in the tree, I think the Ultron has some bokeh ball outlining that the 'cron doesn't. However, they aren't equally blurred, so not a definite result.
I think you are both right. The corners have increased DOF (as is typical with a lens with high optical vignetting) and I think that is the chief problem, but the I think the lens probably has more astigmatism in the corners (also pretty common) which makes the bokeh a little more nervous in the corners. After having this lens and using it for awhile, to get good shots with the corners blurred it is important that the background in the corners is pretty distant (in practice I try to get the background in the corners to be at least 20 ft away) and for portraits in particular it is really helpful to crop to 4 X 5 (which I like for most portraits) that cleans up the corners quite a bit.
I think that when using the CV 28/2 II on the correct sensor stack thickness, there is little astigmatism.
Check the extreme corners at infinity. It's capable of high resolution from wide open: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1704868/0#15621051
Someone wrote that the Voigtlander 28/2 II's rendering could benefit from a wider filter thread. I think 46mm instead of 39mm would lower optical vignetting significantly. It would still be a very compact lens. Too late for that.
Fred Miranda wrote:
I think that when using the CV 28/2 II on the correct sensor stack thickness, there is little astigmatism.
Check the extreme corners at infinity. It's capable of high resolution from wide open: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1704868/0#15621051
Someone wrote that the Voigtlander 28/2 II's rendering could benefit from a wider filter thread. I think 46mm instead of 39mm would lower optical vignetting significantly. It would still be a very compact lens. Too late for that.
Yes, I did complain about the vignetting and - rhetorically - asked why they didn't go for a bigger front lens element and a 46mm filter thread. I also don't see astigmatism on my Nikon Z6 (w/ Kolari UT mod) even wide open in the corners.
Green fringe seemed a bit prominent, and the pic with the plant container in the corner looked kinda wonky. I didn't see Leica comps of the same, though. Any .02 on those aberrations?
Unfortunately I didn't do the same test with the Summicron. The reason was probably that it was for service at the time or on the way back to me. Regarding green LoCA in those crops of the plant, I need to say that the branches are very green themselves, so what we see there is not (only) LoCA. The 28mm Ultron II does have some green fringing in the OOF areas, but it's about the same as the Summicron-M Asph II.
Yesterday evening I did a quick check with the Ultron II by putting the focus box in the extreme side and then zoom to 200%. While adjusting focus in and out, I can see no astigmatism when the subject is in focus, but when I unfocus something odd happens: radial lines with very high contrast show some kind of doubling effect in the transition zone, which is what causes the nervous bokeh. When I turn the camera 90 degrees, this doubling/nervous effect is gone. I have no technical explanation for this behavior though.
The odd behavior doesn't show up in the center (just to make that clear).
RustyBug wrote:
Lars, appreciate the comps.
Green fringe seemed a bit prominent, and the pic with the plant container in the corner looked kinda wonky. I didn't see Leica comps of the same, though. Any .02 on those aberrations?
LarsHP wrote:
Unfortunately I didn't do the same test with the Summicron. The reason was probably that it was for service at the time or on the way back to me. Regarding green LoCA in those crops of the plant, I need to say that the branches are very green themselves, so what we see there is not (only) LoCA. The 28mm Ultron II does have some green fringing in the OOF areas, but it's about the same as the Summicron-M Asph II.
Yesterday evening I did a quick check with the Ultron II by putting the focus box in the extreme side and then zoom to 200%. While adjusting focus in and out, I can see no astigmatism when the subject is in focus, but when I unfocus something odd happens: radial lines with very high contrast show some kind of doubling effect in the transition zone, which is what causes the nervous bokeh. When I turn the camera 90 degrees, this doubling/nervous effect is gone. I have no technical explanation for this behavior though.
The odd behavior doesn't show up in the center (just to make that clear).
Green fringe seemed a bit prominent, and the pic with the plant container in the corner looked kinda wonky. I didn't see Leica comps of the same, though. Any .02 on those aberrations?
The behavior you describe sounds like astigmatism to me (i.e., different perform based on whether the camera is in horizontal vs. vertical orientation).
Steve Spencer wrote:
The behavior you describe sounds like astigmatism to me (i.e., different perform based on whether the camera is in horizontal vs. vertical orientation).
We agree that this behavior, in the transition zone (when the subject is out of focus), sounds and looks like astigmatism. However, when the subject is in focus, there's no astigmatism, so AFAIK this behavior isn't called astigmatism, since it happens out of focus. So, what is this optical phenomenon in the OOF area called? I have no idea. EDIT: We usually just call it "nervous bokeh", but that's an unscientific description that doesn't say what the cause is.
It's perhaps like the term apochromatic correction: the term is historically and scientifically only used about the plane of focus, not out of focus areas. Modern high quality lenses are (at least as a general rule) nearly or free of LoCA in the plane of focus, but particularly superfast lenses are in no way free of color fringing in the OOF areas. Some lens reviewers call lenses free of bokeh fringing "true apochromatic", but this is about semantics, just like above.
LarsHP wrote: Steve Spencer wroteThe behavior you describe sounds like astigmatism to me (i.e., different perform based on whether the camera is in horizontal vs. vertical orientation).We agree that this behavior, in the transition zone (when the subject is out of focus), sounds and looks like astigmatism. However, when the subject is in focus, there's no astigmatism, so AFAIK this behavior isn't called astigmatism, since it happens out of focus. So, what is this optical phenomenon in the OOF area called? I have no idea.
It's perhaps like the term apochromatic correction: the term is historically and scientifically only used about the plane of focus, not out of focus areas. Modern high quality lenses are (at least as a general rule) nearly or free of LoCA in the plane of focus, but particularly superfast lenses are in no way free of color fringing in the OOF areas. Some lens reviewers call lenses free of bokeh fringing "true apochromatic", but this is about semantics, just like above. ...Show more →
I think of astigmatism as different field curvature for the saggital and tangential planes, or perhaps put differently there are of course an infinite number of orientations of the plane going through the focus point and if the focus point is the center that means if the different orientations of the focal plane have different field curvature patterns then you get astigmatism. I don't think given that understanding of astigmatism it makes sense to think of its consequences as only occurring in the focus plane because it is a field curvature issue it will by its very nature have affects outside the focus plane.
Great thread. Curious to see the rendering differences. I have long had the 28 cron v2 on my list—always love the draw. And it’s beyond my threshold for optical competency. The CV 28/2v2 will be purchased soon.
I still think we might see a faster, more rendering based 28 from voigtlander at some point.
friedrice1212 wrote:
Anyone here tried the 28 cron V1 on an M10-R? I know it’s not the best but wondering if the 40MP makes it unusable
I’ve only been using my 28 Cron v1 on an M246 but yesterday I did a comparison of the Cron 28 v1 and Ultron 28/2 v2 on an M10-R that I’ll post later today.
genji wrote: friedrice1212 wroteAnyone here tried the 28 cron V1 on an M10-R? I know it’s not the best but wondering if the 40MP makes it unusableI’ve only been using my 28 Cron v1 on an M246 but yesterday I did a comparison of the Cron 28 v1 and Ultron 28/2 v2 on an M10-R that I’ll post later today.
genji wrote: friedrice1212 wroteAnyone here tried the 28 cron V1 on an M10-R? I know it’s not the best but wondering if the 40MP makes it unusableI’ve only been using my 28 Cron v1 on an M246 but yesterday I did a comparison of the Cron 28 v1 and Ultron 28/2 v2 on an M10-R that I’ll post later today.
So, here is the first set of pictures comparing the Summicron-M 28mm f/2 v1 with the Ultron VM 28mm f/2 v2 on an M10-R. I should stress that this kind of testing is not my forté! I would have preferred sunny weather but currently Sydney reminds me of the few months I spent living in Portland. Focus on the central sign was done wide open using the Visoflex 020 and remained constant through the aperture series. The lens name and aperture appears before each picture.
I've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)
Joseph. wrote:
I've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)
Are they identical optically with same exact optical design? I never really researched this.
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.
Supposedly some minor improvements in optical performance.
David Farkas wrote at the time:
Leica isn't offering too many particulars about the optical updates, other than to say that these lenses have reduced field curvature. This enables the updated lens designs to have improved sharpness across the entire image area, from center to corner.
With these lenses he means the Elmarit-M 28mm, the Summicron-M 28mm and the Summicron-M 35mm. The were redesigned at the same time.
Supposedly they were also redesigned to work better on the Leica SL whereas on the M the differences between v1 and v2 were less pronounced.
SlowDriver wrote: Fred Miranda wroteAlthough I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.Supposedly some minor improvements in optical performance.
David Farkas wrote at the time:
Leica isn't offering too many particulars about the optical updates, other than to say that these lenses have reduced field curvature. This enables the updated lens designs to have improved sharpness across the entire image area, from center to corner.
With these lenses he means the Elmarit-M 28mm, the Summicron-M 28mm and the Summicron-M 35mm. The were redesigned at the same time.
Supposedly they were also redesigned to work better on the Leica SL whereas on the M the differences between v1 and v2 were less pronounced.
Thanks for posting the info.
I wish that David Farkas, having access to all these lenses, would do a quick side by side test and draw his own conclusions instead of repeating what Leica says. Perhaps someone has done this but I can't find any reference, only the same info getting repeated everywhere.