Fred Miranda wrote: Joseph. wroteI've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)Are they identical optically with same exact optical design? I never really researched this.
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.
No, Joseph is incorrect, they’re not optically identical. The v2’s design was updated for digital and it’s already been stated on the forum by someone who upgraded from a v1 to a v2 that the v2’s corners are better.
genji wrote: Fred Miranda wroteJoseph. wroteI've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)Are they identical optically with same exact optical design? I never really researched this.
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.No, Joseph is incorrect, they’re not optically identical. The v2’s design was updated for digital and it’s already been stated on the forum by someone who upgraded from a v1 to a v2 that the v2’s corners are better.
Thanks. Have you seen any side by side images actually showing the v2's advantage?
Fred Miranda wrote: genji wroteFred Miranda wroteJoseph. wroteI've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)Are they identical optically with same exact optical design? I never really researched this.
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.No, Joseph is incorrect, they’re not optically identical. The v2’s design was updated for digital and it’s already been stated on the forum by someone who upgraded from a v1 to a v2 that the v2’s corners are better.Thanks. Have you seen any side by side images actually showing the v2's advantage?
No, my plan was that to replace my v1 with a v2 as soon as my dealer could find one for me. But that went out the window when I realised that at best the Cron v2 would only be marginally better than the Ultron v2 (at 4x the cost for a used Cron vs a new Ultron). Then he found an almost new Lux 28 at an attractive price so I settled on a Lux + Ultron v2 duo.
genji wrote: Fred Miranda wrotegenji wroteFred Miranda wroteJoseph. wroteI've owned both versions. IIRC they are very identical optically. The issue was that the v1 usually suffered from front wobble - a design that was fixed on the V2. Also the V1 had a huge plastic hood, but there is an alternative hood that was way smaller. (It's the hood for an older 35 1.4 non-asph)Are they identical optically with same exact optical design? I never really researched this.
Although I have never seen a conclusive test, many believe the v2 is optically superior.No, Joseph is incorrect, they’re not optically identical. The v2’s design was updated for digital and it’s already been stated on the forum by someone who upgraded from a v1 to a v2 that the v2’s corners are better.Thanks. Have you seen any side by side images actually showing the v2's advantage?No, my plan was that to replace my v1 with a v2 as soon as my dealer could find one for me. But that went out the window when I realised that at best the Cron v2 would only be marginally better than the Ultron v2 (at 4x the cost for a used Cron vs a new Ultron). Then he found an almost new Lux 28 at an attractive price so I settled on a Lux + Ultron v2 duo.
SlowDriver wrote:
Perhaps this helps:
The Old and New Leica 28mm Summicron Asph.
Tested on the Leica M(240) the Leica SL and the Sony A7 mark ii https://www.slack.co.uk/leica-m-resolution.html
IIRC the MTF charts from Leica show improved performance towards the corners with the 2nd version versus the first. As mentioned (and observed by users) the issue with the v1 was (reverse) field curvature. Saying v1 wasn't designed for digital as such isn't true, since it was released about the time of the M8. However, it obviously didn't work well with later digital M cameras that were full frame (and has a slightly thicker sensor glass, IIRC).
The above was the reason I only looked for and bought the v2. Slack's review was one of the reasons I decided on the v2 for use on my (unmodded) Nikon Z6. However, that didn't work well, and I ended up both selling the Summicron and getting the Kolari UT conversion.
LarsHP wrote:
IIRC the MTF charts from Leica show improved performance towards the corners with the 2nd version versus the first. As mentioned (and observed by users) the issue with the v1 was (reverse) field curvature. Saying v1 wasn't designed for digital as such isn't true, since it was released about the time of the M8. However, it obviously didn't work well with later digital M cameras that were full frame (and has a slightly thicker sensor glass, IIRC).
The above was the reason I only looked for and bought the v2. Slack's review was one of the reasons I decided on the v2 for use on my (unmodded) Nikon Z6. However, that didn't work well, and I ended up both selling the Summicron and getting the Kolari UT conversion.
carlosmcse wrote:
I have the Ultron II. Once you own this lens there’s no reason to spend money on a Summicron or Elmarit unless you just want your lens to say Leica.
The Voigtlander 28/2 Ultron II is significantly smaller and shorter, which greatly minimizes frameline blocking. This achievement can be considered a major success for Cosina. I have compared the 28/2 cron II and the 28/2 Ultron II side by side, and they show remarkably similar resolution and rendering. The only noticeable difference is that Leica's rendering shows slightly more specular highlights' outlining, while the Voigtlander lens exhibits higher optical vignetting, resulting in a more swirly, cat's eye-shaped bokeh towards the edges. However, overall, both lenses offer a modern and clean look with minimal flaws.
Regarding resolution and contrast, they are also very much alike. Both lenses are capable of delivering high resolution across the entire field even when wide open. The Voigtlander lens performs slightly better in this aspect, but the margin is not significant.
carlosmcse wrote:
I have the Ultron II. Once you own this lens there’s no reason to spend money on a Summicron or Elmarit unless you just want your lens to say Leica.
For me the only way from that would be a Summilux or a Summaron. Personally I would go for the Summaron for what I do.
I have both the Ultron II and the Cron v2. Optically both are fantastic, but from a haptics/handling and aesthetic point of view, the Leica lens is much nicer.
If you don’t care about that, definitely get the Ultron II.
Fred Miranda wrote: LarsHP wroteIIRC the MTF charts from Leica show improved performance towards the corners with the 2nd version versus the first. As mentioned (and observed by users) the issue with the v1 was (reverse) field curvature. Saying v1 wasn't designed for digital as such isn't true, since it was released about the time of the M8. However, it obviously didn't work well with later digital M cameras that were full frame (and has a slightly thicker sensor glass, IIRC).
The above was the reason I only looked for and bought the v2. Slack's review was one of the reasons I decided on the v2 for use on my (unmodded) Nikon Z6. However, that didn't work well, and I ended up both selling the Summicron and getting the Kolari UT conversion.
Fred Miranda wroteThat helps! Thank you.How much thinner the sensor stack was on the M8/M9 compared to M10/M11 sensors?
However, as I understand it, the reason why Leica made version 2 was field curvature when using digital full frame cameras. The v1 was made at a time when only film Leica's and the M8 existed.
Got Ultron II today , did some sharpness test against cron v2 with Sony A7R3 (Kolar UT Mod) at my backyard. focusing subject is backside of my house, about 10-11 meters (32 to 36 feet) away
1. Cron is little bit wider, little bit warmer.
2. In some situation, Cron has more purple fringing than Ultron.
3. Regarding sharpness:
a. At center, they are about same, very difficult to tell difference , same thing towards mid frame.
b. Start at 25% from edge, Cron is noticeable better than Ultron, (F2 , F2.8, F4)
c. At corner, Cron is much better than Ultron, I think Ultron is about 1.5 stop behind Cron (F2 to F5.6), at F8, it's getting close, but Cron is still noticeable better.
Cron's corner improves from F2 to F5.6, at F8 it is same as F5.6, although it's already very good at F2 and F2.8;
Ultron's corner keep improving from F2 all the way to F8.
I was planning to replace my cron v2 with ultron II, so I can sell the cron v2 to have some fund toward a new Q3, now I'm not sure.
I guess I will use Ultron for couple more months for some real photo shooting situations , then make up my mind.
LongVoyage wrote:
Got Ultron II today , did some sharpness test against cron v2 with Sony A7R3 (Kolar UT Mod) at my backyard. focusing subject is backside of my house, about 10-11 meters (32 to 36 feet) away
1. Cron is little bit wider, little bit warmer.
2. In some situation, Cron has more purple fringing than Ultron.
3. Regarding sharpness:
a. At center, they are about same, very difficult to tell difference , same thing towards mid frame.
b. Start at 25% from edge, Cron is noticeable better than Ultron, (F2 , F2.8, F4)
c. At corner, Cron is much better than Ultron, I think Ultron is about 1.5 stop behind Cron (F2 to F5.6), at F8, it's getting close, but Cron is still noticeable better.
Cron's corner improves from F2 to F5.6, at F8 it is same as F5.6, although it's already very good at F2 and F2.8;
Ultron's corner keep improving from F2 all the way to F8.
I was planning to replace my cron v2 with ultron II, so I can sell the cron v2 to have some fund toward a new Q3, now I'm not sure.
I guess I will use Ultron for couple more months for some real photo shooting situations , then make up my mind.
The Summicron is the better overall lens (price not factored in) if you account for handling, looks and ease of use. I have owned the Voigt Ultron II two times now. It’s no doubt a stunner of a lens and by a far margin the better value lens.
I just don’t like it. The looks, the feel, the handling etc. I also prefer the look of the Summicron over the Ultron. The Ultron is just razor sharp with a very sterile look to me.
Again, the Ultron is by far the smarter choice if budget is a part of the equation at all. Even without budget, you could argue it’s the better lens for some people. I just truly don’t like it and prefer the look and feel of the Summicron v2.
LongVoyage wrote:
Got Ultron II today , did some sharpness test against cron v2 with Sony A7R3 (Kolar UT Mod) at my backyard. focusing subject is backside of my house, about 10-11 meters (32 to 36 feet) away
1. Cron is little bit wider, little bit warmer.
2. In some situation, Cron has more purple fringing than Ultron.
3. Regarding sharpness:
a. At center, they are about same, very difficult to tell difference , same thing towards mid frame.
b. Start at 25% from edge, Cron is noticeable better than Ultron, (F2 , F2.8, F4)
c. At corner, Cron is much better than Ultron, I think Ultron is about 1.5 stop behind Cron (F2 to F5.6), at F8, it's getting close, but Cron is still noticeable better.
Cron's corner improves from F2 to F5.6, at F8 it is same as F5.6, although it's already very good at F2 and F2.8;
Ultron's corner keep improving from F2 all the way to F8.
I was planning to replace my cron v2 with ultron II, so I can sell the cron v2 to have some fund toward a new Q3, now I'm not sure.
I guess I will use Ultron for couple more months for some real photo shooting situations , then make up my mind....Show more →
When I tested the Ultron and the Leica 28/2 Cron II lenses at infinity distance, I observed that the Ultron had slightly better resolution and contrast throughout the entire field and especially at center. However, the difference between the two lenses in terms of resolution and contrast was not significant.
There is an important factor to keep in mind regarding the variability of lens copies. The Voigt 28/2 Ultron II exhibited more variation in performance among different copies compared to the Leica lens. When I wrote my review for the CV 28/2 Ultron II, the initial copy I had was fortunately optimal. Unfortunately, that specific copy was stolen from my hotel room in Portugal. It took me four additional copies of the lens to find one that performed similarly well in the mid-zone and corners. On the other hand, with the Leica lens, I tried two copies: one new and another much older, and both performed equally well (both v2). This indicates that the Leica lens has better consistency in performance across different copies.
RustyRus wrote:
The Summicron is the better overall lens (price not factored in) if you account for handling, looks and ease of use. I have owned the Voigt Ultron II two times now. It’s no doubt a stunner of a lens and by a far margin the better value lens.
I just don’t like it. The looks, the feel, the handling etc. I also prefer the look of the Summicron over the Ultron. The Ultron is just razor sharp with a very sterile look to me.
Again, the Ultron is by far the smarter choice if budget is a part of the equation at all. Even without budget, you could argue it’s the better lens for some people. I just truly don’t like it and prefer the look and feel of the Summicron v2. ...Show more →
I need more time to compare the rendering of two lens.
Regarding the handling, the aperture and focus ring of Ultron works pretty well, Cron's works well too but little bit loose to my taste (that would be my only complain of Cron v2 in my about six years usage , and I'm already used to the "loose" feel few years ago). Other than that, Cron v2 handles much better than ultron 2, size/lens hood/lens cap... just overall in general. I don't understand why Voigtlander didn't just go with a 46mm front element, the handling will be much better , it will also improve vignetting.
Fred Miranda wrote:
When I tested the Ultron and the Leica 28/2 Cron II lenses at infinity distance, I observed that the Ultron had slightly better resolution and contrast throughout the entire field and especially at center. However, the difference between the two lenses in terms of resolution and contrast was not significant.
There is an important factor to keep in mind regarding the variability of lens copies. The Voigt 28/2 Ultron II exhibited more variation in performance among different copies compared to the Leica lens. When I wrote my review for the CV 28/2 Ultron II, the initial copy I had was fortunately optimal. Unfortunately, that specific copy was stolen from my hotel room in Portugal. It took me four additional copies of the lens to find one that performed similarly well in the mid-zone and corners. On the other hand, with the Leica lens, I tried two copies: one new and another much older, and both performed equally well (both v2). This indicates that the Leica lens has better consistency in performance across different copies.
I got the lens new from a Japanese vendor on ebay (he sold about 60 already on that list), it's more trouble for me to return or exchange it (the item has to be defected to be able to be returned). definitely not four times though.
During my test , I noticed a very slight difference of sharpness between left and right edge of photo taken by Ultron which suggest a tiny bit decentering, but it's very tiny difference, I will need to do more testing to confirm. Even so, it probably cannot be considered as defected.
Too much of variability of lens copies is the thing I really hate, I'm still dealing with a warranty process of laowa 9mm /5.6 with Venus right now, bought it in Jan from B&H(I should just get it from laowa Canada), being too busy didn't use it for like four months until my trip in May, found out that it's so badly decentered (about 25% of left side are smeared while right side is reasonable sharp) ......
Anyway, I will have to think about what to do with this one.