p.7 #1The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
woodstork wrote:
Thank you for the excellent advice! Only disagreement is I would contend the light in Italy is more beautiful than Florida. At least that’s what I saw the week I was in Rome and Naples. Florida light is almost always angry, probably by being choked by stifling humidity all day. It’s best to shoot before it’s had its coffee and wakes up.
I will shop the Nikon and Leica diopters (and order the Kenko UV41). How much better is the Leica Elpro vs Nikon 4T? Worth the price difference? For reference, I have Canon 500D closeup filter that I’ve used maybe twice in 20 years. It’s very good but I’d like better.
...Show more →Ripolini wrotewoodstork wrote1) anyone using extension tubes with this lens to get closer, if so, which ones and how do you like the results? I will say the mfd isn’t bad at all (0.18x I think) but I’d like to get to 0.3x at times. I’m also open to diopters but feel like that could be like putting a pig on some lipstick.Achromatic (two-element) close-up filters have higher quality and aren't "pig on lipstick"
In my previous post I showed some results one can get with the Nikon 4T diopter: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1722699/3#16070017
Consider that Leica makes a even higher quality close-up filter, the (expensive) Elpro 52 that can be used on their M 50/2 Apo-Summicron: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1431562-REG/leica_14125_elpro_52_set.html/overview
With the Elpro 52 + Leica M 50/2 Apo Summicron one gets magnifications in the range 1:2.6-1:2 (0.38-0.5 X) at 20-22 cm focusing distances. I bet similar figures holds for the 50/2 Apo Lanthar too.
As a general remark, a lens that was not designed to take close-ups will not maintain its full optical qualities when "forced" to focus closer by adding extension. Therefore, a loss of quality (e.g., field curvature) must be expected even with extension tubes (even if they don't have any lens element).
woodstork wrote3) maybe I’m not color-cast sensitive but so far I’m not seeing the magenta cast on the margins of the frame Sony users were encountering. Or maybe Florida sunshine eats marginal magenta for breakfast. If I ever start to notice, my understanding is there’s a Zeiss UV filter to get. I think something like would also help protect the lens from Florida. Thoughts?I use permanently the Kenko Zéta UV L41. It reduces the (slight) magenta color cast I noted with my Z6. And sunshine in Rome (Italy) is not that different from Florida's
No image degradation occurs.
Latitude probably counts too. North Florida is on a latitude closer to Cairo.
p.7 #2The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
woodstork wrote:
I will shop the Nikon and Leica diopters (and order the Kenko UV41). How much better is the Leica Elpro vs Nikon 4T? Worth the price difference? For reference, I have Canon 500D closeup filter that I’ve used maybe twice in 20 years. It’s very good but I’d like better.
Me too have the Canon 500D (77 mm) and it's very good with my 70-200. Obviously, a macro lens is better
I have never used the Elpro 52 so I can't comment on image quality. I bet it's good. Well, I'd pretend it's very good at 450 $
However, it's different from the Nikon 4T. The Elpro 52 is more powerful in that it allows larger magnifications with a 50mm lens. So it depends on the final maximum magnification you need.
Extensions tubes are cheaper, so I'd try them first.
All info on Elpro 52 here: https://www.reddotforum.com/content/2018/08/leica-releases-elpro-52-close-up-lens-set/
p.7 #3The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Thank you! Nikon 4T is looking pretty good - the Leica is more than I wish to spend.
Ripolini wrote: woodstork wroteI will shop the Nikon and Leica diopters (and order the Kenko UV41). How much better is the Leica Elpro vs Nikon 4T? Worth the price difference? For reference, I have Canon 500D closeup filter that I’ve used maybe twice in 20 years. It’s very good but I’d like better.Me too have the Canon 500D (77 mm) and it's very good with my 70-200. Obviously, a macro lens is better
I have never used the Elpro 52 so I can't comment on image quality. I bet it's good. Well, I'd pretend it's very good at 450 $
However, it's different from the Nikon 4T. The Elpro 52 is more powerful in that it allows larger magnifications with a 50mm lens. So it depends on the final maximum magnification you need.
Extensions tubes are cheaper, so I'd try them first.
All info on Elpro 52 here: https://www.reddotforum.com/content/2018/08/leica-releases-elpro-52-close-up-lens-set/
p.7 #5The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
I was a bit torn between the 35 and 50mm AL and chose the 50mm for a variety of reasons, including because I figured it would be easy to panostitch with it handheld for a wider FOV when needed. My first test of this was a quick 3-shot stitch with 33% overlap (1/150s at f/2.5). Stitching done in Capture One 22 producing an 87mp file 10,686 pixels on the long axis. Capture One is far from the best stitcher, but serves its purpose for demonstration today. This was easy peasy with great IQ. The lens is a great stitch source.
p.7 #6The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
ksmmike wrote:
What you said about the harsh light in Florida is correct but that also leads to amazing sunsets at times as well as great light for infrared.
Mike
Agree. Great sunsets available year round. But my favorite FL light for color photography is in October - less heat haze versus the summer and it almost seems like the whole atmosphere is crisp and clear like it is self-polarized, and it is still offering some great towering cloudscapes.
I didn't think much about IR until you mentioned it, but definitely makes sense. I do enjoy taking advantage of high contrast scenes here for B&W.
p.7 #8The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
In the Sony Forum we are discussing about the shape of the aperture of the 50/2 Apo Lanthar for E and M mount.
I think it might be useful for Nikon Z users to know at what aperture the diaphragm has a perfectly round shape.
Actually, in the German website of Voigtlander, we read:
"The aperture blades, consisting of 12 elements, have a special shape that is circular not only at the maximum aperture of F2, but also at F2.8 and F5.6. This allows the photographer to take full advantage of the “ball blur” effect of point light sources and other objects."
Please click on the link to see a video (57 MB download) showing the behavior of the Z 50/2 AL (my sample) shape of aperture blades video
The aperture is perfectly round @ f/2 (obviously) & f/2.8; @ f/16 I'd say it is almost perfectly round. Therefore, the German site is not exactly accurate ...
The official Cosina website (here) inform us that: "A 12-blade aperture is used to make the holes formed by the blades closer to a circle. The out-of-focus part has a natural depiction, and the point light source is not a polygon but a round and soft bokehl"
with no indication as to which aperture has a perfectly round shape.
Watching my video you'll know.