I also agree that having a 24mm indoors is invaluable. However, the downside (so far) of midrange zooms that can hit 24 is almost double the weight. Even Tokina's just announced 24-70 f2.8 zoom weights double the Tamron 28-75. Which is why I own the Tamron. When I need wider I go with the Sony 16-35 f2.8 or my 24mm f1.4.
Either the original Tamron 28-75 or the G2 is an excellent lens, even for pro use. Everything has its tradeoffs. For me, I don't often shoot between roughly 40-60mm so having a lighter midrange zoom is that tradeoff that's best for my shooting style.
chez wrote:
JVan_02 wrote
Wonder how the GM II will fare against this Tamron G2... especially with regards to price.
Like with the first gen of each, I don't see the GM II eclipsing the Tamron optically—even if the GM II is nicer in some areas, it probably won't be enough to justify the more expensive option on its own. Where this gets interesting for me, is at the time of release of the first gen Tamron, the GM was already established... and the price was the price. At this point, however, the G2 is already out—and it has excellent optics, solid construction (even if the G2 won't be quite as good as the GM II, the G1 Tamron has already proven to be quite the sturdy lens), and even a linear motor (I know, not the 2—4 we're likely to see in the GM II).
We're probably going to see a straight price increase like we did with the 70-200 GM II... but maaaaaaaybe the 28-75 G2 is good enough to keep Sony on its toes price wise. Between the G2 (technical performance) and the Sigma (rendering), the competition has got to be eating into enough of Sony's sales in this area that if the price goes up the only people buying the GM II will be people wanting the GM II's exclusive software features like breathing correction. Shooting events the difference between 24 and 28 is quite large at times, especially in cramped quarters. For me, that difference is why I would pick a 24-70 over the Tamron if I was to shoot a zoom. I shoot my events with two cameras and a 25 / 85 combo.