p.3 #2What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Man, I was really hoping they'd make another 35mm.
Just kidding.
The Ultron 28 is great. I've bought and sold it twice now. May have to pick one up again before prices go nuts, I really don't care for the chrome filter rings Cosina keeps putting on all the new lenses. Ultron has a nice matte black stealth thing going on.
Hoping for a 90/2.4 and maybe an updated Skopar 24/28 eventually. I don't know if anyone is ever going to break the curse of "no 28 for Sony", sorry to say.
p.3 #3What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote:
interestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.
I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.
p.3 #5What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size....Show more →
I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?
p.3 #6What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote: Steve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?
I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.
p.3 #7What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person. ...Show more →
The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.
p.3 #8What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.
Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen.
p.3 #9What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen....Show more →
The CV 35/2.5 Color-Skopar and CV 35/2 Ultron have very similar rendering and resolution. That was surprising to me.
The former actually renders slightly smoother towards the edges (less optical vignetting...another surprise). It's also sharper at f/2.5 than the Ultron is at f/2. Both are similar at f/2.5. Definitely no blockage for the Color-Skopar.
The Leica 28/2 Asph blocks the viewfinder while the 28/2.8 does not. The latter is very affordable for Leica's terms. (especially the made in Portugal version)
Personally, I am waiting to see what Voigtlander comes up with.
p.3 #10What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote: Steve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteinterestingly, to me the big question here is does the new version play nicely on Sony sensor stacks. I owned the recently discontinued one, And I thought it was quite a nice lens. It’s a highly competent optically, neutral to smooth draw for a fast 28mm and ergonomically pleasant and quite compact.
To me, the two big gotchas on that lens are that it’s not nice on Sony’s and it has focus shift on film.
But I’m getting the vibe that other people were expecting something new/better/different—or won’t be happy even if it plays nice on Sony.I expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?
Usually when Nokishita has tweeted that Cosina will announce something soon, the official announcement comes in a matter of days. Might even come today... And release date might be sometime in May after Japanese Golden week holidays at the earliest.
p.3 #11What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteSteve Spencer wroteI expect that a new version on a non-APO lens will not play nice on a Sony. Instead I expect a CVM 28 f/2 non-APO, to try to compete with Leica M on size, which probably does not bode well for it playing nice on Sony. The Leica M 28 f/2 (both versions) have about a 53mm diameter and are 41mm long. For me this is close to an ideal size for a Leica M lens. One problem with the current CVM 28 f/2 is that it is both fatter 55mm vs. 53mm and substantially longer 51mm vs. 41mm that larger size even though it is a little bit lighter doesn't look great in comparison to the Leica lenses. And given that version 1 of the Leica M lens has been around for twenty years now used versions can sometime be found for less than $2,000. That means although the price difference is still substantial between CVM and Leica M, it isn't nearly the size it is for something like the 50 f/2 APOs or the 35 f/2 APOs. All that together suggests to me Cosina would be smart if they make a new version of this lens to make it smaller. It would seem a 53mm diameter ought to be possible and maybe they can even make it a bit shorter.
One of the attractions of the CVM 35 f/2 ultron is that it is both a little thinner (52mm vs. 53mm) and a bit shorter (28mm vs. 35mm) than the Leica M 35 f/2 Asph. I don't know that Cosina can make a 28 f/2 that is actually smaller than the Leica M, but it seems they could at least make one a lot closer in size.I always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen.The CV 35/2.5 Color-Skopar and CV 35/2 Ultron have very similar rendering and resolution. That was surprising to me.
The former actually renders slightly smoother towards the edges (less optical vignetting...another surprise). It's also sharper at f/2.5 than the Ultron is at f/2. Both are similar at f/2.5. Definitely no blockage for the Color-Skopar.
The Leica 28/2 Asph blocks the viewfinder while the 28/2.8 does not. The latter is very affordable for Leica's terms. (especially the made in Portugal version)
Personally, I am waiting to see what Voigtlander comes up with.
Are you getting another M10 Steve?
Yes, I am planning on getting an M10, but I will wait until things open up with the pandemic. Things are still very lockdowned here and the Leica M10 I am getting as my travel/street camera. There just aren't opportunities to travel right now and it isn't the best time for street shooting either. That plus I normally travel to the US more weeks than not, but I am not doing that now, means it will be easier to buy the camera and new lenses for it when the border opens up. So, right now I am kind of obsessively planning a Leica M10 system, but won't be able to buy for at least a few months.
So, at 28mm I already have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 which I will keep when I want a really fast 28mm, but I am thinking I will probably get the Leica M 28 f/2 first version which can be had for around $2,000 as a smaller alternative. I might get the new CVM 28 f/2, however, if it is small enough and has good performance. How much does the Leica M 28 f/2 block the viewfinder? I had hoped at just 53mm in diameter and 41mm in length it would be only moderate. Part of the reason I don't think I will need a super light 28 is that it seems to me if you want to go light with a Leica kit that going with a 21, 35, 75 three lens kit is the way to go. So, I want a very light 35 and 75 for such a kit, but I feel less need to go super light at 28mm as it will be part of my moderately light 21, 28, 50, and 90 more versatile kit where I will tolerate a little more weight and viewfinder blockage.
p.3 #12What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteI always appreciate the insights and thoughts Steve. Personally, when the differences are that small, I don’t see that as significant, but everybody will differ. Voigtlander is a tough nut to crack, some things that would seem pretty obvious don’t happen (35/1.7 e-mount) while other things are unexpected (3 versions of the 40/1.2 at this point for instance). I would still like to see them try some simple zooms or tri-elmars.
Does soon mean a week or 8 weeks once it hits Nokoshita?I agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen.The CV 35/2.5 Color-Skopar and CV 35/2 Ultron have very similar rendering and resolution. That was surprising to me.
The former actually renders slightly smoother towards the edges (less optical vignetting...another surprise). It's also sharper at f/2.5 than the Ultron is at f/2. Both are similar at f/2.5. Definitely no blockage for the Color-Skopar.
The Leica 28/2 Asph blocks the viewfinder while the 28/2.8 does not. The latter is very affordable for Leica's terms. (especially the made in Portugal version)
Personally, I am waiting to see what Voigtlander comes up with.
Are you getting another M10 Steve?Yes, I am planning on getting an M10, but I will wait until things open up with the pandemic. Things are still very lockdowned here and the Leica M10 I am getting as my travel/street camera. There just aren't opportunities to travel right now and it isn't the best time for street shooting either. That plus I normally travel to the US more weeks than not, but I am not doing that now, means it will be easier to buy the camera and new lenses for it when the border opens up. So, right now I am kind of obsessively planning a Leica M10 system, but won't be able to buy for at least a few months.
So, at 28mm I already have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 which I will keep when I want a really fast 28mm, but I am thinking I will probably get the Leica M 28 f/2 first version which can be had for around $2,000 as a smaller alternative. I might get the new CVM 28 f/2, however, if it is small enough and has good performance. How much does the Leica M 28 f/2 block the viewfinder? I had hoped at just 53mm in diameter and 41mm in length it would be only moderate. Part of the reason I don't think I will need a super light 28 is that it seems to me if you want to go light with a Leica kit that going with a 21, 35, 75 three lens kit is the way to go. So, I want a very light 35 and 75 for such a kit, but I feel less need to go super light at 28mm as it will be part of my moderately light 21, 28, 50, and 90 more versatile kit where I will tolerate a little more weight and viewfinder blockage....Show more →
I also like 21/35/75 but on the Leica, I exclusively use the rangefinder and 28mm is my wider lens. (Do not like using optical finders either)
I was thinking about 28/50 and calling it a day. The 50mm is the 50/2 APO and the 28mm is still a ??.
p.3 #14What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
expwmbat wrote:
Isn’t there a very good ZM 28/2.8? I assume it doesn’t play well with the Sony sensor stack, but might be a good pair for the CV 50APO?
DJK
It is very good and noticeably adversely affected by the sony sensor stack. The f2.8 is a bit slow, and it’s actually not that small for a 2.8 compared to the CV/Cron’s, but a good lens nonetheless
p.3 #15What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteI agree the differences are small and I do think understanding Voigtlander is tough and I am not sure I do at all. A great example is when they dropped the 35 f/1.7 and instead went with the 35 f/2 ultron. To me the 35 f/1.7 is just a better lens and one I am much more interested in using, but when I thought for a bit about using both lenses on a Leica M camera using the rangefinder I realized the 35 f/2 ultron does not block the viewfinder at all and the 35 f/1.7 does. Now the amount that the 35 f/1.7 blocks the rangefinder doesn't bother me, but I can see why others would value a lens that doesn't block the viewfinder when shooting a Leica M. That is what I think they will be going for with the new 28 f/2 ultron, or at least that is my guess (and it is just a guess). I think they will go for a small 28 f/2 that doesn't block (or more likely blocks less because at 28 the frame lines go right to the edge) the frame lines.
In contrast, if they make a 28 f/2 APO, which I think they still might make, it is going to block the viewfinder quite a bit. This won't matter to some, but it will matter to others. It might even matter to me. For example, I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 35 f/1.7 over the CVM 35 f/2 APO as the APO lens is 7mm longer and 3mm fatter. The APO lens looks like a great performer, but when you think of the rangefinder view it gets in the way enough to be sort of annoying and the CVM 35 f/1.7 is both half a stop faster and has nicer rendering to my eye. Sure the APO is sharper, controls aberrations a lot better, and has that nifty aperture blades arrangement that is circular at f/2, f/2.8, and f/5.6 but has great sunstars everywhere else. Both to me are great options, but I am likely to ge with the smaller CVM 35 f/1.7.
Much of that is a commentary on the CVM 35 f/1.7, however, and that I really like that lens, because at 50mm I am pretty sure I am going to go with the CVM 50 f/2 APO over something like a Leica M 50 f/2 (fifth version). Here the Leica is about the same amount smaller than the CVM 50 APO as the CVM 35 f/1.7 is vs the CVM 35 APO, but I see very little to recommend the cron 5th version (even though I like that lens) over the CVM 50 APO and I think the Voigt 50 APO is enough better than I will opt for the bigger lens that blocks the viewfinder more (keep in mind, however the 50 frame lines take up less of the viewfinder and the CVM 50 APO is 5mm shorter than the CVM 35 APO). Said, another way I think, but will need to confirm, that the 50 APO has viewfinder blockage I can live with, but the CVM 35 APO crosses my personal threshold and I believe with block the viewfinder too much. These are of course very personal decisions and what one tolerates is likely to vary a lot from person to person.The CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen.The CV 35/2.5 Color-Skopar and CV 35/2 Ultron have very similar rendering and resolution. That was surprising to me.
The former actually renders slightly smoother towards the edges (less optical vignetting...another surprise). It's also sharper at f/2.5 than the Ultron is at f/2. Both are similar at f/2.5. Definitely no blockage for the Color-Skopar.
The Leica 28/2 Asph blocks the viewfinder while the 28/2.8 does not. The latter is very affordable for Leica's terms. (especially the made in Portugal version)
Personally, I am waiting to see what Voigtlander comes up with.
Are you getting another M10 Steve?Yes, I am planning on getting an M10, but I will wait until things open up with the pandemic. Things are still very lockdowned here and the Leica M10 I am getting as my travel/street camera. There just aren't opportunities to travel right now and it isn't the best time for street shooting either. That plus I normally travel to the US more weeks than not, but I am not doing that now, means it will be easier to buy the camera and new lenses for it when the border opens up. So, right now I am kind of obsessively planning a Leica M10 system, but won't be able to buy for at least a few months.
So, at 28mm I already have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 which I will keep when I want a really fast 28mm, but I am thinking I will probably get the Leica M 28 f/2 first version which can be had for around $2,000 as a smaller alternative. I might get the new CVM 28 f/2, however, if it is small enough and has good performance. How much does the Leica M 28 f/2 block the viewfinder? I had hoped at just 53mm in diameter and 41mm in length it would be only moderate. Part of the reason I don't think I will need a super light 28 is that it seems to me if you want to go light with a Leica kit that going with a 21, 35, 75 three lens kit is the way to go. So, I want a very light 35 and 75 for such a kit, but I feel less need to go super light at 28mm as it will be part of my moderately light 21, 28, 50, and 90 more versatile kit where I will tolerate a little more weight and viewfinder blockage.I also like 21/35/75 but on the Leica, I exclusively use the rangefinder and 28mm is my wider lens. (Do not like using optical finders either)
I was thinking about 28/50 and calling it a day. The 50mm is the 50/2 APO and the 28mm is still a ??.
I found using a wide like 21mm super easy with the M10. Once you get to know the lens, shooting f/5.6, f/6.8, or f/8 it is super easy to focus without having to check focus. Framing can be set in most cases with the LCD or if the light or angle is wrong to use the LCD, the Visoflex 020 which tilts works great. For travel photography I feel I just have to have something wider than 28, so 21, 35, & 75 works quite well, but I like 21, 28, 50, & 90 even better but of course that brings more weight. If I know I will shoot a lot of architecture I even want something wider than 21, so adding a 15mm is nice (but adds even more weight) in that case.
p.3 #16What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteThe CV 50/2 APO M blocks the 50mm frame line slightly at MFD and it reaches the 75mm line at infinity. I consider this a small blockage. The 35/2 APO M blocks the 35mm frame lines significantly in comparison.
I really like the 50/2 APO on the Leica. I've tried many options and settled for that.
For the 35mm, I will compare the 35/2 Ultron vs 35/2 APO and see which rendering I like the best. (Do not love either though)
I'm very curious about what Voigtlander brings in their new 28mm. It could be the perfect solution for me: 28/50.Thanks for the report Fred. That is pretty much what I had inferred from the measurements and other lenses I had used. I had the Leica M 50 f/2 APO and the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO isn't that much bigger and very close in size to the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. Your report on the CVM 35 f/2 APO confirms my fears about viewfinder blockage, but I think I can be quite happy with the CVM 35 f/1.7 and of course the CVM 35 f/2.5 is a quite nice lens that won't block the finder at all. At 28mm I can be quite happy with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph, which doesn't have the stratospheric price of the Leica 35 or 50 f/2 APO. Still I would love for Cosina to make a nice CVM 28 f/2 that was competitive in size and performance and less than half the price. That is a lot to ask, but I think it could happen.The CV 35/2.5 Color-Skopar and CV 35/2 Ultron have very similar rendering and resolution. That was surprising to me.
The former actually renders slightly smoother towards the edges (less optical vignetting...another surprise). It's also sharper at f/2.5 than the Ultron is at f/2. Both are similar at f/2.5. Definitely no blockage for the Color-Skopar.
The Leica 28/2 Asph blocks the viewfinder while the 28/2.8 does not. The latter is very affordable for Leica's terms. (especially the made in Portugal version)
Personally, I am waiting to see what Voigtlander comes up with.
Are you getting another M10 Steve?Yes, I am planning on getting an M10, but I will wait until things open up with the pandemic. Things are still very lockdowned here and the Leica M10 I am getting as my travel/street camera. There just aren't opportunities to travel right now and it isn't the best time for street shooting either. That plus I normally travel to the US more weeks than not, but I am not doing that now, means it will be easier to buy the camera and new lenses for it when the border opens up. So, right now I am kind of obsessively planning a Leica M10 system, but won't be able to buy for at least a few months.
So, at 28mm I already have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 which I will keep when I want a really fast 28mm, but I am thinking I will probably get the Leica M 28 f/2 first version which can be had for around $2,000 as a smaller alternative. I might get the new CVM 28 f/2, however, if it is small enough and has good performance. How much does the Leica M 28 f/2 block the viewfinder? I had hoped at just 53mm in diameter and 41mm in length it would be only moderate. Part of the reason I don't think I will need a super light 28 is that it seems to me if you want to go light with a Leica kit that going with a 21, 35, 75 three lens kit is the way to go. So, I want a very light 35 and 75 for such a kit, but I feel less need to go super light at 28mm as it will be part of my moderately light 21, 28, 50, and 90 more versatile kit where I will tolerate a little more weight and viewfinder blockage.I also like 21/35/75 but on the Leica, I exclusively use the rangefinder and 28mm is my wider lens. (Do not like using optical finders either)
I was thinking about 28/50 and calling it a day. The 50mm is the 50/2 APO and the 28mm is still a ??.I found using a wide like 21mm super easy with the M10. Once you get to know the lens, shooting f/5.6, f/6.8, or f/8 it is super easy to focus without having to check focus. Framing can be set in most cases with the LCD or if the light or angle is wrong to use the LCD, the Visoflex 020 which tilts works great. For travel photography I feel I just have to have something wider than 28, so 21, 35, & 75 works quite well, but I like 21, 28, 50, & 90 even better but of course that brings more weight. If I know I will shoot a lot of architecture I even want something wider than 21, so adding a 15mm is nice (but adds even more weight) in that case....Show more →
My issue is more framing than focusing. The latter can be done with the rangefinder patch but framing requires the LCD, Visoflex or a 21mm optical viewfinder. I just dislike using all three when composing the shot. Definitely a matter of preference.
p.3 #17What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Interesting discussion. 21mm became a real favourite of mine on Leica M back with the M9. I eventually gave up on the external 21mm finder an just winged it, generally with pretty good success. No, it's not ideal if you require really precise framing, but it worked well for my expectations. With practice you can get pretty good at guesstimating framing.
Back when I was looking for an M-mount 28 (~2012), I did a brief test shoot with both the VM Ultron and the ZM. IMO the ZM was the clearly superior optic. Great Zeiss contrast/punch and at least centrally very sharp. The Ultron was underwhelming (not sure if it was that specific copy). In comparison it was fairly low contrast and focus shift was noticeable (if not severe enough to be a deal-breaker). Outer zone performance also needed a lot of stopping down to meet my expectations. Of the two, I would have taken the ZM in a heartbeat. But back then with the M9's rather poor high ISO capability, the extra light at f/2, particularly for indoor use, was critical. So I ended up with the 28 Cron despite the considerably higher cost. IMO the only drawback of the 28 Cron v1 was field curvature that bent away from the camera towards the edges/corners. Not ideal for flat field subjects unless you can stop down to around f/5.6. The M240 didn't considerably improve high ISO performance so I found f/2 at 28 was still somewhat limiting and ended up with the Lux. I find it good enough as a general purpose 28 but it's definitely on the large side for OVF shooting. Biggest flaw of the Lux IMO is purple fringing in high contrast transitions at wider apertures, but it even persists at f/8 in the extreme corners. There's also some bokeh fringing.
Right now my M kit has settled on slow 21 (SEM), fast 28 (Lux), VM 35/1.7, fast 50 (Lux ASPH) and depending on the situation, either slow 90 (f/4 Macro) or fast 90 (APO ASPH).
Of these, for urban and natural landscape situations, I'd like to swap out the 50 Lux (but still keep it) for the VM 50 APO, which is about the same size but will offer better backlighting veiling flare resistance and no wider aperture mid-zone sharpness drop. Still up in the air about 35mm given that I'm quite happy with the 35/1.7 and not so thrilled by the VM 35 APO's mid-distance background bokeh characteristics and greater OVF blockage. But for deeper focus images, the APO looks really great. 28 will be a bit of a conundrum. I really like what Cosina has done for design of the 35 Ultron v2 over the v1. If similar, it could put the 28 Ultron v2 on my radar.
Fred, if you're on the fence between the Voigtlander 35 APO and Ultron, take a look at some of the sample images now coming out from the Leica 35 Cron APO. Yes, I know it's insanely expensive! IMO, it looks amazing. Sharp but smooth. Background rendering even at mid distances without significant subject-background separation mostly avoids outlining, unlike the VM 35 APO. Just based on sample images, I think it ticks all of the boxes I would want from an M-mount 35: sharp across the frame but with pleasing bokeh/rendering while still being relatively small and light. Only flaw I've seen so far appears to be fairly strong pincushion distortion.
Regarding viewfinder blockage (M240), I think I've posted these somewhere before. Perhaps they will be a useful reference.
28 Lux with hood at infinity:
28 Lux no hood at infinity:
50 Lux ASPH at infinity (the VM 50 APO will be very similar):
p.3 #18What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
Interesting discussion. 21mm became a real favourite of mine on Leica M back with the M9. I eventually gave up on the external 21mm finder an just winged it, generally with pretty good success. No, it's not ideal if you require really precise framing, but it worked well for my expectations. With practice you can get pretty good at guesstimating framing.
Back when I was looking for an M-mount 28 (~2012), I did a brief test shoot with both the VM Ultron and the ZM. IMO the ZM was the clearly superior optic. Great Zeiss contrast/punch and at least centrally very sharp. The Ultron was underwhelming (not sure if it was that specific copy). In comparison it was fairly low contrast and focus shift was noticeable (if not severe enough to be a deal-breaker). Outer zone performance also needed a lot of stopping down to meet my expectations. Of the two, I would have taken the ZM in a heartbeat. But back then with the M9's rather poor high ISO capability, the extra light at f/2, particularly for indoor use, was critical. So I ended up with the 28 Cron despite the considerably higher cost. IMO the only drawback of the 28 Cron v1 was field curvature that bent away from the camera towards the edges/corners. Not ideal for flat field subjects unless you can stop down to around f/5.6. The M240 didn't considerably improve high ISO performance so I found f/2 at 28 was still somewhat limiting and ended up with the Lux. I find it good enough as a general purpose 28 but it's definitely on the large side for OVF shooting. Biggest flaw of the Lux IMO is purple fringing in high contrast transitions at wider apertures, but it even persists at f/8 in the extreme corners. There's also some bokeh fringing.
Right now my M kit has settled on slow 21 (SEM), fast 28 (Lux), VM 35/1.7, fast 50 (Lux ASPH) and depending on the situation, either slow 90 (f/4 Macro) or fast 90 (APO ASPH).
Of these, for urban and natural landscape situations, I'd like to swap out the 50 Lux (but still keep it) for the VM 50 APO, which is about the same size but will offer better backlighting veiling flare resistance and no wider aperture mid-zone sharpness drop. Still up in the air about 35mm given that I'm quite happy with the 35/1.7 and not so thrilled by the VM 35 APO's mid-distance background bokeh characteristics and greater OVF blockage. But for deeper focus images, the APO looks really great. 28 will be a bit of a conundrum. I really like what Cosina has done for design of the 35 Ultron v2 over the v1. If similar, it could put the 28 Ultron v2 on my radar.
Fred, if you're on the fence between the Voigtlander 35 APO and Ultron, take a look at some of the sample images now coming out from the Leica 35 Cron APO. Yes, I know it's insanely expensive! IMO, it looks amazing. Sharp but smooth. Background rendering even at mid distances without significant subject-background separation mostly avoids outlining, unlike the VM 35 APO. Just based on sample images, I think it ticks all of the boxes I would want from an M-mount 35: sharp across the frame but with pleasing bokeh/rendering while still being relatively small and light. Only flaw I've seen so far appears to be fairly strong pincushion distortion.
Regarding viewfinder blockage (M240), I think I've posted these somewhere before. Perhaps they will be a useful reference.
Most informative and useful, Ron. Might I ask how you did the “view through the viewfinder” pictures? I wouldn’t mind adding ZM 28/2.8 and 7A 28/1.4 views.
p.3 #19What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
Interesting discussion. 21mm became a real favourite of mine on Leica M back with the M9. I eventually gave up on the external 21mm finder an just winged it, generally with pretty good success. No, it's not ideal if you require really precise framing, but it worked well for my expectations. With practice you can get pretty good at guesstimating framing.
Back when I was looking for an M-mount 28 (~2012), I did a brief test shoot with both the VM Ultron and the ZM. IMO the ZM was the clearly superior optic. Great Zeiss contrast/punch and at least centrally very sharp. The Ultron was underwhelming (not sure if it was that specific copy). In comparison it was fairly low contrast and focus shift was noticeable (if not severe enough to be a deal-breaker). Outer zone performance also needed a lot of stopping down to meet my expectations. Of the two, I would have taken the ZM in a heartbeat. But back then with the M9's rather poor high ISO capability, the extra light at f/2, particularly for indoor use, was critical. So I ended up with the 28 Cron despite the considerably higher cost. IMO the only drawback of the 28 Cron v1 was field curvature that bent away from the camera towards the edges/corners. Not ideal for flat field subjects unless you can stop down to around f/5.6. The M240 didn't considerably improve high ISO performance so I found f/2 at 28 was still somewhat limiting and ended up with the Lux. I find it good enough as a general purpose 28 but it's definitely on the large side for OVF shooting. Biggest flaw of the Lux IMO is purple fringing in high contrast transitions at wider apertures, but it even persists at f/8 in the extreme corners. There's also some bokeh fringing.
Right now my M kit has settled on slow 21 (SEM), fast 28 (Lux), VM 35/1.7, fast 50 (Lux ASPH) and depending on the situation, either slow 90 (f/4 Macro) or fast 90 (APO ASPH).
Of these, for urban and natural landscape situations, I'd like to swap out the 50 Lux (but still keep it) for the VM 50 APO, which is about the same size but will offer better backlighting veiling flare resistance and no wider aperture mid-zone sharpness drop. Still up in the air about 35mm given that I'm quite happy with the 35/1.7 and not so thrilled by the VM 35 APO's mid-distance background bokeh characteristics and greater OVF blockage. But for deeper focus images, the APO looks really great. 28 will be a bit of a conundrum. I really like what Cosina has done for design of the 35 Ultron v2 over the v1. If similar, it could put the 28 Ultron v2 on my radar.
Fred, if you're on the fence between the Voigtlander 35 APO and Ultron, take a look at some of the sample images now coming out from the Leica 35 Cron APO. Yes, I know it's insanely expensive! IMO, it looks amazing. Sharp but smooth. Background rendering even at mid distances without significant subject-background separation mostly avoids outlining, unlike the VM 35 APO. Just based on sample images, I think it ticks all of the boxes I would want from an M-mount 35: sharp across the frame but with pleasing bokeh/rendering while still being relatively small and light. Only flaw I've seen so far appears to be fairly strong pincushion distortion.
Regarding viewfinder blockage (M240), I think I've posted these somewhere before. Perhaps they will be a useful reference.
Thanks so much Ron for a very informative post. So much of what you write mirrors my own thinking. At 21mm, I too am pretty set on getting the 21 SEM, at 28mm I had the 28 lux and your description matches my recollection with that lens and your picture demonstrates what bugged me about its viewfinder blockage. I too am down to deciding between the 28 cron v1 and the new Voigtlander 28 f/2 (I am hoping it is smaller--approaching Leica 28 cron size) similar performance, and less than half the price of the 28 cron v1 used, which I think is not too unreasonable of a hope. At 35mm, I plan to go with the CV 35 f/1.7, but agree the uber expensive 35 f/2 APO looks close to ideal. At 50mm I also plan to go with the CV 50 f/2 APO and Leica 50 lux Asph, and at 90mm I plan to go with the Leica 90 f/4 macro and the Leica 90 f/2.4 summarit instead of the very nice 90 f/2 cron AA that I had and really liked. To me I think I will appreciate the 90 summarit for its smaller size and it will still complement the 90 f/4 macro in the way I would like. I also plan to add the Leica 75 f/2.4 summarit, which I think I will like to pair with the CV 35 f/1.7 and 21 SEM for a nice and quite small kit.
All that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
p.3 #20What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
genji wrote:
Most informative and useful, Ron. Might I ask how you did the “view through the viewfinder” pictures? I wouldn’t mind adding ZM 28/2.8 and 7A 28/1.4 views.
Thanks. I just wedged an iPhone 11 up against the eyepiece, but it still couldn't see the full width of the view seen by the eye, hence why the frame lines are outside the edges. Unfortunately I don't have those lenses to add to the collection.