fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?

  
 
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.8 #1What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
We eagerly anticipate Fred's test outcome. We hopefully VC 28mm F2 V2 would be good enough closer or near APO quality.
Jun 09, 2021 at 07:04 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.8 #2What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Keep in mind it is a Vintage Line lens, and this matters when setting your expectations. Expect very good CA control that will not necessarily stand up to 35/2 APO standards (very high) and house style colour and contrast. F2 may be a 'design extension' for street ad close focus work, corners less important here.

f4-f11 is where many will want to use this one, for intimate landscapes and near-far compositions. A 28mm version of the 21/3.5 would fit the bill nicely. And bear in mind Fred puts lenses through the 61mp wringer, they do not necessarily fail out at 24/42mp. It does need to at least equal the 28/2.8s from Leica R and CY et al however, to be considered. If it does not, the wait goes on.
Jun 09, 2021 at 07:21 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #3What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Makten wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
mapgraphs wrote
Fred Miranda wrote....

New version: 10 elements in 7 groups with one (1) double sided aspherical elements, two (2) with anomalous partial dispersion
Interestingly, the new 10/7 28 Ultron seems to be an update of the earlier 9/7 Ultron f/1.9 LTM, or at least it looks closer to the earlier LTM version than to the more recent M version...
Indeed!!
Isn't that a strange conclusion? Apart from the bulging front of the old 28/2, I find all three about as similar.


Not really both the 28 f/1.9 and the new lens have a rear aspherical element whereas the 28 f/2 does not and the second and third element form a cemented group in both the 28 f/1.9 and the new lens and these elements are not cemented as a group in the first 29 f/2. The new 28 f/2 looks very much like the old 28 f/1.9 with three additions: 1) a new element second to the last: 2) the first element is now an anomalous partial dispersion element; 3) the second element is now an anomalous partial dispersion element. Even the shape of the other elements are pretty similar in the new lens to the 28 f/1.9.
Jun 09, 2021 at 07:32 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.8 #4What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
philip_pj wrote:
Keep in mind it is a Vintage Line lens, and this matters when setting your expectations. Expect very good CA control that will not necessarily stand up to 35/2 APO standards (very high) and house style colour and contrast. F2 may be a 'design extension' for street ad close focus work, corners less important here.

f4-f11 is where many will want to use this one, for intimate landscapes and near-far compositions. A 28mm version of the 21/3.5 would fit the bill nicely. And bear in mind Fred puts lenses through the 61mp wringer, they do not necessarily fail out at 24/42mp.
...Show more →

Hi Philip,

Unfortunately Fred does not have a Leica R 28mm f2.8 V2 available for comparison and only a relatively small number of us on FM do. I will have to wait for the tests by Fred and Juha and then decide if I want to take the plunge and compare the lens with my R 28mm f2.8 Elmarit V2. I would be reluctant to send Fred my R 28mm V2 copy, but it would be something to consider. In my case though, with my Kolari Vision UT sensor modded A7rII I have a potential alternative if this lens will perform well on an M body camera with across the frame and corner performance.

Rich

Jun 09, 2021 at 08:19 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #5What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
naturephoto1 wrote:
philip_pj wroteKeep in mind it is a Vintage Line lens, and this matters when setting your expectations. Expect very good CA control that will not necessarily stand up to 35/2 APO standards (very high) and house style colour and contrast. F2 may be a 'design extension' for street ad close focus work, corners less important here.

f4-f11 is where many will want to use this one, for intimate landscapes and near-far compositions. A 28mm version of the 21/3.5 would fit the bill nicely. And bear in mind Fred puts lenses through the 61mp wringer, they do not necessarily fail out at 24/42mp. It does need to at least equal the 28/2.8s from Leica R and CY et al however, to be considered. If it does not, the wait goes on.
Hi Philip,

Unfortunately Fred does not have a Leica R 28mm f2.8 V2 available for comparison and only a relatively small number of us on FM do. I will have to wait for the tests by Fred and Juha and then decide if I want to take the plunge and compare the lens with my R 28mm f2.8 Elmarit V2. I would be reluctant to send Fred my R 28mm V2 copy, but it would be something to consider. In my case though, with my Kolari Vision UT sensor modded A7rII I have a potential alternative if this lens will perform
...Show more →

Just as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
Impressive and way better than its predecessor even though this one is more compact. It looks like Voigtlander has another winner here. Too bad it's M-mount only.




Jun 09, 2021 at 09:15 PM
fwdesign
Offline
Details
p.8 #6What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Holy moly.
Jun 09, 2021 at 09:46 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.8 #7What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
M has all the luck, they even stole our new APOs.

The count is up to M-20 and E-14. Two of 'ours' are heavy macros, and the rest are custom adapted for M in parallel production or exist stand alone in M mount. So I can't agree with Mr Gandy that they consider made for Sony lenses 'very important'. They embarked on this venture into E mount on 23 Feb 2017 - 52 moons back.

They may say that of course, but words are cheap and deeds are precious. The longest regular Voigtlander lens made for Sony is a 50mm lens! Worse still, among the Leica M-only lenses are some of the best: this 28/2, 50/3.5, 75/1.5. Not many M users are pining for the macros. And they lavished attention on this 28, with three versions - the blighters!

Not enough (current) manual focus competition - strange world, the photographic world, a lot of unmet demand. You would think they would want more exposure. But home is where the heart is, and the M lenses beat inside the Cosina chest. They have still done better than the competition, if you can find any. As a recent person used to say: 'Sad!'
Jun 09, 2021 at 11:00 PM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.8 #8What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
Makten wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
mapgraphs wrote
Fred Miranda wrote....

New version: 10 elements in 7 groups with one (1) double sided aspherical elements, two (2) with anomalous partial dispersion
Interestingly, the new 10/7 28 Ultron seems to be an update of the earlier 9/7 Ultron f/1.9 LTM, or at least it looks closer to the earlier LTM version than to the more recent M version...
Indeed!!
Isn't that a strange conclusion? Apart from the bulging front of the old 28/2, I find all three about as similar.
Not really both the 28 f/1.9 and the new lens have a rear aspherical element whereas the 28 f/2 does not and the second and third element form a cemented group in both the 28 f/1.9 and the new lens and these elements are not cemented as a group in the first 29 f/2. The new 28 f/2 looks very much like the old 28 f/1.9 with three additions: 1) a new element second to the last: 2) the first element is now an anomalous partial dispersion element; 3) the second element is now an anomalous partial dispersion element.
...Show more →

To me, those similarities are of the same magnitude that we can see between the old 28/2 and the new one. Also, I don't think one can draw any conclusions at all about rendering and performance based on a lens diagram, unless you are an optical expert and know the exact measurements and curvatures of the surfaces. Most (old, double Gauss) fast 50 mm look virtually identical but can behave extremely different, for example.
Jun 10, 2021 at 12:38 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.8 #9What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
I got my lens earlier today and I did some shooting just after I got it in Shinjuku and a bit more later at Ebisu. I had some work meetings along the day so couldn't spend a lot of time on shooting with it yet. There is some field curvature when using the lens on the Sony sensor but I was hoping it would work well for infinity shots when stopped down to f5.6 and I think it works pretty decently there on my A7C, certainly manageable for my purposes even if a native E-mount version would be even more desirable. Here are my first samples taken at f5.6 (all long distance shots) and at f2 (close-ups), all of them are SOOC JPEGs from Sony A7C.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/2qMfs4qjK9QFQoiw8

I will also try it out on my Sigma fp soon. It might well have a bit better corner-to-corner performance there due to thinner sensor stack, but I also expect more vignetting and color-shading there based on my experiences with other RF lenses on these 2 cameras.

As for size and handling, I'm very pleased with the lens.
Jun 10, 2021 at 04:28 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.8 #10What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
philip_pj wrote:
M has all the luck, they even stole our new APOs.



That's where the money is they might think.....other M lenses like the TTArtisan 11/2.8 fisheye have a quite significant increase in price just for the M-mount with otherwise the same lens design as used for other mounts.
Jun 10, 2021 at 05:09 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.8 #11What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Fred Miranda wrote:
Just as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
....


If it's this good on the M-10R, it's going to be the same on my Z7. Wasn't planning on another f/2 but there you go, Cosina and DJ Optical; for a niche mount no less... ; - )
Jun 10, 2021 at 05:13 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.8 #12What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mapgraphs wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteJust as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
....
If it's this good on the M-10R, it's going to be the same on my Z7. Wasn't planning on another f/2 but there you go, Cosina and DJ Optical; for a niche mount no less... ; - )


I doubt that. I believe that the Nikon Z7 has a sensor cover much thicker than a Leica M-mount camera. I am hoping that my Kolari Vision UT sensor modded A7rII will perform close to the M-10R camera that Fred has used for this initial test. The Kolari Vision UT sensor modification is about the same thickness as a Leica M-mount camera and is much thinner than the stock Sony E-mount sensor covers.

Rich

Jun 10, 2021 at 06:42 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #13What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mapgraphs wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteJust as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
....
If it's this good on the M-10R, it's going to be the same on my Z7. Wasn't planning on another f/2 but there you go, Cosina and DJ Optical; for a niche mount no less... ; - )


I'm not so sure. I have a number of lenses that are a lot better on my M10 than on my Z7 (the 21 SEM is a prime example). I think it is certainly possible that the lens could be fine on the M10R and not so good on the Z7.
Jun 10, 2021 at 06:51 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.8 #14What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
mapgraphs wrote
Fred Miranda wroteJust as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
....
If it's this good on the M-10R, it's going to be the same on my Z7. Wasn't planning on another f/2 but there you go, Cosina and DJ Optical; for a niche mount no less... ; - )
I'm not so sure. I have a number of lenses that are a lot better on my M10 than on my Z7 (the 21 SEM is a prime example). I think it is certainly possible that the lens could be fine on the M10R and not so good on the Z7.


Of the Leica, Zeiss, Voigtländer, DJ Optical and other M and LTM lenses I have,12mm to 90mm, only one so far is not equal on both my Z7 and M-240, and that one is better on the Z7 than on the M-240.

I know there are specific lenses that can be a challenge on the M, especially if the registration calibration is at an extreme end of the tolerance range (as is my one lens), often combined with pronounced or extreme field curvature, and when used outside of the 2m range, without accounting for a possible lens abnormality such as a de-centered or tilted element but what I've found is that all my lenses perform the same. The same defects, the same without defects. And that has been using them on the Z7, M-240 and a A7ii. The A7ii skews things because of the accentuated field curvature but even there, it's interesting that the lenses exhibit pretty much the same behavior. We can only speak to our individual usage I suppose... ; - )

Edit:
I should probably add that I've moved to using two different M adapters on the Z7, one with near perfect registration and a second short and unshimmed for the one lens. That's been the clue for me.
Jun 10, 2021 at 07:26 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #15What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mapgraphs wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
mapgraphs wrote
Fred Miranda wroteJust as a tease, here is an extreme corner crop (1:1) from the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II showing the lens "wide open" on the Leica M10-R (41MP).
....
If it's this good on the M-10R, it's going to be the same on my Z7. Wasn't planning on another f/2 but there you go, Cosina and DJ Optical; for a niche mount no less... ; - )
I'm not so sure. I have a number of lenses that are a lot better on my M10 than on my Z7 (the 21 SEM is a prime example). I think it is certainly possible that the lens could be fine on the M10R and not so good on the Z7.
Of the Leica, Zeiss, Voigtländer, DJ Optical and other M and LTM lenses I have,12mm to 90mm, only one so far is not equal on both my Z7 and M-240, and that one is better on the Z7 than on the M-240.

I know there are specific lenses that can be a challenge on the M, especially if the registration calibration is at an extreme end of the tolerance range (as is my one lens), often combined with pronounced or extreme field curvature, and when used outside of the 2m range, without accounting for a possible lens abnormality such as
...Show more →

I think you have to look lens by lens. For example the CVM 15 f/4.5 III is nearly identical on Leica M and Sony as Fred has shown and if you have the CVM 12 f/5.6 I wouldn't be surprised if that were true for it as well. With the lenses that I have the CVM 75 f/1.5 and the Leica M 75 f/2.4 has nearly identical performance on the M10 and Z7 as well. The 21 SEM, however, does much much better on Leica M than the Z7. This is also true for the CVM 35 f/1.7 (see the tests at philipreeve that find the same thing on Sony) and for infinity focus for the Leica M 50 f/1.4 Asph. There is some difference, but it isn't as big as with those three lenses with the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4.

Where I have seen no differences is between the Nikon Z7 and the Sony a7r ii. Every lens I have looks very very similar on those two cameras. So based on my experience if the lens has problems on a Sony camera, I do worry that it will have problems on the Z7. I haven't seen a lens yet that has problems on a Sony and is clearly better on the Z7. They might exist, but it doesn't happen for any of my lenses.

The bottom line is that with this new CVM 28 f/2 v II, that we will have to wait for tests. If Fred's tests look good, I will probably get it very soon and I would be happy to report how it does on the Z7.
Jun 10, 2021 at 07:49 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.8 #16What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Based on Fred's single example above and how my f/1.9 LTM Ultron behaves (and it exhibits a slight tilt), I'd have no qualms about sharing this between mounts.
(Just an aside, my 35/1.7 LTM is also indistinguishable between mounts.)
Jun 10, 2021 at 08:37 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.8 #17What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Jun 10, 2021 at 09:42 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #18What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mapgraphs wrote:
Based on Fred's single example above and how my f/1.9 LTM Ultron behaves (and it exhibits a slight tilt), I'd have no qualms about sharing this between mounts.
(Just an aside, my 35/1.7 LTM is also indistinguishable between mounts.)


Interesting my CVM 35 f/1.7 is much better on my M10 than on my Z7. Lots of field curvature on my Z7, and basically none on my M10.
Jun 10, 2021 at 10:00 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.8 #19What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
mapgraphs wroteBased on Fred's single example above and how my f/1.9 LTM Ultron behaves (and it exhibits a slight tilt), I'd have no qualms about sharing this between mounts.
(Just an aside, my 35/1.7 LTM is also indistinguishable between mounts.)
Interesting my CVM 35 f/1.7 is much better on my M10 than on my Z7. Lots of field curvature on my Z7, and basically none on my M10.


Hi Steve,

And I can confirm there is a large difference and improved performance when using my Zeiss 35mm f1.4 Distagon ZM on my Kolari Vision UT modded A7rII vs my stock A7rIII cameras.

Rich

Jun 10, 2021 at 10:04 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #20What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
mapgraphs wroteBased on Fred's single example above and how my f/1.9 LTM Ultron behaves (and it exhibits a slight tilt), I'd have no qualms about sharing this between mounts.
(Just an aside, my 35/1.7 LTM is also indistinguishable between mounts.)
Interesting my CVM 35 f/1.7 is much better on my M10 than on my Z7. Lots of field curvature on my Z7, and basically none on my M10.


I only appreciated how good the Voigtlander 35/1.7 and Zeiss 35/1.4 ZM were when using them on the thin Leica sensor. Thicker sensors induce field curvature and amplify astigmatism. I've heard that the Leica SL is the best alternative to the M body and works best than another other mirrorless with M lenses.
Jun 10, 2021 at 10:08 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister