p.4 #1What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve, unfortunately I haven't had the 28 Cron for about 5 years now and don't recall how much VF blockage was caused by the hood. There was some, but I don't remember it ever really bothering me. That said, the brief time I had the second version, I did appreciate the improved hood design.
My first 90 was the 2.5 Summarit. In hindsight, I was happy with it and still would be, but wanted to try the Cron APO, which I found to be slightly better corrected and more transparent looking. The Macro is also good, but shows lateral CA, which of course is correctable. I briefly tried the 75 Summarit and thought it was slightly sharper than its 90mm sibling, but 75mm hasn't really stuck for me in Leica M.
p.4 #2What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
The stock hood on the 28 Cron V1 is a plastic monstrosity (12451) that has significant viewfinder blockage. Better to use the hood from the Summilux 35 ASPH Pre-FLE (12589) that works great and is much more compact and less intrusive. Alternately, if money is no object try the 12466 hood.
p.4 #5What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Type II Black looks nicest to me. I guess Type I will again have aluminium barrel and lighter weight and Type II will be brass and a bit heavier. I'm getting tempted to try it though I'm not so positive that it will play very nicely on Sony sensors. Could also use it on Sigma fp with (probably) better corner-to-corner performance but blue edge/corner color shading is more of an issue there with all wider RF glass.
Map Camera price is likely to be around 88-89K yen including tax based on the 98K yen mass retail price that Nokishita reported. Official announcement should come in ~2h.
p.4 #6What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Type II Black looks nicest to me. I guess Type I will again have aluminium barrel and lighter weight and Type II will be brass and a bit heavier. I'm getting tempted to try it though I'm not so positive that it will play very nicely on Sony sensors. Could also use it on Sigma fp with (probably) better corner-to-corner performance but blue edge/corner color shading is more of an issue there with all wider RF glass.
Map Camera price is likely to be around 88-89K yen including tax based on the 98K yen mass retail price that Nokishita reported. Official announcement should come in ~2h....Show more →
Type II Chrome is lovely, and I nearly always prefer black to silver.
p.4 #7What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Type II Black looks nicest to me. I guess Type I will again have aluminium barrel and lighter weight and Type II will be brass and a bit heavier. I'm getting tempted to try it though I'm not so positive that it will play very nicely on Sony sensors. Could also use it on Sigma fp with (probably) better corner-to-corner performance but blue edge/corner color shading is more of an issue there with all wider RF glass.
Map Camera price is likely to be around 88-89K yen including tax based on the 98K yen mass retail price that Nokishita reported. Official announcement should come in ~2h....Show more →
Maybe I got this wrong but Cameraquest lists both CV 35/2 Type I and II weighing 6oz (Type II is painted brass). Could be wrong but if not, it's likely the same story with the new 28 Ultron types.
p.4 #9What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
nehemiahphoto wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteType II Black looks nicest to me. I guess Type I will again have aluminium barrel and lighter weight and Type II will be brass and a bit heavier. I'm getting tempted to try it though I'm not so positive that it will play very nicely on Sony sensors. Could also use it on Sigma fp with (probably) better corner-to-corner performance but blue edge/corner color shading is more of an issue there with all wider RF glass.
Map Camera price is likely to be around 88-89K yen including tax based on the 98K yen mass retail price that Nokishita reported. Official announcement should come in ~2h.Type II Chrome is lovely, and I nearly always prefer black to silver.
I like it too but since all my cameras are all-black, usually the black lenses look better on camera. I have the black as well as silver (chrome) versions of CV 28/3.5 Color-Skopar in LTM, and silver (chrome) version of CV 50/2.5 Color-Skopar LTM.
p.4 #10What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Map’s price seems nice. I wish Cosina would publish MTFs for all their lenses. It would at least give some idea of what to expect.
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.
p.4 #11What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
......
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.
Thanks for noticing that. Almost seems like a warning "but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance. so let's hope for an optimized Sony lens.
p.4 #12What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mcbroomf wrote: rscheffler wrote......
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.Thanks for noticing that. Almost seems like a warning "but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance. so let's hope for an optimized Sony lens.
Did you see this "warning / disclaimer" about not being able to demonstrate original optical performance" on the product page for the new 28/2 Ultron? I couldn't find such disclaimer there.
On the 50/2 APO VM product page there is a disclaimer like this:
* This lens can be attached to Sony E-mount, Fujifilm X-mount, and Nikon Z-mount digital cameras via our mount adapter, but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance.
But on the 28/2 Ultron I can just see these references to digital and mirrorless:
● Modern lens design In
consideration of use in digital cameras, we have adopted an optical design consisting of 10 elements in 7 groups with measures against color cast around the screen. Maintains good image quality on both film and digital.
● Bayonet type VM mount
A VM mount compatible with the Leica M mount is used for the lens mount. Not only can it be used with rangefinder-linked cameras, but it also has an excellent design balance when attached to a mirrorless digital camera via a mount adapter.
p.4 #14What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Juha Kannisto wrote: mcbroomf wroterscheffler wrote......
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.Thanks for noticing that. Almost seems like a warning "but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance. so let's hope for an optimized Sony lens.Did you see this "warning / disclaimer" about not being able to demonstrate original optical performance" on the product page for the new 28/2 Ultron? I couldn't find such disclaimer there.
On the 50/2 APO VM product page there is a disclaimer like this:
* This lens can be attached to Sony E-mount, Fujifilm X-mount, and Nikon Z-mount digital cameras via our mount adapter, but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance.
But on the 28/2 Ultron I can just see these references to digital and mirrorless:
● Modern lens design In
consideration of use in digital cameras, we have adopted an optical design consisting of 10 elements in 7 groups with measures against color cast around the screen. Maintains good image quality on both film and digital.
● Bayonet type VM mount
A VM mount compatible with the Leica M mount is used for the lens mount. Not only can it be used with rangefinder-linked cameras, but it also has an excellent design balance when attached to a mirrorless digital camera via a mount adapter. ...Show more →
OK so that is weird. After reading Ron's post I clicked on the link and found the text he referred to (just above the MTF graphs at the bottom) and copied the text I italicized above. NOW however the same link takes me to a modified page. No MTF or any comment about adapting lenses, just as you say. In case I had clicked on the wrong lens I went through EVERY lens, VM and SE and no mention. So they must have changed the page. No idea why ... maybe Ron can chime in to let me know I'm not going crazy
p.4 #15What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
mcbroomf wrote: Juha Kannisto wrotemcbroomf wroterscheffler wrote......
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.Thanks for noticing that. Almost seems like a warning "but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance. so let's hope for an optimized Sony lens.Did you see this "warning / disclaimer" about not being able to demonstrate original optical performance" on the product page for the new 28/2 Ultron? I couldn't find such disclaimer there.
On the 50/2 APO VM product page there is a disclaimer like this:
* This lens can be attached to Sony E-mount, Fujifilm X-mount, and Nikon Z-mount digital cameras via our mount adapter, but since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, these lenses are available. Please note that the camera cannot demonstrate its original optical performance.
But on the 28/2 Ultron I can just see these references to digital and mirrorless:
● Modern lens design In
consideration of use in digital cameras, we have adopted an optical design consisting of 10 elements in 7 groups with measures against color cast around the screen. Maintains good image quality on both film and digital.
● Bayonet type VM mount
A VM mount compatible with the Leica M mount is used for the lens mount. Not only can it be used with rangefinder-linked cameras, but it also has an excellent design balance when attached to a mirrorless digital camera via a mount adapter.OK so that is weird. After reading Ron's post I clicked on the link and found the text he referred to (just above the MTF graphs at the bottom) and copied the text I italicized above. NOW however the same link takes me to a modified page. No MTF or any comment about adapting lenses, just as you say. In case I had clicked on the wrong lens I went through EVERY lens, VM and SE and no mention. So they must have changed the page. No idea why ... maybe Ron can chime in to let me know I'm not going crazy ...Show more →
Thanks! I understand. I've found that after newly publishing newly announced products Cosina often have some little mistakes on the content that they update shortly after so maybe this was such copy-paste leftover thing that they removed soon after initial publishing and you saw the page at such intermediate phase.
I think they usually apply this kind of warnings/disclaimers about the lens not being optimal for adapting to their APO-Lanthar lenses where the APOness and MTF curves wouldn't really meet the targets if the lens was adapted to another mount.
p.4 #16What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Unfortunately I had closed the page otherwise I could have saved it and we could have debated whether it was a mistake or useful info ... of course I think we all know that lenses, especially wider FOV, need to be modified for best performance on Sony. Note that the original text that was removed listed all FF mirrorless. I had been hoping for an APO 28/2 for Sony I must say, but I cancelled my order for the 35/2 APO Lanthar as I didn't much care for the OOF background. Will likely get the 35i Sigma. I'm not sure how a 28mm version would do.
p.4 #17What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
Steve Spencer wrote:
All that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.
I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.
The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly.
p.4 #18What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
kidtexas wrote: Steve Spencer wroteAll that said, could you say a bit about or even give a picture of the viewfinder blockage of the 28 cron? I have assumed it isn't too bad given the small size of the lens, and thanks again for the very thoughtful description and pictures of blockage of the viewfinder that you have provided.I can try to get pics with both 28 Summicrons. The v1 hood is pretty massive, though it has a very large cutout for the viewfinder. You get used to it, but it's not ideal. There are a lot of replacement options for it as well - one of the 35mm hoods as mentioned, generic screw-in hoods, or do what I do and use it without a hood. It's a pretty compact lens then.
The v2 hood is much more compact and intrudes into the viewfinder less. It does make the lens longer, and since it is the new special screw in type, it's less convenient to pop on and off quickly. ...Show more →
Thank you. The picture would be great, but just your verbal description is very helpful. I certainly like the size of this new Voigtlander 28 f/2 and I am hopeful I will like the rendering, but I am also cautious about the rendering as I don't really like the rendering of the new 35 f/2 ultron. So far size and price look very good for this new 28 f/2 ultron if the performance is there I may not have to worry about a 28 summicron.
p.4 #20What might replace the recently discontinued CV Ultron 28/2?
rscheffler wrote:
Map’s price seems nice. I wish Cosina would publish MTFs for all their lenses. It would at least give some idea of what to expect.
Interesting on the official announcement page, they specifically mention adapting the VM lens to mirrorless. Seems to be hinting not to expect an E mount version, just like the 35 Ultron. Maybe there’s still hope for an APO.