p.6 #1Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
My 45i was horrendous on my A7rII. Constantly back-focusing even in very deliberate testing where it looked in focus on-screen, I would check later and see it OOF. I had basically written the lens off and was ready to try a Sony 35/2.8 or 40/2.5 or just stick with my 55/1.8.
But then when I upgraded to the A7IV, I tested the lens and it performs as it should. I was really surprised. Now it makes sense to me that we hear mixed reports on the AF accuracy here, given people are using it on various bodies.
p.6 #3Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
In my experience the only significant improvement in AF I observed on A1 (after moving from A7III) was with native-native Sony lenses (in my case it was ZA 50/1.4).
p.6 #4Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
GMPhotography wrote:
So how is it on the A1 mine finally being delivered today as I was thinking of maybe getting this
My i series 45/2.8 focuses much better on the A1 and A9 than it did on the A7RIV, to the point where I don't think about it mcuh anymore. Also, Sigma's firmware updates might have improved the AF, though they don't claim that. And that lens is available at a great price, which you will appreciate after buying the A1.
There is an official Sigma blog interview with the designers of this lens where they talked about specifically designing this lens for rendering and leaving in flaws and limiting the aperture to 2.8 in order to do so. I can't find the interview, or I would link it.
p.6 #7Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I have noticed AF variation between copies of a lens. I have two copies of the Samyang 24mm F1.8. One focuses accurately and the other one doesn't. The later also has more optical misalignment.
I've only had a single copy of the Sigma 45. I haven't experienced AF issues with it on my A7RIV or previous cameras. It can have pretty awful out-of-focus foreground rendering. But it is pretty great at everything else. I have and have had a lot of other lenses in this range.
p.6 #9Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
QuietOC wrote:
I have noticed AF variation between copies of a lens. I have two copies of the Samyang 24mm F1.8. One focuses accurately and the other one doesn't. The later also has more optical misalignment.
I've only had a single copy of the Sigma 45. I haven't experienced AF issues with it on my A7RIV or previous cameras. It can have pretty awful out-of-focus foreground rendering. But it is pretty great at everything else. I have and have had a lot of other lenses in this range.
The question is if you shoot wide open from close distance...
45mm at f/2.8 is not really that demanding in terms of DoF so slight focusing errors can simply be masked .
p.6 #10Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
j4nu wrote: QuietOC wroteI've only had a single copy of the Sigma 45. I haven't experienced AF issues with it on my A7RIV or previous cameras. It can have pretty awful out-of-focus foreground rendering. But it is pretty great at everything else. I have and have had a lot of other lenses in this range.The question is if you shoot wide open from close distance...
45mm at f/2.8 is not really that demanding in terms of DoF so slight focusing errors can simply be masked .
Yes, I checked the AF accuracy wide-open on a bookshelf just before posting.
p.6 #11Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I guess I need to finally start using it again to see how it fares in real life again... but I redid the test shots and they basically show the same behavior
One of these, shot from just below 1 meter, is AF-S:
p.6 #12Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
On A7iii still a poor AF preformance for me with this lens. Which doesn't stop me from using it. It is still much better AF as any of the A-mount lenses I'ver ever used on a Alpha camera. It lacks some AF speed yes, still many keepers if used with this in mind.
p.6 #13Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
After reading about soft iq while up close wide open. Does this go away stopped down to f4? I really love the rendering and size and about to pull the trigger. Thanks
p.6 #14Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
mrpicky wrote:
After reading about soft iq while up close wide open. Does this go away stopped down to f4? I really love the rendering and size and about to pull the trigger. Thanks
p.6 #15Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
mrpicky wrote:
After reading about soft iq while up close wide open. Does this go away stopped down to f4? I really love the rendering and size and about to pull the trigger. Thanks
Yes, resolution basically explodes at f/4 inside of, say, 1m/3ft. I posted two selfies w/ crops of my old mug here:
You can see that f/2.8 is pretty kind to old faces, f/4 sharp as you'd ever want. I think that's a good trade off, being the old face in question
It glows more the closer you get due to the uncorrected SA, but I'm almost always seeking DOF that close, so f/4 or f/5.6 is a much more typical aperture for me at that distance and it's as sharp as you could want.
Here's another selection of shots from a weekend at my friend's cider farm, so a more real world use case:
p.6 #16Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Thank for the samples!
keepcoding wrote: mrpicky wroteAfter reading about soft iq while up close wide open. Does this go away stopped down to f4? I really love the rendering and size and about to pull the trigger. Thanksyes, sharpens up nicely at F4
p.6 #17Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Perfect samples as I’ll be using it as a walk around casual portrait lens. Thanks
Dave Sanders wrote: mrpicky wroteAfter reading about soft iq while up close wide open. Does this go away stopped down to f4? I really love the rendering and size and about to pull the trigger. ThanksYes, resolution basically explodes at f/4 inside of, say, 1m/3ft. I posted two selfies w/ crops of my old mug here:
You can see that f/2.8 is pretty kind to old faces, f/4 sharp as you'd ever want. I think that's a good trade off, being the old face in question
It glows more the closer you get due to the uncorrected SA, but I'm almost always seeking DOF that close, so f/4 or f/5.6 is a much more typical aperture for me at that distance and it's as sharp as you could want.
Here's another selection of shots from a weekend at my friend's cider farm, so a more real world use case:
It was the only lens I brought and the 45 acquitted itself well.
A few posts below I posted a landscape shot or two as well. The 45 is really sharp at infinity, no problem edge to edge, corner to corner. ...Show more →
p.6 #19Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I will keep that in mind. Lens is on the way. Thanks
philip_pj wrote:
It seems to lose panache at f4, and wide open can be not quite there. Fred's stand off portrait distances images were shot at f3.2, a good compromise.