p.5 #1Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Curious which bodies people are shooting with where they had AF problems with the Sigma 45.
I have been using it mostly with the A7C using AF-C in tracking mode to focus and recompose. Honestly if I hadn't seen all of these threads, I wouldn't have had any idea that an AF problem exists with this lens. I've been using the original firmware too.
I wonder if certain bodies are more prone to having problems with this lens.
p.5 #2Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
ramesesthe2nd wrote:
I updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞....Show more →
I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm.
p.5 #3Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote: ramesesthe2nd wroteI updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞.I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm....Show more →
I completely disagree for what the 65mm is concerned.
Super fast and accurate.
p.5 #4Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
scalanc2 wrote: chiron wroteramesesthe2nd wroteI updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞.I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm.I completely disagree for what the 65mm is concerned.
Super fast and accurate.
In my experienc, the 65mm is a very nice lens that I plan to keep, but I find that the AF of the 65 does not acquire focus as quickly and is not as sticky in AF-C Eye-AF as the Samyang 75/1.8 is, for example. More missed shots of small children moving about.
I think Sigma has a real general weakness in its AF. There are a number of Sigma lenses that have been the subject of complaints about slow or inaccurate or wandering AF. Certainly there are many that are very functional or even excellent. But I think they are weaker in AF than other makers, with more frequent problems.
p.5 #5Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote: scalanc2 wrotechiron wroteramesesthe2nd wroteI updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞.I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm.I completely disagree for what the 65mm is concerned.
Super fast and accurate.In my experienc, the 65mm is a very nice lens that I plan to keep, but I find that the AF of the 65 does not acquire focus as quickly and is not as sticky in AF-C Eye-AF as the Samyang 75/1.8 is, for example. More missed shots of small children moving about.
I think Sigma has a real general weakness in its AF. There are a number of Sigma lenses that have been the subject of complaints about slow or inaccurate or wandering AF. Certainly there are many that are very functional or even excellent. But I think they are weaker in AF than other makers, with more frequent problems....Show more →
wow, Samyang focusing faster than Sigma. It came a long way.
p.5 #6Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Fred Miranda wrote: chiron wrotescalanc2 wrotechiron wroteramesesthe2nd wroteI updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞.I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm.I completely disagree for what the 65mm is concerned.
Super fast and accurate.In my experienc, the 65mm is a very nice lens that I plan to keep, but I find that the AF of the 65 does not acquire focus as quickly and is not as sticky in AF-C Eye-AF as the Samyang 75/1.8 is, for example. More missed shots of small children moving about.
I think Sigma has a real general weakness in its AF. There are a number of Sigma lenses that have been the subject of complaints about slow or inaccurate or wandering AF. Certainly there are many that are very functional or even excellent. But I think they are weaker in AF than other makers, with more frequent problems.wow, Samyang focusing faster than Sigma. It came a long way.
My sense of the Samyang tiny series is that they work very well. I do sometimes find their colors just a bit strong and bright. They are probably a bit low in what phillip_pj calls "color discrimination" and which he values a lot. But I never seem to notice a problem with the AF of the tiny series while I do seem to notice AF issues while shooting more with the i series.
p.5 #7Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
chiron wrote: ramesesthe2nd wroteI updated to the latest firmware last week and it didn't seem to improve AF at all. I stopped using AFC with this lens a while ago and mainly shoot it now on AFS.
I shot exclusively with this lens yesterday and I have a strong love hate relationship with this lens. It works consistently with grown ups but with my toddler I maybe only got 60% of shots in focus. In some shots I had to add clarity to make it acceptably sharp which screwed up the bokeh. My wife's hit rate is even lower and using this lens yesterday was mostly frustrating. Then there are days when I go out to shoot with the lens and images knocks the socks off. As of right now, i feel like i should just let it go. Nobody should suffer with this kind of AF especially on Sony's AF tech.
I need something with 35/2.8 ZA like AF performance and 45/2.8 like rendering. Sigma 35I might do the trick, but it is bigger and heavier 😞.I have all four of the Sigma i series lenses--the 24, 35, 45, and 65. They are optically very fine lenses with a very nice build and form factor. The 45mm has beautiful rendering that I think is very special and lovely.
But all of the lenses are in my usage sub-par to lenses from Sony, Samyang, or Batis. This is particularly true of the 45mm which does very poorly on AF-C especially. The other three, while quite functional in AF-C, are not quite as good in AF as the lenses made by other third party makers. The real test of AF on these lenses for me is AF-C used to photograph a toddler. But the weaknesses also show up in other situations, especially for the 45mm....Show more →
My only other Sigma lens is Bigma 35/1.2. Bigma is certainly accurate and fast enough for my toddler photography needs and I absolutely love the images from Bigma. By far my most favorite lens on Sony sans weight and size and that's the only reason I have the Sigma 45. If Sigma 35I is as fast focusing as Bigma, it is more than fast enough for my needs.
I need a lens between 35 to 45 range that I can leave on my camera 90% of the time and its weight and size don't turn grabbing a camera into a hassle. 45 could be that lens. It's a shame that it has such a sub par AF performance.
p.5 #8Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
teddoman wrote:
Curious which bodies people are shooting with where they had AF problems with the Sigma 45.
I have been using it mostly with the A7C using AF-C in tracking mode to focus and recompose. Honestly if I hadn't seen all of these threads, I wouldn't have had any idea that an AF problem exists with this lens. I've been using the original firmware too.
I wonder if certain bodies are more prone to having problems with this lens.
I would imagine that issues are more noticeable on higher resolution bodies
p.5 #9Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Honestly I use this lens all the time and rarely get a miss-focus. I did have AF issues in AF-C with my review copy though.
Not sure if this was fixed with the recent firmware updates or Sigma silently did something to the lens. My latest copy is from 5 months ago.
p.5 #10Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Fred Miranda wrote:
Honestly I use this lens all the time and rarely get a miss-focus. I did have AF issues in AF-C with my review copy though.
Not sure if this was fixed with the recent firmware updates or Sigma silently did something to the lens. My latest copy is from 5 months ago.
Fred, do you use eye AF with the Sigma 45, and if so in AF-S or AF-C mode? I would like a small 45 and wonder if I should consider the Sigma or something else (e.g. Sony 40 or 50 G or SY 45).
p.5 #11Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Like Fred, I am happy with the AF of that lens. The problem I have is not using that lens enough… but that’s a completely different story all together. My gear is setup on AF-C 99% of the time.
p.5 #12Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
AGeoJO wrote:
Like Fred, I am happy with the AF of that lens. The problem I have is not using that lens enough… but that’s a completely different story all together. My gear is setup on AF-C 99% of the time.
I like using the 45i for traveling or when taking family shots in good light. Usually I don't want to obliterate the background with too much blur to show the background scene. I also prefer stopping down any lens to at least f/2.8 when shooting environment portraits with 2, 3 or more people. The only downside to the f/2.8 is shooting in very low light (higher ISO) but I have faster lenses for that.
I don't know a 45-50mm lens that renders better than this one at f/2.8.
p.5 #13Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Fred Miranda wrote: AGeoJO wroteLike Fred, I am happy with the AF of that lens. The problem I have is not using that lens enough… but that’s a completely different story all together. My gear is setup on AF-C 99% of the time.I like using the 45i for traveling or when taking family shots in good light. Usually I don't want to obliterate the background with too much blur to show the background scene. I also prefer stopping down any lens to at least f/2.8 when shooting environment portraits with 2, 3 or more people. The only downside to the f/2.8 is shooting in very low light (higher ISO) but I have faster lenses for that.
I don't know a 45-50mm lens that renders better than this one at f/2.8.
This is exactly the use scenario I have for 45-50mm type of lens, and I don't mind AF-S for this purpose. I found one for $100 off from an authorized dealer, so going to give it a shot.
p.5 #14Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I do love the rendering on this lens, which is really lovely without being a blur-meister and I am using it often. I like the images that I get from it. For candid images with AF-C where people are moving I tend to shift to the 55/1.8.
p.5 #15Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I've had the Sigma 45mm for about a year and a half now and feel like I've finally figured out how to get consistent autofocus in single autofocus mode (not continuous). Thought I'd share. This is with the latest lens firmware update and on an A7RIV.
I have the autofocus area set to Flexible Spot M. This is the key. With every lens including the Sigma 45mm (and with other lenses whether in single autofocus or continuous), I am getting much more consistent autofocus with Flexible Spot M. Not sure why, but it makes a difference. I previously always had it set to Flexible Spot S.
The other key is to have one button set to Autofocus On and another to Eye AF. (1) I have the AEL button set to Autofocus On. (2) I then have the AF-On button set to Eye AF.
If I want to focus on a person or animal's eye(s), I typically first need to hit the AEL button to get focus close to the being's eye/face (using Flexible Spot M), and then AF-On (set to Eye AF) works its magic.
This setup, for me, works better than any other autofocus settings I've had with the Sony A7RIVs, which I've had since they were first released. The keys are Flexible Spot M and having two buttons for autofocus, one for autofocus on and the other for Eye AF. This works great for other lenses also (including in continuous focus mode for other lenses, but with the Sigma 45mm I only use it in single shot autofocus mode).
p.5 #16Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I have noticed new AF life in some of my lenses after switching from the A7RIV to the A1. The Sony 85 GM, for instance, seems to AF significantly faster and with better accuracy. I haven't had time to shoot my Sigma 45/2.8 but have a week off coming up and will see if the AF behavior is similarly improved on the A1. I love everything about this lens except for its AF-C performance. Maybe the A1 will help...
p.5 #17Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
You know, I took a chance - not much of one, actually (price) - and got the Samyang 45 f1.8. Man, that thing is sharp, fast and accurate. Like you, I do a lot of fast-moving, low light stuff. I wasn't expecting much but that lens exceeded every aspect of what I needed. Plus, it's full frame capable, so I don't really need to worry about coverage.
p.5 #18Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
The Sigma 45mm f2.8 is sharp, but that is not its defining characteristic. It has beautiful bokeh wide open, and when stopped down to f4 to f5.6 it is quite sharp across the frame and into the corners. It produces beautiful colors and rendering at all apertures. It is compact, light, well built (metal exterior), and inexpensive. . . . Once you get the autofocus issues well under control, as I fortunately now have, what's not to like? I'd prefer it were 40mm to 45mm, but it's quite a lens. . . . For ultimate sharpness in this range of 35mm to 45mm, the Sony GM 35mm f1.4 is probably the best lens I've used. But the Sigma 45mm f2.8 is a nice compliment when you prefer to use a smaller, lighter lens.
p.5 #20Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
I would love to see your results. I haven't shot extensively since I got this lens again back in December, but AF-C seems more accurate on my A9 and a I am getting more keepers now compared to what I was getting on my A7iii. AF system on A1 is better than A9, so I would expect better AF performance.
smpetty wrote:
I have noticed new AF life in some of my lenses after switching from the A7RIV to the A1. The Sony 85 GM, for instance, seems to AF significantly faster and with better accuracy. I haven't had time to shoot my Sigma 45/2.8 but have a week off coming up and will see if the AF behavior is similarly improved on the A1. I love everything about this lens except for its AF-C performance. Maybe the A1 will help...