p.7 #2Very frustrated by Sigma 45mm 2.8 autofocus problems
Dave Sanders wrote:
Unfortunately this is a very well known and much discussed issue. The spherical aberration that gives this lens its wonderful rendering appears to make it a very unreliable AF-C performer. It does not appear to be fixable. It is what it is at this point... This is an AF-S lens.
This is why I hesitated stated so long in buying this lens but I don't use AF-C a lot so I went for it and I've been happy.
But, unfortunately, if you use AF-C frequently, it's not the lens for you. A bummer, as it makes for a fatal flaw in a lovely lens for so many folks.
I haven't tested the new firmware update but I suspect it won't make a big difference.
For relatively static portraits, street scenes and landscapes, it's a great little lens. But it's not a general purpose lens, at least not in my eyes, and I love this lens. That's why I'm curious for the 50/2.5 G reviews to come out.
...Show more →chiron wroteitai195 wroteIt's a combo of AF-C being unreliable and the lens generally seeming soft under 2-3m to me. I like the rendering a lot, just have to decide whether that's something you can live with or not. It does make it decidedly not a general purpose lens for me, which is a shame given I like a lot of its attributes.
I installed the firmware update and plan to give it a go this weekend alongside the 28-70.There is some softness close up, but I was not at MFD and the shots of the static subject (the oil painting) were sharp enough and satisfying at about 1.5 meters.
The conclusion you draw that it may not be a general purpose lens for you is exactly what I am feeling. If I can't put it on my camera to shoot a range of subjects appropriate to that focal length, then I think it just gets in the way and takes up space since I would have to carry another similar focal length lens and go through a lens change to make some images. Very unworkable and just silly.
I'd be very interested to hear your results after you get a chance this weekend.
Yes, there are "AF-S lenses" and "AF-C lenses".
One has to know which is which.
For instance, my older-design Sony lenses (12-24 G and 16-35 f4) work well in AF-S, but not in AF-C. My little Tamrons (24 2.8 and 35 2.8), though, are crap with AF-S and work like a charm with AF-C.
Most probably only newer native Sony lenses, perhaps even only the more expensive ones, work equally well in both AF settings...