fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

You see it in all 4 RAWs?

inksandpaper wrote:
tsdevine wroteThanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness.
I do see this diagonal mess of streaks in your raws too. Just use a strong contrast increasing curve and it's pretty obvious. I wonder - could there be a film of grease or oil on the cover glass which is causing this problem? Would cleaning the cover glass help?

Jan 21, 2021 at 06:14 PM
inksandpaper
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
tsdevine wrote:
You see it in all 4 RAWs?

inksandpaper wrote
tsdevine wroteThanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness.
I do see this diagonal mess of streaks in your raws too. Just use a strong contrast increasing curve and it's pretty obvious. I wonder - could there be a film of grease or oil on the cover glass which is causing this problem? Would cleaning the cover glass help?


Yes
Jan 21, 2021 at 06:27 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

I have an a7R and a7R II, I'll have to try the lens on that camera. Maybe it's specific to the III...or at least my III.

If I don't see it on my II, then hopefully I won't see it on the next body I buy. Maybe this is just temporary then.

inksandpaper wrote:
Hi Tim,

I looked at your raws and I can easily see the magenta shift off-axis as you mentioned, as well as the notable improvement with the Zeiss UV filter.

I tried to replicate the results with my CV 50/2 APO on my a7R II and I also have data from the a7R IV. Unfortunately, I have no a7R III on hand to try. I did not think there should be a significant difference in the result between the R II and III at least. However, I am completely unable to induce any magenta shift at all. I am using a LCC
...Show more →

Jan 21, 2021 at 06:54 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

I dread wet cleaning the sensor, I assume if it is grease or oil, then that's the only thing that will remove it.

Never have wet cleaned a Sony sensor.....I guess I need to do some research......

inksandpaper wrote:
tsdevine wroteYou see it in all 4 RAWs?

inksandpaper wrote
tsdevine wroteThanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness.
I do see this diagonal mess of streaks in your raws too. Just use a strong contrast increasing curve and it's pretty obvious. I wonder - could there be a film of grease or oil on the cover glass which is causing this problem? Would cleaning the cover glass help?
Yes


Jan 21, 2021 at 06:56 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

Could the blue/cyan you're seeing be color drift?

https://www.reidreviews.com/examples/flatfieldnew.html


inksandpaper wrote:
Hi Tim,

I looked at your raws and I can easily see the magenta shift off-axis as you mentioned, as well as the notable improvement with the Zeiss UV filter.

I tried to replicate the results with my CV 50/2 APO on my a7R II and I also have data from the a7R IV. Unfortunately, I have no a7R III on hand to try. I did not think there should be a significant difference in the result between the R II and III at least. However, I am completely unable to induce any magenta shift at all. I am using a LCC
...Show more →

Jan 21, 2021 at 07:01 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

So I have sky shots taken after this, and I don't see that streaking....now I'm really confused. I need to shoot some more and see if it's really still there.

inksandpaper wrote:
tsdevine wroteYou see it in all 4 RAWs?

inksandpaper wrote
tsdevine wroteThanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness.
I do see this diagonal mess of streaks in your raws too. Just use a strong contrast increasing curve and it's pretty obvious. I wonder - could there be a film of grease or oil on the cover glass which is causing this problem? Would cleaning the cover glass help?
Yes


Jan 21, 2021 at 07:21 PM
inksandpaper
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

tsdevine wrote:
Could the blue/cyan you're seeing be color drift?

https://www.reidreviews.com/examples/flatfieldnew.html

inksandpaper wroteHi Tim,

I looked at your raws and I can easily see the magenta shift off-axis as you mentioned, as well as the notable improvement with the Zeiss UV filter.

I tried to replicate the results with my CV 50/2 APO on my a7R II and I also have data from the a7R IV. Unfortunately, I have no a7R III on hand to try. I did not think there should be a significant difference in the result between the R II and III at least. However, I am completely unable to induce any magenta shift at all. I am using a LCC filter similar to the Phase One product used for flat field correction (2mm thick transluscent white acrylic) to photograph an overcast sky. I tried with lens comp. corrections all OFF and then I turned on the Shading Comp also to check. Even with shading compensation, no shift towards magenta occurred.

Rather, I have a slight blue/cyan shift of ~1-3 points off axis, which is the total opposite of what you are seeing.

I did have a B+W UV-haze XS-Pro 010filter on the lens. I tried it both with and without the filter. The results on my side were the same. No magenta cast, rather a slight blue cast remained and it is hardly noticeable even so. I also tried just shooting plain sky as you did, no diffusion filter in place. Same.

I thought about it for a day and I have no clue why you are experiencing this. Mysterious!


I believe it is exactly that. The correct term should be "sensor cast". Phase One called it "lens cast". With BSI sensors the effect is extremely minimal.

Edit: Oops the writer suggests it is the IR filter that is causing the problem. It sounds like the problem indeed, not sensor cast.
Jan 21, 2021 at 07:52 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
I thought I would pass along this post from a thread in the Nikon forum. I think it is relevant to this thread and is consistent with Tim's argument that the Zeiss UV filter would help.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1665002/4#15474805
Jan 24, 2021 at 09:41 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

Thanks Steve, that's a good thread. The Petapixel article I posted in the opening post talks a little bit about this, referencing Kolari. Here's the full Kolari article that I think has that graph in the Nikon thread.

https://kolarivision.com/uv-filter-effectiveness-article/

-Tim

Steve Spencer wrote:
I thought I would pass along this post from a thread in the Nikon forum. I think it is relevant to this thread and is consistent with Tim's argument that the Zeiss UV filter would help.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1665002/4#15474805


Jan 24, 2021 at 11:11 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

So I shot both the CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mmm f/2.8 Di III on my Sony a7R II. I see very similar behavior with and without the Zeiss UV filter as I do on my a7R III. Meaning I see similar magenta shading without the filter, and more neutral performance with the filter. I didn't bother trying it on my a7R, but I suspect similar behavior.

Hopefully this thread helps someone, it's been an interesting exercise either way.

Tim
Jan 27, 2021 at 03:51 PM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
tsdevine wrote:
So I shot both the CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mmm f/2.8 Di III on my Sony a7R II. I see very similar behavior with and without the Zeiss UV filter as I do on my a7R III. Meaning I see similar magenta shading without the filter, and more neutral performance with the filter. I didn't bother trying it on my a7R, but I suspect similar behavior.

Hopefully this thread helps someone, it's been an interesting exercise either way.

Tim


Well, I never noticed this on my lenses, but this thread inspired me to try a Zeiss UV filter ...
Jan 27, 2021 at 03:59 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

Well, I don't see this behavior on all my lenses....and my intent wasn't really to have anyone try to find a problem where there was none. I hope you don't find this problem...or if you do, that the filter helps fix it.

j4nu wrote:
tsdevine wroteSo I shot both the CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mmm f/2.8 Di III on my Sony a7R II. I see very similar behavior with and without the Zeiss UV filter as I do on my a7R III. Meaning I see similar magenta shading without the filter, and more neutral performance with the filter. I didn't bother trying it on my a7R, but I suspect similar behavior.

Hopefully this thread helps someone, it's been an interesting exercise either way.

Tim
Well, I never noticed this on my lenses, but this thread inspired me to try a Zeiss UV filter ...


Jan 27, 2021 at 04:03 PM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
tsdevine wrote:
Well, I don't see this behavior on all my lenses....and my intent wasn't really to have anyone try to find a problem where there was none. I hope you don't find this problem...or if you do, that the filter helps fix it.

j4nu wrote
tsdevine wroteSo I shot both the CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mmm f/2.8 Di III on my Sony a7R II. I see very similar behavior with and without the Zeiss UV filter as I do on my a7R III. Meaning I see similar magenta shading without the filter, and more neutral performance with the filter. I didn't bother trying it on my a7R, but I suspect similar behavior.

Hopefully this thread helps someone, it's been an interesting exercise either way.

Tim
Well, I never noticed this on my lenses, but this thread inspired me to try a Zeiss UV filter ...


I didn't know about the cut-off level difference between various UV filters so that's something I found interesting and that's also why I want to try the Zeiss one and check if I can see any difference (as it seems most other brands UV cut-off doesn't really do anything on Sony sensors).
Jan 27, 2021 at 04:23 PM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
Hey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!

I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.
Jan 28, 2021 at 03:03 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

Thanks, I wish they were a little cheaper even here in the US.

Glad someone sees a benefit.

TakenWild wrote:
Hey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!

I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.

Jan 28, 2021 at 09:31 AM
Petegh
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
tsdevine wrote:
Thanks, I wish they were a little cheaper even here in the US.

Glad someone sees a benefit.

TakenWild wroteHey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!

I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.


So, what have we concluded here Tim?: that the problem stems from the IR-filtering coatings on the cover glass in combination with ray angle, or is it just ray angle effects on the cover glass itself? I recall the older Leica M9 had a problem with its IR cut filter which gave darker areas of the frame a purplish tinge.
Jan 29, 2021 at 04:01 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

No, other end of the spectrum I believe. Sony has a less aggressive UV filter on its sensor, around 409nm or so according to Kolari. Some lenses may filter UV at a higher frequency and don't seem to show the magenta shading, while some pass more UV which then shows up as a magenta'ish shading. Whether or not ray angle comes into play, I don't know. But certain lenses seem to benefit from a UV filter that has a hard cut at 410nm (like the Zeiss) or higher. Unfortunately I can't find any filter that is multicoated that has a hard cut of UV higher than 410nm. A filter with 415nm or 420nm might even work better. Most UV filters have a softer cut and/or cut frequencies lower than 410nm, so you will probably see no benefit. The Zeiss actually seems to give more of the results of what you'd want for a UV filter on Sony stack.

I think that's the theory we landed at here. The IR filter might cause sensor drift that isn't corrected by Sony, but that exhibits different behavior.

So if you don't see the problem on a lens, it probably is inherently filtering UV above where Sony does. If you do see magenta shading, the Zeiss filter may help knock it down (may still not be perfect, but may improve substantially.)

Again, I'm not sure many people see and/or care about this, I just may be anal about it.

-Tim

Petegh wrote:
tsdevine wroteThanks, I wish they were a little cheaper even here in the US.

Glad someone sees a benefit.

TakenWild wroteHey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!

I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.
So, what have we concluded here Tim?: that the problem stems from the IR-filtering coatings on the cover glass in combination with ray angle, or is it just ray angle effects on the cover glass itself? I recall the older Leica M9 had a problem with its IR cut filter which gave darker areas of the frame a purplish tinge.


Jan 29, 2021 at 05:55 AM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
I have a Hoya multicoated UV/IR cut filter, but only cuts below 390nm in UV and above 700nm in IR.
Jan 29, 2021 at 06:42 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

That won't cut it (sorry for the pun.) I don't think you'll see much of any difference in terms of magenta shading, as it's below what Sony's sensor stack already filters.

TakenWild wrote:
I have a Hoya multicoated UV/IR cut filter, but only cuts below 390nm in UV and above 700nm in IR.


Jan 29, 2021 at 06:53 AM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
UV/IR cut filters cut UV and IR light much more strongly than UV filters, because they use a different way of cutting the light off. They cut very similar to Zeiss UV filters.
Jan 29, 2021 at 06:54 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister