I think I see it faintly... These were processed though Photo Ninja.
-TimBoth exhibit concentric circles from shading compensation. The second exhibits clearly less magenta tinting than the first. So I assume the second has the UV filter attached. A big improvement if we want to partially remove unwanted magenta tinting.
I think I see it faintly... These were processed though Photo Ninja.
-TimBoth exhibit concentric circles from shading compensation. The second exhibits clearly less magenta tinting than the first. So I assume the second has the UV filter attached. A big improvement if we want to partially remove unwanted magenta tinting.
Just to be clear, you have all in-camera corrections turned off here right? And the contacts of the lens are properly attached to the camera too?
I think I see it faintly... These were processed though Photo Ninja.
-TimBoth exhibit concentric circles from shading compensation. The second exhibits clearly less magenta tinting than the first. So I assume the second has the UV filter attached. A big improvement if we want to partially remove unwanted magenta tinting.Just to be clear, you have all in-camera corrections turned off here right? And the contacts of the lens are properly attached to the camera too?
abadger wrote: vdo1 wroteabadger wrotetsdevine wroteConsider these preliminary as I did them in a hurry and realized afterward that partially dismounting the lens (so the contacts don't make connections) changes the exposure. I ran these all through Lightroom, chose "Daylight" color temp and tried to equalize the exposure. All were taken with the CV 50 on my a7R III.
I'll try to do a more controlled test later this week or this weekend.
-TimThank you for doing this test! So in reviewing these, the magenta remains in all photos, but is dampened by the UV filter which does improve the look as you said (and adds a very slight green tint). In the contactless photos, the concentric rings have disappeared. So I would call the shading compensation theory correct (the camera bakes in shading correction even with all corrections turned off), while also noting that the magenta tint probably is independent of shading correction.
Also of note that the magenta seems to appear near the corners of the images most prominently, and in some cases flares to one side or the other. So the direction of light input does appear to impact it, and that would make some sense if it was from UV filtering.How can we find out whether it's the camera or the raw conversion software that is adding the rings? Does it happen with all raw converters? I remember reading some time ago that Lightroom was applying some "corrections" that one couldn't disable (the buttons were grayed out) and the only possible cure was indeed to tape the lens contacts. Is it still the case with LR?I can’t immediately find the thread but I do recall people having the same issue with Capture One, for what it’s worth. So I think the correction has already been baked into the file in camera.
I've had the issue with magenta rings in Capture One too.
AdaptedLenses wrote:
There is a bit of a precedent for something like this happening. In the earlier days of micro 4/3 some Panasonic lenses did not behave all that well on Olympus bodies. As far as I remember the reason was that Panasonic was doing more of the UV IR filtering in their stack and the glass was letting more pollution through the Olympus sensor.
It would follow that the sharper cut off of the size filter is preventing the issue that you’re seeing here. The filter is basically blocking the wavelength that’s causing the mild issue.
I can attest to that. Had the Pana 7-14 f4 on an Oly E-M10II and often got nasty magentaish blotches in different parts of the image. Only a (rear) UV filter alleviated that.
I find it remarkable just how good the Zeiss T* UV filter is for actual UV filtering and at the same time how bad other manufacturers' UV filters are. (as for protective filters I stand by my opinion that B+W is better for less money)
Just started looking for it in some of my lenses. Can’t find it in my APO 110. Yes in my APO 50. Yes in my Tamron 35/2.8. Yes in my Loxia 25. I’ve order 52 and 49mm filters to see the difference. I’ve seen this magenta shift before. I’ve certainly noticed it my using my 35/2.8 Tamron and my Loxia 25 before.
Thanks for the post. This is interesting to me because with the NEX mirrorless cameras they all had bad magenta corners and I had thought with the newer cameras it had gone. On the older cameras it was the angle of light into the microlens being too steep and causing reflection/refraction energy to spill to the nearby pixels. In those older NEX cameras UX light exasperated the issue because the energy was more intense. I am guessing on a summers day with high UV even with your filter you may be able to detect it. One trick from the NEX days was to use green vignetting as it counteracts the magenta but there is no real fix once captured and it’s best to keep it out of your raw like you are doing with the filter.
I think I see it faintly... These were processed though Photo Ninja.
-Tim
The first image seems to have less of a problem now when processed through Ninja vs Lightroom; that said, as you say Tim, the more cyan sky in the later examples might be masking the problem somewhat, as the corners would tend to blue rather than to magenta.
This is quite an incorrect conclusion coming out of a flaw in the lens (specifically the APO 50/2, I do not have the Tamron).
The old NEX shading comes from issues discussed at length earlier and that is NOT the case here. All those issues arising out of lenses with short back focal lengths and a front illuminated sensor are history.
Slingers wrote:
Thanks for the post. This is interesting to me because with the NEX mirrorless cameras they all had bad magenta corners and I had thought with the newer cameras it had gone. On the older cameras it was the angle of light into the microlens being too steep and causing reflection/refraction energy to spill to the nearby pixels. In those older NEX cameras UX light exasperated the issue because the energy was more intense. I am guessing on a summers day with high UV even with your filter you may be able to detect it. One trick from the NEX days was to use green vignetting as it counteracts the magenta but there is no real fix once captured and it’s best to keep it out of your raw like you are doing with the filter. ...Show more →
I don't think the Zeiss filter knocks as much out of the Tamron as it does the CV, but I've had some positive results in limited use since I got one from for the Tamron.
TakenWild wrote:
Just started looking for it in some of my lenses. Can’t find it in my APO 110. Yes in my APO 50. Yes in my Tamron 35/2.8. Yes in my Loxia 25. I’ve order 52 and 49mm filters to see the difference. I’ve seen this magenta shift before. I’ve certainly noticed it my using my 35/2.8 Tamron and my Loxia 25 before.
I can tell you from experience that Photo Ninja shows the magenta as well, as you note, I think it's being masked a little by the color balance in that processing. It was just quick and dirty to see if I could see the magenta ring (a different problem.)
Petegh wrote: tsdevine wroteSee it in these? Excuse the color differences from the other samples.
I think I see it faintly... These were processed though Photo Ninja.
-TimThe first image seems to have less of a problem now when processed through Ninja vs Lightroom; that said, as you say Tim, the more cyan sky in the later examples might be masking the problem somewhat, as the corners would tend to blue rather than to magenta.
Yes, I'm not sure the Zeiss will filter out all the magenta in all conditions. I wish I could find a multi-coated Haze 2A, something that filters at 420nm vs 410nm for the Zeiss. But so far no luck, seems as though they are all non-coated filters available.
Slingers wrote:
Thanks for the post. This is interesting to me because with the NEX mirrorless cameras they all had bad magenta corners and I had thought with the newer cameras it had gone. On the older cameras it was the angle of light into the microlens being too steep and causing reflection/refraction energy to spill to the nearby pixels. In those older NEX cameras UX light exasperated the issue because the energy was more intense. I am guessing on a summers day with high UV even with your filter you may be able to detect it. One trick from the NEX days was to use green vignetting as it counteracts the magenta but there is no real fix once captured and it’s best to keep it out of your raw like you are doing with the filter. ...Show more →
No idea, but I see it in all my displays (Mid 2014 MBP, Benq 27SW2700PT, iPhone 12 Pro Max). I have not specifically tried to see if it shows up in print.
-Tim
Petegh wrote:
Also Tim, are you running an 8bit or 10bit monitor? and have you ever tried to print out a sample with this phenomena, to see if its visible in print?
Thank you for the images and information Tim.
I got interested in this so I downloaded for of your images. Here are two of them after some post-processing (because it is easier you identify color versus grey than faint magenta versus sky blue and vignetting):
Above: Image by Tim: No electrical contact between the lens and the camera, with Zeiss UV filter
I don't know exactly what conclusions one can draw... the concentric circles are there in all four images. The images with electric contacts connected in a normal way show some diagonal ugliness. Why? The images with UV-filter attached to the lens are somewhat cleaner.
The images are here. At the top of the album I put a note about what PP was done.
Thanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness. The effort you put in here validates my desire to post these on FM and get feedback.
Your versions seem to corroborate what I felt looking at my versions. The worst is fully mounted and no filter. The best is not fully mounted but with the Zeiss filter. I'm not going to shoot the lens partially mounted (or tape contacts).....so ding ding ding....I'm going with the lens mounted along with the Zeiss UV filter.
Seems like the most reasonable solution for me, unless someone comes up with a better one. Good or bad, it's one of the things I look at when thinking about buying a lens. Whether or not I'm going to see this behavior. Having some mitigation strategy is nice, even if imperfect.
-Tim
Jonas B wrote:
Thank you for the images and information Tim.
I got interested in this so I downloaded for of your images. Here are two of them after some post-processing (because it is easier you identify color versus grey than faint magenta versus sky blue and vignetting):
Above: Image by Tim: No electrical contact between the lens and the camera, with Zeiss UV filter
I don't know exactly what conclusions one can draw... the concentric circles are there in all four images. The images with electric contacts connected in a normal way show some diagonal ugliness. Why? The images with UV-filter attached to the lens are somewhat cleaner.
The images are here. At the top of the album I put a note about what PP was done....Show more →
I looked at your raws and I can easily see the magenta shift off-axis as you mentioned, as well as the notable improvement with the Zeiss UV filter.
I tried to replicate the results with my CV 50/2 APO on my a7R II and I also have data from the a7R IV. Unfortunately, I have no a7R III on hand to try. I did not think there should be a significant difference in the result between the R II and III at least. However, I am completely unable to induce any magenta shift at all. I am using a LCC filter similar to the Phase One product used for flat field correction (2mm thick transluscent white acrylic) to photograph an overcast sky. I tried with lens comp. corrections all OFF and then I turned on the Shading Comp also to check. Even with shading compensation, no shift towards magenta occurred.
Rather, I have a slight blue/cyan shift of ~1-3 points off axis, which is the total opposite of what you are seeing.
I did have a B+W UV-haze XS-Pro 010filter on the lens. I tried it both with and without the filter. The results on my side were the same. No magenta cast, rather a slight blue cast remained and it is hardly noticeable even so. I also tried just shooting plain sky as you did, no diffusion filter in place. Same.
I thought about it for a day and I have no clue why you are experiencing this. Mysterious!
tsdevine wrote:
Thanks Jonas, it is easier to see in your versions and I have no explanation for that diagonal ugliness.
I do see this diagonal mess of streaks in your raws too. Just use a strong contrast increasing curve and it's pretty obvious. I wonder - could there be a film of grease or oil on the cover glass which is causing this problem? Would cleaning the cover glass help?