Okay...would you agree that the IR aspect probably doesn't impact this phenomena. AFAIK, the Zeiss UV filter does no IR filtering. So you are saying that you see positive impact to magenta shading from your UV/IR cut filter? What would be very interesting given it's cut is well below the Zeiss (390nm vs 410nm).
tsdevine wrote:
No, other end of the spectrum I believe. Sony has a less aggressive UV filter on its sensor, around 409nm or so according to Kolari. Some lenses may filter UV at a higher frequency and don't seem to show the magenta shading, while some pass more UV which then shows up as a magenta'ish shading. Whether or not ray angle comes into play, I don't know. But certain lenses seem to benefit from a UV filter that has a hard cut at 410nm (like the Zeiss) or higher. Unfortunately I can't find any filter that is multicoated that has a hard cut of UV higher than 410nm. A filter with 415nm or 420nm might even work better. Most UV filters have a softer cut and/or cut frequencies lower than 410nm, so you will probably see no benefit. The Zeiss actually seems to give more of the results of what you'd want for a UV filter on Sony stack.
I think that's the theory we landed at here. The IR filter might cause sensor drift that isn't corrected by Sony, but that exhibits different behavior.
So if you don't see the problem on a lens, it probably is inherently filtering UV above where Sony does. If you do see magenta shading, the Zeiss filter may help knock it down (may still not be perfect, but may improve substantially.)
Again, I'm not sure many people see and/or care about this, I just may be anal about it.
-Tim
...Show more →Petegh wrotetsdevine wroteThanks, I wish they were a little cheaper even here in the US.
Glad someone sees a benefit.
TakenWild wroteHey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!
I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.So, what have we concluded here Tim?: that the problem stems from the IR-filtering coatings on the cover glass in combination with ray angle, or is it just ray angle effects on the cover glass itself? I recall the older Leica M9 had a problem with its IR cut filter which gave darker areas of the frame a purplish tinge.
Good to hear that you found an answer as to what is happening here. I also noticed the post about the Loxia 25mm and voigtländer 50 apo improving with a Zeiss UV filter (these are the lenses I use on my A7rII). To me though, the issue is too small to start using an UV-filter, but for sure it is good to know the solution to the mild magenta shading, and the cause.
I am still totally in the dark myself about what caused the Zeiss Loxia lenses to exhibit a strong blue cast in the corners and left/right frame edges on the Nikon Z7, especially wide open. It was so bad that I eventually returned to the Sony A7rII, which btw. I like much better color wise overall with the Loxia lenses anyhow.
I unfortunately took a detour selling my Loxia lenses and getting the Z S lenses, but my time with these taught me, that although much less, there was still a blue type of shading in the corners and on the left/right frame edges, that I could make visible by pushing the tonality and color saturation. A grey, clouded sky for instance, would get blue-ish corners when pusing exposure or saturation, whilst the middle part stayed perfectly, neutral grey. So either my Z7 had issues (which I don't believe to be so), or Nikon has its own share of problems with the short flange distance. I think that the fact that I personally don't mind the Sony magenta shading, proves that I am not one to look for issues where there are none. It was really quite apparant with the Nikon Z7, once you knew what to look for. I spent too much time in CO1 with the lens cast correction tool.
But the real reason I am glad to be back, is the Zeiss and Voigtlander lenses. Sad that Nikon doesn't let Zeiss and Voigtlander make lenses for the Z mount. They simply have this bit extra in many ways.
Yes, I see the magenta on both my CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mm f/2.8 Di III, on both my a7R II and a7R III. The Zeiss UV filter has positive impact to both. Yeah, and in terms of whether it bothers you, understand completely if it doesn't.
The blue cast is interesting. That would be higher in the spectrum than what we're talking about here, and if you filtered that, you'd lose much more visible spectrum.
I believe Nikon used a much thinner cover glass on their sensors, is it possible that would be the cause? Sony is relatively thick, and Nikon is relatively thin.
ChrisMak wrote: tsdevine wroteNo, other end of the spectrum I believe. Sony has a less aggressive UV filter on its sensor, around 409nm or so according to Kolari. Some lenses may filter UV at a higher frequency and don't seem to show the magenta shading, while some pass more UV which then shows up as a magenta'ish shading. Whether or not ray angle comes into play, I don't know. But certain lenses seem to benefit from a UV filter that has a hard cut at 410nm (like the Zeiss) or higher. Unfortunately I can't find any filter that is multicoated that has a hard cut of UV higher than 410nm. A filter with 415nm or 420nm might even work better. Most UV filters have a softer cut and/or cut frequencies lower than 410nm, so you will probably see no benefit. The Zeiss actually seems to give more of the results of what you'd want for a UV filter on Sony stack.
I think that's the theory we landed at here. The IR filter might cause sensor drift that isn't corrected by Sony, but that exhibits different behavior.
So if you don't see the problem on a lens, it probably is inherently filtering UV above where Sony does. If you do see magenta shading, the Zeiss filter may help knock it down (may still not be perfect, but may improve substantially.)
Again, I'm not sure many people see and/or care about this, I just may be anal about it.
-Tim
Petegh wrotetsdevine wroteThanks, I wish they were a little cheaper even here in the US.
Glad someone sees a benefit.
TakenWild wroteHey Tim, many thanks for posting about this. I’ve tested my VC 50 APO and my Loxia 25 with the Zeiss UV filters and I can confirm improvement. Amazing!
I want to get a 67mm for my Tamron 35/2.8. But Zeiss UV filters are very expensive ($125 in Australia, half the cost of the lens). Anyway, it’s on the wishlist for now.So, what have we concluded here Tim?: that the problem stems from the IR-filtering coatings on the cover glass in combination with ray angle, or is it just ray angle effects on the cover glass itself? I recall the older Leica M9 had a problem with its IR cut filter which gave darker areas of the frame a purplish tinge.Good to hear that you found an answer as to what is happening here. I also noticed the post about the Loxia 25mm and voigtländer 50 apo improving with a Zeiss UV filter (these are the lenses I use on my A7rII). To me though, the issue is too small to start using an UV-filter, but for sure it is good to know the solution to the mild magenta shading, and the cause.
I am still totally in the dark myself about what caused the Zeiss Loxia lenses to exhibit a strong blue cast in the corners and left/right frame edges on the Nikon Z7, especially wide open. It was so bad that I eventually returned to the Sony A7rII, which btw. I like much better color wise overall with the Loxia lenses anyhow.
I unfortunately took a detour selling my Loxia lenses and getting the Z S lenses, but my time with these taught me, that although much less, there was still a blue type of shading in the corners and on the left/right frame edges, that I could make visible by pushing the tonality and color saturation. A grey, clouded sky for instance, would get blue-ish corners when pusing exposure or saturation, whilst the middle part stayed perfectly, natural grey. So either my Z7 had issues, or Nikon has its own share of problems with the short flange distance. ...Show more →
tsdevine wrote:
Yes, I see the magenta on both my CV 50/2 APO and Tamron 35mm f/2.8 Di III, on both my a7R II and a7R III. The Zeiss UV filter has positive impact to both. Yeah, and in terms of whether it bothers you, understand completely if it doesn't.
The blue cast is interesting. That would be higher in the spectrum than what we're talking about here, and if you filtered that, you'd lose much more visible spectrum.
I believe Nikon used a much thinner cover glass on their sensors, is it possible that would be the cause? Sony is relatively thick, and Nikon is relatively thin. ...Show more →
The side effect of the blue casting would for instance be a noticeable de-saturation effect on the frame left/rigt edges, So not in all cases was there a "blue overlay" like with a grey sky, but a typical sort of mild "color-drain". I did not like that effect at all, and see no such thing with the Sony A7rII at all, where the whole frame is perfectly even in saturation. It depended on the scene of course, and images in sunny light with the sun coming from an angle would be worst. We all have our own particular sensitivities to issues I guess...
Sony a7R III + CV 50/2 APO shot in manual mode with daylight WB set in camera. Processed in LR and just bumped up exposure, exactly the same amount in each shot.
The Zeiss UV has a hard cutoff around 410nm. I don't know the exact start of the cutoff for the Tiffen, I believe it's at least 420nm, but it is more gradual. The big knock on the Tiffen is that it is uncoated. Notice too that it seems to block enough light that the exposure looks darker.
I see a hint of magenta in the Zeiss filtered version, but to me it is noticeably better than the no filter shot. My guess would be that a hard cutoff at 415nm would work better....but I can find no solution above a hard 410nm cutoff that is multicoated.
All processed in LR. A few more samples, shot on different days, but includes a Kenko L41 UV filter. Both filters are similarly effective, although it seems that the Kenko filters are discontinued.
Sony a7R III + Tamron 35/2.8 Di III OSD 1:2 (Please ignore the snow geese, they were just flying through....)
tsdevine wrote:
Sony a7R III + CV 50/2 APO shot in manual mode with daylight WB set in camera. Processed in LR and just bumped up exposure, exactly the same amount in each shot.
The Zeiss UV has a hard cutoff around 410nm. I don't know the exact start of the cutoff for the Tiffen, I believe it's at least 420nm, but it is more gradual. The big knock on the Tiffen is that it is uncoated. Notice too that it seems to block enough light that the exposure looks darker.
I see a hint of magenta in the Zeiss filtered version, but to me it is noticeably better than the no filter shot. My guess would be that a hard cutoff at 415nm would work better....but I can find no solution above a hard 410nm cutoff that is multicoated.
Yeah, and it's not multicoated to boot. After using the Zeiss and Kenko filters more (just got the Kenko....but they seem very similar in behavior to the Zeiss), I'm happy with the 410nm cutoff. I don't plan on using the Tiffen.
Petegh wrote: tsdevine wroteSony a7R III + CV 50/2 APO shot in manual mode with daylight WB set in camera. Processed in LR and just bumped up exposure, exactly the same amount in each shot.
The Zeiss UV has a hard cutoff around 410nm. I don't know the exact start of the cutoff for the Tiffen, I believe it's at least 420nm, but it is more gradual. The big knock on the Tiffen is that it is uncoated. Notice too that it seems to block enough light that the exposure looks darker.
I see a hint of magenta in the Zeiss filtered version, but to me it is noticeably better than the no filter shot. My guess would be that a hard cutoff at 415nm would work better....but I can find no solution above a hard 410nm cutoff that is multicoated.
-TimTo my eye Tim, the Tiffen haze 2A takes too much of the visible blues out of the sky, making it look too cyan for my tastes.
If we examine them one by one, many lenses have the magenta color shift of multi-layer ring,especially wide angle lens,and it will be more strong in thick clouds or rainy days.
I have used: VE15/4.5iii, loxa21, loxa25, loxa35, all can be seen on a7riii, a7riv, a7iii, a7ii.
In fact, the color shift of AL50/2 is very slight, even negligible.
UV filter can not solve this problem, the simplest solution is LCC,maybe using 410nm UV with LCC is an ideal solution.
I don't think it fully solves the problem, but I don't think it has no positive impact either. I think the type of light and intensity has an impact, and it's hard to correct for that with LCC. So I'm not sure either can solve this 100%
olalafoto wrote:
If we examine them one by one, many lenses have the magenta color shift of multi-layer ring,especially wide angle lens,and it will be more strong in thick clouds or rainy days.
I have used: VE15/4.5iii, loxa21, loxa25, loxa35, all can be seen on a7riii, a7riv, a7iii, a7ii.
In fact, the color shift of AL50/2 is very slight, even negligible.
UV filter can not solve this problem, the simplest solution is LCC,maybe using 410nm UV with LCC is an ideal solution.
I agree, theoretically the type and intensity of light have an impact, but I have been using LCC to correct it. even in deep post production pictures, the effect is satisfactory
tsdevine wrote:
I don't think it fully solves the problem, but I don't think it has no positive impact either. I think the type of light and intensity has an impact, and it's hard to correct for that with LCC. So I'm not sure either can solve this 100%
olalafoto wroteIf we examine them one by one, many lenses have the magenta color shift of multi-layer ring,especially wide angle lens,and it will be more strong in thick clouds or rainy days.
I have used: VE15/4.5iii, loxa21, loxa25, loxa35, all can be seen on a7riii, a7riv, a7iii, a7ii.
In fact, the color shift of AL50/2 is very slight, even negligible.
UV filter can not solve this problem, the simplest solution is LCC,maybe using 410nm UV with LCC is an ideal solution.
I’ve used Cornerfix in the past, but I think the L41 UV is still the better solution. At least for these two lenses.
olalafoto wrote:
I agree, theoretically the type and intensity of light have an impact, but I have been using LCC to correct it. even in deep post production pictures, the effect is satisfactory
tsdevine wroteI don't think it fully solves the problem, but I don't think it has no positive impact either. I think the type of light and intensity has an impact, and it's hard to correct for that with LCC. So I'm not sure either can solve this 100%
olalafoto wroteIf we examine them one by one, many lenses have the magenta color shift of multi-layer ring,especially wide angle lens,and it will be more strong in thick clouds or rainy days.
I have used: VE15/4.5iii, loxa21, loxa25, loxa35, all can be seen on a7riii, a7riv, a7iii, a7ii.
In fact, the color shift of AL50/2 is very slight, even negligible.
UV filter can not solve this problem, the simplest solution is LCC,maybe using 410nm UV with LCC is an ideal solution.
The color shift of edge and corners is easy to correct, but the ring color shift of central area is very difficult to correct. I use LCC to solve the problem
This is an FM member once posted a color shading map of Loxia21(on a7Rii), but I can't find the original post any more. It can be seen that the magenta ring is basically consistent with the sketch map I drew, I'm not sure what caused it, but it's real,and the intensity of color shading,a7Riii and a7Riv is significantly higher than a7iii
Quite frankly I’m thinking of getting L41 filters for all my lenses now. I’ve always been a UV filter or CPL user to protect my lenses anyway, so isn’t a big deal for me. I’ll still keep my Hoya HD3 filters, as they never flare anymore than a naked lens shooting into direct light due to 16 nano coatings on each side.
People who don’t use them for landscape photography always end up with micro scratches on their lenses. I have to replace filters from time to time, but I’d much prefer to replace UV filters. When you are shooting into direct sun a clean lens is quite important for flaring. When I’m on a mountain top and it blowing a gale or by the ocean. I’d much prefer cleaning a UV filter than a naked lens. Proper cleaning technique goes out the window in fast moving conditions. A UV filter is a no brainer for me.
The color shift of edge and corners is easy to correct, but the ring color shift of central area is very difficult to correct. I use LCC to solve the problem
I don't think you'd have to replace your HD3 filters with an L41 unless you noticed something like what I've shown here in the samples. Of the lenses I own, I've only noticed this on the CV 50 APO, CV 65 APO, and Tamron 35 Di III.
Tim
TakenWild wrote:
Quite frankly I’m thinking of getting L41 filters for all my lenses now. I’ve always been a UV filter or CPL user to protect my lenses anyway, so isn’t a big deal for me. I’ll still keep my Hoya HD3 filters, as they never flare anymore than a naked lens shooting into direct light due to 16 nano coatings on each side.
People who don’t use them for landscape photography always end up with micro scratches on their lenses. I have to replace filters from time to time, but I’d much prefer to replace UV filters. When you are shooting into direct sun a clean lens is quite important for flaring. When I’m on a mountain top and it blowing a gale or by the ocean. I’d much prefer cleaning a UV filter than a naked lens. Proper cleaning technique goes out the window in fast moving conditions. A UV filter is a no brainer for me....Show more →
The magenta ring problem is definitely something Sony should fix. Up to this point though, I haven't really noticed it causing a visible problem (to the extent it does in your example.) Not sure why.
-Tim
olalafoto wrote:
This is an FM member once posted a color shading map of Loxia21(on a7Rii), but I can't find the original post any more. It can be seen that the magenta ring is basically consistent with the sketch map I drew, I'm not sure what caused it, but it's real,and the intensity of color shading,a7Riii and a7Riv is significantly higher than a7iii
The color shift of edge and corners is easy to correct, but the ring color shift of central area is very difficult to correct. I use LCC to solve the problem