Were you wanting the final images to be BW or color? For color, you need to create a camera profile using a tool like Adobe Profile Editor to set the WB to allow more latitude for blue. Although you can (and Shea has a video on how to) channel swap within Lightroom, I tend to get the WB where I want it in LR and the go to PS for color editing thereafter. Usually, I use an action that does the following:
1. Channel mixer layer to swap channels…. Red goes to 0 red and 100 blue; blue does the opposite
2. Saturation layer, setting red sat down by about 50%, everything else up 10
3. Curves layer to apply an S curve
All of those get tweaked, but it saves a few minutes to create them by using an action.
These days, I mostly use an IR-Chrome filter for color and 720nm for BW.
Thanks Jim
Profile editor was the nudge I needed, actually when I did this I found the profiles I made last time round, so had done this before but totally forgot.
Without doing this I was getting stuck because LR white balance couldn't go any lower.
Anyway, I'm getting some colour IR 720 now, this one not channel swapped as I like the warm tones on the bridge
It's definitely not a fad but difficult for me to do well. Here are some of my latest images from the past couple months. I am shooting with a Nikon D810 currently but I don't particularly care for the workflow of a DSLR so I'm going to try a Sony a7r again. I had to send the last one back to the seller because there was an insane amount of dust under the sensor glass.
NIKON D81017-35 mm f/2.8-4 lens17mmf/9.01/500s64 ISO-0.3 EV
NIKON D81028-200 mm f/3.5-5.6 lens40mmf/8.01/500s64 ISO-0.3 EV
NIKON D8100 mm f/-- lens50mmf/8.01/400s64 ISO0.0 EV
NIKON D810Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens110mmf/9.01/800s200 ISO+0.7 EV
NIKON D810Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens95mmf/8.01/800s200 ISO-0.7 EV
NIKON D810Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens78mmf/8.01/800s200 ISO-0.7 EV
NIKON D81028-200 mm f/3.5-5.6 lens38mmf/8.01/400s64 ISO+0.7 EV
NIKON D81028-200 mm f/3.5-5.6 lens62mmf/8.01/250s64 ISO+0.7 EV
NIKON D81028-200 mm f/3.5-5.6 lens95mmf/8.01/250s64 ISO+0.7 EV
NIKON D81028-200 mm f/3.5-5.6 lens32mmf/8.01/400s64 ISO+0.7 EV
NIKON D81017-35 mm f/2.8-4 lens24mmf/8.01/125s64 ISO-1.0 EV
NIKON D81017-35 mm f/2.8-4 lens19mmf/10.01/2s200 ISO-0.7 EV
Frogfish wrote:
Here are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
My a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wrote: Frogfish wroteHere are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
secondclaw wrote:
My a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wroteFrogfish wroteHere are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
Will see....
My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.
Joe Colson wrote: TGPhotography wroteI don’t know what color swaps are or how to do them.I use Photoshop's Channel Mixer (Image>Adjustments>Channel Mixer) to swap the Red and Blue channels using the following settings:
Red Channel: Red=0%, Green=0%, Blue=100%
Blue Channel: Red=100%, Green=0%, Blue=0%
Green Channel: Red=0%, Green=100%, Blue=0%.
FWIW, it’s really easy to create a PS action to do this with a button click.
I am late to the thread, but since it’s been resurrected I figured I’d comment. I’ve always enjoyed IR images but up until recently hardly had enough time to shoot normal images, so resisted adding an IR body to the mix. However, I am now retired so maybe it’s time? At this point I’m thinking an A7Riiia — is that a good option? I’m hoping my 20-70/4 zoom works out well for IR. I would do full spectrum and get a Kolari clip in 720 and probably call it good.
As re false color vs channel swap vs mono, I tend to appreciate mono the most. However I also appreciate more subtle false color, like the 720, non swapped @johnahill posted a few back.
Appreciate feedback on best full frame, higher resolution Sony bodies to convert, again I am currently leaning towards an A7Riii-a.
Wow, I can't believe it's been a year since I posted in this thread. I have been shooting IR on and off. I think it's something I like to do as a change-of-pace but even in the summer, you can't fake good light. I love the long shadows that early morning or evening light gives you.
I've been making changes to equipment this year as well. I sold my full spectrum D850 (which I somewhat regret) and I sold my full spectrum Canon EOS M5 (which I really regret as I am going back to that setup) and I have been experimenting with various gear. Ultimately, I am going with a more portable setup in a Canon EOS M5 as I have had that camera in the past and understand it's performance.
Here are some IR shots I have taken this year.
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens28mmf/8.01/30s160 ISO+0.3 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens52mmf/8.01/60s250 ISO0.0 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens95mmf/8.01/320s400 ISO+0.3 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens40mmf/8.01/1000s400 ISO+0.3 EV
Canon EOS M5Canon EF-M 15-45mm f/3.5-6.3 IS STM lens17mmf/8.01/200s400 ISO-0.3 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens120mmf/10.01/250s64 ISO-0.7 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens58mmf/8.01/60s64 ISO0.0 EV
NIKON D850Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-120mm f/4G ED VR lens92mmf/10.01/100s80 ISO0.0 EV
NIKON D8100 mm f/-- lens50mmf/8.01/50s125 ISO+1.7 EV
NIKON D810Tamron SP AF 28-75mm f/2.8 XR Di LD Aspherical IF Macro (Nikon F) lens45mmf/11.01/50s140 ISO+0.3 EV
Harold Carlson wrote:
Wow, I can't believe it's been a year since I posted in this thread. I have been shooting IR on and off. I think it's something I like to do as a change-of-pace but even in the summer, you can't fake good light. I love the long shadows that early morning or evening light gives you.
I've been making changes to equipment this year as well. I sold my full spectrum D850 (which I somewhat regret) and I sold my full spectrum Canon EOS M5 (which I really regret as I am going back to that setup) and I have been experimenting with various gear. Ultimately, I am going with a more portable setup in a Canon EOS M5 as I have had that camera in the past and understand it's performance.
Here are some IR shots I have taken this year....Show more →
Great work, Herold! Thank you for keeping this thread alive.
I haven't done much IR shooting in the last two years, but here are some. I didn't post them in this thread because this thread is under the Sony forum and I have been shooting with the 830nm Canon R5 in the last 18 months. I guess anyone could post images from other brands here since we all like to see them. It's really a niche so it's good to have more participants.
I just bought a Sony A6700 specifically to convert to 830nm, should have it already for my trip to Zhangjiajie National Park and Guilin in China next month. Not sure if the trees in Zhangjiajie NP will still have leaves by the time we get there.
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens24mmf/8.01/20s100 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens50mmf/9.01/20s100 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens35mmf/8.01/25s200 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens34mmf/8.01/15s100 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens24mmf/9.01/25s100 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5EF16-35mm f/4L IS USM lens23mmf/10.01/10s100 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5EF16-35mm f/4L IS USM lens25mmf/8.01/40s250 ISO0.0 EV
Canon EOS R5RF24-50mm F4.5-6.3 IS STM lens50mmf/9.01/15s100 ISO0.0 EV
Douglas L wrote: secondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wroteFrogfish wroteHere are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
Will see....My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be. ...Show more →
Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?
Jack Flesher wrote: Douglas L wrotesecondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wroteFrogfish wroteHere are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
Will see....My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?
As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.
Douglas L wrote: Jack Flesher wroteDouglas L wrotesecondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wroteFrogfish wroteHere are a few taken yesterday with the Sony 10-20 PZ on a FS Sony A6000 with a Zomei 680nm filter. All taken at f4, various SS and all at either 10mm or 20mm (15mm or 30mm on FF).
I have not come across any hotspots whatsoever with the 10-20 PZ. It seems really really good in fact !
Note the shots below have been reduced from around 26MP each to ca. 1.0 to 1.5MP for online posting. They do seem a little darker after posting here than in 'real life'.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
Will see....My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.
Appreciate your reply. I did just that after posting this yesterday, and got this response:
The A7CR is one of the better cameras to have converted to Full Spectrum. Mainly because it does not have an internal diagnostic IR LED, which can cause light leaks. The Sony A7CR does not suffer from traditional Phase-Detection Autofocus (PDAF) grid artifacts or "striping/banding" after a full-spectrum conversion. The 61MP BSI CMOS sensor has proven highly resistant to these phase-detection pixel artifacts. You will not see the typical horizontal/vertical sensor mask banding in the sky from the autofocus readout points. Additionally, we have not received any complaints about banding with this camera.
So now I just need to decide if I’ll actually use it enough as an IR cam or even enough as a visible light cam to justify the total investment 🤷🏼
Jack Flesher wrote: Douglas L wroteJack Flesher wroteDouglas L wrotesecondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.
Douglas L wroteResurrecting this old thread.
Long story short, I liked my 830nm Sony A7III so much that I had a Sony A7RIV converted to 830nm because I wanted a higher resolution IR body. The banding/stripes in the sky were very very visible, due to the PDAF used in the Sony sensor. Kolari recommended the Canon R5 for 850nm conversion because Canon doesn't use PDAF. I love the IR Canon R5 but it's kind of big to lug around for limited usage. In my recent trip to Europe, I brought a Sony A1II, A7RVI and the IR Canon R5. Bringing a different battery charger adds a bit weight too.
Now I sort of want to come back to Sony for deep B&W IR. This time I am looking to convert a Sony A6700 to 830nm. I know the tiny Sony 28-60 has very little hot spot issues because I used it. For wider angle, I am thinking of getting the Sony E PZ 10-20mm f/4, based on Kevin's observation in his post.
Will see....My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.Appreciate your reply. I did just that after posting this yesterday, and got this response:
The A7CR is one of the better cameras to have converted to Full Spectrum. Mainly because it does not have an internal diagnostic IR LED, which can cause light leaks. The Sony A7CR does not suffer from traditional Phase-Detection Autofocus (PDAF) grid artifacts or "striping/banding" after a full-spectrum conversion. The 61MP BSI CMOS sensor has proven highly resistant to these phase-detection pixel artifacts. You will not see the typical horizontal/vertical sensor mask banding in the sky from the autofocus readout points. Additionally, we have not received any complaints about banding with this camera.
So now I just need to decide if I’ll actually use it enough as an IR cam or even enough as a visible light cam to justify the total investment 🤷🏼 ...Show more →
Interesting. I wonder if the A7CR converted to 850nm (instead of full spectrum+850nm filter) will show banding? The A7CR and the A7RV share the same sensor, I think. Joe Coleson's full spectrum A7RV+filter didn't show banding, according to him. But my 850nm A7RV showed very very messy banding. Maybe full spectrum conversion is the way to go
BTW, Life Pixel just converted my A6700 to 830nm and I should receive it back next week. Before I sent it to Life Pixel, I asked them if an 830nm A6700 will show banding, they said no. Will find out soon!
Douglas L wrote: Jack Flesher wroteDouglas L wroteJack Flesher wroteDouglas L wrotesecondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.Appreciate your reply. I did just that after posting this yesterday, and got this response:
The A7CR is one of the better cameras to have converted to Full Spectrum. Mainly because it does not have an internal diagnostic IR LED, which can cause light leaks. The Sony A7CR does not suffer from traditional Phase-Detection Autofocus (PDAF) grid artifacts or "striping/banding" after a full-spectrum conversion. The 61MP BSI CMOS sensor has proven highly resistant to these phase-detection pixel artifacts. You will not see the typical horizontal/vertical sensor mask banding in the sky from the autofocus readout points. Additionally, we have not received any complaints about banding with this camera.
So now I just need to decide if I’ll actually use it enough as an IR cam or even enough as a visible light cam to justify the total investment 🤷🏼Interesting. I wonder if the A7CR converted to 850nm (instead of full spectrum+850nm filter) will show banding? The A7CR and the A7RV share the same sensor, I think. Joe Coleson's full spectrum A7RV+filter didn't show banding, according to him. But my 850nm A7RV showed very very messy banding. Maybe full spectrum conversion is the way to go
BTW, Life Pixel just converted my A6700 to 830nm and I should receive it back next week. Before I sent it to Life Pixel, I asked them if an 830nm A6700 will show banding, they said no. Will find out soon!
They did specifically say “full spectrum” so perhaps there is something to the added sensor glass and filter spacing that eliminates the issue?
I’ll look forward to your A6700 images and thoughts! I vacillate between 720 and 830, and why the full spectrum plus filter option made more sense for me. I’m hoping my 20-70 zoom plays nice with ir.
Oh another PS FWIW bit of news. ACR currently goes down to 1500K color temp, so at least in my tests with 720, no need to do the DNG profile converter anymore for false or direct IR color, gray dropper actually works pretty well. Don't know when this changed, but IIRC it used to limit at 3000K...
Douglas L wrote: Jack Flesher wroteDouglas L wroteJack Flesher wroteDouglas L wrotesecondclaw wroteMy a7r3 doesn't show any banding and in general works really well with Kolari conversion. Its odd that 4 shows PDAF lines.
Mine is a full spectrum conversation and it works great with 720. At 850nm I see a more pronounced hot spot with some lenses.My 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.Appreciate your reply. I did just that after posting this yesterday, and got this response:
The A7CR is one of the better cameras to have converted to Full Spectrum. Mainly because it does not have an internal diagnostic IR LED, which can cause light leaks. The Sony A7CR does not suffer from traditional Phase-Detection Autofocus (PDAF) grid artifacts or "striping/banding" after a full-spectrum conversion. The 61MP BSI CMOS sensor has proven highly resistant to these phase-detection pixel artifacts. You will not see the typical horizontal/vertical sensor mask banding in the sky from the autofocus readout points. Additionally, we have not received any complaints about banding with this camera.
So now I just need to decide if I’ll actually use it enough as an IR cam or even enough as a visible light cam to justify the total investment 🤷🏼Interesting. I wonder if the A7CR converted to 850nm (instead of full spectrum+850nm filter) will show banding? The A7CR and the A7RV share the same sensor, I think. Joe Coleson's full spectrum A7RV+filter didn't show banding, according to him. But my 850nm A7RV showed very very messy banding. Maybe full spectrum conversion is the way to go
BTW, Life Pixel just converted my A6700 to 830nm and I should receive it back next week. Before I sent it to Life Pixel, I asked them if an 830nm A6700 will show banding, they said no. Will find out soon!
Interesting. The 6700 has more sensors to reflect covering more of the frame area. My stock sensored cameras will band under the right lighting conditions. I'll be curious to see what you find.
freaklikeme wrote: Douglas L wroteJack Flesher wroteDouglas L wroteJack Flesher wroteDouglas L wroteMy 830nm A7III showed minor banding/stripes, mainly in the sky, but not very visible. The 830nm A7RIV was a mess. I recall Joe Coleson posted some pages back that his full spectrum A7RIV didn't show banding either when using a Kolari 850nm filter. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that yours and Joe's are full spectrum conversion instead of 830nm conversion? In my chat with Kolari, they said the banding affects the A7RIII too if the conversion is 830nm. Basically, the higher the resolution, the darker the conversion, the more visible the banding will be.Any idea what the expected banding might be if I do a full-spectrum conversion to n A7CR, and then use Kolaris clip-in 720 and IR/UV?As I mentioned in one of my past posts, Joe Coleson had a full spectrum A7RIV and saw no banding with 830nm filter. I am guessing 720nm should be even better. The darker the conversion, the more visible the banding. Kolari's customer service folks are very knowledgeable and honest. I had numerous email exchanges with them regarding the banding issue. If I were you, I would shoot them an email.Appreciate your reply. I did just that after posting this yesterday, and got this response:
The A7CR is one of the better cameras to have converted to Full Spectrum. Mainly because it does not have an internal diagnostic IR LED, which can cause light leaks. The Sony A7CR does not suffer from traditional Phase-Detection Autofocus (PDAF) grid artifacts or "striping/banding" after a full-spectrum conversion. The 61MP BSI CMOS sensor has proven highly resistant to these phase-detection pixel artifacts. You will not see the typical horizontal/vertical sensor mask banding in the sky from the autofocus readout points. Additionally, we have not received any complaints about banding with this camera.
So now I just need to decide if I’ll actually use it enough as an IR cam or even enough as a visible light cam to justify the total investment 🤷🏼Interesting. I wonder if the A7CR converted to 850nm (instead of full spectrum+850nm filter) will show banding? The A7CR and the A7RV share the same sensor, I think. Joe Coleson's full spectrum A7RV+filter didn't show banding, according to him. But my 850nm A7RV showed very very messy banding. Maybe full spectrum conversion is the way to go
BTW, Life Pixel just converted my A6700 to 830nm and I should receive it back next week. Before I sent it to Life Pixel, I asked them if an 830nm A6700 will show banding, they said no. Will find out soon!Interesting. The 6700 has more sensors to reflect covering more of the frame area. My stock sensored cameras will band under the right lighting conditions. I'll be curious to see what you find.
That's what I thought too. The A6700's sensor has about the same density as the A7RIV's sensor. I asked Life Pixel before I decided to buy an A6700 for the sole purpose of 830nm conversion, given the horrible banding issue I had with the A7RIV 830nm conversion.
Here is what I wrote them: "I had a Sony A7III 830nm conversion and a Sony A7RIV 830nm conversion done by Life Pixel. The A7RVI showed really visible banding/stripes in the sky. I am wondering If you know the Sony A6700 830nm IR camera shows the banding too?".
Here is their reply: "I don't see any PDAF banding with any images from the A6700 converted with our Deep BW IR filter."
I asked a follow-up question as to why the A6700 doesn't have the banding issue since it has a dense sensor with PDAF, but never got a reply. Will find out next Wed when the 830nm A6700 arrive.
Okay, just for thread posterity and hopefully some revival with the three or four of us interested 😂 I found a used already converted A7Riv. It was done by Kolari to full spectrum and included 720, 830 and OEM Hot Mirror drop-in filters.
Based on what had been relayed here about the 61MP sensor banding in another members A7Riv, I was extremely skeptical, so had the seller send me a raw file to play with. It had a lot of busyness in it, but I saw no banding, so decided to give it a try. In the limited research I did, it appeared the Sony 20-70/4 lens I already owned was a good IR candidate with low (and generally usable) hot-spotting.
So I recently received it, navigated the HORRIBLE Sony menu system to get it basically set up. (All I can say is the A7CR and A7R6 menus are HUGELY better than the A7Riv. Anyway, I digress.) Took it into my backyard and here are a few examples for thread posterity.
My conclusion is, there must be some significant difference between full conversion and full spectrum as it relates to sensor banding, as I don't have any that I can see. Next, I can confirm the lens works reasonably enough for me, though there is some slight hot-spotting with associated slight center hue shift. Both seem subtle enough to not bother me for now, and moreover they all but disappear with an appropriate WB.
A note about my WB routine and I'd appreciate feedback. I set the cam to a low as it will go at 2500 and this is definitely workable for composition. It also seems to aid better auto-exposure than AWB. Next, I gray dropper and find in raw that 1700K -100 tint is close to rendering gray as gray, so that's my base starting point in the raw converter for the first 3 images. THe last sky image was interesting, because with tint at 0 and the minus 1700K, the sky went this blue -- slide the tint slider down and goes dark amber-red. Anyway, I thought it an interesting discussion point. For this last frame, I needed a +1 stop exposure boost in raw, but only needed a +½ stop for the first 3 images.
All FWIW...
Base file converted to full mono
RB channel swap false color
Full channel swap false color (more neutral grays and whites)
Very interesting that the full spectrum A7RIV doesn't show banding. Which IR filter did you use for these?
I received the 830nm A76700 back from Life Pixel an hour ago. Took a few test shots with the Sony PZ 10-20mm f4 lens. The good news is, the 830nm A6700 does not exhibit visible banding like my 830nm A7RIV; the bad news is, the 10-20mm lens shows very strong hotspot at 10mm (APS-C), but is mostly fine at 20mm. I didn't take shots in between.
ILCE-6700E PZ 10-20mm F4 G lens10mmf/6.31/250s100 ISO0.0 EV
ILCE-6700E PZ 10-20mm F4 G lens10mmf/6.31/250s100 ISO0.0 EV
ILCE-6700E PZ 10-20mm F4 G lens20mmf/6.31/250s100 ISO0.0 EV
ILCE-6700E PZ 10-20mm F4 G lens20mmf/6.31/250s100 ISO0.0 EV
Douglas L wrote:
Very interesting that the full spectrum A7RIV doesn't show banding. Which IR filter did you use for these?
I received the 830nm A76700 back from Life Pixel an hour ago. Took a few test shots with the Sony PZ 10-20mm f4 lens. The good news is, the 830nm A6700 does not exhibit visible banding like my 830nm A7RIV; the bad news is, the 10-20mm lens shows very strong hotspot at 10mm (APS-C), but is mostly fine at 20mm. I didn't take shots in between.
Here's a few from mine with the 830 just so you know. I actually bumped the exposure about 3 stops on the sky shot to try and force any banding, I just don't see any. Nor does it appear to hot-spot much if at all...