fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses

  
 
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.29 #1Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Steve Spencer wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
zhangyue wrote
imagesfromobjects wroteTransition zones are going to be really important for the 24mm. For environmental portraiture and street photography with people, you are going to be shooting between 1m and 3m, otherwise the subjects will be too small in the frame. 1m on 24mm FOV will cover approximately a full-body shot of a kid, or a head-and-torso of an adult. At f/3.5, that's going to give you <2 feet total DOF, so the transition will begin almost immediately after the subject. At 2m, you're going to have about 6 feet DOF coverage, so the transition zone will pretty much dominate the background. Any excessive structure is going to be difficult there, for any lens.

Fortunately, the shot of the woman walking up the steps (shot at f/5.6) looks really promising if you zoom in on the rocky/grassy area by her foot. Either way, I'm definitely going to pick one up. It's a no-brainer for my fp. Yeah, mayyyyybe a little bigger than I was hoping, but still will make for a compact setup.
---------------------------------------------

Fred Miranda wrote
imagesfromobjects wroteTransition zones are going to be really important for the 24mm. For environmental portraiture and street photography with people, you are going to be shooting between 1m and 3m, otherwise the subjects will be too small in the frame. 1m on 24mm FOV will cover approximately a full-body shot of a kid, or a head-and-torso of an adult. At f/3.5, that's going to give you <2 feet total DOF, so the transition will begin almost immediately after the subject. At 2m, you're going to have about 6 feet DOF coverage, so the transition zone will pretty much dominate the background. Any excessive structure is going to be difficult there, for any lens.

Fortunately, the shot of the woman walking up the steps (shot at f/5.6) looks really promising if you zoom in on the rocky/grassy area by her foot. Either way, I'm definitely going to pick one up. It's a no-brainer for my fp. Yeah, mayyyyybe a little bigger than I was hoping, but still will make for a compact setup.
It's interesting that most official samples are close-ups. I guess we will know more when we try it out and start shooting at 2m to see what's up.
I agree that the transition zone is particularly crucial for this lens since it will show behind the subject when shooting at mid-distance -- and without the help of blur to hide any possible roughness.

If it complements the 45/2.8's look, it could have nice rendering without much blur which is great for traveling.
I actually don't disagree with you two and we might be able to reveal the problems in 24mm images. I don't think I spend enough time to explain what is in my mind. (for my personal case though)
Here are some further discussion on this topic.

First of all, 45mm at f2.8 will give about the same amount of blur of 32mm f2. (almost identical to RX1's wider than 35mm lens) This will give a tough blur requirement and tons of case require background in my Lightroom lib for this focal.

for 24mm, the bokeh we are talking about and user case is in a different zone now.

1. You want blur at this focal, you might need go to faster glass at least f2 or say 24mm f1.4 unless do macro.
2. Most lens stop down to f3.5 or f4, things will smooth up a lot naturally (this is the advantage 45mm has over other ones compare against it) and that is why we naturally no longer talk about rendering for slow wide lens. Not that there is no difference between lenses in this focal but just not as a priority. (again, maybe just for me)
3. The DOF we use here is mainly for reasonable sharpness. The background blur of wide angle at f3.5 will be very different than a 35mm f2 or 50mmf1.4. The good looking and poor looking one tend to converge here. Don't let me prove it Let's go extreme, we never really talk about rendering of Leica 21mm SEM
4. Again, user case, for me, 24mm is starting point of 2470mm and end point of 1424 zoom. I do use them a lot, check my library, maybe 90% is deep dof stuff. For family image with story, usually are person with landscape or cityscape as background as well, even not deep DOF, the background seem still clear visible that not blur. I really have hard time to differentiate the rendering difference say between14-24mm and 24-70mm Nikon zoom at 24mm, even at f2.8. Take a shot at f2.8, you can see yourself at what distance, you start seeing bokeh and will you put your human subject in that distance?

I also have to admit I am into a different thinking after having FP in hand. I want a lens cap for a "lens cap" I bet many Sony A7C users would want the same.

Now back to rendering, transition zone is just one of the character. It is not like we have to evaluate this to differentiate lenses, otherwise we can't see the difference say between this sigma and Sony 35mm f1.8? There are many other problems out there. I see "tons" of difference in those samples between 35mm lenses out there. Just this thing require lots of times and experience and attention to know. you must care this first. To some, they are small, non-exist or doesn't matter. To me it could be a go or no go, simple as that. This sigma set might have transition problem here or there, but as mentioned, after initial samples, I get enough information already. if nitpicking, I wish both 35 and 65 can have a little bit more SA WO, it will smooth out face a lot, they both seems too pop for my taste but not a show stopper. For lens like samyang, I don't even care about rendering, the sample variation and build qualify are already enough to turn me around, but that is just me.
Something that differentiates the 24/3.5 is the high resolution and contrast at MFD (1:2 magnification). That leads me to think it's not under corrected for SA like the 45mm.

Here is a sample:
_https://www.sigma-global.com/common/lenses/cas/product/contemporary/c021_24_35/gallery/images/original_img01.jpg

Perhaps that's the differential for this lens and the reason Sigma is showing so many examples at MFD.
At this distance it's sharp, well corrected and with enough blur -- It's capable of compelling images despite its size and slow aperture. I suspect it will be amazing at infinity for landscapes as well.
That may be true, but another reason is surely that this is a macro lens, only the second ever 24mm macro after the recent Tamron. Since a lot of my photography is botanical (semi scientific stuff for a herbarium and native plant groups) I’m tempted just for this reason, though Loxia 25 with a tube works well. Though I wish this sigma had more blades for macro bokeh..
David, have you ever tried the Laowa 25 f/2.8 super high magnification (2.5X - 5X) macro? I have been curious about that lens for awhile. We might have several of these wide angle macros to compare before long. Obviously comparing the Tamron or the Sigma at .5X to the Laowa is a bit like comparing apples to oranges, but still I would love to see what each of these lenses do.


No I haven't. I've considered it - I use the Canon MP-E for 2-5x macro. I'm not entirely sure that the angle of view of the Laowa is what you'd expect from it's focal length, given that it has a much longer working distance than you would expect from a 25mm, so is it really wide angle, as you would expect from the FL? I don't really understand what happens with these designs. Something to read up on.
Dec 11, 2020 at 05:45 PM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.29 #2Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Strangely, the new Apple Silicon is more exciting to me than these lenses lately, and I've never been a Mac user. Why can't these companies learn from the like of Apple that on the day of the announcement, we can actually buy the actual items instead of more sitting here and speculating more.

That 24 would have been an instant if it was a 28. A close-up WA does give a very unique look, great for urban travel as the main/only lens.
Dec 11, 2020 at 06:51 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.29 #3Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
hiepphotog wrote:
Strangely, the new Apple Silicon is more exciting to me than these lenses lately, and I've never been a Mac user. Why can't these companies learn from the like of Apple that on the day of the announcement, we can actually buy the actual items instead of more sitting here and speculating more.

That 24 would have been an instant if it was a 28. A close-up WA does give a very unique look, great for urban travel as the main/only lens.


The fun thing about the ongoing speculation is that it's like obsessing over which subcompact car has more leg room, all while dismissing midsize cars and SUV's as being "unpractically large".
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:11 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.29 #4Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
hiepphotog wrote:
Strangely, the new Apple Silicon is more exciting to me than these lenses lately, and I've never been a Mac user. Why can't these companies learn from the like of Apple that on the day of the announcement, we can actually buy the actual items instead of more sitting here and speculating more.

That 24 would have been an instant if it was a 28. A close-up WA does give a very unique look, great for urban travel as the main/only lens.


28mm is evil. No one wants to make it. I got tired of begging.

I believe it would be your only lens. It's the most used focal length in the world. (phones)
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:16 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.29 #5Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
28mm is COVID I have no doubts about it
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:20 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #6Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
hiepphotog wrote:
Strangely, the new Apple Silicon is more exciting to me than these lenses lately, and I've never been a Mac user. Why can't these companies learn from the like of Apple that on the day of the announcement, we can actually buy the actual items instead of more sitting here and speculating more.

That 24 would have been an instant if it was a 28. A close-up WA does give a very unique look, great for urban travel as the main/only lens.


If there was no speculation...this place would be very quiet.
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:23 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #7Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
There are 28mm options...just use what best fits your needs. It's like when the A7r came out...not the best camera by far, but people made do with it.
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:25 PM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.29 #8Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses


hiepphotog wrote:
Strangely, the new Apple Silicon is more exciting to me than these lenses lately, and I've never been a Mac user. Why can't these companies learn from the like of Apple that on the day of the announcement, we can actually buy the actual items instead of more sitting here and speculating more.

That 24 would have been an instant if it was a 28. A close-up WA does give a very unique look, great for urban travel as the main/only lens.


Apple's habit of making products available immediately after launch is awesome. I wish it were emulated. I do like speculating, though, but that's what rumours are for. Drop a hint or two, maybe a leak to SAR, let the forums go crazy with speculation, then announce and release. As for Apple's silicon, I'll be more excited if the 16" gets a mini-LED display to go with it.

Also, add me to the list of people who would buy a 28mm. Maybe as this line fills out we'll see one from Sigma.
Dec 11, 2020 at 07:43 PM
timerickson
Offline
Details
p.29 #9Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
chez wrote:
There are 28mm options...just use what best fits your needs. It's like when the A7r came out...not the best camera by far, but people made do with it.


Huh? There's literally one 28mm, an f/2 with mediocre performance. There's no 28mm in G, GM, Loxia, Batis, nor from Sigma, Tamron, or Voigtlander.

Options plural would imply choice.
Dec 11, 2020 at 09:30 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #10Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
timerickson wrote:
chez wroteThere are 28mm options...just use what best fits your needs. It's like when the A7r came out...not the best camera by far, but people made do with it.
Huh? There's literally one 28mm, an f/2 with mediocre performance. There's no 28mm in G, GM, Loxia, Batis, nor from Sigma, Tamron, or Voigtlander.

Options plural would imply choice.


You are forgetting the Sigma 28 1.4...quite spectacular lens by most reviews.
Dec 11, 2020 at 09:48 PM
tsdevine
Online
Details
p.29 #11Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses

While that's true, it's basically a unibody DSLR+adapter design isn't it? There's also the FE Plus Sony optimized 7A 28, but you have to adapt from M and there's no lens communication.

I'm not sure there is more than one mirrorless design native E mount option, the FE 28/2.

I adapt for 28mm coverage, it really does seem as though there is a lack of choice.

-Tim

chez wrote:
timerickson wrote
chez wroteThere are 28mm options...just use what best fits your needs. It's like when the A7r came out...not the best camera by far, but people made do with it.
Huh? There's literally one 28mm, an f/2 with mediocre performance. There's no 28mm in G, GM, Loxia, Batis, nor from Sigma, Tamron, or Voigtlander.

Options plural would imply choice.
You are forgetting the Sigma 28 1.4...quite spectacular lens by most reviews.


Dec 11, 2020 at 09:52 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.29 #12Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
chez wrote:
timerickson wrote
chez wroteThere are 28mm options...just use what best fits your needs. It's like when the A7r came out...not the best camera by far, but people made do with it.
Huh? There's literally one 28mm, an f/2 with mediocre performance. There's no 28mm in G, GM, Loxia, Batis, nor from Sigma, Tamron, or Voigtlander.

Options plural would imply choice.
You are forgetting the Sigma 28 1.4...quite spectacular lens by most reviews.


Yes, but that's a SLR lens adapted to mirrorless...Sigma does make an E-mount version but it's just the same exact lens with an extension tube glued to it.

We are lacking 28mm lenses for mirrorless. Sony has the vanilla 28/2 which is good but not great (Also actually wider than 28mm). There is also the 7artisans 28/1.4 MF lens.

My last 28mm was the Zeiss 28/2 ZF adapted to Sony. Quite good even for landscapes but the corners needed f/8-11.
Dec 11, 2020 at 09:55 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.29 #13Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
DavidBM wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
zhangyue wrote
imagesfromobjects wroteTransition zones are going to be really important for the 24mm. For environmental portraiture and street photography with people, you are going to be shooting between 1m and 3m, otherwise the subjects will be too small in the frame. 1m on 24mm FOV will cover approximately a full-body shot of a kid, or a head-and-torso of an adult. At f/3.5, that's going to give you <2 feet total DOF, so the transition will begin almost immediately after the subject. At 2m, you're going to have about 6 feet DOF coverage, so the transition zone will pretty much dominate the background. Any excessive structure is going to be difficult there, for any lens.

Fortunately, the shot of the woman walking up the steps (shot at f/5.6) looks really promising if you zoom in on the rocky/grassy area by her foot. Either way, I'm definitely going to pick one up. It's a no-brainer for my fp. Yeah, mayyyyybe a little bigger than I was hoping, but still will make for a compact setup.
---------------------------------------------

Fred Miranda wroteIt's interesting that most official samples are close-ups. I guess we will know more when we try it out and start shooting at 2m to see what's up.
I agree that the transition zone is particularly crucial for this lens since it will show behind the subject when shooting at mid-distance -- and without the help of blur to hide any possible roughness.

If it complements the 45/2.8's look, it could have nice rendering without much blur which is great for traveling.
I actually don't disagree with you two and we might be able to reveal the problems in 24mm images. I don't think I spend enough time to explain what is in my mind. (for my personal case though)
Here are some further discussion on this topic.

First of all, 45mm at f2.8 will give about the same amount of blur of 32mm f2. (almost identical to RX1's wider than 35mm lens) This will give a tough blur requirement and tons of case require background in my Lightroom lib for this focal.

for 24mm, the bokeh we are talking about and user case is in a different zone now.

1. You want blur at this focal, you might need go to faster glass at least f2 or say 24mm f1.4 unless do macro.
2. Most lens stop down to f3.5 or f4, things will smooth up a lot naturally (this is the advantage 45mm has over other ones compare against it) and that is why we naturally no longer talk about rendering for slow wide lens. Not that there is no difference between lenses in this focal but just not as a priority. (again, maybe just for me)
3. The DOF we use here is mainly for reasonable sharpness. The background blur of wide angle at f3.5 will be very different than a 35mm f2 or 50mmf1.4. The good looking and poor looking one tend to converge here. Don't let me prove it Let's go extreme, we never really talk about rendering of Leica 21mm SEM
4. Again, user case, for me, 24mm is starting point of 2470mm and end point of 1424 zoom. I do use them a lot, check my library, maybe 90% is deep dof stuff. For family image with story, usually are person with landscape or cityscape as background as well, even not deep DOF, the background seem still clear visible that not blur. I really have hard time to differentiate the rendering difference say between14-24mm and 24-70mm Nikon zoom at 24mm, even at f2.8. Take a shot at f2.8, you can see yourself at what distance, you start seeing bokeh and will you put your human subject in that distance?

I also have to admit I am into a different thinking after having FP in hand. I want a lens cap for a "lens cap" I bet many Sony A7C users would want the same.

Now back to rendering, transition zone is just one of the character. It is not like we have to evaluate this to differentiate lenses, otherwise we can't see the difference say between this sigma and Sony 35mm f1.8? There are many other problems out there. I see "tons" of difference in those samples between 35mm lenses out there. Just this thing require lots of times and experience and attention to know. you must care this first. To some, they are small, non-exist or doesn't matter. To me it could be a go or no go, simple as that. This sigma set might have transition problem here or there, but as mentioned, after initial samples, I get enough information already. if nitpicking, I wish both 35 and 65 can have a little bit more SA WO, it will smooth out face a lot, they both seems too pop for my taste but not a show stopper. For lens like samyang, I don't even care about rendering, the sample variation and build qualify are already enough to turn me around, but that is just me.
Something that differentiates the 24/3.5 is the high resolution and contrast at MFD (1:2 magnification). That leads me to think it's not under corrected for SA like the 45mm.

Here is a sample:
_https://www.sigma-global.com/common/lenses/cas/product/contemporary/c021_24_35/gallery/images/original_img01.jpg

Perhaps that's the differential for this lens and the reason Sigma is showing so many examples at MFD.
At this distance it's sharp, well corrected and with enough blur -- It's capable of compelling images despite its size and slow aperture. I suspect it will be amazing at infinity for landscapes as well.
That may be true, but another reason is surely that this is a macro lens, only the second ever 24mm macro after the recent Tamron. Since a lot of my photography is botanical (semi scientific stuff for a herbarium and native plant groups) I’m tempted just for this reason, though Loxia 25 with a tube works well. Though I wish this sigma had more blades for macro bokeh..
David, have you ever tried the Laowa 25 f/2.8 super high magnification (2.5X - 5X) macro? I have been curious about that lens for awhile. We might have several of these wide angle macros to compare before long. Obviously comparing the Tamron or the Sigma at .5X to the Laowa is a bit like comparing apples to oranges, but still I would love to see what each of these lenses do.
No I haven't. I've considered it - I use the Canon MP-E for 2-5x macro. I'm not entirely sure that the angle of view of the Laowa is what you'd expect from it's focal length, given that it has a much longer working distance than you would expect from a 25mm, so is it really wide angle, as you would expect from the FL? I don't really understand what happens with these designs. Something to read up on.


The Laowa 25/2.8 sounds like it’s designed as a reverse mounted wide angle, much the same way as reverse mounting a manual focus Nikon F-mount wide angle with Nikon’s reverse ring BR2A. Of course the Laowa lens will be further optimized like e.g. the Olympus OM Zuiko 20/2 and 38/2.8 bellow lenses made for high magnification.
Dec 12, 2020 at 03:24 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.29 #14Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
bjornthun wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
zhangyue wrote---------------------------------------------

I actually don't disagree with you two and we might be able to reveal the problems in 24mm images. I don't think I spend enough time to explain what is in my mind. (for my personal case though)
Here are some further discussion on this topic.

First of all, 45mm at f2.8 will give about the same amount of blur of 32mm f2. (almost identical to RX1's wider than 35mm lens) This will give a tough blur requirement and tons of case require background in my Lightroom lib for this focal.

for 24mm, the bokeh we are talking about and user case is in a different zone now.

1. You want blur at this focal, you might need go to faster glass at least f2 or say 24mm f1.4 unless do macro.
2. Most lens stop down to f3.5 or f4, things will smooth up a lot naturally (this is the advantage 45mm has over other ones compare against it) and that is why we naturally no longer talk about rendering for slow wide lens. Not that there is no difference between lenses in this focal but just not as a priority. (again, maybe just for me)
3. The DOF we use here is mainly for reasonable sharpness. The background blur of wide angle at f3.5 will be very different than a 35mm f2 or 50mmf1.4. The good looking and poor looking one tend to converge here. Don't let me prove it Let's go extreme, we never really talk about rendering of Leica 21mm SEM
4. Again, user case, for me, 24mm is starting point of 2470mm and end point of 1424 zoom. I do use them a lot, check my library, maybe 90% is deep dof stuff. For family image with story, usually are person with landscape or cityscape as background as well, even not deep DOF, the background seem still clear visible that not blur. I really have hard time to differentiate the rendering difference say between14-24mm and 24-70mm Nikon zoom at 24mm, even at f2.8. Take a shot at f2.8, you can see yourself at what distance, you start seeing bokeh and will you put your human subject in that distance?

I also have to admit I am into a different thinking after having FP in hand. I want a lens cap for a "lens cap" I bet many Sony A7C users would want the same.

Now back to rendering, transition zone is just one of the character. It is not like we have to evaluate this to differentiate lenses, otherwise we can't see the difference say between this sigma and Sony 35mm f1.8? There are many other problems out there. I see "tons" of difference in those samples between 35mm lenses out there. Just this thing require lots of times and experience and attention to know. you must care this first. To some, they are small, non-exist or doesn't matter. To me it could be a go or no go, simple as that. This sigma set might have transition problem here or there, but as mentioned, after initial samples, I get enough information already. if nitpicking, I wish both 35 and 65 can have a little bit more SA WO, it will smooth out face a lot, they both seems too pop for my taste but not a show stopper. For lens like samyang, I don't even care about rendering, the sample variation and build qualify are already enough to turn me around, but that is just me.
Something that differentiates the 24/3.5 is the high resolution and contrast at MFD (1:2 magnification). That leads me to think it's not under corrected for SA like the 45mm.

Here is a sample:
_https://www.sigma-global.com/common/lenses/cas/product/contemporary/c021_24_35/gallery/images/original_img01.jpg

Perhaps that's the differential for this lens and the reason Sigma is showing so many examples at MFD.
At this distance it's sharp, well corrected and with enough blur -- It's capable of compelling images despite its size and slow aperture. I suspect it will be amazing at infinity for landscapes as well.
That may be true, but another reason is surely that this is a macro lens, only the second ever 24mm macro after the recent Tamron. Since a lot of my photography is botanical (semi scientific stuff for a herbarium and native plant groups) I’m tempted just for this reason, though Loxia 25 with a tube works well. Though I wish this sigma had more blades for macro bokeh..
David, have you ever tried the Laowa 25 f/2.8 super high magnification (2.5X - 5X) macro? I have been curious about that lens for awhile. We might have several of these wide angle macros to compare before long. Obviously comparing the Tamron or the Sigma at .5X to the Laowa is a bit like comparing apples to oranges, but still I would love to see what each of these lenses do.
No I haven't. I've considered it - I use the Canon MP-E for 2-5x macro. I'm not entirely sure that the angle of view of the Laowa is what you'd expect from it's focal length, given that it has a much longer working distance than you would expect from a 25mm, so is it really wide angle, as you would expect from the FL? I don't really understand what happens with these designs. Something to read up on.
The Laowa 25/2.8 sounds like it’s designed as a reverse mounted wide angle, much the same way as reverse mounting a manual focus Nikon F-mount wide angle with Nikon’s reverse ring BR2A. Of course the Laowa lens will be further optimized like e.g. the Olympus OM Zuiko 20/2 and 38/2.8 bellow lenses made for high magnification.


Likely so, but in my relatively limited experience reverse mounting alone doesn’t increase working distance as much as the Laowa over expectations for a 25. But I haven’t reversed a lens this short.
Dec 12, 2020 at 05:39 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.29 #15Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
DavidBM wrote:
bjornthun wrote
DavidBM wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wroteSomething that differentiates the 24/3.5 is the high resolution and contrast at MFD (1:2 magnification). That leads me to think it's not under corrected for SA like the 45mm.

Here is a sample:
_https://www.sigma-global.com/common/lenses/cas/product/contemporary/c021_24_35/gallery/images/original_img01.jpg

Perhaps that's the differential for this lens and the reason Sigma is showing so many examples at MFD.
At this distance it's sharp, well corrected and with enough blur -- It's capable of compelling images despite its size and slow aperture. I suspect it will be amazing at infinity for landscapes as well.
That may be true, but another reason is surely that this is a macro lens, only the second ever 24mm macro after the recent Tamron. Since a lot of my photography is botanical (semi scientific stuff for a herbarium and native plant groups) I’m tempted just for this reason, though Loxia 25 with a tube works well. Though I wish this sigma had more blades for macro bokeh..
David, have you ever tried the Laowa 25 f/2.8 super high magnification (2.5X - 5X) macro? I have been curious about that lens for awhile. We might have several of these wide angle macros to compare before long. Obviously comparing the Tamron or the Sigma at .5X to the Laowa is a bit like comparing apples to oranges, but still I would love to see what each of these lenses do.
No I haven't. I've considered it - I use the Canon MP-E for 2-5x macro. I'm not entirely sure that the angle of view of the Laowa is what you'd expect from it's focal length, given that it has a much longer working distance than you would expect from a 25mm, so is it really wide angle, as you would expect from the FL? I don't really understand what happens with these designs. Something to read up on.
The Laowa 25/2.8 sounds like it’s designed as a reverse mounted wide angle, much the same way as reverse mounting a manual focus Nikon F-mount wide angle with Nikon’s reverse ring BR2A. Of course the Laowa lens will be further optimized like e.g. the Olympus OM Zuiko 20/2 and 38/2.8 bellow lenses made for high magnification.
Likely so, but in my relatively limited experience reverse mounting alone doesn’t increase working distance as much as the Laowa over expectations for a 25. But I haven’t reversed a lens this short.


Way OT, but here goes
Working distance is 40-45mm depending on magnification, quite in line with the back focal distance of a DSLR wide angle. This is very much in line with how a dedicated bellow lens behaves, I think. Laowa likely employs all the tricks in the book here.
https://www.laowalenses.ca/product/25mm-ultra-macro/
Dec 12, 2020 at 08:07 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #16Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
Fred Miranda wrote:
We are lacking 28mm lenses for mirrorless.


+1

24mm seems to have become the "new 28mm". Even in other mfr / format, the 28mm (equiv) is frequently relegated to pancake lens design.

Whereas 28mm historically had stronger SLR offerings, recent mirrorless offerings seem to go 24mm - 35mm, jumping over 28mm. Oddly, this doesn't seem to be a brand preference, rather industry wide. Not sure I've understood why the 28mm has seen such a significantly decline. I find it to be a very useful lens ... whereas the same lens can be mounted on different bodies to achieve, moderate WA on FF and short, normal on APS-C (42mm equiv).
Dec 12, 2020 at 08:33 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.29 #17Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
RustyBug wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteWe are lacking 28mm lenses for mirrorless.
+1

24mm seems to have become the "new 28mm". Even in other mfr / format, the 28mm (equiv) is frequently relegated to pancake lens design.

Whereas 28mm historically had stronger SLR offerings, recent mirrorless offerings seem to go 24mm - 35mm, jumping over 28mm. Oddly, this doesn't seem to be a brand preference, rather industry wide. Not sure I've understood why the 28mm has seen such a significantly decline. I find it to be a very useful lens ... whereas the same lens can be mounted on different bodies to achieve, moderate WA on FF and short, normal on APS-C (42mm equiv).


A common thought is that most smartphones cameras have typically been 28mm equivalent, so maybe camera makers think they need to make sure that their wide lens doesn’t look similar in AOV.
Dec 12, 2020 at 02:19 PM
nehemiahphoto
Online
Details
p.29 #18Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
DavidBM wrote:
RustyBug wrote
Fred Miranda wroteWe are lacking 28mm lenses for mirrorless.
+1

24mm seems to have become the "new 28mm". Even in other mfr / format, the 28mm (equiv) is frequently relegated to pancake lens design.

Whereas 28mm historically had stronger SLR offerings, recent mirrorless offerings seem to go 24mm - 35mm, jumping over 28mm. Oddly, this doesn't seem to be a brand preference, rather industry wide. Not sure I've understood why the 28mm has seen such a significantly decline. I find it to be a very useful lens ... whereas the same lens can be mounted on different bodies to achieve, moderate WA on FF and short, normal on APS-C (42mm equiv).
A common thought is that most smartphones cameras have typically been 28mm equivalent, so maybe camera makers think they need to make sure that their wide lens doesn’t look similar in AOV.


I think this too.

With computation photography and increasing flexability, IQ of cameras phones and the lower expectations of 95% of the population compared to the FM’ers, I do wonder if cameras makers want to avoid that direct competition.
Dec 12, 2020 at 02:32 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #19Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
I highly doubt it has anything to do with direct competition from phones...they have bigger fish to worry about from the phone market. It just might be not as much need for a 28mm as we all think. Maybe the majority of photographers are happy with a wide angle like say a 24mm or a 20mm and then a traditional 35mm lens...skipping the need for a 28mm altogether.
Dec 12, 2020 at 02:52 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.29 #20Pre-order: Sigma 24mm f/3.5, 35mm f/2 and 65mm f/2 DG DN lenses
RustyBug wrote:
24mm seems to have become the "new 28mm".

This is true, and now seen with standard zooms. The old ranges of 28-70 and 28-85 (my personal fav) has become 24-70 and 24-105. Now 28mm is a FL you zoom past on the way to more respectable destinations.
Dec 12, 2020 at 03:02 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister