fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7

  
 
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I’d talk to Kolari, the only caveat is their thin glass can affect AWB, that was the biggest flaw with Sony. I’ve heard the Sigma Fp does much better with the AWB on a Kolari mod so it may be a Sony issue, not a glass issue.

LarsHP wrote:
I have now received the 28mm Summicron Asph II back from Leica in Germany, who did a thorough service, and it has come back optically very different. In other words, there was in fact something wrong with it. Now it performs much better, if not dramatically much better, on my Nikon Z6. This means it was mostly not the sensor glass that was causing the awful performance outside the center - it was the lens itself actually, which must have taken a beating while in the previous owners' possession.

Regarding the Kolari UT mod, I am not so sure if
...Show more →
Dec 12, 2020 at 04:12 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Now I have checked and found out that the plane of focus curves normally on the 28mm Summicron Asph II (#11672). This is great news, because this means the Kolari UT mod is out of the question. It would make the curvature even more pronounced instead of correcting it (if that lens had reverse field curvature on a stock Z6).

That's the end of the story for me, because the point of getting the UT mod was getting that specific lens to work on the Z6.

EDIT: That's NOT the end of the story. See below.

Edited on Dec 15, 2020 at 06:02 AM · View previous versions
Dec 13, 2020 at 06:26 AM
Postlm
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AdaptedLenses wrote:
I’d talk to Kolari, the only caveat is their thin glass can affect AWB, that was the biggest flaw with Sony. I’ve heard the Sigma Fp does much better with the AWB on a Kolari mod so it may be a Sony issue, not a glass issue.


Yes. SONY in camera AWB does not work at all, but I don't think this is an issue. I don't really understand why someone uploaded uncorrected images here, because I find it is easily manageable in Lightroom and/or custom white balance setting in Sony body even the user does not own precisely calibrated monitor. I'm sure that Nikon mod would be the same.
Dec 13, 2020 at 01:54 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.5 #4Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I'd been shooting with Kolari-modded Sonys for a few years now. I started with M-lenses and enjoyed shooting them. I'm getting ready to start a year of shooting nothing but adapted AF Nikon lenses (AF-D except for my 300/4, which is plain AF) and I've seen some improvement with them as well versus shooting them on my friend's D810 and 850. One thing that's greatly improved my satisfaction with the set-up is the use of UV/IR cut filters on my lenses. It's returned the AWB function to normal (good if I'm in a hurry) and improved the accuracy of setting custom WB. I find that most Sony-branded lenses with SLR-like distanced exit pupils aren't much impacted by the change in sensor coverings. It has more impact on the little manual Zeiss Loxia lenses and the Samyang/Rokinon offerings. I doubt you'd see much difference with the bulk of Nikon's S lenses. The upcoming pancake lenses might be a different story.
Dec 13, 2020 at 02:53 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
freaklikeme wrote:
I'd been shooting with Kolari-modded Sonys for a few years now. I started with M-lenses and enjoyed shooting them. I'm getting ready to start a year of shooting nothing but adapted AF Nikon lenses (AF-D except for my 300/4, which is plain AF) and I've seen some improvement with them as well versus shooting them on my friend's D810 and 850. One thing that's greatly improved my satisfaction with the set-up is the use of UV/IR cut filters on my lenses. It's returned the AWB function to normal (good if I'm in a hurry) and improved the accuracy of setting
...Show more →

Thanks for your input about white balance / colors with the Kolari UT mod.

When you say that you get better AWB when using UV/IR cut filters, that seems to imply that the Kolari UT filter lets some UV (or even some IR) through, right? Or how do you understand this? I think I have seen that Kolari recommends using UV filter on the lens when using UT converted cameras since their hot mirror lets some near UV in.

BTW: What UV/IR cut filters do you use? And which works best with wide angles?

There is one additional advantage doing the UT mod: There is no AA filter, so resolution will be improved (while getting occasional moiré as a downside).
Dec 14, 2020 at 05:08 AM
Postlm
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP, AA filter is not about resolution, in my humble opinion.

I shoot both film and digital, and I started believing that AA filter is the one that makes digital image look very digital. We can see aliasing noise as a moire. We also clearly see AA low pass filter effect, but we can see it ONLY when we compare it with AA filterless camera, because it it there ALL THE TIME.

Many seasoned audiophiles today use "NOS DAC" which does not have low pass filter, and they claim digital audio sounds much more analog with it, even aliasing noise is clearly measurable.
Dec 14, 2020 at 04:55 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.5 #7Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
freaklikeme wroteI'd been shooting with Kolari-modded Sonys for a few years now. I started with M-lenses and enjoyed shooting them. I'm getting ready to start a year of shooting nothing but adapted AF Nikon lenses (AF-D except for my 300/4, which is plain AF) and I've seen some improvement with them as well versus shooting them on my friend's D810 and 850. One thing that's greatly improved my satisfaction with the set-up is the use of UV/IR cut filters on my lenses. It's returned the AWB function to normal (good if I'm in a hurry) and improved the accuracy of setting custom WB. I find that most Sony-branded lenses with SLR-like distanced exit pupils aren't much impacted by the change in sensor coverings. It has more impact on the little manual Zeiss Loxia lenses and the Samyang/Rokinon offerings. I doubt you'd see much difference with the bulk of Nikon's S lenses. The upcoming pancake lenses might be a different story.
Thanks for your input about white balance / colors with the Kolari UT mod.

When you say that you get better AWB when using UV/IR cut filters, that seems to imply that the Kolari UT filter lets some UV (or even some IR) through, right? Or how do you understand this? I think I have seen that Kolari recommends using UV filter on the lens when using UT converted cameras since their hot mirror lets some near UV in.

BTW: What UV/IR cut filters do you use? And which works best with wide angles?

There is one additional advantage doing the
...Show more →

The Kolari does allow some UV through. I couldn't say if that's what impacts the performance, but it's certainly true.

I use a mixture of Leica-branded filters and B+W 486 (I think Leica rebrands the same glass for their filters). I also have a couple of Hoyas, one Hadia, one OptiWest, and a couple of custom filters with Hoya cm-500 and BG40 glass (which I think it what Kolari uses in their screw-in filters).

For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary for them introduces some other color problems that will necessitate a custom WB. Still, if you're interested, BG40's decent for ultra-wides but leaves some low-level IR transmission. Hoya cm-500's the best I've found. It has a hard cut-off at 750nm and then a second spike at around 1200-3100nm. It's what I use on my AF-D 20-35/2.8 when I'm using on my mono-converted rII.

You won't see a real resolution improvement (beyond the better performance with RF and film-era lenses) with the mod. I get a slight resolution advantage between my mono rII and Kolari-modded rIII, which share the same sensor, but the mono's sensor has been stripped of all coverglass and the CFA. Even at that, I have to pixel-peep to see any difference, it's so slight.
Dec 14, 2020 at 06:52 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Postlm wrote:
LarsHP, AA filter is not about resolution, in my humble opinion.

I shoot both film and digital, and I started believing that AA filter is the one that makes digital image look very digital. We can see aliasing noise as a moire. We also clearly see AA low pass filter effect, but we can see it ONLY when we compare it with AA filterless camera, because it it there ALL THE TIME.

Many seasoned audiophiles today use "NOS DAC" which does not have low pass filter, and they claim digital audio sounds much more analog with it, even aliasing noise
...Show more →

In one way we agree that with / without AA filter isn't about resolution: If resolution equals pixel count.

However, if resolution is defined as the ability to resolve fine details in an image, then the AA filter does have an impact. I say that based on the difference in resolution between my full spectrum converted Sony a7 and my Nikon Z6. Both have 24MP sensors (the Nikon even has slightly more than the Sony), but the converted Sony yields a resolution clearly above the stock Z6, not just slightly better.

The reason for this may have to do with lens / camera combination, but viewing the same scene taken with for instance Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.2 Asph VM or the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II on the modded a7 and stock Z6 respectively is a convincing experience.

To be honest, I am now reconsidering doing the Kolari UT mod after checking the images I took in September.
Dec 15, 2020 at 05:28 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
freaklikeme wrote:
The Kolari does allow some UV through. I couldn't say if that's what impacts the performance, but it's certainly true.

I use a mixture of Leica-branded filters and B+W 486 (I think Leica rebrands the same glass for their filters). I also have a couple of Hoyas, one Hadia, one OptiWest, and a couple of custom filters with Hoya cm-500 and BG40 glass (which I think it what Kolari uses in their screw-in filters).

For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary
...Show more →

I am quite surprised to read that you add hot mirror type filters to the one Kolari has in the Ultra Thin mod. If that is needed, then this suggests that the UT hot mirror is not cutting off the IR end enough. Regarding Schott BG40, I have read that it does leak a bit of IR and should be avoided in favor of BG39, which cuts more in the IR end of the spectrum.

I actually also have a mono converted D600 and I agree that the difference in resolution between that and a full spectrum camera isn't that great (even after converting the raw file in Monochrome2DNG). However, there is a quite big difference between my stock Z6 and the full spectrum converted Sony a7. The reason for that may be lens / camera combination, but on the other hand in the center of the image, sensor glass thickness should have practically no effect (based on what experts say), and I did see a clear resolution advantage in the images from the full spectrum sensor all over the image when I tested this in September.
Dec 15, 2020 at 05:58 AM
Postlm
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
However, if resolution is defined as the ability to resolve fine details in an image, then the AA filter does have an impact.


What I don't really understand is, why no pixel peeping is needed to see the difference between stock A7 vs A7 Kolari mod. I think I can easily tell the difference even the image is reduced to 720px jpg. Images from Kolari are less smeared and have warmer, more 3D, intimate and honest feeling to my eyes. So I guessed that more resolution is just one of the side effect of removal of AA filter (good side effect, though), and the direct impact of removal of AA filter would be, removal of cheap-looking AA filter "effect" that remains even the image size is reduced.
Dec 15, 2020 at 09:38 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Postlm wrote:
What I don't really understand is, why no pixel peeping is needed to see the difference between stock A7 vs A7 Kolari mod. I think I can easily tell the difference even the image is reduced to 720px jpg. Images from Kolari are less smeared and have warmer, more 3D, intimate and honest feeling to my eyes. So I guessed that more resolution is just one of the side effect of removal of AA filter (good side effect, though), and the direct impact of removal of AA filter would be, removal of cheap-looking AA filter "effect" that remains even the
...Show more →

I haven't noticed that myself, but I guess that when the image is downsized, the added resolution is carried with it. However, most photographers usually add sharpening after downsizing, so often we can't tell the difference just by looking at an image on Facebook etc.
Dec 15, 2020 at 11:14 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.5 #12Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
freaklikeme wroteThe Kolari does allow some UV through. I couldn't say if that's what impacts the performance, but it's certainly true.

I use a mixture of Leica-branded filters and B+W 486 (I think Leica rebrands the same glass for their filters). I also have a couple of Hoyas, one Hadia, one OptiWest, and a couple of custom filters with Hoya cm-500 and BG40 glass (which I think it what Kolari uses in their screw-in filters).

For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary for them introduces some other color problems that will necessitate a custom WB. Still, if you're interested, BG40's decent for ultra-wides but leaves some low-level IR transmission. Hoya cm-500's the best I've found. It has a hard cut-off at 750nm and then a second spike at around 1200-3100nm. It's what I use on my AF-D 20-35/2.8 when I'm using on my mono-converted rII.

You won't see a real resolution improvement (beyond the better performance with RF and film-era lenses) with the mod. I get a slight resolution advantage between my mono rII and Kolari-modded rIII, which share the same sensor, but the mono's sensor has been stripped of all coverglass and the CFA. Even at that, I have to pixel-peep to see any difference, it's so slight.
I am quite surprised to read that you add hot mirror type filters to the one Kolari has in the Ultra Thin mod. If that is needed, then this suggests that the UT hot mirror is not cutting off the IR end enough. Regarding Schott BG40, I have read that it does leak a bit of IR and should be avoided in favor of BG39, which cuts more in the IR end of the spectrum.

I actually also have a mono converted D600 and I agree that the difference in resolution between that and a full spectrum camera isn't that
...Show more →

Yeah, that's not what I said. For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary for them introduces some other color problems that will necessitate a custom WB. I only use absorption filters on the wides when I'm using my bare-sensor mono mod since the reflective filters increase vignetting and mess with color filters on that camera.

The problem with BG39 is the lower overall transmission in the visible spectrum, so, while is does have a hard cut-off at 800nm, the lower IR pollution also means less visible light in the exposure, so pick your poison. It's why I prefer CM-500.

As far as resolution, I can only speak to my experience, and using the same lens on the same target between a stock a7rII, a UT-modded rII or III and the bare sensor rII is minimal enough to be inconsequential to my eye. The transmission on the bare sensor is nearly a stop faster than a stock or Kolari-mod, which is awesome and can lead to cleaner, more detailed shots than I would get under the same conditions with one of the other cameras.
Dec 15, 2020 at 03:42 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
freaklikeme wrote:
Yeah, that's not what I said. For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary for them introduces some other color problems that will necessitate a custom WB. I only use absorption filters on the wides when I'm using my bare-sensor mono mod since the reflective filters increase vignetting and mess with color filters on that camera.

The problem with BG39 is the lower overall transmission in the visible spectrum, so, while is does have a hard cut-off at 800nm, the lower IR pollution
...Show more →

OK. Thanks for clarifying. (I have read that part about UV+IR cut filters introducing new problems with wide angle lenses.)

Regarding resolution, I think the different experiences are based on that you are comparing cameras that are without AA filter (Sony a7 R-series) in stock condition while I am comparing two cameras that have AA filters and then in one of them, it has been removed together with about 2mm of glass, so in my case you will see the difference between AA filter or no AA filter.

That said, the increased resolution in the center is less than in the sides, so sensor glass thickness definitely add to the equation.

(I also just discovered that I had maxed sharpness setting in the a7FS and moderate in the Z6 camera, which lead me to assume some differences when viewing the RAWs that were not as prominent after RAW-processing with identical sharpness settings.)
Dec 16, 2020 at 03:00 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.5 #14Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
freaklikeme wroteYeah, that's not what I said. For 24 and wider, if I only had the Kolari-modded camera, I'd just go with a good UV filter, simply because the type of glass necessary for them introduces some other color problems that will necessitate a custom WB. I only use absorption filters on the wides when I'm using my bare-sensor mono mod since the reflective filters increase vignetting and mess with color filters on that camera.

The problem with BG39 is the lower overall transmission in the visible spectrum, so, while is does have a hard cut-off at 800nm, the lower IR pollution also means less visible light in the exposure, so pick your poison. It's why I prefer CM-500.

As far as resolution, I can only speak to my experience, and using the same lens on the same target between a stock a7rII, a UT-modded rII or III and the bare sensor rII is minimal enough to be inconsequential to my eye. The transmission on the bare sensor is nearly a stop faster than a stock or Kolari-mod, which is awesome and can lead to cleaner, more detailed shots than I would get under the same conditions with one of the other cameras.
OK. Thanks for clarifying. (I have read that part about UV+IR cut filters introducing new problems with wide angle lenses.)

Regarding resolution, I think the different experiences are based on that you are comparing cameras that are without AA filter (Sony a7 R-series) in stock condition while I am comparing two cameras that have AA filters and then in one of them, it has been removed together with about 2mm of glass, so in my case you will see the difference between AA filter or no AA filter.

That said, the increased resolution in the center is less than in
...Show more →

Good point on the AA filter. I forget that I'm spoiled in that regard. Also, if memory serves, there were reports of the Z6 having a particularly strong AA filter when compared to the D750, so removing it may have a significant impact.
Dec 16, 2020 at 04:58 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
freaklikeme wrote:
Good point on the AA filter. I forget that I'm spoiled in that regard. Also, if memory serves, there were reports of the Z6 having a particularly strong AA filter when compared to the D750, so removing it may have a significant impact.


Initially I had the impression myself, that the AA filter in the Z6 was stronger than in previous 24MP cameras I have owned, but I don't think that is the case. It turned out that the default sharpening when opening in ACR was set to a pixel width of 2.0. When adjusting it down to around 1.0 or slightly lower, it looks normal.

- - -

For reference and possible use to some reading this thread:
I can conclude that, while field curvature on a stock Z6 isn't a problem with the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II, it's plain waste of money buying such an expensive lens for use on a stock mirrorless camera. Resolution outside the center is clearly compromised since the thicker sensor glass causes smearing. This is quite evident when comparing my full spectrum converted Sony a7 (with hot mirror filter on the lens) and the stock Nikon Z6 (lens naked). In short: Either get the Kolari UT mod or use it with a Leica M camera.
Dec 22, 2020 at 09:42 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I re-checked the field curvature of the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II on the stock Nikon Z6. It actually has a slight reverse field curvature. In other words, focus is slightly further away in the sides and corners than in the center. This is only seen when looking for it and not a big issue. That said, this means that when I get the Kolari UT conversion, the reverse field curvature should be gone.
Jan 10, 2021 at 03:37 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Well, I have now ordered the UT conversion (again) and will send the camera to Kolari Vision this Monday.

In the meantime, I have done further research regarding the color reproduction after converting to UT. I want to avoid using IR cut / hot mirror filters since Kolari themselves say that they recommend just using a UV filter. This suggests that the UT doesn't cut much UV, but does a decent job at cutting IR. Kolari Vision said to me in an email that the UT itself will not leak IR. It obviously doesn't cut as much red as a stock Sony camera, but based on their description I understand it that IR should be reduced enough to not be a problem (at least in normal lighting).

Since I am really impressed with the colors I am getting with the Nikon (Z6) in stock condition, I want to avoid a too big disappointment when seeing the colors of my UT converted camera. For this reason I have bought a X-Rite ColorChecker, which I have photographed under controlled lighting conditions (flash and halogen lamp) with my stock Z6, so when I get the UT converted camera back, I can check and compare the colors side by side. I can even use the DNG-profile software in Adobe Camera Raw which should be able to tune the colors to perfection.

Since I also have a full spectrum converted Sony a7, I have a 700nm IR pass filter and a UV pass filter (stack). This allows me to check for IR and UV contamination in both the stock and UT converted camera. I expect zero UV and negligible IR from the stock camera of course, but there might be a leak in IR after the UT conversion since it apparently only employs a thin hot mirror filter. In practice, I will take a picture with correct exposure (in manual) and then add the filter and take one shot more and see. If there is any exposure, it will be IR or UV leak respectively.

The graph below (published at petapixel.com) show the transmission of the stock hot mirror filters on Sony, Nikon and Canon (and a few Fujifilm) digital cameras, which Kolari Vision has removed and measured. It is obvious that Sony cuts the most in the red end of the spectrum followed by Nikon and then Canon. (I will leave out Fujifilm since there is no UT conversion service to those cameras.)

As I have understood it, the UT conversion will make the color balance warmer (more reds) on a Sony camera. When looking at the graph below, it suggests that the UT filter on a Nikon, and even more so on a Canon camera, will mimic the original filter better than on a Sony, and this leads me to the understanding that Nikon Z and Canon R cameras will have less problems with the colors than Sony cameras after the UT conversion.

One more obvious thing we can see from the graph is that the UV cut is quite sharp on all cameras, and it's within the 400-700nm range, not outside. In fact, all the stock filters sharply cuts away everything below 400nm. Sony lets in the most in the violet end of spectrum and Nikon the least. Nikon's graph is centered around 417-420nm, Canon 415nm and Sony 405-410nm.

Those numbers mean that many so-called UV filters are not very helpful when replacing the stock sensor glass with the UT filter, which apparently has a slow UV cut-off. To name a dreadful example, the otherwise solid B+W 010 UV Haze filters are a waste of money for this use (and in my opinion; any UV cut purpose). Particularly Nikon and Canon users need UV filters that cut away below at least 410nm, but almost all UV filters cut below 395nm at best. Sony users should still get UV filters that cut around 410nm, but will not get the same color science penalty as the Canikon users most likely will.

The only UV filters that are useful enough for this use are Zeiss T* UV filter, Tiffen Digital HT (check the LensRentals blog) and Kenko Zeta UV L41 filter. (If you see "L41" in the product name, you are probably safe since L41 signifies the 410nm cut frequency.) Many Hoya filters cut sharply just outside 400nm, so will most likely be fine on Sony cameras, but might not work as well on Nikon and Canon.

https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2020/06/bigchart.jpg


Jan 24, 2021 at 06:51 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Kolari Vision should have been done with my camera this Monday at the latest (after two full weeks). They received it almost three weeks ago, so I emailed them yesterday and was told it will be shipped on next Monday. The excuse is apparently "multiple blizzards" in New Jersey. I would have liked to get a notice about the delay...
Feb 26, 2021 at 05:40 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Today I finally received my camera with UT conversion from Kolari Vision. To my pleasant surprise, auto white balance seems to work relatively well. The graph above may explain why it works better on a Nikon than a Sony camera. That said, this is just my initial impression. I will test it thoroughly and report back.
Mar 11, 2021 at 04:34 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I can see that when using auto white balance outdoors, it generally looks fine, but when going inside in warmer light, the white balance looks warmer and what's worse; the red channel will go into clipping much easier than on a stock camera. This is certainly something I need to be careful with. I also think red colors are on the intense side. The UT filter obviously cuts less red than the stock sensor glass, but not so much that the Nikon Z6 can't compensate for it in AWB.

Regarding infrared leak, it seems negligible at worst. You really need to know what to look for to see it and even then, it seems to be just a faint touch of IR in the blacks. I will test properly later. The stock camera has both a sharp UV and IR cutting filter as well as a colored filter while the Kolari UT mod only has a colored filter.
Mar 11, 2021 at 09:34 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister