fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7

  
 
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
Update! Good news and bad news.

After scrutinizing infinity shots with focus placed in the center, the sides and the corners, it became apparent that the focus plane was skewed; mostly tilted, but also a bit swinged. I have since modified the adapter to get the best possible focus symmetry and after that, the reverse field curvature persists, but looks much less apparent since what I initially saw wasn't only field curvature, but a combination with tilted focus plane.

In other words, the good news is that the reverse field curvature is much less than it looked. The bad news
...Show more →

In my view, the Summicron 28mm is way ahead of the other wide angle M mount lenses that we have discussed, though it is not perfect on the Z series. I use a Novoflex adapter, which I think is manufactured to very low tolerances. I don't know where you got the 28mm Summicron from, but a bargain price is often an indication that the seller tried to sell the lens before and had to take it back.

Sep 25, 2020 at 08:33 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
@ Steve Spencer
Well, you are right that I could just use different adapters. I may consider that if I can't find a compromise. However, there is a warranty from the reseller of the 28mm cron Asph II which I'd rather make use of, if it in fact is off. I have asked if there is a Leica M shooter in a local photography group and there is one who has a M240, who responded. Hopefully we can meet and do a test. That way I will also get to see how a "real" Leica M camera performs with the lenses I have.

BTW:
I read someone who said that he got the "Italian flag" issue on his M9 with a 28mm Elmarit Asph! In other words, this is not just a "mirrorless camera with M wide angle lens"-problem. I am quite ... ehm ... surprised to hear that.
Sep 25, 2020 at 12:06 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote:
In my view, the Summicron 28mm is way ahead of the other wide angle M mount lenses that we have discussed, though it is not perfect on the Z series. I use a Novoflex adapter, which I think is manufactured to very low tolerances. I don't know where you got the 28mm Summicron from, but a bargain price is often an indication that the seller tried to sell the lens before and had to take it back.

Since the reseller offers a three-month warranty on used gear, I think I am safe, but you may actually have a point there.

It was for sale for several months before I bought it, but they didn't note (in the ad on their website) that it was the second aspherical / newest version which may explain why they didn't sell it sooner.
Sep 25, 2020 at 12:15 PM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Hey, who did you speak to at Kolari who gave you the date they'd be getting a shipment in?

I'm starting to feel like they're giving me the runaround. They offered to do the conversion for a reduced price since it would be a "test subject" but they've been saying for weeks now that they have no word on when they're getting the shipment in. Which is all understandable due to COVID but it's been over a month now and they also have my Sigma 45/2.8 lens.

It was nice of them to offer this but I'm starting to get really annoyed and now I hear they're told someone else Mid October? What the heck, y'all.
Sep 25, 2020 at 12:49 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
imagesfromobjects wrote:
Hey, who did you speak to at Kolari who gave you the date they'd be getting a shipment in?

I'm starting to feel like they're giving me the runaround. They offered to do the conversion for a reduced price since it would be a "test subject" but they've been saying for weeks now that they have no word on when they're getting the shipment in. Which is all understandable due to COVID but it's been over a month now and they also have my Sigma 45/2.8 lens.

It was nice of them to offer this but I'm starting to get really
...Show more →
I got the date from William Martinez in an email on September 22nd.

That said, they talk about the Ultra Thin filter for Nikon Z6 (quote: "... we recently ran out of stock on our thin-filters for your camera ..."), and that may be a slightly different size than the one for the Sigma FP. This is of course guesswork, but might explain it.
Sep 25, 2020 at 01:15 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
@ Steve Spencer
Well, you are right that I could just use different adapters. I may consider that if I can't find a compromise. However, there is a warranty from the reseller of the 28mm cron Asph II which I'd rather make use of, if it in fact is off. I have asked if there is a Leica M shooter in a local photography group and there is one who has a M240, who responded. Hopefully we can meet and do a test. That way I will also get to see how a "real" Leica M camera performs with the lenses
...Show more →

Leica lenses that were designed for film may have issues with Leica sensors as well, because the stack thickness of Leica sensors is small, but not zero.

Sep 25, 2020 at 02:27 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
@ AcuteShadows
The 28mm Elmarit-M Asph v1 was introduced in 2006, the same year as the M8. While the M8 is a crop camera, it's only 1.33×. Leica introduced the M9 just three years later, so I feel confident that Leica knew that the lens would be used on full frame digital cameras soon. In other words, I don't find much to excuse this design fault. The only thing that makes sense, is that Leica was relying on 6-bit coding to cover this issue. Not impressive for a high end lens/camera manufacturer in my opinion.
Sep 26, 2020 at 03:58 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Re: Update with good and bad news.
After further fine-tuning of the adapter, I get both the 28mm Asph II and the other M mount lenses to have symmetrical focus at infinity, so none of the lenses are off, as I thought at one point.
Sep 26, 2020 at 04:25 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
@ AcuteShadows
The 28mm Elmarit-M Asph v1 was introduced in 2006, the same year as the M8. While the M8 is a crop camera, it's only 1.33×. Leica introduced the M9 just three years later, so I feel confident that Leica knew that the lens would be used on full frame digital cameras soon. In other words, I don't find much to excuse this design fault. The only thing that makes sense, is that Leica was relying on 6-bit coding to cover this issue. Not impressive for a high end lens/camera manufacturer in my opinion.


The M8 sensor stack is thinner than the stack of current M cameras. In a way, I think Leica was trying to adjust the digital cameras to the lenses, not the lenses to the cameras - an effort that appears understandable given that Leica users had a huge investment in lenses that were supposed to last decades. And you need to use filters with the M8 to cut out light that wasn't filtered out by the sensor stack. My take is that only with the M9 the design of the M lenses swiched from trying to be compatible to past lenses to trying to be compatible with future cameras.

Sep 26, 2020 at 07:48 AM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
BTW:
I read someone who said that he got the "Italian flag" issue on his M9 with a 28mm Elmarit Asph! In other words, this is not just a "mirrorless camera with M wide angle lens"-problem. I am quite ... ehm ... surprised to hear that.


I never saw that. The 28 Elmarit Asph was perfect on my M-E ( M9).
Sep 26, 2020 at 08:28 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
After making another aperture series with the 28mm Summicron Asph II of a landscape with the fine-tuned adapter, I think the reverse field curvature on the Z6 is weak enough that it isn't readily visible.

However, the sharpness across the frame on the Z6 is depressing considering the price of the lens. It really is a tremendous waste of money for _that_ lens on _that_ camera. To be honest, the 7Artisans is sharper in the center @ f/2.8. Okay, it's a f/1.4 lens versus a f/2 lens, but still ... the 7Artisans is literally a fraction of the price.

It should of course be noted, that the Leica lens is designed for a thin sensor stack while the 7Artisans is designed for the thicker Sony stack, but on the other hand, I have read Roger Cicala at Lens Rentals saying that we should not expect to see much difference in the center regarding the sensor stack thickness with different lenses. This may of course be wrong.

When I put the Leica on the full spectrum converted Sony a7, it looks much, much better. Again, this tells me that I need a thin sensor glass with this lens and at present it means doing the Ultra Thin conversion when they get the parts in stock. Next week I will hopefully meet a local who has a Leica M (240) so I can see how the M lenses perform on the intended camera.

All that said, the 90mm Apo and Nokton f/1.2 Asph VM looks stellar on the Z6.
Sep 26, 2020 at 12:59 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
After making another aperture series with the 28mm Summicron Asph II of a landscape with the fine-tuned adapter, I think the reverse field curvature on the Z6 is weak enough that it isn't readily visible.

However, the sharpness across the frame on the Z6 is depressing considering the price of the lens. It really is a tremendous waste of money for _that_ lens on _that_ camera. To be honest, the 7Artisans is sharper in the center @ f/2.8. Okay, it's a f/1.4 lens versus a f/2 lens, but still ... the 7Artisans is literally a fraction of the price.

It
...Show more →

My 28mm Summicron ASPH is not perfect in the corners, but it outresolves the Z7 sensor in the center (moiré, pixel stepping of near central or horizontal thin lines). So I don't think any you would see any difference to a better lens on the Z6 sensor. Given your observations, I would still test if the 28mm Summicron ASPH (or the adapter) might be defective in some way.
Sep 26, 2020 at 01:38 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote:
My 28mm Summicron ASPH is not perfect in the corners, but it outresolves the Z7 sensor in the center (moiré, pixel stepping of near central or horizontal thin lines). So I don't think any you would see any difference to a better lens on the Z6 sensor. Given your observations, I would still test if the 28mm Summicron ASPH (or the adapter) might be defective in some way.


I did actually see moiré in one of the test shots I did with the a7FS, so this is promising. That camera has gotten removed all layers of sensor glass apart from the protection glass, so it's without the AA filter too. (I think that's the only shot with that camera where I have seen moiré.)

Otherwise, I actually don't know how to tell if my sample of the lens underperforms apart from testing it side by side with another sample of the same lens, but I don't have access to that. The best I can do is compare it to other lenses with similar focal lengths.

I should add, that it looks like the sharpness increases as I focus closer and in my experience it's usually a sign that the exit pupil distance is too short for the sensor glass thickness.

Edit:
I just looked at the official MTF charts of the 90mm Apo-Summicron-M and the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II and the latter should be stunning; definitely sharper wide open than even the famous tele lens. This implies that the 28mm is severely underperforming, either because of the mismatch with the sensor or because there is something wrong with the lens.
Sep 26, 2020 at 01:59 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
AcuteShadows wroteMy 28mm Summicron ASPH is not perfect in the corners, but it outresolves the Z7 sensor in the center (moiré, pixel stepping of near central or horizontal thin lines). So I don't think any you would see any difference to a better lens on the Z6 sensor. Given your observations, I would still test if the 28mm Summicron ASPH (or the adapter) might be defective in some way.
I did actually see moiré in one of the test shots I did with the a7FS, so this is promising. That camera has gotten removed all layers of sensor glass apart from the protection glass, so it's without the AA filter too. (I think that's the only shot with that camera where I have seen moiré.)

Otherwise, I actually don't know how to tell if my sample of the lens underperforms apart from testing it side by side with another sample of the same lens, but I don't have access to that. The best I can do is compare it
...Show more →

The degradation of the acuity of a f/2 lens due to the sensor stack should be very minor in the center of the image. https://www.photo.net/discuss/threads/m8-sensor-filter-thickness-and-astigmatism.282546/ By the time you see a degradation of acuity in the center, the periphery should already be more or less unusable.

Sep 26, 2020 at 03:33 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
@ Steve Spencer
Well, you are right that I could just use different adapters. I may consider that if I can't find a compromise. However, there is a warranty from the reseller of the 28mm cron Asph II which I'd rather make use of, if it in fact is off. I have asked if there is a Leica M shooter in a local photography group and there is one who has a M240, who responded. Hopefully we can meet and do a test. That way I will also get to see how a "real" Leica M camera performs with the lenses
...Show more →

The Italian flag was very real when the M9 was first introduced. Many photographers were very frustrated and came up with many fixes. Then finally Leica fixed the problem with a FW update and the problem was resolved.
Sep 27, 2020 at 01:42 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
charles.K wrote:
LarsHP wroteI read someone who said that he got the "Italian flag" issue on his M9 with a 28mm Elmarit Asph! In other words, this is not just a "mirrorless camera with M wide angle lens"-problem. I am quite ... ehm ... surprised to hear that.
The Italian flag was very real when the M9 was first introduced. Many photographers were very frustrated and came up with many fixes. Then finally Leica fixed the problem with a FW update and the problem was resolved.


Thanks for affirming it. This probably means that the lenses with quite short exit pupil makes color casts on every full frame digital sensor on the market, not only mirrorless cameras like Sony a7 series. If Leica makes an M camera with BIS sensor it may improve or even remove the issue, but as far as I can see from a quick search, none are made so far.
Sep 27, 2020 at 05:32 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote:
The degradation of the acuity of a f/2 lens due to the sensor stack should be very minor in the center of the image. https://www.photo.net/discuss/threads/m8-sensor-filter-thickness-and-astigmatism.282546/ By the time you see a degradation of acuity in the center, the periphery should already be more or less unusable.


Yes, I have seen that graph from Caldwell over at LensRentals. It does suggest, that the lens isn't as sharp as it should be.
Sep 27, 2020 at 05:35 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Today I talked to the shop / sales agent on the phone. I am sending the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II back to them and they will send it to Leica in Germany. The sales agent "warned" me that I wouldn't see the lens in three months since Leica service is slow, but thorough.

I did yet another side by side test this morning that confirmed that the Summicron is underperforming (based on the official MTF chart). This time with Voigtländer Ultron 21mm f/1.8; both on Sony a7FS and @ f/2. The Ultron was noticeably sharper in the center, so the Summicron isn't as sharp as it's supposed to be.

This means I will wait with the Ultra Thin conversion until I get the lens back from Leica. Perhaps the lens will perform much better on the stock Z6 after the service in which case I might not get the conversion.

Thanks to everyone who responded.
Sep 28, 2020 at 12:03 PM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
Today I talked to the shop / sales agent on the phone. I am sending the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II back to them and they will send it to Leica in Germany. The sales agent "warned" me that I wouldn't see the lens in three months since Leica service is slow, but thorough.

I did yet another side by side test this morning that confirmed that the Summicron is underperforming (based on the official MTF chart). This time with Voigtländer Ultron 21mm f/1.8; both on Sony a7FS and @ f/2. The Ultron was noticeably sharper in the center, so the
...Show more →

You will still have the color shift towards cyan in the periphery. This is less with Leica M, and there is a profile, so the remaining variation in color is just due to changes of the lens color cast with aperture (which the camera does not know) and possibly focal distance (which may not be fully captured by the lens profile). I have produced lens color cast profiles in Capture One to correct the color shift, but these profiles do not really work since Capture One 20 was issued (bugs have been fixed only to result in or reveal different bugs). Thus, doing the conversion is probably still a good idea. I'm getting somewhat impatient with Capture One, so I'm thinking about finally buying a Leica camera in order to resolve the color shift issue.

Sep 28, 2020 at 01:59 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I have now received the 28mm Summicron Asph II back from Leica in Germany, who did a thorough service, and it has come back optically very different. In other words, there was in fact something wrong with it. Now it performs much better, if not dramatically much better, on my Nikon Z6. This means it was mostly not the sensor glass that was causing the awful performance outside the center - it was the lens itself actually, which must have taken a beating while in the previous owners' possession.

Regarding the Kolari UT mod, I am not so sure if I should do it, considering how the 28mm performs now. However, I might end up doing it anyway because I mostly shoot M lenses and I would like the extra resolution that an AA free sensor yields. This of course could be obtained with a Z7, which on the other hand probably won't perform as well as the Z6 (having a 24MP BIS sensor) regarding steep angles of light, so still undecided on what to do. I might have to compare the two cameras with the 28mm Summicron to see how it plays in practice before I decide what to do.
Dec 12, 2020 at 12:14 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister