p.1 #1Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
It appears that it is mostly (if not entirely) Sony a7 series cameras that people have posted about the (ultra) thin sensor glass conversion, but Kolari offers this service to Nikon Z, Canon R and Panasonic S1 series cameras too.
Did anyone here get an Ultra Thin sensor glass conversion from Kolari Vision?
I have ordered it, but if anyone here has done it and would advise against it, I am all ears and eyes.
I am primarily going to use the camera with M mount lenses, including wide angle lenses.
p.1 #2Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I personally have not gotten this particular conversion, but I have modified my Z6 to be more sensitive to H Alpha for astrophotography.
My only concern about this mod is how it will effect the PDAF. Mine works perfectly fine but that is because they replace all removed filters with clear ones to make sure the overall sensor thickness is maintained.
However, how much better specific Leica M lenses (wide-angles?) do perform after this modification? and how much this modification do impact the performance of Nikkor Z lenses, which were designed, I guess, to fit the original sensor cover glass?
p.1 #4Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I've been using LTM, M and legacy F lenses, ultra wides, wides , normal and short tele on my Z and M-240 since November 2018. There is no difference in the IQ between the two. I haven't seen any Z or R user reports of the types of problems encountered with E bodies since 2018. The mod may be a solution looking for a problem...
p.1 #5Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I have naturally searched the internet thoroughly before ordering the UT conversion and have only bought M mount lenses that are reported to work well on mirrorless cameras like Voigtländer 15mm f/4.5 III, 21mm f/1.8, 50mm f/1.2, Leica 90mm Elmarit-M and 7Artisans 28mm f/1.4 FE+.
Lately I jumped on a Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II (#11672) which is reported* working much better than the first version (#11602). However, when I got it, the new (2016) model does not perform well on the Z6. It shows severe reverse field curvature and astigmatism outside the image center. Luckily I have a full spectrum converted Sony a7 on which it performs brilliantly (with a hot mirror filter on the lens), so this tells me that it is the sensor filter stack which is the problem. In other words, the Ultra Thin conversion was all of a sudden very real option since all my M mount lenses will benefit and that little new gem of a lens will perform much nearer its potential.
p.1 #6Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
mapgraphs wrote:
I've been using LTM, M and legacy F lenses, ultra wides, wides , normal and short tele on my Z and M-240 since November 2018. There is no difference in the IQ between the two. I haven't seen any Z or R user reports of the types of problems encountered with E bodies since 2018. The mod may be a solution looking for a problem...
I didn't have any issues with the carefully selected M mount lenses I have gotten until I got the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II (#11672). With that lens, there are very obvious problems with reverse field curvature and astigmatism.
Edit: I should add, that I have tested my Nikon Z6 side-by-side with my (now sold) Sony a7II with several M mount wide angle lenses and while the Z6 performed slightly better, the difference was rather small and mostly seen in the extreme corners. This was with the wides I have bought that are reported to work well with Sony sensors.
p.1 #7Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
It really helps to understand how a particular M/LTM lens works on an M body. It comes down to the inherent design intent of a lens (as much as it can be discerned from use and the meager data on lens designs available).
Some photojournalist lenses were never designed to have clean edges or corners. That goes for M/LTM lenses and legacy F lenses. The 20mm UD for instance is not sharp to the edges but it is sharper in the center than other 20mm F mounts... One needs to know each specific lens, on the body it was designed to work with before one can make blanket statements about how one thinks they should work on non-native bodies.
Not all M/LTM lenses are equal. What I have found is that M/LTM lenses behave exactly the same on my Z7 as they do on my M-240. I cannot say the same for my Sony. If there are lens design issues that appears on the M-240, such as pronounced coma wide open for example, the same exact signature will be there on the Z7, no more ,no less.
Probably more to the point however, if one is contemplating a sensor mod, it pays to do due-diligence by looking at the wide variety results from mods. Mods seem to be all over the place with some users getting improved edges and corners and other users seeing little or no improvement. Which to me says there's more going on than simple cover glass thickness...
p.1 #8Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
I have naturally searched the internet thoroughly before ordering the UT conversion and have only bought M mount lenses that are reported to work well on mirrorless cameras like Voigtländer 15mm f/4.5 III, 21mm f/1.8, 50mm f/1.2, Leica 90mm Elmarit-M and 7Artisans 28mm f/1.4 FE+.
Lately I jumped on a Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II (#11672) which is reported* working much better than the first version (#11602). However, when I got it, the new (2016) model does not perform well on the Z6. It shows severe reverse field curvature and astigmatism outside the image center. Luckily I have a full spectrum converted Sony a7 on which it performs brilliantly (with a hot mirror filter on the lens), so this tells me that it is the sensor filter stack which is the problem. In other words, the Ultra Thin conversion was all of a sudden very real option since all my M mount lenses will benefit and that little new gem of a lens will perform much nearer its potential.
I think your results are consistent with Jono Slack's review. He reports the new version of the 28 cron Asph is better than the old version on Sony. He doesn't hide, however, that the lens still suffers considerably compared to how it performs on a Leica M camera (the Leica SL is in between). If you want to use this lens on a Nikon Z camera, then the ultra thin modification should considerably improve its performance, but there is likely to be a cost that Z mount lens won't perform quite as well. If you are going to use M mount lenses exclusively then the conversion could be very nice. Watch for white balance issues, however, as some report that can be a problem with the Kolari conversion.
Another alternative if you haven't considered it is using Sony E mount lenses on the Nikon Z cameras and I am thinking particularly of the Zeiss Loxia and Voigtlander lenses. Laowa also makes some very interesting nicely made manual focus lenses and you can even get most of them in Z mount (without electronic contacts, however). There are a number of excellent options if you go this way, but you won't get anything like the 28 cron. One lens you should consider for the Z cameras, however, is the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO for Sony E mount. Just a stunningly good lens and not even that expensive.
p.1 #9Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote: mapgraphs wroteI've been using LTM, M and legacy F lenses, ultra wides, wides , normal and short tele on my Z and M-240 since November 2018. There is no difference in the IQ between the two. I haven't seen any Z or R user reports of the types of problems encountered with E bodies since 2018. The mod may be a solution looking for a problem...I didn't have any issues with the carefully selected M mount lenses I have gotten until I got the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II (#11672). With that lens, there are very obvious problems with reverse field curvature and astigmatism.
Edit: I should add, that I have tested my Nikon Z6 side-by-side with my (now sold) Sony a7II with several M mount wide angle lenses and while the Z6 performed slightly better, the difference was rather small and mostly seen in the extreme corners. This was with the wides I have bought that are reported to work well with Sony sensors.
My tests side by side with the Z7 vs. the Sony A7r II got very similar results. Almost zero difference between any M lenses or Sony E mount lenses with either camera.
p.1 #10Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
The two (main) types of aberrations that are caused by the thicker sensor stack are astigmatism and peripheral color shift. On the Nikon Z7, I would extrapolate from my experience that all M lenses <= 90mm have some peripheral color shift at infinity focus. Older lenses often have astigmatism. The thin sensor modification will reduce these effects, though I think that there are other differences between the sensors, as well as the proprietary Leica lens profiles, so you will get good to near excellent, but not optimal performance - especially if you work with color cast profiles in post processing. I would not expect the performance of Nikon Z lenses to deteriorate substantially with the thinner sensor, but I would be very interested in hearing about your experience in this regard.
p.1 #11Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
One very obvious effect, apart from astigmatism (smear) and color shift towards the sides and corners when using range finder wide angles on mirrorless cameras, is the introduction of field curvature. This is a direct effect of the thicker sensor glass on the mirrorless cameras compared to Leica M cameras. I saw that with Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and now the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II.
Reverse field curvature is in my opinion the biggest issue with M mount lenses on mirrorless since it's impossible to correct in editing and eliminates (or even worsens compared to a slower first party lens) the advantage using faster lenses in order to get background blur.
p.1 #12Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
One very obvious effect, apart from astigmatism (smear) and color shift towards the sides and corners when using range finder wide angles on mirrorless cameras, is the introduction of field curvature. This is a direct effect of the thicker sensor glass on the mirrorless cameras compared to Leica M cameras. I saw that with Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and now the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II.
Reverse field curvature is in my opinion the biggest issue with M mount lenses on mirrorless since it's impossible to correct in editing and eliminates (or even worsens compared to a slower first party lens) the advantage using faster lenses in order to get background blur. ...Show more →
Astigmatism and field curvature (or reverse field curvature if you want to call it that) are two sides to the same coin. Astigmatism occurs when the filed curvature is only or more extreme in either the sagittal or tangential orientation. So field curvature and astigmatism often result from the same sort of problems with the sensor glass.
p.1 #14Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
mapgraphs wrote: AcuteShadows wroteThe two (main) types of aberrations that are caused by the thicker sensor stack are astigmatism and peripheral color shift.
....Interestingly, I have one M lens that exhibits color shift on the M, but not on the Sony or Z... ; - )
Huh, how does the color shift show? Which lens are you referring to, a 21mm f/4 Super-Angulon? Is it a lens profile issue?
p.1 #15Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
One very obvious effect, apart from astigmatism (smear) and color shift towards the sides and corners when using range finder wide angles on mirrorless cameras, is the introduction of field curvature. This is a direct effect of the thicker sensor glass on the mirrorless cameras compared to Leica M cameras. I saw that with Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and now the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II.
Reverse field curvature is in my opinion the biggest issue with M mount lenses on mirrorless since it's impossible to correct in editing and eliminates (or even worsens compared to a slower first party lens) the advantage using faster lenses in order to get background blur. ...Show more →
Field curvature implies that there is an image surface (in space) that may be considered sufficiently in focus. With astigmatism, as I understand this phenomenon, you don't have such a plane, as tangential and sagittal rays focus in different surfaces. With those M lenses that do not show astigmatism, I have not had problems with field curvature (and for those that show astigmatism, I actually don't know, because I do not own any of them).
p.1 #16Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote:
...
Huh, how does the color shift show? ...
It shows a somewhat subtle cyan/magenta "Italian flag" effect. The lens exhibits extreme negative field curvature. On the Sony it's possible to use the Sony's field curvature "enhancement" to sharpen the edges. It is an ultra fast 50mm portrait lens...
p.1 #17Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
mapgraphs wrote: AcuteShadows wrote...
Huh, how does the color shift show? ...It shows a somewhat subtle cyan/magenta "Italian flag" effect. The lens exhibits extreme negative field curvature. On the Sony it's possible to use the Sony's field curvature "enhancement" to sharpen the edges. It is an ultra fast 50mm portrait lens...
A f/1.0 lens, I gather... Magenta in the middle? Is that a true color shift, or are these color fringes of different tint? I think it is a profile issue, as for rays hitting the sensor at oblique angles, the lower frequencies would get lost, and that is true in the center as well (especially at large apertures).
p.1 #18Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote: LarsHP wroteOne very obvious effect, apart from astigmatism (smear) and color shift towards the sides and corners when using range finder wide angles on mirrorless cameras, is the introduction of field curvature. This is a direct effect of the thicker sensor glass on the mirrorless cameras compared to Leica M cameras. I saw that with Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and now the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II.
Reverse field curvature is in my opinion the biggest issue with M mount lenses on mirrorless since it's impossible to correct in editing and eliminates (or even worsens compared to a slower first party lens) the advantage using faster lenses in order to get background blur.Field curvature implies that there is an image surface (in space) that may be considered sufficiently in focus. With astigmatism, as I understand this phenomenon, you don't have such a plane, as tangential and sagittal rays focus in different surfaces. With those M lenses that do not show astigmatism, I have not had problems with field curvature (and for those that show astigmatism, I actually don't know, because I do not own any of them).
You are right that field curvature and astigmatism are two different optical phenomena, but regarding the effect of a thicker sensor glass than the lens was designed for, it is caused by the same thing and thus can be solved by the same measure.
When I focus the 28mm Asph II in the extreme corner, I get an impressively sharp image with the full spectrum converted Sony a7 (all layers of sensor glass removed, hot mirror filter on lens), but doing the same with the Z6, I get a mediocre result in the corner which show some astigmatism. Also, when I focus at infinity with both cameras, the sides and corners on the Z6 are plainly awful due to both field curvature and visible astigmatism, but I get a very impressive result with the converted a7 in the entire image.
p.1 #19Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
AcuteShadows wrote: mapgraphs wroteAcuteShadows wrote...
Huh, how does the color shift show? ...It shows a somewhat subtle cyan/magenta "Italian flag" effect. The lens exhibits extreme negative field curvature. On the Sony it's possible to use the Sony's field curvature "enhancement" to sharpen the edges. It is an ultra fast 50mm portrait lens...A f/1.0 lens, I gather... Magenta in the middle? Is that a true color shift, or are these color fringes of different tint? I think it is a profile issue, as for rays hitting the sensor at oblique angles, the lower frequencies would get lost, and that is true in the center as well (especially at large apertures).
I know he has (had) the 7Artisans 50mm f/1.1, so I expect it may be that one, so you are possibly right.
p.1 #20Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote: AcuteShadows wroteLarsHP wroteOne very obvious effect, apart from astigmatism (smear) and color shift towards the sides and corners when using range finder wide angles on mirrorless cameras, is the introduction of field curvature. This is a direct effect of the thicker sensor glass on the mirrorless cameras compared to Leica M cameras. I saw that with Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and now the Leica 28mm Summicron-M Asph II.
Reverse field curvature is in my opinion the biggest issue with M mount lenses on mirrorless since it's impossible to correct in editing and eliminates (or even worsens compared to a slower first party lens) the advantage using faster lenses in order to get background blur.Field curvature implies that there is an image surface (in space) that may be considered sufficiently in focus. With astigmatism, as I understand this phenomenon, you don't have such a plane, as tangential and sagittal rays focus in different surfaces. With those M lenses that do not show astigmatism, I have not had problems with field curvature (and for those that show astigmatism, I actually don't know, because I do not own any of them).You are right that field curvature and astigmatism are two different optical phenomena, but regarding the effect of a thicker sensor glass than the lens was designed for, it is caused by the same thing and thus can be solved by the same measure.
When I focus the 28mm Asph II in the extreme corner, I get an impressively sharp image with the full spectrum converted Sony a7 (all layers of sensor glass removed, hot mirror filter on lens), but doing the same with the Z6, I get a mediocre result in the corner which show some astigmatism. Also, when I focus at infinity with both cameras, the sides and corners on the Z6 are plainly awful due to both field curvature and visible astigmatism, but I get a very impressive result with the converted a7 in the entire image. ...Show more →
Looking at the cone of rays converging (roughly) at one point of the sensor, I'd say that for smaller apertures, you may get almost "pure" field curvature, but for larger apertures, the divergence of rays in the tangential plane induced by sensor glass thickness becomes relevant, and you get astigmatism (in addition to field curvature). Maybe someone should do a thorough calculation of these effects.