fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7

  
 
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
@ kwalsh
Thanks for the link.

A bit off topic here, but I will try to make it short:
From my practical experience I would say that built-in image stabilization with both the a7II and Z6 has been most effective with from wide angles and up to short telephoto lenses. When I did a side by side comparison between AF-S Nikkor 70-200mm f/2.8G VRII and my 180mm Apo-Lanthar, both with image stabilization on in the Z6, the manual lens + IBIS had much less stabilization than the VR2 lens + Z6 with IBIS.

Also, just by focusing with magnification tells me that the IBIS is much more effective with shorter focal lengths than medium telephoto lenses.

I understand from your posts and link, that with super wides IBIS won't work as well outside the center, and that's an important take away for me here nonetheless.
Sep 23, 2020 at 08:46 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
For wide angle, a certain change in angle induces less movement of the image on the sensor (at least in the corner). So one could argue that, while IBIS is not as efficient for wide angle lenses, there is less need for stabilisation in the first place. Alternatively, the corner performance for wide angle lenses might actually be worse than the center performance for tele lenses.

Another question is whether image stabilization in the lens would have similar or different characteristics as image stabilization in the sensor, and whether combining both would improve corner performance of the overall stabilization mechanism.

kwalsh wrote:
@LarsHP@ - No each crop is a separate exposure. That's why I did 9 or 10 of each because of course with the human body things are a bit different each time so wanted to see the variation and distribution of results to make any conclusion. I'd need to dig out another pinhole and then place it carefully to do a test showing performance in the center and edges simultaneously. That said I've done about 300 exposures at different shutter speeds and focal lengths and they all show the same effect. Also see below for a link to another thread
...Show more →

Sep 23, 2020 at 09:47 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
@ kwalsh
Thanks for the link.

A bit off topic here, but I will try to make it short:
From my practical experience I would say that built-in image stabilization with both the a7II and Z6 has been most effective with from wide angles and up to short telephoto lenses. When I did a side by side comparison between AF-S Nikkor 70-200mm f/2.8G VRII and my 180mm Apo-Lanthar, both with image stabilization on in the Z6, the manual lens + IBIS had much less stabilization than the VR2 lens + Z6 with IBIS.

Also, just by focusing with magnification tells me
...Show more →

Yep, when it comes to longer focal lengths usually IBIS performance drops in comparison to OIS because the required actuator displacement and velocity just keeps increasing for IBIS as focal length goes up. We've even seen Olympus the "king of IBIS" has put OIS into their longer focal lenses precisely because of this.

The only additional wrinkle as you say is just being aware as we get very wide now we see an additional IBIS limitation in corner performance.

---------------------------------------------

AcuteShadows wrote:
For wide angle, a certain change in angle induces less movement of the image on the sensor (at least in the corner). So one could argue that, while IBIS is not as efficient for wide angle lenses, there is less need for stabilisation in the first place. Alternatively, the corner performance for wide angle lenses might actually be worse than the center performance for tele lenses.


As best I can tell for a fixed shutter speed then going wider never hurts because as you say angular motion is less magnified.

Where we see things degrade is in reference to how much improvement we see compared to a rule like 1/f which is how most people claim IS performance. In this case yes wide angle edges/corners degrade a lot at very wide angles to the point the center might still benefit by say five stops while the edges only by one or two. This in comparison to say a telephoto that might at some focal length only achieve three stops improvement compared to 1/f but that three stops is effective across the entire frame.


Another question is whether image stabilization in the lens would have similar or different characteristics as image stabilization in the sensor, and whether combining both would improve corner performance of the overall stabilization mechanism.


In the DPR thread it is stated without justification that OIS won't have the wide angle problem. I can't quite wrap my head around that one way or another as I've not been able to find unambiguous documentation as to how OIS functions. I did a quick test with OIS at an effective focal length of 28mm shot for 1 second and actually at first blush it does look like the OIS corners are just fine in comparison to performance in the center. So perhaps the statement in the DPR thread is correct and OIS doesn't suffer in the same way. But I'm very cautious about drawing conclusions from a single test using a different lens and camera system. I'm going to try some more OIS vs IBIS tests at wide angle over the coming days.

Anyway, apologies to @LarsHP for the thread derail. Maybe this IBIS/OIS topic should spawn its own thread instead. I'll create one in a few days when I have more data. I'm particularly curious about say the 24-70/4S compared to the 24-200/4-6.3 which has a VR system. I'm not sure how Nikon decides between what to use when both VR and IBIS are available. I do have a m43 camera and lens that I can actively force to IBIS or OIS so I'll do some tests with that as well.
Sep 23, 2020 at 10:01 AM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
mapgraphs wrote:
Desmolicious wrote...

I compared my M240 to my Z7 w my Leica 50mm Asph, 35mm cron Asph, 28mm Elmarit Asph, 18mm Asph and every one was better on the Leica.
And if I down-sample to 24mp, Nikon's imaging architecture wins every time. It isn't even a contest.


I did that and it made no difference.
If you’re happy w the results you’re getting that is cool.
I’ll keep using my Leica glass on the M, and my Nikon mount glass on my Z7.

Right now a Leica M240 can be had for just over $2k which is an insane buy as they were $7k-ish new. Most of them are barely used.
Sep 23, 2020 at 10:49 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
kwalsh wrote:
LarsHP wrote@ kwalsh
Thanks for the link.

A bit off topic here, but I will try to make it short:
From my practical experience I would say that built-in image stabilization with both the a7II and Z6 has been most effective with from wide angles and up to short telephoto lenses. When I did a side by side comparison between AF-S Nikkor 70-200mm f/2.8G VRII and my 180mm Apo-Lanthar, both with image stabilization on in the Z6, the manual lens + IBIS had much less stabilization than the VR2 lens + Z6 with IBIS.

Also, just by focusing with magnification tells me that the IBIS is much more effective with shorter focal lengths than medium telephoto lenses.

I understand from your posts and link, that with super wides IBIS won't work as well outside the center, and that's an important take away for me here nonetheless.
Yep, when it comes to longer focal lengths usually IBIS performance drops in comparison to OIS because the required actuator displacement and velocity just keeps increasing for IBIS as focal length goes up. We've even seen Olympus the "king of IBIS" has put OIS into their longer focal lenses precisely because of this.

The only additional wrinkle as you say is just being aware as we get very wide now we see an additional IBIS limitation in corner performance.

---------------------------------------------

AcuteShadows wroteFor wide angle, a certain change in angle induces less movement of the image on the sensor (at least in the corner). So one could argue that, while IBIS is not as efficient for wide angle lenses, there is less need for stabilisation in the first place. Alternatively, the corner performance for wide angle lenses might actually be worse than the center performance for tele lenses.
As best I can tell for a fixed shutter speed then going wider never hurts because as you say angular motion is less
...Show more →
Earlier quoteAnother question is whether image stabilization in the lens would have similar or different characteristics as image stabilization in the sensor, and whether combining both would improve corner performance of the overall stabilization mechanism.


I think I've read that both work together, increasing the stabilization capability. But I don't know whether this true for both Nikkor Z lenses and F mount lenses.
Sep 23, 2020 at 11:47 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
mapgraphs wrote:
I've been using LTM, M and legacy F lenses, ultra wides, wides , normal and short tele on my Z and M-240 since November 2018. There is no difference in the IQ between the two. I haven't seen any Z or R user reports of the types of problems encountered with E bodies since 2018. The mod may be a solution looking for a problem...


What M and LTM lenses do you have? Legacy F lenses should be as unaffected on the Z cameras as they were on F mount DSLRs. A number of M and LTM lenses work fine on the Z cameras, but a number of lenses don't. It would be interesting to you input on what lenses are working for you.
Sep 23, 2020 at 12:15 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
It appears that it is mostly (if not entirely) Sony a7 series cameras that people have posted about the (ultra) thin sensor glass conversion, but Kolari offers this service to Nikon Z, Canon R and Panasonic S1 series cameras too.

Did anyone here get an Ultra Thin sensor glass conversion from Kolari Vision?
I have ordered it, but if anyone here has done it and would advise against it, I am all ears and eyes.

I am primarily going to use the camera with M mount lenses, including wide angle lenses.

https://kolarivision.com/product/sony-a7-series-thin-filter-legacy-lens-upgrade/


I wanted to respond more fully to your initial email and share my experience. I had considered getting the Kolari vision thin sensor modification, but in the end I decided not to do so. Here is my basic thinking:

1) Although I love Leica M glass, I have come to love the small manual focus lenses made for Sony E mount as well. These include the Zeiss Loxia lenses and a growing set of Voigtlander lenses as well as a few other manufacturers (Laowa, 7 Artisans). With the exception of 2 focal lengths (18mm and 28mm) these small manual focus E mount lenses provide an excellent alternative to Leica M glass. Further they can be used on the Nikon camera with an unmodified sensor and either a simple mechanical adapter or with the TZE-01 adapter that provides focus confirmation and EXIF data.

Anything wider than 15mm is equally available in Leica M and Sony E mount; at 21mm there are 3 lenses all of which are excellent (the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 is excellent and I think both smaller and better than the Summilux and of course far/far cheaper, there is the fantastic Loxia 21 f/2.8; and the tiny and high performing Voigtlander 21 f/3.5); at 24/25mm there is the excellent Loxia 25 f/2.4; at 35mm there is the excellent Voigtlander 35 f/1.2 and Loxia 35 f/2; at 50mm there are 3 excellent lenses including the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO (which may even exceed the Leica 50 cron APO in performance for a seventh the cost), the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 (a wonderfully rendering and performing fast 50), and the Loxia 50 f/2 (a very nice 6 element 4 groups double gauss classic lens), longer than 50mm lenses Leica M lenses can mostly be used without problems, but there I also the Loxia 85 f/2.4 that is a fantastic if a heavy lens. My take is you can build a wonderful very much Leica like kit without having to resort to modifying the sensor on the Z camera and without having to resort to Leica M lenses that underperform.

2) The cost savings between going with the E mount lenses and the M mount lenses is massive despite the very similar performance.

3) When replacing the sensor glass on the Z cameras I have 3 worries that are for me serious. First, from all the samples I have seen and from discussion on the board I worry that replacing the cover glass with negative affect color. It is clear color is changed by swapping the cover glass, and I really like Nikon colors. I would like to avoid having to deal with color issues and with the stock sensor glass I don't have to worry. Second, (and this would especially be an issue with the Z6) you lose the AA filter with the change in sensor glass. Some might see this as a benefit, but I am not a fan of the false sharpness and moire that sometimes come from digital sensors and that is much worse with a lower MP body without an AA filter. Third, although I don't use AF lenses very much with the Z7 I worry that replacing the sensor glass would negatively affect Z lens performance. We are talking about removing about 1mm of glass, so there should be some effect if the theories are right.

None of this is to say that my decision needs to apply to you. You seem particularly concerned with the Leica M 28 f/2 Asph II, and that is a stellar lens and one of the cases in which you can't get anything like it in E mount. For me, however, I will struggle with a less than optimal choice at 28mm to get a fantastic 21 f/2.8 that is small and a 50 f/2 APO that is small and spend less than $1,000 on either lens. Of course, YMMV.
Sep 23, 2020 at 12:48 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
There are at least two factors regarding how well range finder lenses perform on Z kameras. One is which lenses is used (including, but not only, the focal lengths) and the other is how and for what the lenses are used. If not scrutinized shot wide open, then problems may not be discovered. As and example reverse field curvature may go unnoticed if the lens is primarily shot well stopped down or the issue isn't tested for.

For instance, I had the Nokton 50mm f/1.5 and thought it performed well on the Z6 until I tested it against another 50mm and discovered that it had severe reverse field curvature.
Sep 23, 2020 at 12:55 PM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Steve Spencer wrote:
... The mod may be a solution looking for a problem...


What M and LTM lenses do you have? Legacy F lenses should be as unaffected on the Z cameras as they were on F mount DSLRs. A number of M and LTM lenses work fine on the Z cameras, but a number of lenses don't. It would be interesting to you input on what lenses are working for you.

I suspect from the foregoing that it probably comes down to usage. I use the M as a recording or photojournalism tool and use M lenses in that regard, as they were designed to be used... Subject two to three meters, wide open if the effect is needed... In that context, I tend to use either a 28mm or 35mm Ultron LTM although I have other lenses that come into play as needed or desired: 12mm Heliar VM, 21mm Ultron VM, 28 Ultron VM, 35mm Biogon ZM, 40mm Nokton VM, 50mm Planar ZM, 50mm Elmar M (v1), 5cm Summitar, 75mm summarit, 75mm Nokton VM, Summicron 90 (M & R), and a handful of other lenses.

None of the above lenses "don't work" for my usage, however they won't work for the hobbyist or generalist who is looking for edge to edge sharpness at infinity, wide open. As an aside, I didn't buy the Z7 for M lenses, I bought it for Z lenses. I use mostly jpg so the editor variable doesn't enter the equation. I've been doing RGB imaging as profession in one form or another since the early 1980s...

But, in the end, my use isn't necessarily your use or vice versa... ; - )



Edited on Sep 24, 2020 at 05:23 AM · View previous versions
Sep 23, 2020 at 01:41 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
@ Steve Spencer

Thanks for your elaborate and well thought response.

I agree that the color change may impact the images negatively, but so far I haven't seen anyone complain about it after converting their Sony a7 series camera. This may be brand related: a Nikon Z camera may suffer in terms of color reproduction while a Sony a7 might do fine. However, I have no indication that Nikon Z cameras will perform worse than Sony cameras after the UT conversion, so I am willing to take a small risk in that department.

Regarding lens selections, I am set on the M mount and have no interest in changing that. One of the several reasons for that is that I can buy used lenses in very good condition at good prices and - when needed - sell them without a loss or at least only a small loss. Leica brand lenses, particularly the M mount ones, seems to hold their value very well, so even though the used price may be high, I can sell at just as high a price.

One of the exceptions to buying used is the Voigtländer Nokton 50mm f/1.2 Asph, which I love and adore. I have decided that 35mm is too close to 50 which "unfortunately" means I need a good 28mm lens. I have the 7Artisans FE+ and while it is stellar for the money, it has its issues - first and foremost a wavy field curvature that compromises the mid frame at wide apertures. It also has very rounded aperture blades which makes it almost impossible to get sun stars and its relatively big and heavy considering its a M mount lens. The Voigtländer 28mm f/2 isn't working well on mirrorless cameras either. I bought the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II used at a very good price in the belief that it would work well on the Z6, but it doesn't. So, what to do? I could either return the lens or convert the Z6 which will make the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II work while all the other M mount will benefit too. That was my conclusion; that it will be a win for all the M mount lenses I have.

Regarding the removal of the anti aliasing filter, I have no worries. I have had the full spectrum converted a7 for a while and never seen moire so far. To me, it doesn't make sense to talk about false sharpness with sensors without AA filter. You could just as well say that the AA filter (in most cases) introduces unnecessary blur to the image. I know that moire may occur, but I don't shoot fashion or architecture where this typically may cause problems.
Sep 23, 2020 at 01:55 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
@ Steve Spencer

Thanks for your elaborate and well thought response.

I agree that the color change may impact the images negatively, but so far I haven't seen anyone complain about it after converting their Sony a7 series camera. This may be brand related: a Nikon Z camera may suffer in terms of color reproduction while a Sony a7 might do fine. However, I have no indication that Nikon Z cameras will perform worse than Sony cameras after the UT conversion, so I am willing to take a small risk in that department.

Regarding lens selections, I am set on the
...Show more →

That makes total sense. It is interesting that we have thought along very similar lines (I too have a 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 and my evaluation is very similar to yours), but came to just slightly different conclusions. I think both are quite reasonably approaches. Good luck and let us know what you think of the Kolari modification.
Sep 23, 2020 at 03:04 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
I should perhaps add that Kolari Vision contacted me and said that they didn't have the Ultra Thin filter needed for the Z6 conversion in their inventory until mid October. So I canceled the order and expect to reorder when they notify me that it's in house.
Sep 23, 2020 at 03:10 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
The 28mm Elmarit-M Asph is plainly awful on a Nikon Z camera. Sharp in the center, but increasingly blurred the more away from the center you look. ...

The Elmarit-M 28 ASPH is indeed a problem prime. A7ii results are execrable but merely unusable on the Z6. Disappointing because it handles beautifully on both bodies. You can be quite confident of good results from 50mm onward ('lux 50 ASPH excepted). Perhaps Kolari, or a proper digital M, can reduce the problems of astigmatism and color shift but I simply use SLR lenses for WA coverage, or a native-mount optic.
Sep 23, 2020 at 04:05 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
I should perhaps add that Kolari Vision contacted me and said that they didn't have the Ultra Thin filter needed for the Z6 conversion in their inventory until mid October. So I canceled the order and expect to reorder when they notify me that it's in house.


Too bad you have to wait. Personally, with COVID-19 keeping me in the house much more than usual and cancelling all my travel plans I am in no hurry to change my camera gear. I hope it is minimal inconvenience to you. It is good to hear someone from Europe is able to use Kolari's services. I know a couple years ago, it was hard to get them to work on gear from Europe.
Sep 24, 2020 at 06:42 AM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7

Yeah, I saw this thread and was going to tell you that you may want to hold off. My Sigma fp has been at Kolari for over a month. Apparently their supplier can't give them a date when they'll have the glass in, so I'm actually having them ship it back - half finished so it'll be a full spectrum camera - until they get their shipment in.


LarsHP wrote:
I should perhaps add that Kolari Vision contacted me and said that they didn't have the Ultra Thin filter needed for the Z6 conversion in their inventory until mid October. So I canceled the order and expect to reorder when they notify me that it's in house.

Sep 24, 2020 at 09:09 AM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
...
Sep 24, 2020 at 09:09 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
imagesfromobjects wrote:
Yeah, I saw this thread and was going to tell you that you may want to hold off. My Sigma fp has been at Kolari for over a month. Apparently their supplier can't give them a date when they'll have the glass in, so I'm actually having them ship it back - half finished so it'll be a full spectrum camera - until they get their shipment in.

Ouch! That was a severe bummer.

They said the UT glass should be shipped October 8th with express shipping, but from where, I don't know. If it's Schott, then it would be Germany perhaps?
Sep 24, 2020 at 12:52 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
After Steve Spencer mentioned that he was concerned that the colors could be altered by the Ultra Thin conversion, responded that I haven't seen anyone complain about it, but yesterday I thought that it might have been because it hadn't looked properly for it.

After re-reading the UT review at Philip Reeve's site ( https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification ) I did a quick search on Flickr and found a guy who has done a few side by side tests with a stock Sony a7RIII versus a Kolari UT modded a7II. (Note that there is both a generation difference and a _resolution_ difference in favor of the stock camera.) See link below and scroll to the bottom.

It appears to me that there is some difference in colors, but nothing that couldn't be fixed in editing relatively easy.

I understand that Fred Miranda has done some tests with a Kolari UT converted camera too. Anyone who can post a link? I don't seem to find it when googling.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/fornerolj/albums/72157625730486439/page2/
Sep 25, 2020 at 02:59 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
Update! Good news and bad news.

After scrutinizing infinity shots with focus placed in the center, the sides and the corners, it became apparent that the focus plane was skewed; mostly tilted, but also a bit swinged. I have since modified the adapter to get the best possible focus symmetry and after that, the reverse field curvature persists, but looks much less apparent since what I initially saw wasn't only field curvature, but a combination with tilted focus plane.

In other words, the good news is that the reverse field curvature is much less than it looked. The bad news is that after fine tuning the adapter to the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II, the 90mm Apo-Summicron-M is off in the right hand side... I will have to recheck, but I anticipate that it's the 28mm which is swinged.
Sep 25, 2020 at 07:38 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Kolari Ultra Thin conversion on Nikon Z6 / Z7
LarsHP wrote:
Update! Good news and bad news.

After scrutinizing infinity shots with focus placed in the center, the sides and the corners, it became apparent that the focus plane was skewed; mostly tilted, but also a bit swinged. I have since modified the adapter to get the best possible focus symmetry and after that, the reverse field curvature persists, but looks much less apparent since what I initially saw wasn't only field curvature, but a combination with tilted focus plane.

In other words, the good news is that the reverse field curvature is much less than it looked. The bad news
...Show more →

That is good news Lars about adjusting the adapter and the problems with the 90 cron APO seems like they can easily be fixed by simply getting another adapter for that lens, so even that bad news doesn't seem so bad.
Sep 25, 2020 at 08:19 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister