fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)

  
 
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
shadow9d9 wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot of Sony's customers would not mind paying a premium price for say a GM 35mm f2 lens for example. Think how small a GM 24 F2 might be? I have the 35mm 1.8 currently and it is OK but we all know they have the ability to make a better overall lens. Heck they did it 5+ years ago on the RX1 . At the end of the day I get they have to fill out the system. But in a time when sales are more critical than ever I question the value of releasing say this lens verse something that would sell many times the amount of units and making more money. I mean that's what it really is all about. Making money right? Would people be more interested to switch or stay in the Sony Platform because of a stellar 3000 dollar UW zoom or because Sony has GM level roadmap of smallish f2 primes they will be making. Maybe I'm in the minority on that. I'm sure people will let me know if I am
Except this "halo lens" is actually useable. Lighter than the competition, has autofocus unlike the Nikon, has an excellent and useable range... It came in much lighter than was expected. THe NIkon is a 6k lens with no autofocus... NOt exactly comparable to this. I have use for this lens. I have no use for a 35 f2.
Well then if you have no use for it than your right Sony shouldn't build it


I didn't mean that!
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:12 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
bjornthun wrote:
shadow9d9 wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot of Sony's customers would not mind paying a premium price for say a GM 35mm f2 lens for example. Think how small a GM 24 F2 might be? I have the 35mm 1.8 currently and it is OK but we all know they have the ability to make a better overall lens. Heck they did it 5+ years ago on the RX1 . At the end of the day I get they have to fill out the system. But in a time when sales are more critical than ever I question the value of releasing say this lens verse something that would sell many times the amount of units and making more money. I mean that's what it really is all about. Making money right? Would people be more interested to switch or stay in the Sony Platform because of a stellar 3000 dollar UW zoom or because Sony has GM level roadmap of smallish f2 primes they will be making. Maybe I'm in the minority on that. I'm sure people will let me know if I am
Except this "halo lens" is actually useable. Lighter than the competition, has autofocus unlike the Nikon, has an excellent and useable range... It came in much lighter than was expected. THe NIkon is a 6k lens with no autofocus... NOt exactly comparable to this. I have use for this lens. I have no use for a 35 f2.
The Zeiss Batis range contains three f/2 lenses, 25/2, 40/2, 85/1.8, and my impression is that these may no longer be the long term success Zeiss had hoped for. It is almost two years since the Batis 40/2 came out, and it had AF issues and was quite large for a 40/2 lens. Has Zeiss since lost interest? Surely Sony, Sigma et al have been watching this. So, I think too that a GM f/2 range might run into trouble. The Sony 35/1.8 is the right size, I think. Could Sony turn it into a GM lens while maintaining the
...Show more →

It really is an interesting question about what set of lenses sells. Although, it looks like the Batis lenses were not a great success, both Nikon (with the Z mount) and Leica (with the L mount) have taken a similar strategy. Nikon has a whole set of f/1.8S (and S in their premium line for mirrorless) primes (20, 24, 35, 50, & 85) and these lenses are genuinely well regarded and although not small, not huge and generally fall right around 400-500g. Leica for the L mount has built a whole set of APO summicron (i.e., f/2) lenses (35, 50, 75, & 90) as their primary lenses for the L mount. These lenses are a bit big (typically around 750g) but are fantastic optically and even though f/2 still carry the hefty Leica price. Canon of course didn't go this route at first but now have a 35 f/1.8, a 50 f/1.8, and an 85 f/2 and have took the interesting approach of making the 35 and 85 (and maybe the 50?) 1:2 magnification macros.

So, I think it makes sense for Sony to rethink their lineup of smaller lenses. They have a lot of small lenses, the 20 f/1.8 G, 24 f/1.4 GM, 28 f/2, Sony/Zeiss 35 f/2.8 ZA, 35 f/1.8, 50 f/1.8, 50 f/2.8 Macro, Sony/Zeiss 55 f/1.8, 85 f/1.8, but there isn't a coherence to this lineup of small lenses. You have an excellent 20 f/1.8 G lens, and an even better 24 f/1.4 GM, but you also have a fairly weak 28 f/2 and everything in between. What I would like to see Sony do is launch a series of small G prime lenses using the 20 f/1.8G as a sort of model. These could be lenses generally less than 400g, with a close MFD, very good aberration control, sharp, and better than decent bokeh. The price should be under $1,000.

They could start with a 28 f/1.8, where an additional lens is definitely needed. Then add a 50 f/1.8 as an alternative to both the cheap plain 50 f/1.8 and even the Sony/Zeiss which is starting to get a bit long in the tooth. If these sell well then add a 35 f/1.8 with 1:2 macro and an 85 f/1.8 with OS (and at least 1:3 max magnification at MFD) and a bit sharper than the current plain 85 f/1.8 (and with better bokeh than the Batis)--I know this is a tall order but it won't be easy to justify why this lens costs more than the already excellent plain 85 f/1.8. Together these would make an excellent line of G primes to compete with Nikon, Canon, and the L-mount. A line of such G lenses at 20, 28, 35, 50, & 85 all under 400g (well maybe keep the 85 under 500g), would be excellent for people who want to keep their kit smaller.

Of course these aren't the only lenses Sony needs to develop. A replacement for the Sony/Zeiss 35 f/1.4 seems needed. Do they make a 50 f/1.2? What about all the long lenses? One would think they would want a 300 f/2.8 and 500 f/4 at least. Do they make a 200 f/2? Do they make a 200-400 f/4 zoom? How about DO/PF lenses? How about tilt/shift lenses?

Sony has built a wonderful system of lenses, but it is not as though they don't still have a lot of work to do. I am glad I don't have to decide, even at this fairly mature state of their system, what to build and what to wait to build.
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:32 AM
httivals
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I agree wholeheartedly that the Sony 20mm f1.8 is a fantastic lens and should be the new model/strategy. It's more compact than the 24mm f1.4, less expensive, and sharper into the corners; although the 24mm f1.4 also has its advantages. Thinking about the primes that Sony has released most recently - 20mm f1.8, 35 mm f1.8, 135mm f1.8 and 24mm f1.4 (am I missing any?) -- the 35mm f1.8 is the only disappointment (to me, at least). . . . It's curious to me that it's so difficult to get a great 35mm f2 or so reasonably compact lens. . . Too bad I can't adapt the Nikon 35mm f1.8S to my Sony.
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:45 AM
sismailian
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Well this is some awesome times to be a sony shooter! I am waiting for dustin abbot to review it eagerly
The price is pretty steep though! I might be interested in this but maybe not right now.

Interestingly enough I watched tony and chesley's review and their sample photo showed the 16-35 GM to be superior from 16-24mm in the shots at same settings and same distance. But they didn't really show infinity test and shooting against the sun really comparison like Ted did with the 2.8 and F4 version. Sample variation will of course play a role here. They may have gotten a softer copy? No idea.

Edited on Jul 08, 2020 at 10:18 AM · View previous versions
Jul 08, 2020 at 10:04 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Dpreview tested the Nikon 35/1.8S against the Sony and the Sony comes out a bit better, https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/sony-fe-35mm-f1-8-review/4

If we look beyond marketing labels, Sony G, GM, ZA, Nikon S, ED etc we see that Sony has got a lineup, 20/1.8, 35/1.8, 55/1.8 and 85/1.8 compared to Nikon S 20/1.8, 24/1.8, 35/1.8, 50/1.8 and 85/1.8. Sony then appears to be missing a 24/1.8 rather than a 28/1.8. I think that the Sony 28/2 and 50/1.8 form a lineup more consistent with the Nikon compact 28mm and 50mm non-S lenses on their roadmap. A 28/1.8 to fit in with those I mentioned above would be 2-2.5x the price of the current 28/2.

You get what you pay for, so generally I’m not concerned with marketing labels.

There are two lenses Sony should take a closer look at, the Zony 35/1.4 and the Zony 24-70/4 and give them an update.

Sorry for digressing away from the subject of the new Sony 12-24/2.8 GM, which no one beats at the moment!
Jul 08, 2020 at 10:13 AM
Bob_S
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)


shadow9d9 wrote:
Bob_S wroteWow, apparently no one told Sony that this will be 'too heavy to use' like the Sigma 35 1.2.

Has anyone compared it to the f4 version? That's all I care about, a reason to bother spending more and carrying the extra around.

Appreciate it if you could reply without calling me a racist and having my posts deleted, that would be super 👍
Only 50 grams heavier than the Sigma that everyone is extolling as the best thing ever.

A few have compared it to the F4. Better in the corners and less distortion correction(none needed at all according to Alex).


Ism a big fan of both the 12-24 G and Sigma Art 35/1.2, use them daily.

I was commenting that if the Sigma was too big to use then this would be too.

Thanks for the info re the comparison. Not sure why it's being compared to the Sigma 14-24 so much, the f4 G is the direct competitor imo.

The distortion of the G isn't a problem for me, the extra stop of the GM isn't useful for me either, so interested in why people would be choosing the GM over the G.
Jul 08, 2020 at 10:16 AM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Bob_S wrote:
shadow9d9 wrote
Bob_S wroteWow, apparently no one told Sony that this will be 'too heavy to use' like the Sigma 35 1.2.

Has anyone compared it to the f4 version? That's all I care about, a reason to bother spending more and carrying the extra around.

Appreciate it if you could reply without calling me a racist and having my posts deleted, that would be super 👍
Only 50 grams heavier than the Sigma that everyone is extolling as the best thing ever.

A few have compared it to the F4. Better in the corners and less distortion correction(none needed at all according to Alex).
Ism a big fan of both the 12-24 G and Sigma Art 35/1.2, use them daily.

I was commenting that if the Sigma was too big to use then this would be too.

Thanks for the info re the comparison. Not sure why it's being compared to the Sigma 14-24 so much, the f4 G is the direct competitor imo.

The distortion of the G isn't a problem for me, the extra stop of the GM isn't useful for me either, so interested in why people would be choosing the GM over the G.


I think some people just want the "best" toys. Slightly better in the corners and overall. Better flare resistance too. Huge difference? No. Value? No.

I was quite surprised when they announced this. I am hoping for a 300 2.8, tilt shift, or longer macro.
Jul 08, 2020 at 10:19 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #9Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Holger wrote:
Looks good for astro, too. Corners, 200%
from
https://www.autumnschrock.com/blog/sony-12-24mm-f28-g-master-lens-review



It looks like the above image was at 12mm + f/2.8. This is something none of the other zooms can do....Nightscapes at 12mm wide open at f/2.8 with great coma control. There are no 12mm primes with this level of coma wide open. I'm sure the two large extreme asph. front elements have something to do with this. Another lens with amazing coma control with an extreme aspherical front element is the 24/1.4 GM.
Jul 08, 2020 at 01:23 PM
asnapper
Offline
Details
Jul 08, 2020 at 01:26 PM
Alex W
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Sounds like an awesome lens. However as much as I am a GM fan with the announcement and price I ordered the Sigma 14-24mm that arrived today. Very pleased at less than half the cost of the GM.
Jul 08, 2020 at 03:14 PM
ifxbonz
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Im wondering how does it compares with the 16-35 at 16-24mm. Thinking of replacing the 16-35 so i can go with a 2 lens kit 12 to 70 using the 12-24 & 24-70?

Andy
Jul 08, 2020 at 04:01 PM
Justin Stone
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
In the end I’ll probably go with the money-is-no-object route here because I love this hobby.

Sony 12-24 2.8 GM
CV 21 3.5
Jul 08, 2020 at 04:14 PM
Dustin Gent
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Watch, Sigma will raise the price of the 14-24 to $2399. I mean Nikon charged $1999 for their 14-24, and the Sigma smokes that lens for $500 less.

With all of this said, I may just buy the Sony 12-24 and do my own test. Fall is just around the corner, as is my birthday
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:10 PM
knshshnk
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
people love to complain about youtubers but I'm really glad Sony have such wide portfolio of people to test their products, I think it's especially fun to see them trying to figure out such odd focal length, in pre-youtube era would take much longer and wouldn't have nearly enough variety of styles and backgrounds (from urban scenes in Hong Kong, to the mountains in Italy and then portrais in Chicago)
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:48 PM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Haven’t people been crushing Architecture,Astro & Milky Way photos before this lens?
Who’s going to notice the differences with this one.
$3000US? I hope you can sell those prints. Mazel tov if you can! Thats a lot of scratch to fork over. Wow.
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:28 PM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
KarmaKramer wrote:
Haven’t people been crushing Architecture,Astro & Milky Way photos before this lens?
Who’s going to notice the differences with this one.
$3000US? I hope you can sell those prints. Mazel tov if you can! Thats a lot of scratch to fork over. Wow.


Why would anyone need to sell prints? Photography is more for a hobby than to make money nowadays. It is one of the worst professions. Honestly, I've been forced to cancel 4 trips between March and this upcoming Labor Day. And now my country is banned from visiting the civilized world indefinitely and who knows if that will ever be reversed, if I am to be honest. So, while I am suffocating in this country, unable to go to restaurants, see events, have boardgaming night, and being forced to homeschool my child, you better believe I am going to buy this lens for fun and sell zero prints.
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:40 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #18Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Dustin Gent wrote:
Watch, Sigma will raise the price of the 14-24 to $2399. I mean Nikon charged $1999 for their 14-24, and the Sigma smokes that lens for $500 less.

With all of this said, I may just buy the Sony 12-24 and do my own test. Fall is just around the corner, as is my birthday


The Sigma was on sale for $1,199 three months ago:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1641983
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:45 PM
PixiPhotography
Online
Details
p.8 #19Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)

Jul 08, 2020 at 10:39 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
vdo1 wrote:
ftllens wroteImagine if all new GM lenses had built-in electronic variable ND.
Imagine that the new "one of a kind" camera touted by the rumours site has an integrated ND

Plus a novel shutter with variable speed across the frame as to simulate graduated NDs.

OTOH the logic of wanting a big, heavy f/2.8 UWA to ultimately use it with NDs kind of escapes me.


It's a versatility thing. Some of us don't want a different lens for every conceivable purpose. If I'm going into the back country and want to keep my lens load-out light yet versatile, I'd want a single UWA optic that I could use at f/2.8 (for night photography) and also accept NDs (for slowing down motion without getting into diffraction-inducing f/stops). Sure, I could accomplish this with two lenses, but it's easy enough to put an ND filter holder in the back of an f/2.8 and then just carry one thing.

I'm glad Sony did it. $3000 though? That's a lot. I'll wait for some second-hand ones to start appearing.
Jul 08, 2020 at 10:44 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister