p.19 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
trstahly wrote: Fred Miranda wroteThey are here, ready to be tested!
Hopefully two good copies.You have an anxious group to see the results this should be interesting.
Just finished the infinity tests and I'm downloading the files right now. Did a quick flare test as well. It's hot today!
It's amazing how similar they are in size and weight. The main difference is the GM's larger front element. I just weighted them and they are exactly 49 grams apart.
p.19 #5Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
rvh23 wrote:
Excellent Fred. Very much looking forward to the side-by-side flare examples.
Quick tease flare test. Both lenses are flare resistant (way better than 12-24/4G) but I get more purple blob ghosts with the Sigma. Here is a sample at 14mm and f/8:
(It's a big hazy and hot so don't expect any sunstar definition)
p.19 #8Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Happy to report i picked up an excellent copy that doesnt have that insane af pulsing issue. It has a very slight pulse at 12mm if you focus on something far that has multiple layers ay 12mm. I think its normal. Peeeking at all corners looks really looks amazing at f2.8 even just wow what a difference.
p.19 #10Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Fred Miranda wrote: rvh23 wroteExcellent Fred. Very much looking forward to the side-by-side flare examples.Quick tease flare test. Both lenses are flare resistant (way better than 12-24/4G) but I get more purple blob ghosts with the Sigma. Here is a sample at 14mm and f/8:
(It's a big hazy and hot so don't expect any sunstar definition)
Thanks Fred, much appreciated. Yes, against full sun I regularly see small blobs like that with the Sigma. It would be very nice not to have to carry an additional lens to shoot against the sun...
* edit * although looking more carefully, it looks like the Sony still has ghosts too - not as well defined, but spread over a larger area which has pros and cons in terms of post work to eliminate them.
p.19 #11Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
rvh23 wrote: Fred Miranda wrotervh23 wroteExcellent Fred. Very much looking forward to the side-by-side flare examples.Quick tease flare test. Both lenses are flare resistant (way better than 12-24/4G) but I get more purple blob ghosts with the Sigma. Here is a sample at 14mm and f/8:
(It's a big hazy and hot so don't expect any sunstar definition)Thanks Fred, much appreciated. Yes, against full sun I regularly see small blobs like that with the Sigma. It would be very nice not to have to carry an additional lens to shoot against the sun...
* edit * although looking more carefully, it looks like the Sony still has ghosts too - not as well defined, but spread over a larger area which has pros and cons in terms of post work to eliminate them.
Yes both have great flare resistance. It took me a while to find a spot showing some ghosting. The Sony also shows ghosting but it's more subtle in comparison.
I got lucky with the Sigma again. It's perfectly centered even at 24mm just like my previous copy.
The GM is very slightly asymmetric only at 12mm but keep in mind that I used my decentering test wide open at 61MP which is pretty unforgiving. These are great results for ultra wide zooms tested on the A7R4.
When I post crops at 12mm, the slight asymmetry @12mm won't be shown since the top left (where I usually demonstrate corners) is the sharpest of the 4. From 14mm until 24mm it's perfect just like the Sigma. At least we will know for sure how they compare.
Just for kicks, I also tested the Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III and Voigtlander 21mm f/3.5 Color-Skopar against the GM.
I may be only be able to post the comparison test tomorrow because I just heard we may have a planned blackout where I live due to excessive heat. It looks like Death Valley broke new heat record today since 1931! https://twitter.com/i/events/1295326459062411264
p.19 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Great feedback Fred. Yeah the heat is insane here in los angeles. Not looking forward to the outtages. 2020 keeps getting on new levels of crazy Be careful with this heat its seriously taxing trying to photograph anything outside for even a minute jesus.
p.19 #15Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Fred Miranda wrote: rvh23 wroteFred Miranda wrotervh23 wroteExcellent Fred. Very much looking forward to the side-by-side flare examples.Quick tease flare test. Both lenses are flare resistant (way better than 12-24/4G) but I get more purple blob ghosts with the Sigma. Here is a sample at 14mm and f/8:
(It's a big hazy and hot so don't expect any sunstar definition)Thanks Fred, much appreciated. Yes, against full sun I regularly see small blobs like that with the Sigma. It would be very nice not to have to carry an additional lens to shoot against the sun...
* edit * although looking more carefully, it looks like the Sony still has ghosts too - not as well defined, but spread over a larger area which has pros and cons in terms of post work to eliminate them.Yes both have great flare resistance. It took me a while to find a spot showing some ghosting. The Sony also shows ghosting but it's more subtle in comparison.
I got lucky with the Sigma again. It's perfectly centered even at 24mm just like my previous copy.
The GM is very slightly asymmetric only at 12mm but keep in mind that I used my decentering test wide open at 61MP which is pretty unforgiving. These are great results for ultra wide zooms tested on the A7R4.
When I post crops at 12mm, the slight asymmetry @12mm won't be shown since the top left (where I usually demonstrate corners) is the sharpest of the 4. From 14mm until 24mm it's perfect just like the Sigma. At least we will know for sure how they compare.
Just for kicks, I also tested the Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 III and Voigtlander 21mm f/3.5 Color-Skopar against the GM.
I may be only be able to post the comparison test tomorrow because I just heard we may have a planned blackout where I live due to excessive heat. It looks like Death Valley broke new heat record today since 1931! https://twitter.com/i/events/1295326459062411264...Show more →
Although the CVs will no doubt look pretty sad in terms of resolution, it might be informative to compare their flare performance to the zooms as well when you have the time.
p.s. I can't believe your luck again with the Sigma. Maybe I should get you to order my next zoom on my behalf.
p.p.s. The Death Valley temperature made it to front page news even here in Australia, and we're pretty familiar with hot days ourselves.
p.19 #16Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I just tested out the new lens and tested all focal lengths + apertures and am simply amazed what a golden copy I got. It's literally the perfect copy pretty much. I think at 12, 18 and especially 24mm it wow'd me; just biting sharp even wide open.
I really have no idea how I got such a bad copy before but my vacation is saved. Going to be an epic week. I noticed if you use a smaller focus point with AF-C the AF works really great. I also noticed this copy is snappier in AF somehow, strange but cool Me a happy camper now!
p.19 #17Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
sismailian wrote:
I just tested out the new lens and tested all focal lengths + apertures and am simply amazed what a golden copy I got. It's literally the perfect copy pretty much. I think at 12, 18 and especially 24mm it wow'd me; just biting sharp even wide open.
I really have no idea how I got such a bad copy before but my vacation is saved. Going to be an epic week. I noticed if you use a smaller focus point with AF-C the AF works really great. I also noticed this copy is snappier in AF somehow, strange but cool Me a happy camper now!...Show more →
I got one today and am getting another in a couple days a mix up at BH so excited to test one against the other and keep the best one.
Does anyone have any tips on how to test or compare two lenses against each other?
p.19 #18Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Congrats! Look forward to seeing what you do with it.
sismailian wrote:
I just tested out the new lens and tested all focal lengths + apertures and am simply amazed what a golden copy I got. It's literally the perfect copy pretty much. I think at 12, 18 and especially 24mm it wow'd me; just biting sharp even wide open.
I really have no idea how I got such a bad copy before but my vacation is saved. Going to be an epic week. I noticed if you use a smaller focus point with AF-C the AF works really great. I also noticed this copy is snappier in AF somehow, strange but cool Me a happy camper now!...Show more →
p.19 #19Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
trstahly wrote: sismailian wroteI just tested out the new lens and tested all focal lengths + apertures and am simply amazed what a golden copy I got. It's literally the perfect copy pretty much. I think at 12, 18 and especially 24mm it wow'd me; just biting sharp even wide open.
I really have no idea how I got such a bad copy before but my vacation is saved. Going to be an epic week. I noticed if you use a smaller focus point with AF-C the AF works really great. I also noticed this copy is snappier in AF somehow, strange but cool Me a happy camper now!I got one today and am getting another in a couple days a mix up at BH so excited to test one against the other and keep the best one.
Does anyone have any tips on how to test or compare two lenses against each other?
Go shoot with the one in hand and if it works well, don’t open the other. Send it straight back. Enjoy.
Otherwise, lock down all changing variables and shoot a repeatable scene at all focal lengths and apertures at different focal distances (mfd, mid, infinity). Compare and contrast. Send back weaker of the two.
Keep testing and you’ll always find flaws, especially with big glass elements. The lens profile will make a difference.
p.19 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
That's pretty cool you get to test two copies! Honestly the philip's decentering test is great way to test but I also like shooting the same scene that has something far away, focusing in the same area. Preferably like a building you can be on the same level at to be able to judge the corners. Honestly I'd try to not be too critical as you will find a focal length it will be a bit weaker at.If the replacement one you getting is good to your mind don't even waste time testing the other. I know I probably would not
trstahly wrote: sismailian wroteI just tested out the new lens and tested all focal lengths + apertures and am simply amazed what a golden copy I got. It's literally the perfect copy pretty much. I think at 12, 18 and especially 24mm it wow'd me; just biting sharp even wide open.
I really have no idea how I got such a bad copy before but my vacation is saved. Going to be an epic week. I noticed if you use a smaller focus point with AF-C the AF works really great. I also noticed this copy is snappier in AF somehow, strange but cool Me a happy camper now!I got one today and am getting another in a couple days a mix up at BH so excited to test one against the other and keep the best one.
Does anyone have any tips on how to test or compare two lenses against each other?