fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)

  
 
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Holger wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I am sure Sony did a market query/analysis before developing the lens. Priorities differ between people. Yours aren't mine. We don't know exactly as to why the price is higher by this factor (but still comparable to the Canon 11-24/4), although fluorine coating, the special lens elements etc. will add up costs. We don't know what extra development effort is required to get the 12 vs. 14mm to a similar performance. The diameter is clearly different and developing the largest XA element ever made is not a simple task.
Being engineer tells me, it might not be that easy as many
...Show more →

I don’t think this would be an easy lens to make (though I don’t have any insightful logistical information of lens cost production), but that doesn’t change the fact that customers will pay that extra 1.8k for 2mm...needs differ, but ultra wide premium fixed 2.8k at 12 and 13mm just don’t seem that practical for many users—and maybe the high cost per unit reflects an anticipated lower total sales volume. Interestingly, Sigma can and does release their lenses across mounts, which must help control prices per unit.

Though I agree with DavidBM—this lens strikes me more as a statement/presence/line-up booster lens.
Jul 08, 2020 at 12:50 AM
Beni
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
BenUES wrote:
shadow9d9 wrote
BenUES wrote
trstahly wroteOne could also say why not save two thousand dollars and buy a Laowa 12mm and skip UWA zoom and keep your 16-35GM?

There are some on here including myself are are excited to see Sony continue to push the envelope and that comes at a price.

I have yet to see anyone on here say they do not think the lens is an exciting and outstanding lens. Just a bunch of whiners complaining about how much it cost. Whats new?
I'm excited about new technology too, but I don't see the utility in criticizing people who are wary about paying for a lens that costs as much as a decent used car. Especially during a global economic collapse! It strikes me as poor timing to release a lens like this right now. I know you can't speed up development of technology but if I were Sony's marketing team, I think it would be extremely tough to sell this lens to all but those who are most shielded from what's going on around us.
The US has 1/4 of the entire world's virus. Japan, Sk, Canada, most of Europe, China are beginning to go back to normal. Why should a Japanese country withhold release when their own country is doing absolutely fine? It isn't their fault that things are out of control in the single country-the US.

So they should keep warehouses full of lenses that have been produced over many months unsold because of one country? Let them sell to anyone who will buy. Canada's government is paying every citizen 2k a month. UK is paying 80% of everyone's salary. And of course, taiwan, japan, and sk have all but eradicated the virus. As have many others. The world doesn't revolve around the US and shouldn't be forced to put everything on hold for a single country.

Oh, and I'm from the US and I'm buying the lens.
My point is not about coronavirus caseload. It's about the economic fallout of the pandemic, which is hurting every nation, rich or poor. This is not the time nor place for this discussion but the reason governments are bankrolling salaries of businesses and establishing UBI is because people are at risk of financial collapse. Everything doesn't revolve around the US, of course, but no reasonable argument can be made that the rest of the developed world successfully eradicated the virus and recovered the health of its economy. The world over is tightening purse strings and selling non-essentials until better days
...Show more →

I'm not sure how relevant that might be. These lenses are made in batches. Release now makes far more sense than in 2021 when the economic belt tightening will be in full force. They will probably sell most of the first batch and then can decide, based on the market and demand, when to make another batch of them. To be honest Sony can probably easily afford to simply warehouse a batch of lenses like this made primarily for bragging rights. Similar to the long telephoto primes which are made in small batches and then sit in warehouses for the trickle of orders. Like them, this is a very specialised use case scenario lens and isn't created with mass sales in mind.

Not to say that these won't sell well, the manufacturers have us very well trained by now. Remember when a top pro WA lens was $1300 and that gave us pause? The drive for more megapixels has trained us to be willing to pay the prices that those megapixels demand on the rest of our equipment.
Jul 08, 2020 at 01:14 AM
Bob_S
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Wow, apparently no one told Sony that this will be 'too heavy to use' like the Sigma 35 1.2.

Has anyone compared it to the f4 version? That's all I care about, a reason to bother spending more and carrying the extra around.

Appreciate it if you could reply without calling me a racist and having my posts deleted, that would be super 👍

Edited on Jul 08, 2020 at 03:29 AM · View previous versions
Jul 08, 2020 at 02:32 AM
spannr
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
DavidBM wrote:
On thing which very slightly depresses me is that I notice this lens has four independent focus motors, which means four focus groups moving independently, and in any pattern the firmware dictates. That's floating elements on complete steroids.


The Sony website describes it as two independent focus groups, two motors per group. So maybe just a moderate dose of steroids.

DavidBM wrote:
But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might... It's about protecting the GM brand.


It's also about pushing the technology forward - it'll be interesting to see what they can do with really big extreme aspherical elements in future designs.

Personally as an owner of the Sigma I'm just happy that the 'second-best' option is such a magnificent lens. Let's not think of this as Sony vs Sigma when really this should be about sticking it to Canon fans who don't have a 12-24 f/2.8
Jul 08, 2020 at 03:28 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
nehemiahphoto wrote:
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
Yeah, I get it. But I don’t like it! I’d love to see the lenses I listed, or a host of other products, like a compact RF ff body, an RX1r3, premium compact f1.8/2 primes, medium format fixed lens etc.

And thus far, the GM’s have been pretty impeccable, except I was unimpressed by the GM 70-200. Not at all a bad lens, but doesn’t strike me as special at it’s tier.
Yes, that's my impression too about the GMs. Roger Circala seems to think the issue there was they just couldn't manufacture the design to its potential (which means maybe there are some copies out there? But I wouldn't try to play that golden copy game...)

We seem to agree on dream products. The compact RF style ff body might come in a couple of months if the chatter is correct. That would be a likely purchase for me, especially if it has an EVF, for hiking purposes.
Did he find any excellent copies? Seems like other 70-200 2.8 from Canon and Nikon are regarded better (I haven’t used them), I wonder why Sony couldn’t nail it.


I don’t know, but I think he must have. Why? Because the average performance he records is very good, not quite as good as the Canon and Nikon. But he also records that variability in this model is very high. In which case there must be copies with both very much worse, and very much higher performance. So yep there are probably copies as good as the amazing MTF. But it would be a fools errand to try to find one.
Jul 08, 2020 at 03:47 AM
jschn372
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Lets just be thankful they're not releasing f/7.1 zooms or f/11 long primes like Canon. There's definitely more of a market for this than there is for those.

nehemiahphoto wrote:
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
Yeah, I get it. But I don’t like it! I’d love to see the lenses I listed, or a host of other products, like a compact RF ff body, an RX1r3, premium compact f1.8/2 primes, medium format fixed lens etc.

And thus far, the GM’s have been pretty impeccable, except I was unimpressed by the GM 70-200. Not at all a bad lens, but doesn’t strike me as special at it’s tier.


Jul 08, 2020 at 03:55 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
DavidBM wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having
...Show more →

"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot of Sony's customers would not mind paying a premium price for say a GM 35mm f2 lens for example. Think how small a GM 24 F2 might be? I have the 35mm 1.8 currently and it is OK but we all know they have the ability to make a better overall lens. Heck they did it 5+ years ago on the RX1 . At the end of the day I get they have to fill out the system. But in a time when sales are more critical than ever I question the value of releasing say this lens verse something that would sell many times the amount of units and making more money. I mean that's what it really is all about. Making money right? Would people be more interested to switch or stay in the Sony Platform because of a stellar 3000 dollar UW zoom or because Sony has GM level roadmap of smallish f2 primes they will be making. Maybe I'm in the minority on that. I'm sure people will let me know if I am
Jul 08, 2020 at 04:46 AM
RayinNY
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
This will be a great lens for cityscapes and I think will sell very well for Sony. Almost a must have for anyone who shoots in an urban setting. There's only so much you can back up to before running out of room.
Jul 08, 2020 at 04:51 AM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
For the enthusiast kr professional, a lens like this might be more desirable than those lenses, but I guarantee Canon will sell more of those than Sony sells of this.

jschn372 wrote:
Lets just be thankful they're not releasing f/7.1 zooms or f/11 long primes like Canon. There's definitely more of a market for this than there is for those.

nehemiahphoto wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
Yeah, I get it. But I don’t like it! I’d love to see the lenses I listed, or a host of other products, like a compact RF ff body, an RX1r3, premium compact f1.8/2 primes, medium format fixed lens etc.

And thus far, the GM’s have been pretty impeccable, except I was unimpressed by the GM 70-200. Not at all a bad lens, but doesn’t strike me as special at it’s tier.

Jul 08, 2020 at 05:12 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
What Sony has done a really good job of with this lens and they have now done it for the second time is bring out a lens that tops an excellent Sigma lens that looked close to unbeatable. We first saw that with the 135 f/1.8. The Sigma was and is a fantastic lens, but Sony made a GM that was lighter, faster focussing, and sharper.

They seem to have done much the same thing with this lens. It is wider, and it looks like it might have a bit better IQ (which is pretty shocking as good as the Sigma is), and it is only a tiny bit heavier.

Sony needs some of these lenses in their GM line that top even the best Sigma lenses, so that the Sigma Art lenses don't become the premium brand. Sony as a brand in more vulnerable to these incursions from other lens makers for two reasons: 1) they don't have a long history with making lenses and the cachet that comes with that, and 2) they have an open mount which doesn't put the other lens makers at a disadvantage. So, I think they need to have these over the top lenses from time to time to make the case their lenses are indeed the creme de la creme.

I think it was doubly important that they do so with particular lens, because their other 2 lenses in the f/2.8 trinity (the 70-200 f/2.8 GM and the 24-70 f/2.8 GM) are not their strongest efforts. This trinity of lenses, IMO, is very important for a brand as they seem to be used a lot by a lot of people. Their 24-70 f/2.8 GM at least in reputation seems to be a notch behind the Nikon 24-70 f/2.8S, and Canon has the exciting 28-70 f/2 RF. Sony looks in this competition to be a bit behind. The Sony 70-200 f/2.8 GM if anything looks in worse position. Canon has their considerably smaller 70-200 f/2.8 RF, and if Nikon ever gets their act together and brings out their 70-200 f/2.8S and it is at least as good as the F mount lens, then Sony GM is likely to overshadowed by Canon and Nikon at the long end of the GM lineup. So, IMO, Sony needed to make a lens that makes it clear they are a serious lens maker in the f/2.8 trinity line up. This lens serves that purpose quite well.

Sony now have excellent GM lenses at 24, 85 (some might argue this but not me), 100, 135, 400, & 600. So they can make excellent primes. They now have excellent GM lenses at 12-24 and 100-400, so they can make excellent zooms. I think establishing that is very important for Sony. What I think they need to do soon, however, is come out with a Mark II of the 70-200 f/2.8 for sure and maybe the 24-70 f/2.8 as well. If they do so, then this new 12-24 would pair nicely with those, but it does set the marker for the price as well.
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:10 AM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
$3,000? A bridge too far.
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:14 AM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
They should make 24-105 GM next
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:17 AM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.7 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
BenUES wrote:
shadow9d9 wrote
BenUES wrote
trstahly wroteOne could also say why not save two thousand dollars and buy a Laowa 12mm and skip UWA zoom and keep your 16-35GM?

There are some on here including myself are are excited to see Sony continue to push the envelope and that comes at a price.

I have yet to see anyone on here say they do not think the lens is an exciting and outstanding lens. Just a bunch of whiners complaining about how much it cost. Whats new?
I'm excited about new technology too, but I don't see the utility in criticizing people who are wary about paying for a lens that costs as much as a decent used car. Especially during a global economic collapse! It strikes me as poor timing to release a lens like this right now. I know you can't speed up development of technology but if I were Sony's marketing team, I think it would be extremely tough to sell this lens to all but those who are most shielded from what's going on around us.
The US has 1/4 of the entire world's virus. Japan, Sk, Canada, most of Europe, China are beginning to go back to normal. Why should a Japanese country withhold release when their own country is doing absolutely fine? It isn't their fault that things are out of control in the single country-the US.

So they should keep warehouses full of lenses that have been produced over many months unsold because of one country? Let them sell to anyone who will buy. Canada's government is paying every citizen 2k a month. UK is paying 80% of everyone's salary. And of course, taiwan, japan, and sk have all but eradicated the virus. As have many others. The world doesn't revolve around the US and shouldn't be forced to put everything on hold for a single country.

Oh, and I'm from the US and I'm buying the lens.
My point is not about coronavirus caseload. It's about the economic fallout of the pandemic, which is hurting every nation, rich or poor. This is not the time nor place for this discussion but the reason governments are bankrolling salaries of businesses and establishing UBI is because people are at risk of financial collapse. Everything doesn't revolve around the US, of course, but no reasonable argument can be made that the rest of the developed world successfully eradicated the virus and recovered the health of its economy. The world over is tightening purse strings and selling non-essentials until better days
...Show more →

My point is that the majority of the first world countries have beaten back the virus and returning slowly to normal. They also have financial security due to their governments.

In any case, releasing a lens now does NOT prevent you from buying it in a year or two from now, so I don't understand why it should be delayed. Especially since the country it was made in, Japan, never really even shut down. They just put on masks, went on with their lives, and have a rdiculously low number of cases. Why should a Japanese company not release a product just because the US has decided to sit in a corner and punch itself in the face?
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:21 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
ftllens wrote:
They should make 24-105 GM next


Given that they already have a very good 24-105 f/4 G, I don't see them doing that. Unless you mean a 24-105 f/2.8 GM, which I would think might be too big for most people, but if they could keep it under 900g and have excellent IQ throughout the range (both big ifs), then I think that would be an interesting statement lens.
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:22 AM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot
...Show more →

Except this "halo lens" is actually useable. Lighter than the competition, has autofocus unlike the Nikon, has an excellent and useable range... It came in much lighter than was expected. THe NIkon is a 6k lens with no autofocus... NOt exactly comparable to this. I have use for this lens. I have no use for a 35 f2.
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:26 AM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Bob_S wrote:
Wow, apparently no one told Sony that this will be 'too heavy to use' like the Sigma 35 1.2.

Has anyone compared it to the f4 version? That's all I care about, a reason to bother spending more and carrying the extra around.

Appreciate it if you could reply without calling me a racist and having my posts deleted, that would be super 👍


Only 50 grams heavier than the Sigma that everyone is extolling as the best thing ever.

A few have compared it to the F4. Better in the corners and less distortion correction(none needed at all according to Alex).
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:28 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
shadow9d9 wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot of Sony's customers would not mind paying a premium price for say a GM 35mm f2 lens for example. Think how small a GM 24 F2 might be? I have the 35mm 1.8 currently and it is OK but we all know they have the ability to make a better overall lens. Heck they did it 5+ years ago on the RX1 . At the end of the day I get they have to fill out the system. But in a time when sales are more critical than ever I question the value of releasing say this lens verse something that would sell many times the amount of units and making more money. I mean that's what it really is all about. Making money right? Would people be more interested to switch or stay in the Sony Platform because of a stellar 3000 dollar UW zoom or because Sony has GM level roadmap of smallish f2 primes they will be making. Maybe I'm in the minority on that. I'm sure people will let me know if I am
Except this "halo lens" is actually useable. Lighter than the competition, has autofocus unlike the Nikon, has an excellent and useable range... It came in much lighter than was expected. THe NIkon is a 6k lens with no autofocus... NOt exactly comparable to this. I have use for this lens. I have no use for a 35 f2.


The Zeiss Batis range contains three f/2 lenses, 25/2, 40/2, 85/1.8, and my impression is that these may no longer be the long term success Zeiss had hoped for. It is almost two years since the Batis 40/2 came out, and it had AF issues and was quite large for a 40/2 lens. Has Zeiss since lost interest? Surely Sony, Sigma et al have been watching this. So, I think too that a GM f/2 range might run into trouble. The Sony 35/1.8 is the right size, I think. Could Sony turn it into a GM lens while maintaining the small size with a 55mm filter thread?

The new 12-24/2.8 GM weighs about as much as three Zeiss Batis lenses, and covers a lot of ground.

Edited on Jul 08, 2020 at 07:47 AM · View previous versions
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:45 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #18Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
shadow9d9 wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
DavidBM wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteLike I said at the beginning of this thread, good luck versus the Sigma 14-24. If this lens is better in the 14-24 range, you’re going to need very high res sensor/heavy crops to see it. And I doubt there’s a ton of demand to the tune of an extra 1.8K for that 10-12mm.

I get the 10 vs. 12mm, but I don’t really feel like this was a hole Sony needed to fill. I (and many others) would like a 15/2 GM or a nice 28mm option. A wide relatively compact 10 or 12mm would have been more enticing to me as well.

It’s always good to have options though, and I am sure some people will appreciate this lens. I am always interested in contrast and colors, and good work on electronic variable ND filters Sony.

Maybe Sony will release a 35mm f1.1 lens and charge 2.5x the Sigma 35 1.2 😂
I'm agree that even if the Sony is measurably better than the Sigma, it won't be visibly better.
And personally I wouldn't want 12mm; but hell, personally I don't want f2.8 at this FL either.

But I totally see why Sony have released it. They need to stake out the premium end of the market which is where the $$ are; it's important - even if sales of this lens don't justify it, though I think they might - to have a lens which can be spruiked as "better" than the Sigma - and being a fair bit wider and having even better looking MTF does that for them. It's about protecting the GM brand.

So yeah, a 1.1/35 (1.2/28?) for 2.5x Sigma is is not out of the question!
"It's about protecting the GM brand." If that is the reason and I was a stock holder I would be questioning Sony. They are there to sell lens to compliment the body's they produce. Not to make a halo place holder. Let Nikon make the halo lenses that no one buys. I don't understand why Premium has to equal 1.2 / 1.4 for example or highest price. Sure that can be one aspect but Sony would "protect the Brand" better in my opinion with releasing smaller GM quality IQ/rendering primes for example. I could be wrong but I think alot of Sony's customers would not mind paying a premium price for say a GM 35mm f2 lens for example. Think how small a GM 24 F2 might be? I have the 35mm 1.8 currently and it is OK but we all know they have the ability to make a better overall lens. Heck they did it 5+ years ago on the RX1 . At the end of the day I get they have to fill out the system. But in a time when sales are more critical than ever I question the value of releasing say this lens verse something that would sell many times the amount of units and making more money. I mean that's what it really is all about. Making money right? Would people be more interested to switch or stay in the Sony Platform because of a stellar 3000 dollar UW zoom or because Sony has GM level roadmap of smallish f2 primes they will be making. Maybe I'm in the minority on that. I'm sure people will let me know if I am
Except this "halo lens" is actually useable. Lighter than the competition, has autofocus unlike the Nikon, has an excellent and useable range... It came in much lighter than was expected. THe NIkon is a 6k lens with no autofocus... NOt exactly comparable to this. I have use for this lens. I have no use for a 35 f2.


Well then if you have no use for it than your right Sony shouldn't build it
Jul 08, 2020 at 07:47 AM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
They should just build out more specialty flex lenses, since there's enough glass for general purpose usage (Sony and third party) in the ecosystem already that covers all budgets more or less already.

It's not just to snatch up the pro market, but it's also so that sector can forward that flex to the clients. Just look at Hollywood and how clients want Alexa, but couldn't tell the difference from a GH4. Same thing with audio, same thing with all things in life.

Anyway, I'll probably buy this lens lol
Jul 08, 2020 at 08:02 AM
trstahly
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Steve Spencer wrote:
What Sony has done a really good job of with this lens and they have now done it for the second time is bring out a lens that tops an excellent Sigma lens that looked close to unbeatable. We first saw that with the 135 f/1.8. The Sigma was and is a fantastic lens, but Sony made a GM that was lighter, faster focussing, and sharper.

They seem to have done much the same thing with this lens. It is wider, and it looks like it might have a bit better IQ (which is pretty shocking as good as
...Show more →

I could not agree more Steve, I have always thought the 24-70 GM will be the first series II lens.

Sony has come a long way since this lens came out and it is a given it can be improved in IQ, size, weight, AF and rendering.

I rarely pick mine up because I like my 24 GM, 35 Voigtlander SE, 50 1.4 ZA & 85GM so much better or I will take my 16-35 and 50 instead. But if they released a 24-70 II that matches these it would be glued to my camera.

I sold my 70-200GM which is the only GM lens I do not own after I got the 135 GM there was no point it sucks with tc's and is too heavy and I grab other lenses instead. I doubt I would replace it with a series II as it is not a hole I need to fill I use my 135 or 100-400 for these purposes. Now concerts or something one might be handy but for the rare occasion for me at least the 135 can be cropped and I like the extra speed.

I ordered my 12-24 GM yesterday and am excited I have not really done a lot of UWA and after watching some videos and seeing some perspectives and how close you can get to the subject and have everything in focus from 3.5' to infinity it opens up a lot of possibilities on the creative side.

I agree with Fred that it is ironic that to get a truly great 12mm lens you have to buy a zoom.

If Sony had a 12mm 2.8 or even 2.0 with stunning IQ or perhaps even better IQ being a prime I would skip the zoom and use my 16-35 GM instead and keep my 12-24G if I thought I absolutely needed 13 thru 15mm.
Jul 08, 2020 at 09:11 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister