fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)

  
 
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.16 #1Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Chris_88 wrote:
Tokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.


Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.
Aug 11, 2020 at 11:38 PM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.16 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
pdmphoto wrote:
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.


It's indeed a decentered copy, but sadly that's just how it goes. It's always a lottery. I hardly ever manage to get non-decentered GM lenses and when you look at the Tamron and Sigma threads (like the 14-24) it's not much better there.


Aug 12, 2020 at 02:45 AM
abase21
Offline
Details
p.16 #3Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
..a few words, after two days working with the lens. The resistance against strong backlight is very good. Tony Northrup mentioned in his review that the lens is not as sharp as the 16-35 GM. For me the opposite is true. My test (same camera settings, same lighting conditions) the new GM is definitely sharper across the frame at 16mm, 18mm and 21mm (24 not tested)
Aug 12, 2020 at 03:06 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.16 #4Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Jochenb wrote:
pdmphoto wrote
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.
It's indeed a decentered copy, but sadly that's just how it goes. It's always a lottery. I hardly ever manage to get non-decentered GM lenses and when you look at the Tamron and Sigma threads (like the 14-24) it's not much better there.



To be honest, I think it's a big problem in this industry that is quietly swept under the carpet...
The money I paid for Sigma were already significant enough for me that I went through 4 copies to get the one that made me feel I'm not being robbed (sure, in real life pictures you often don't notice the imperfections but the "bad taste remains"). It takes a lot of fun out of acquiring new gear for me, but I do have lower expectations for cheaper lenses (if I ever got a decentered GM 12-24 though...).
Aug 12, 2020 at 03:33 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.16 #5Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
j4nu wrote:
Jochenb wrote
pdmphoto wrote
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.
It's indeed a decentered copy, but sadly that's just how it goes. It's always a lottery. I hardly ever manage to get non-decentered GM lenses and when you look at the Tamron and Sigma threads (like the 14-24) it's not much better there.
To be honest, I think it's a big problem in this industry that is quietly swept under the carpet...
The money I paid for Sigma were already significant enough for me that I went through 4 copies to get the one that made me feel I'm not being robbed (sure, in real life pictures you often don't notice the imperfections but the "bad taste remains"). It takes a lot of fun out of acquiring new gear for me, but I do have lower expectations for cheaper lenses (if I ever got a decentered GM 12-24 though...).


I fully agree. It has really taken the fun out of buying new lenses for me too.
I know I'm always quite vocal about decentered lenses here, because it's just so frustrating. Especially now that the cameras have such high resolution.
Aug 12, 2020 at 03:52 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.16 #6Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
pdmphoto wrote:
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.


Thanks for pointing that out. I didn't have a lot of time earlier today. I just went ahead and posted the link without examining all the shots close up. I liked the flare resistance. Unfortunately, buying especially zooms seems to be a bit of a lottery in the days of high MP sensors. A few years back, I had to send back two 24-70 2.8's before I got a decent one.
Aug 12, 2020 at 06:35 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #7Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
j4nu wrote:
Jochenb wrote
pdmphoto wrote
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.
It's indeed a decentered copy, but sadly that's just how it goes. It's always a lottery. I hardly ever manage to get non-decentered GM lenses and when you look at the Tamron and Sigma threads (like the 14-24) it's not much better there.
To be honest, I think it's a big problem in this industry that is quietly swept under the carpet...
The money I paid for Sigma were already significant enough for me that I went through 4 copies to get the one that made me feel I'm not being robbed (sure, in real life pictures you often don't notice the imperfections but the "bad taste remains"). It takes a lot of fun out of acquiring new gear for me, but I do have lower expectations for cheaper lenses (if I ever got a decentered GM 12-24 though...).



I would not say it’s quietly swept under the carpet. Far from it here on this forum. I have had my share along with Fred and many others. Yes it’s disheartening to say the least and you feel cheated but I have seen it often. I got lucky the last several lenses on first try. Sigma 14-24 and my Sony’s 12-24 all good out of the gate but I certainly went through 5 FE 35 1.4 lenses . Which lens rentals had issues too. But I see the complaints from members all the time. Just look at the Sigma 14-24 thread. Lots of problems.its exactly why I test the crap out of my lenses when I get one. I’m not going to get stuck with a bad lens and I’ll send it back. Look how many Big Bronco tests I’ve done , for me it’s my testing bed. I know exactly what a lens is doing. I encourage everyone to test there lenses.

BTW there is no such thing as real life pictures. They all are. I shoot for pay I’m not going to use crap on a clients Images. Every shot counts even the cat. Lol
Aug 12, 2020 at 06:44 AM
sismailian
Offline
Details
p.16 #8Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I got a bit worried too seeing just the issues people encountered with the sigma 14-24 and i will make sure to test out the lens immediately at the store shooting at something mid distance that has a flat surface. I did that actually before in the store with a Tamron 24-70 2.8 G2 and Sigma 24-70 2.8 for DSLR and found the tamron to be a bad copy immediately. I shot against the wall of tons of lenses and text they have on display and it was surprisingly a good quick test. I still couldnt believe how much worse the tamron was.

When i bought my 16-35 gm at the store i tested it at the store, at home and outdoors and was happy with it. Now with a 3k lens i for sure will take extra measures to make sure it has no issues. I would ignite on fire if i find out immediately that my copy is bad but so far every lens I've bought new from samys camera in pasadena has been great (minus the first copy of the sigma 35 1.2 making a noticable noise when making large focus pulls that i exchanged for a great copy). Luckily this is the reason why I like buying from store because i can exchange quickly. When i got a sigma 40 1.4 from b&h i had a copy that had TERRIBLE scratches inside when i shined light inside. I sent it back for an exchange and got another that was better but still had somewhat similar issue which bugged me. I looked at my sigma 35 1.4 that didnt have this issue and my friends 40 1.4 didn't have this issue too. So yeah I've had a mixed experience too.
Aug 12, 2020 at 07:17 AM
abase21
Offline
Details
p.16 #9Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
..normally I test a lens only if I'm not satisfy with the results - today I have tested the new GM, for me it is OK - I see a small different between 2 and 4. I have tested at 24mm the subject was about 100 feet away at aperture 2.4 manuel focus



https://www.make-beauty.de/html/Lens-Test%2012-24GM.jpg
Aug 12, 2020 at 07:23 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #10Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Now it’s going to be tough to test at 12mm. It’s a tough focal length as infinity is maybe 10 ft away. Really hard to find a building to shoot with lower and upper Quadrant. If you can find a structure actually two structures one where you can maybe get to third level . Like a parking garage and get a structure across the street that maybe close enough for 12mm. I know my Big Bronco is a bear with 12mm I’m about 8 ft away to get the top from left to right. So not going to be easy

But do buy and I hate even say this but make sure you can return without stock fees and such.

One thing I have done when I want to buy used is rent from Lensrentals test it than if good buy it. That way you eliminate that return stuff.

Good luck. I would love to at least test this. I’m not buying till next year when our business comes back to life. But I’m curious

Edited on Aug 12, 2020 at 07:47 AM · View previous versions
Aug 12, 2020 at 07:42 AM
glowrider
Offline
Details
p.16 #11Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
B&H charged my card this morning. Hopefully it will arrive tomorrow. That’d be great. I know I got in on the first batch of orders, so if you also did, may get very lucky for the weekend!
Aug 12, 2020 at 07:42 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.16 #12Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
GMPhotography wrote:
j4nu wrote
Jochenb wrote
pdmphoto wrote
Chris_88 wroteTokyo-based camera store Map Camera has published its review of the 12-24 GM.
The fourth picture from the bottom shows off the lens' flare resistance at 12mm and f4. There is a small orange blob next to the subject in the center of the frame, but nothing too bad, I'd think.
Taking a quick look at the pics, I would say their lens is decentered. The 24mm pic (sharp bottom left , soft bottom right corners) and the 12mm pic with the grass (blurry left , sharper right hand sides), don't look good to me. Let's hope Sony has their QA in check for this lens. I'd be a little upset if my new $3K baby was decentered. Not that I will be buying. I have an excellent, very well centered copy of the Sigma 14-24, and a VC 12mm.
It's indeed a decentered copy, but sadly that's just how it goes. It's always a lottery. I hardly ever manage to get non-decentered GM lenses and when you look at the Tamron and Sigma threads (like the 14-24) it's not much better there.
To be honest, I think it's a big problem in this industry that is quietly swept under the carpet...
The money I paid for Sigma were already significant enough for me that I went through 4 copies to get the one that made me feel I'm not being robbed (sure, in real life pictures you often don't notice the imperfections but the "bad taste remains"). It takes a lot of fun out of acquiring new gear for me, but I do have lower expectations for cheaper lenses (if I ever got a decentered GM 12-24 though...).
I would not say it’s quietly swept under the carpet. Far from it here on this forum. I have had my share along with Fred and many others. Yes it’s disheartening to say the least and you feel cheated but I have seen it often. I got lucky the last several lenses on first try. Sigma 14-24 and my Sony’s 12-24 all good out of the gate but I certainly went through 5 FE 35 1.4 lenses . Which lens rentals had issues too. But I see the complaints from members all the time. Just look at the Sigma 14-24
...Show more →

Yes, this forum is eye-opening on many issues which is a good thing, but not common.
Aug 12, 2020 at 08:13 AM
sismailian
Offline
Details
p.16 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I think they are already shipping it out as supposedly it will go out on 11th from adorama. Oh i will be so excited if i can get mine today/tomorrow for the weekend. I think shooting a parking garage with multiple levels is a good idea. I will see what I can test it against to satisfy my needs
Aug 12, 2020 at 09:35 AM
mark1958
Offline
Details
p.16 #14Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Same here

glowrider wrote:
B&H charged my card this morning. Hopefully it will arrive tomorrow. That’d be great. I know I got in on the first batch of orders, so if you also did, may get very lucky for the weekend!


Aug 12, 2020 at 10:12 AM
rvh23
Offline
Details
p.16 #15Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Not sure if this has been posted in this thread, but in case not there's a (french language) review that looks pretty thorough at https://www.lesnumeriques.com/zooms/sony-fe-12-24-mm-f-2-8-gm-p58665/test.html and includes measured mtf curves at 12,18 and 24mm.

The curves look very impressive especially at wider apertures. The site also has data for the Sigma 14-24 DN zoom, but unfortunately they are on a different camera (a7r2 rather than 4) and displayed using different units, but my rough calculations indicate that the Sony is indeed a bit sharper than the Sigma at wider apertures.

By F8 the Sony is diffraction limited across the whole range, and if you are usually shooting at that aperture or beyond, any sharpness advantage over the Sigma will be all but impossible to detect according to these curves. In fact, I suspect no matter what aperture you are shooting at, the difference will likely be visble only under pixel-peeping test conditions, and not in actual real-world prints of any reasonable size.

Nevertheless, of special note is the Sony's performance at 18mm (which is a great focal length for astro) where it's already optimal wide open.
Aug 13, 2020 at 01:01 AM
MRK2019
Offline
Details
p.16 #16Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
So two days ago I found a copy of the lens in stock online, ordered it and received it the next day.

Sadly it’s already boxed up and ready to go back. The copy was badly decentered on the right hand side from 18mm to 24mm even when stopped down.

For a lens of this price I wasn’t prepared to compromise. I suspect someone else had pre-ordered this lens first and then returned it.

Didn’t get to check flare resistance either as it rained all day. I think I’ll now wait until there are more reviews before trying another copy.






Aug 13, 2020 at 02:24 PM
sismailian
Offline
Details
p.16 #17Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
That's a bummer. Good reason to hold on to my 16-35 gm which i love. Will definitely need to test it against the 12-24 gm to see if its worth keeping or not. No word yet on lens arriving so i suspect it will be next week.
Aug 13, 2020 at 03:04 PM
rvh23
Offline
Details
p.16 #18Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Due to the increased front diameter of this lens compared to other lenses, Nisi have released a new S6 filter holder system specifically for this lens. (price in the link is in $AU)
However, if you already have an S5 system, the good news is that the S6 adapter can use the round CPL filters and attachment for rectangular filters from the S5 system. Nisi Australia are currenlty selling only full S6 kits, but have informed me they will release the S6 "adapter-only" once demand has been met for full kits.
Aug 14, 2020 at 05:24 PM
sismailian
Offline
Details
p.16 #19Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I did phillip preeve.net de-centering test and it looks like it's softer on the right side at most focal lengths. I also did stop down to F4 to see difference. Left side definitely looks sharper....I guess I'll either exchange for another copy or just return it or maybe give the sigma 14-24 a go (maybe not since I am pretty impressed with the flare performance so far). I will test it outdoors as indoors really isn't the best test with something in close range. So far not too happy for a $3k lens.

Besides that very impressive flare resistance and better distortion straight out of camera compared to 16-35 GM.
Aug 15, 2020 at 01:35 AM
rvh23
Offline
Details
p.16 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
sismailian wrote:
I did phillip preeve.net de-centering test and it looks like it's softer on the right side at most focal lengths. I also did stop down to F4 to see difference. Left side definitely looks sharper....I guess I'll either exchange for another copy or just return it or maybe give the sigma 14-24 a go (maybe not since I am pretty impressed with the flare performance so far). I will test it outdoors as indoors really isn't the best test with something in close range. So far not too happy for a $3k lens.

Besides that very impressive flare resistance and better
...Show more →

Two decentered reports already. That's not good for such an expensive lens

The Sigma 14-24 DN's flare performance is also noticeably better than the Sony 16-35 GM, so don't give it a miss on that basis. I haven't yet seen a side-by-side flare comparison betwene the Sigma and Sony 12-24 GM, but hopefully we soon will. My guess is that they will both be very good "for an UWA zoom", but won't compete with the likes of Loxia and CV WA primes, which also have great coatings, have fewer elements, and don't have to accomodate a large bulbous front element.
Aug 15, 2020 at 02:30 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister