p.17 #1Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Yeah I was immediately suspicious when I looked at the right corners. Also what's strange is that in some instances stopping down did not improve corner performance but made it slightly worse.
I'm going to call the store today to see if i can exchange it this week before I go to lake tahoe. If I can't i will need to return because ill be outside of the return policy when I come back. I am taking it outdoors with me today to get a feel of it but so far this has really let me down. Kind of had this feeling im the back of my mind that pre ordering first batch lenses is a bad idea. Yet I don't want to give up this easily. I am sure getting a new copy will make me happy. If I get another bad one ok that will annoy me. My gripe with the 16-35 gm has been its so so flare performance. The 12-24 gm put a smile on my face in that category at least.
I am curious to see Fred's experience. I want to stay positive because this can happen but still for this price range common Sony wtf get your QC under check. Kind of makes me miss my zeiss prime. Their QC is top notch.
p.17 #2Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Not trying to divert the conversation/topic, but do Canon's EF/RF lenses seem to come decentered as much/often as the lenses for Sony's system. I know it was mentioned Sigma, Zeiss, and others seem to have these problems so I'm assuming it's not only Sony. As others have mentioned the decentering takes some of the excitement out of getting new lenses. To stay on topic I'm looking forward to Fred's comparison of the Sigma and the GM. I'd really love to get one of these.
p.17 #3Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Duowing wrote:
Not trying to divert the conversation/topic, but do Canon's EF/RF lenses seem to come decentered as much/often as the lenses for Sony's system. I know it was mentioned Sigma, Zeiss, and others seem to have these problems so I'm assuming it's not only Sony. As others have mentioned the decentering takes some of the excitement out of getting new lenses. To stay on topic I'm looking forward to Fred's comparison of the Sigma and the GM. I'd really love to get one of these.
Unfortunately it happens in all brands even in high end medium format digital. Anything really that has a higher production rate seems more problematic . But some like Leica glass does not happen often. But every lens is checked not just a random pull one off the belt and inspect it. Its like cars if there is a recall of a fuel filter or something than it followed the same issue down the line. Ive been around a long time and its been around a long time but we see it more now since we are at 100 percent viewing we spot it. In the film days rarely the case of blowing up that big to inspect. We are also somewhat obsessed by all this. Im extremely critical but thats me. Honestly some folks never ever bother to check or even care for that matter. So reality is we dont know how bad this might be or not. For instance I went through 5 FE 35 1.4 lenses and it was the same issue confirmed by lenrentals and Fred as well. Soft right side. It was something in production the setup or something of that nature. Today not sure on that lens
p.17 #6Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Well i called another location and luckily they have one in the warehouse which will arrive monday so I'll go exchange it. I took it out today hiking early in the day and will look at the sample shot on tripod with timer.
Hopefully this copy will be good. I'll update monday. Yeah i guess i shouldn't get too annoyed because seriously i never checked my 16-35 gm at all
I took some proper decentering landscape tests just as philip's test suggest with only focusing in middle and then showing each 4 extreme corners and i will post it later today. I would like feedback please to see what you guys think. Just by looking at the samples thru the lcd zooming in they look pretty damn good at 12mm. Curious to hear your guys feedback to decide if its worth exchanging for another copy.
p.17 #8Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
I suspect there are more people with lenses that are fine. People tend to report problems more often. My decentered copy was just bad luck. It’s too early to say if there is a widespread problem
j4nu wrote:
Huh, 2 decentered copies and 1 DOA from reported samples so far ... seems it's not gonna be easier to get a good copy of this lens than the Sigma .
p.17 #9Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Re: decentering, very small sample set so far but a disappointing start nonetheless.
The B&H's of the world know how much the return and replace cycle costs them, but I wonder if the manufacturers realize there are people like me, who stick with the kit they have in large part because of the unpleasantness of trying to find a lens with no significant decentering or tilt problems?
I absolutely hate testing and having to return a lens (to an irrational extent, I'll admit). For example, last fall, I tried 2 different Sigma 14-24's, both had a weak side at 14mm, gave up. I can't be the only one.
Is poor manufactuer QA actually costing them money in the long run? Would spending the money to insure that a $3,000 lens is up to snuff, even for demanding photographers like us, pay off?
p.17 #10Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
For sure, looking for perfection in terms of corner symmetry with an UWA zoom is asking for trouble, especially at 61MP. But rather good performance across the whole range should be feasible in high end zooms.
You would hope that Sony has gone the extra mile in terms of quality control at this price point, and that these early indicators are anomalous rather than indicative. However, the 16-35 GM also has a track record of considerable sample variation with many reported decentered copies.
In most countries exchange policies are not as generous as in the States, so getting a good copy of this lens could otherwise end up being a very expensive exercise.
I guess, we'll have to wait until he gets his hands on enough copies of the 12-24 to run his battery of tests, to get an overall picture of where things stand with the new GM zoom.
Then again, even if the 12-24 has lower variation than the 16-35, there is a reasonably chance you'll end up with a lemon. The 24-70 GM's variation is in line with its Canikon competition, but I still had to go through two copies that were seriously bad from 60-70mm to get a decent one. The person at the Sony hotline came close to saying "impossible", when I told him I kept having issues with different copies of the lens.
People here don't want to hear it, but I think makers get far fewer copies back than we all think, because a very low % of people actually test their lens as vigorously as many FM users.
p.17 #13Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
j4nu wrote:
Huh, 2 decentered copies and 1 DOA from reported samples so far ... seems it's not gonna be easier to get a good copy of this lens than the Sigma .
p.17 #14Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
GMPhotography wrote:
When we going to get past this.
Not sure whether this was directed at me or the thread in general, but get past what, Guy? The variation issues, the resulting complaints about lemons or me pointing out that things won't change easily ?
I remember asking Roger about the additional cost of reducing variance and seem to recall he mentioned that it wouldn't cost a lot to reduce the number of bad copies, but quite a bit to increase the % of close to perfect copies.
From what I can tell, Sony has improved things quite a bit since the early e-mount days, even though they are still far from perfect. As to how much things will improve from now on, I'm skeptical that thing will change drastically. Yes, higher MP sensors allow easier detection of flaws, so lower tolerances in lens production might be a positive for makers. But at what cost? And would the average user actually appreciate those changes or just complain about makers passing on the cost of lower tolerances on to them?
We make all these assumptions on how "good" or "great" copies are hard to get, based on our own FM feedback loop, i.e. a very flawed sample. In the end, other than Roger's great tests of a dozen copies, we just don't have enough data.
p.17 #15Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Chris_88 wrote: GMPhotography wroteWhen we going to get past this.Not sure whether this was directed at me or the thread in general, but get past what, Guy? The variation issues, the resulting complaints about lemons or me pointing out that things won't change easily ?
I remember asking Roger about the additional cost of reducing variance and seem to recall he mentioned that it wouldn't cost a lot to reduce the number of bad copies, but quite a bit to increase the % of close to perfect copies.
From what I can tell, Sony has improved things quite a bit since the early e-mount days, even though they are still far from perfect. As to how much things will improve from now on, I'm skeptical that thing will change drastically. Yes, higher MP sensors allow easier detection of flaws, so lower tolerances in lens production might be a positive for makers. But at what cost? And would the average user actually appreciate those changes or just complain about makers passing on the cost of lower tolerances on to them?
We make all these assumptions on how "good" or "great" copies are hard to get, based on our own FM feedback loop, i.e. a very flawed sample. In the end, other than Roger's great tests of a dozen copies, we just don't have enough data.
You shouldn't expect that just because a lens is expensive, that it will have tighter manufacturing tolerances. Roger Circala's lens variation testing showed that even Zeiss Otus have similar variation levels to other pro lenses; why?, because the Otus lenses are a complex design, and complexity can cause more sample variation, not less. That said, every Otus is MTF bench tested before leaving the factory, so even Zeiss considers this degree of variation within spec.
The Sony 12-24f2.8 is also a complex design; I doubt Sony does anything more regarding testing this lens before it leaves the factory than it does for any of its other lenses, i.e. the normal procedure of testing a statistically valid sample of each batch is the best you can hope for.
p.17 #16Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Petegh wrote:
You shouldn't expect that just because a lens is expensive, that it will have tighter manufacturing tolerances. Roger Circala's lens variation testing showed that even Zeiss Otus have similar variation levels to other pro lenses; why?, because the Otus lenses are a complex design, and complexity can cause more sample variation, not less. That said, every Otus is MTF bench tested before leaving the factory, so even Zeiss considers this degree of variation within spec.
The Sony 12-24f2.8 is also a complex design; I doubt Sony does anything more regarding testing this lens before it leaves the factory than it does for any of its other lenses, i.e. the normal procedure of testing a statistically valid sample of each batch is the best you can hope for....Show more →
Honestly, I'm not expecting anything. That's exactly the point I was trying to make. On the net, plenty of people seem to believe there is an easy fix to copy variation issues. As a single end user with limited time I consider it an issue as well, but I'm not sure whether the lens manufacturers (after all, this is not just a Sony issue) would even agree with the notion that there is a (major) problem that requires fixing.
p.17 #17Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Chris_88 wrote: GMPhotography wroteWhen we going to get past this.Not sure whether this was directed at me or the thread in general, but get past what, Guy? The variation issues, the resulting complaints about lemons or me pointing out that things won't change easily ?
I remember asking Roger about the additional cost of reducing variance and seem to recall he mentioned that it wouldn't cost a lot to reduce the number of bad copies, but quite a bit to increase the % of close to perfect copies.
From what I can tell, Sony has improved things quite a bit since the early e-mount days, even though they are still far from perfect. As to how much things will improve from now on, I'm skeptical that thing will change drastically. Yes, higher MP sensors allow easier detection of flaws, so lower tolerances in lens production might be a positive for makers. But at what cost? And would the average user actually appreciate those changes or just complain about makers passing on the cost of lower tolerances on to them?
We make all these assumptions on how "good" or "great" copies are hard to get, based on our own FM feedback loop, i.e. a very flawed sample. In the end, other than Roger's great tests of a dozen copies, we just don't have enough data.
p.17 #19Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Chris_88 wrote: GMPhotography wroteThe thread. Why did you think you.never
I’m sick of this cross forum crap. I don’t want to read Canon in a Sony forum. Is I want to read Canon I’ll go thereAh, sorry, my bad. Never mind, it's early, when I posted and probably didn't have enough coffee. I wholeheartedly agree on the cross-posting stuff.
p.17 #20Now In-Stock: Sony FE 12-24mm f/2.8 GM ($2,998)
Even though I was not planning on this lens it’s upsetting to continually see this copy variation. I wish I knew the secret to avoid this. I’ve been really lucky lately with my purchases but how long is that going to last