fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019The 24-240 kicks you know what

  
 
paulfeng
Offline
Details
p.3 #1The 24-240 kicks you know what


JohanEickmeyer wrote:
paulfeng wrote
JohanEickmeyer wroteI also wonder, if Canon has no problem faking their lenses at the wide end, then why would anyone complain if they released a 600mm f4 lens that is less than half the size and weight of the current model, yet to find out Canon just crops the sensor digitally and outputs the same FOV using a 300mm lens design. I personally think people would be laughing them off the ends of the Earth, but for whatever reason, seem more accepting of trickery at the wide end.
On the tele end, one can take an actual 300mm FOV image and crop tighter to a 600mm FOV (obviously with fewer pixels than the 300mm image).

But on the wide end, it's obviously impossible to start with an actual 30mm FOV image and widen the crop for a 24mm FOV. If I understand correctly, what Canon and others are doing is taking an actual 22mm FOV (just for example) with awful vignetting and then cropping tighter to a 24mm FOV, with obviously fewer pixels. Yes?

I'm not thrilled with this approach, but you are getting an image (albeit not at full sensor resolution) with the FOV of the stated focal length on a FF sensor. Similarly, one could adapt an EF-S 10-18mm on an RF mount, then at the reduced image circle get an image having a FOV equivalent to a FF 16mm wide-angle.

I would prefer that Canon (and other camera makers) come up with a clear way of communicating to consumers that this is how they are achieving the advertised "focal lengths".
My point was that the final image output will be less sensor surface area in both instances, but for the logner lenses, people would laugh at Canon for selling a 300mm lens for mirrorless and just cropping it in camera without ever telling anyone it is not a 600mm lens. It's just magically small!


Understood. And my point (which I believe you understand also) is that with this approach on the wide side, they at least do need to supply the optics to provide the appropriately wide FOV, though unfortunately over a smaller image circle.
Sep 07, 2019 at 06:33 AM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.3 #2The 24-240 kicks you know what
So, how big is the barrel distortion at 24mm with the correction off? It's got to be pretty massive if correcting it also removes enough of the corner to compensate for such huge vignetting.
Sep 07, 2019 at 07:06 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #3The 24-240 kicks you know what
mb126 wrote:
Does vignetting settle when stopped down as well?

stanj wrote:
Not really. This is at f8 without lens correction. More testing is needed.


The lens looks quite defective, not fit for purpose.

EBH
Sep 07, 2019 at 08:22 AM
whistlerdan
Offline
Details
p.3 #4The 24-240 kicks you know what
Just to confirm... I also have this lens and I also see the same behaviour. So it’s not a problem with your specific lens.

As others have pointed out, there are other brands that do this but I think it’s going to come as a shock to Canon users.

Not sure how I feel about it.
Sep 07, 2019 at 11:34 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.3 #5The 24-240 kicks you know what
whistlerdan wrote:
Just to confirm... I also have this lens and I also see the same behaviour. So it’s not a problem with your specific lens.

As others have pointed out, there are other brands that do this but I think it’s going to come as a shock to Canon users.

Not sure how I feel about it.


Yeah but nobody does that to such extent... The worst offenders so far had been the Sony 16-50 and 24-105 lenses but their worst was looking like this:
https://opticallimits.com/images/8Reviews/lenses/sony_1650_3556/vig16mmf35.jpg
(from the OpticalLimits.com test of the 16-50 PZ lens at 16mm f/3.5 with lens corrections off)

Edited by Guest on Sep 09, 2019 at 01:33 AM · View previous versions
Sep 08, 2019 at 03:27 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #6The 24-240 kicks you know what
whistlerdan wrote:
Just to confirm... I also have this lens and I also see the same behaviour. So it’s not a problem with your specific lens.

As others have pointed out, there are other brands that do this but I think it’s going to come as a shock to Canon users.

Not sure how I feel about it.


At least this is a cheap, non-L lens. One can hope there will be an L zoom lens with f/5.6 at the long end to replace the 28-300L, but somewhat lighter. Severe distortion correction creates several IQ issues.

EBH
Sep 08, 2019 at 11:25 AM
whistlerdan
Offline
Details
p.3 #7The 24-240 kicks you know what
EB-1 wrote:
At least this is a cheap, non-L lens. One can hope there will be an L zoom lens with f/5.6 at the long end to replace the 28-300L, but somewhat lighter. Severe distortion correction creates several IQ issues.

EBH


Despite this rather startling discovery, I will say that the lens appears to be very sharp. Particularly at the longer end which isn't too surprising because so much less distortion correction is happening there.

My immediate reaction when I saw the vignetting was "this lens is going back". But after looking through more photos I think it will stay because it does what it's supposed to which is provide a light(ish) one lens solution when I don't want to carry my 70-200 or 100-400 II etc.
Sep 08, 2019 at 04:16 PM
judyg
Offline
Details
p.3 #8The 24-240 kicks you know what
I also just purchased this lens. So far, I am loving it. I shoot mostly nature and wildlife, so I don't care all that much about the wide angle part of the equation.

What I am looking for in any lens is focus, sharpness, and bokeh. I found that focus with this lens on the R was quick and accurate. The lens is also very sharp. I was surprised at the sharpness, I did not expect that on a non-L lens. The bokeh is never going to look like the bokeh from the 70-200, but it's not bad, and certainly better than most other non-L lenses I've used.

I wanted this lens as a walkaround lens. I'm tired of always switching lenses. I'm tired of the weight of the L lenses I carry around. This lens is a perfect alternative. It's sharp, it focuses well, and gets good enough bokeh for my everyday purposes.

If I go on a photo vacation or safari, or if I'm going to be shooting birds in flight, I'll take my trusty workhorse 5DIII and my 24-105, 70-200, and 100-400. But for everyday shooting, I will take the R and the 24-240 and be very happy to not be carrying all that gear.

Here is a shot with the R and the 24-240, taken at my local botanical garden.


https://photos.smugmug.com/Other/Butterflies/i-FdcC67g/0/41b451c5/M/tower%20hill%209%205%2019-1--M.jpg
Sep 08, 2019 at 04:47 PM
boxigen
Offline
Details
p.3 #9The 24-240 kicks you know what
judyg wrote:
What I am looking for in any lens is focus, sharpness, and bokeh.


I'm usually looking for love, understanding and commitment in my lenses, but these would work, too.
Sep 08, 2019 at 05:00 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.3 #10The 24-240 kicks you know what
Ok, I have tested the lenses against each other, and I can only say a few things: The lens is not particularly good for servo shooting. Big surprise, but just for kicks I used it today for a shoot of wake boarding on a boat and let's just say that I have way more rejects than when I shoot with my L glass.

The question that I think has been on other people's mind - the huge uncorrected vignetting at the wide end - I think that has a fairly simple explanation, too: at 24mm the lens is actually wider than that, so that the correction profiles can do a pretty good job correcting. Shown below is the uncorrected vignetting compared to the RF24-10L and the EF 24-70m2 at the wide end, wide open to all the way to f8. Note that the uncorrected RF24-240 image is quite a bit wider.








































Sep 08, 2019 at 08:25 PM
jeraldcook
Offline
Details
p.3 #11The 24-240 kicks you know what
stanj wrote:
The question that I think has been on other people's mind - the huge uncorrected vignetting at the wide end - I think that has a fairly simple explanation, too: at 24mm the lens is actually wider than that, so that the correction profiles can do a pretty good job correcting.


Thanks for the test. Looks like I might need to give this lens a chance after all.
Sep 08, 2019 at 08:58 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.3 #12The 24-240 kicks you know what
Indeed. The other thing that I learned was that AF speed and accuracy aside, at f8 the lens is pretty darn impressive across the whole focal range, which is where I'd be using it anyway. A great travel lens.
Sep 08, 2019 at 09:14 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.3 #13The 24-240 kicks you know what
With digital and in particular with EVF, lens designers get away with murder. They simply make the lens a little wider than spec at the wide end, so as to have enough coverage, then apply correction. Distortion and vignetting be damned.

I miss the old days when shooting on slides, truly WYSIWYG, and the lenses have to perform optically.

OK, maybe I don't miss shooting slides, but I like those lenses.

Howard
Sep 10, 2019 at 07:42 AM
MintMar
Offline
Details
p.3 #14The 24-240 kicks you know what
Don't worry guys, L lens f/1.2 bokeh coming soon for your RF 28-90/3.5-5.6 kit lens....
Sep 10, 2019 at 10:45 AM
icefime
Offline
Details
p.3 #15The 24-240 kicks you know what
The question that I think has been on other people's mind - the huge uncorrected vignetting at the wide end - I think that has a fairly simple explanation, too: at 24mm the lens is actually wider than that, so that the correction profiles can do a pretty good job correcting. Shown below is the uncorrected vignetting compared to the RF24-10L and the EF 24-70m2 at the wide end, wide open to all the way to f8. Note that the uncorrected RF24-240 image is quite a bit wider.

Thank you for keeping your cool instead of going for the pitchfork

This will be the perfect family travel lens for me. I wanted a full frame camera And was already invested in canon lenses so now I own an RP because it was cheaper and lighter than a 6d mk2. I already own a few good lenses. But when I travel with my family I dislike carrying besides water, food and coloring books two zooms and a prime. So this lens is perfect. This way I can use my nice full frame camera both when traveling with the family and when I go out specifically to shoot and carrying 5 lenses, flashes and a tripod.
Sep 11, 2019 at 05:09 AM
Aristophanes
Offline
Details
p.3 #16The 24-240 kicks you know what
There appears to be a growing trend in the dedicated camera market towards less lens changes, especially by mid-level consumers.

Many also enjoy the option of not changing lenses for travel purposes or in environments where changing glass may contaminate the sensor.

Therefore it follows that the manufacturers will use any and all techniques to keep the lens compact and affordable.
Sep 11, 2019 at 08:42 AM
diverhank
Offline
Details
p.3 #17The 24-240 kicks you know what
stanj wrote:
Indeed. The other thing that I learned was that AF speed and accuracy aside, at f8 the lens is pretty darn impressive across the whole focal range, which is where I'd be using it anyway. A great travel lens.


Thanks for the thread and the good info. I just ordered one to go with the RP - it will help me enjoy my travels a bit more .
Sep 11, 2019 at 10:05 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #18The 24-240 kicks you know what
Aristophanes wrote:
There appears to be a growing trend in the dedicated camera market towards less lens changes, especially by mid-level consumers.

Many also enjoy the option of not changing lenses for travel purposes or in environments where changing glass may contaminate the sensor.

Therefore it follows that the manufacturers will use any and all techniques to keep the lens compact and affordable.


Actually I'd say the opposite in the MILC arena. There are a myriad of little primes people are using now on SONY for example! Every focal length has about three lenses with apertures from 1.4 to 1.8 to 2.

EBH
Sep 11, 2019 at 08:39 PM
diverhank
Offline
Details
p.3 #19The 24-240 kicks you know what
After reading this thread, I went ahead and ordered one of these. I've had it for a week now...
All in all I like the lens just fine especially for travelling.

Chromatic aberration is fairly pronounced at the wide end, in addition to the darkened corners but everything can be corrected in post. Sharpness around the edges suffer a bit but it's pretty good in the middle. I can tell that overall IQ is not as sharp at the telephoto end.

Like many of you, I have mostly L-lenses...so my data point is against the L-lens performance which is rather unfair for this lens. To me, this is not on-par with the L-lenses but then I know that before I bought it.

I took a whole bunch of pictures in near dark conditions (ISO 8000) and the images

I want to spare myself from lugging multiple heavy L-lenses with me while on travel with family but I also don't want a really bad cheap lens that won't give me the IQ I'm used to. I'd say the 24-240mm will do just fine for me while travelling.

Here's a picture I took @ 240mm...the bokeh is not bad... EOS RP, @ 240mm, f/6.3, 1/500, ISO 250

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2hjsKZ4]
Lovely...[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/tongho58/]
Hien (Hank) Tongho[/url], on Flickr

Sep 23, 2019 at 01:38 PM
RobertLynn
Offline
Details
p.3 #20The 24-240 kicks you know what

I always enjoy reading your posts and feedback and I’m looking forward to your results.
stanj wrote:
I just got the 24-240 and already based on the posted raw photos on DPR I knew it would be great, but I'm very happy with it. It will be my new point & shoot on the R; it's vastly better than the 28-300 that it replaces in my drawer, and better than pretty much anything I had in my collection in 2003 when I got the 1DS.

Given that I just got the RX100v7, there's a definite difference between the "true" P&S and this baby. For people who don't mind the slightly bigger bulk definitely a worthwhile "update".

Because
...Show more →
Sep 23, 2019 at 03:01 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister