I'm expecting the price to drop a bit after a year. I think that's the usual cycle? I'm generally not an early adopter. As long as it's good, I don't mind paying $700 for a 35/1.8.
Charlie N wrote: hiepphotog wroteHolger wrotehiepphotog wroteFred Miranda wroteI'm surprised it only has one aspherical element and the MTF is not much different than the FE 28/2's. The latter is equipped with 3 asphericals (one advanced aspherical) and 2 ED elements.Possibly that Sony optical engineering team has gotten much better since then, though the Nikon has 3 ASPH and 2 ED while the Canon has one ASPH. The Nikon is only a bit better than the Canon in aberration control with flatter FC. Given the Canon can do half size with IS incorporated, I say the Canon was better designed than the Nikon."I say the Canon was better designed than the Nikon"
In what respect? I think it is not really comparable. The Canon is a macro lens and extends. Then there are aspects as sharpness, focus speed etc.In that it's noticeably smaller and lighter with semi-macro and IS (a more compromised design), while showing a slightly inferior IQ (slightly more FC and CA, but with sharper corners). I was talking about the optical design, but even when you look at the focus speed, the Canon isn't behind Nikon. The only thing the Nikon clearly has over the Canon is weather sealing.Looked like a neat lens until I saw the focus zooming out.... that's nifty fifty territory....
Internal focus macro will reduce the focal length as you change the focus closer to the macro distance, so that will shorten the MFD even further. That would make the 35's semi macro ability quite useless I imagine.
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.
vdo1 wrote:
After browsing the available samples, my impression is that optically this lens is in the same league as the Pentax FA 35/2.
We need better samples!!!
Is that good or bad? I don’t know the Pentax lens.
---------------------------------------------
Jman13 wrote:
Conspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.
Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......
The price is a little too high to instantly seal the deal over the Batis 40, but it remains in contention. Glad Sony finally put this lens out but I'll wait for more info before I decide which 35/40 AF to fill my kit with.
Holger wrote: hiepphotog wroteHolger wrotehiepphotog wroteFred Miranda wroteI'm surprised it only has one aspherical element and the MTF is not much different than the FE 28/2's. The latter is equipped with 3 asphericals (one advanced aspherical) and 2 ED elements.Possibly that Sony optical engineering team has gotten much better since then, though the Nikon has 3 ASPH and 2 ED while the Canon has one ASPH. The Nikon is only a bit better than the Canon in aberration control with flatter FC. Given the Canon can do half size with IS incorporated, I say the Canon was better designed than the Nikon."I say the Canon was better designed than the Nikon"
In what respect? I think it is not really comparable. The Canon is a macro lens and extends. Then there are aspects as sharpness, focus speed etc.In that it's noticeably smaller and lighter with semi-macro and IS (a more compromised design), while showing a slightly inferior IQ (slightly more FC and CA, but with sharper corners). I was talking about the optical design, but even when you look at the focus speed, the Canon isn't behind Nikon. The only thing the Nikon clearly has over the Canon is weather sealing.That doesn't say a lot. We don't know the constraints in designing the lenses to judge the expertise and skill of the designers.
Well, can you really draw any conclusion regarding the expertise and skill of the designers for the modern day designs? I can say I'm a little biased to draw that conclusion in that the Z-mount is the biggest and shallowest of all the mirrorless and Nikon wasn't really shy about bringing that up. So in theory, it has all the advantages one can ask for. I personally expected more from the S 35/1.8. It has its focus shift problem and the sharpness at WO is not really world beater by any mean while being the biggest and heaviest 35/1.8 among the mirrorless.
That’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wrote: Jman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......
Mathieu18 wrote:
That’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wroteJman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......
Mathieu18 wrote:
That’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wroteJman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......
Suboptimal AF on the Nikon, especially for the adapted Sony, no thanks :P. I do give it to Nikon that they did break the mold of treating the "slow" 1.8 lenses as consumer-grade products with their Z system. Apparently, they have only produced S-class (Superior) lenses so far regardless of the apertures.
Fred Miranda wrote: Mathieu18 wroteThat’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wroteJman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......Is this still the Sony board?
The EOS RP and the A7 III are not competitors either....the A7 III is better in effectively every single way. And Sony has the A7II available cheaper than the RP.
I still love Sony. Actually I really want to see how this compares. The Z 35/1.8 isn’t perfect but it’s a quite good lens, or I have a Unicorn.paired with the 85 it might not be amazing rendering but should be quite competent.
Fred Miranda wrote: Mathieu18 wroteThat’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wroteJman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......Is this still the Sony board?
Jman13 wrote: bjornthun wroteThe Eos RP is cheaper.The EOS RP and the A7 III are not competitors either....the A7 III is better in effectively every single way. And Sony has the A7II available cheaper than the RP.
Still I think Canon will sell Eos R(I)P + RF 24-240mm as a kit. They are after all behind in mirrorless bodies and sensor tech, which is of their own doing or lack thereof.
Mathieu18 wrote:
That’s why Nikon is better. I can buy this lens or use Nikon’s 35/1.8!
Do wish this had come a couple years ago...
Charlie N wroteJman13 wroteConspiracy theory:
Sony priced this lens solely so that it would be priced less than Nikon and Canon's combined price with their 35/1.8's (regular price...both bodies are discounted at the moment.)
Canon EOS R + 35/1.8 = $2300+500 = $2800.
Nikon Z6 + 35/1.8 = $2000+850 = $2850.
Sony A7 III + 35/1.8 = $2000+750 = $2750.Didn't both Nikon and Canon have body price drops?
Cant imagine folks paying full retail for Nikon and canon bodies...... Sony price is what they think they can get away with. We're sort of trapped aren't we. What option do I have.......
No man, no
Dont trust Nikon innovation, they've dropped the ball so often in the past, they scare me.
bjornthun wrote: Jman13 wrotebjornthun wroteThe Eos RP is cheaper.The EOS RP and the A7 III are not competitors either....the A7 III is better in effectively every single way. And Sony has the A7II available cheaper than the RP.Still I think Canon will sell Eos R(I)P + RF 24-240mm as a kit. They are after all behind in mirrorless bodies and sensor tech, which is of their own doing or lack thereof.
Canon is selling it as a kit RP+24/240 for $2200 (no discount)
For myself... looking forward to some used RX1rII hitting the BS board now. But I'll wait a week or two to see what the mystery RX camera announcement is