I have to admit I was very negative when Sigma were about to release their Art series in the FE mount just looking at the size and weight. I will now say it is a great move as Sigma is also a company that cannot afford to redesign their lenses but in the FE mount will be superb.
I have the 20/1.4, 24/1.4, 35/1.4 and 50/1.4 Art lenses and they are superb lenses.
I have used for portraits the FE 35/1.4 and GM 85 lenses extensively and they are great, but having the Art series in the FE mount with full AF functionality will be amazing. More choices
I had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.
Sigma says that their native FE mounts will exceed the performance of their EF Mount lenses with a MC-11. We are now seeing that there appears to be no redesign of the lens line to meet mirrorless FE Mount specs. The extra size and length with, paid factory, lens mount swapping seems to verify this.
That there are less focus problems with their mirrorless lenses is a result of the mirrorless system not necessarily better Sigma design.
Yes out of 8-12 lenses one or two might be better than Sony/Zeiss however, if you are lucky, you will get what you paid for from Sigma. However, no guarantee that a new body/sensor design will be optimum with an existing Sigma lens. Sigma always has been a lens line that is made for a lesser price. Where are all the those older Sigma lenses for resale like the revered legacy CaNikon lenses?
I don't see a bit of hunting in AF-S as problem (it is just last contrast detect confirmation step) while it works well in AF-C. But camera locking up and later giving problems communicating with lens is a big problem.
This one guy complaining about single AF hunting in YouTube;
I tested with all my cameras (A7, A7r, A7 mkII and A7r mkII) and all lenses except Alpha-mount lenses w/ LA-EA3 will "hunt". But in Sony lenses you can see it only in viewfinder as they don't have window & scale showing where lens is focusing. This was very obvious w/ GM85 (slow & noisy, I can hear back and forth movement of focus group), but with Sony 1.4/35 less obvious (fast & silent, I did only see the "hunting" or "pumping" in the viewfinder). And naturally with Sigma it's obvious as you can see it "externally" just by looking the focusing distance window.
Question: is it really so that A7r mkIII does not at all "hunt" in single AF w/ Sony lenses and works differently compared to all previous models? Or is it just this guy don't know how single AF works?
Ken_Cravillion wrote:
I had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.
Ken, love this shot! Waiting to see more shots with the 105 Art...
Ken_Cravillion wrote:
I had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.
Woooo boy that’s sharp! I’ve been toying around with possibly ordering this lens but was concerned about the size and limited applications of the lens in comparison to something like the 70-200GM but that’s just a beautiful rendered image. 💸
Ken_Cravillion wrote:
I had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.
fotografur wrote: Ken_Cravillion wroteI had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.Was this shot hand held and was eye focus used?
---------------------------------------------
JBM7777 wrote:
Woooo boy that’s sharp! I’ve been toying around with possibly ordering this lens but was concerned about the size and limited applications of the lens in comparison to something like the 70-200GM but that’s just a beautiful rendered image. 💸
Ken_Cravillion wroteI had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.
Yup, shot handheld with Eye-AF.
Having owned the 70-200mm GM thing thing obviously destroys it. It's as sharp as my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E.
And as big as the lens looks it didn't feel big when shooting.
Ken_Cravillion wrote: fotografur wroteKen_Cravillion wroteI had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.Was this shot hand held and was eye focus used?---------------------------------------------
JBM7777 wroteWoooo boy that’s sharp! I’ve been toying around with possibly ordering this lens but was concerned about the size and limited applications of the lens in comparison to something like the 70-200GM but that’s just a beautiful rendered image. 💸
Ken_Cravillion wroteI had a chance to play with a Canon mount Sigma Art 105mm and compared it to my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E AF with the MC11 was pretty good on my A9. Definitely faster than the Nikkor/Commlite combo.Yup, shot handheld with Eye-AF.
Having owned the 70-200mm GM thing thing obviously destroys it. It's as sharp as my Nikkor 105mm f1.4E.
And as big as the lens looks it didn't feel big when shooting.
charles.K wrote:
I have to admit I was very negative when Sigma were about to release their Art series in the FE mount just looking at the size and weight. I will now say it is a great move as Sigma is also a company that cannot afford to redesign their lenses but in the FE mount will be superb.
I have the 20/1.4, 24/1.4, 35/1.4 and 50/1.4 Art lenses and they are superb lenses.
I have used for portraits the FE 35/1.4 and GM 85 lenses extensively and they are great, but having the Art series in the FE mount with full AF functionality will be amazing. More choices ...Show more →
I still see it as meh......
as nice as it is to have a native sony lens, the size factor gets to you real fast. It's nice to have on occasion, but a well balanced lens and camera combo is sort of a big deal after you've shot sony for so long.
no doubt they are great lenses, I have the 135, and it's an amazing optic, but for items like the wider lenses, I think many are willing to pay the same price Sigma charges, for a stop slower and significantly smaller. I think a lens like the tamron 28-75, will outsell all of the sigma lenses combined, and mainly due to the practicality of form factor and performance.
The adapter change could have been done many months ago IMO, sigma had capable firmware for a while now, and I think these new releases just illustrate sigma sitting and waiting. I'm sure they're developing native E-mount lenses now, but they also squandered some time away, not having any foresight into the market.
Ken_Cravillion wrote:
I have this lens till Sunday and will be using it at a wedding tomorrow.
This is too close in my personal opinion. Many lenses can produce an extreme OOF background at these distances, so this doesn't show the real value one could get with this lens. The difference to a studio shot with a backdrop is too small in my opinion.