fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.

  
 
kbutler84
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
I got my Sigma 85mm in day before yesterday and used it for a session yesterday. An hour outside and then another in the studio. So far so good. I don’t mind the size; I knew what I was getting into on that front. I just like the image quality I get from the Art series. AF was snappy. Eye Auto worked great. No complaints here
Jun 09, 2018 at 11:55 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Dj R wrote:
T Gordon you can skip this post, b/c you know how I feel....

I really don't understand who is going to buy these lenses. I suppose folks who don't know any better? Meaning folks transitioning to Sony right now....?



As good as the Sony options are, they're generally significantly more expensive than the Sigma, and their only real advantage is size. The Sigma's are outstanding glass at very reasonable prices.
Jun 09, 2018 at 12:37 PM
BlueBomberTurbo
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
In regards to the OP and the soft corners on the older camera, remember that Sony has also optimized microlenses in each generation.
Jun 09, 2018 at 06:17 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Dj R wrote:
T Gordon you can skip this post, b/c you know how I feel....

I really don't understand who is going to buy these lenses. I suppose folks who don't know any better?

Kind of a rude remark isnt it? Just because is not a product for you, does not mean others considering them "just don't know any better".
Sure when it comes to the 50mm 1.4, IQ wise there is nothing that the Sigma can do to match it. But still $$$ may not be a factor for you but it could be to others.
The 85mm GM is one of my favorite lenses ever and probably the one I use the most. I tested it against two copies of the Sigma and kept the GM but still the Sigma is a really good lens and cheaper. Sure is bigger with the built in adapter but I dont care about size. If someone does then there is the GM or the 1.8 or Batis. Plenty of 85mm options indeed.
How about 135mm 1.8 Art. That lens is simply stunning and no, the Batis does not do it for all of us performance wise.
The Zeiss 35mm 1.4...well the Sigma is sharper across the frame but I never liked the Bokeh. Still, much rather have the Samyang which so far I have yet to see a Zeiss copy that can match the much cheaper Samyang (check Fred's comparisons for example).

So sure, the 85mm GM and 50mm 1.4 are kickass lenses but the 35mm 1.4 with its quick drop of sharpness away from the center, CA and onion rings does not play at that level.
In any case...it is about options..cheaper options, some maybe superior options in some regards at least (35mm) or lenses we do not have at all from Sony like 135mm 1.8 and 105mm 1.4.
In the end, is ALWAYS better to have more options so why get bothered by it?
Regards
Jun 09, 2018 at 08:50 PM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
GabrielPhoto wrote:
Dj R wroteT Gordon you can skip this post, b/c you know how I feel....

I really don't understand who is going to buy these lenses. I suppose folks who don't know any better?
Kind of a rude remark isnt it? Just because is not a product for you, does not mean others considering them "just don't know any better".
Sure when it comes to the 50mm 1.4, IQ wise there is nothing that the Sigma can do to match it. But still $$$ may not be a factor for you but it could be to others.
The 85mm GM is one of my favorite lenses ever and probably the one I use the most. I tested it against two copies of the Sigma and kept the GM but still the Sigma is a really good
...Show more →

Fair response.

I’m offended that they basically just slapped an extra mount onto already large lenses. It’s completely mind boggling.
Jun 09, 2018 at 09:12 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Dj R wrote:
GabrielPhoto wrote
Dj R wroteT Gordon you can skip this post, b/c you know how I feel....

I really don't understand who is going to buy these lenses. I suppose folks who don't know any better?
Kind of a rude remark isnt it? Just because is not a product for you, does not mean others considering them "just don't know any better".
Sure when it comes to the 50mm 1.4, IQ wise there is nothing that the Sigma can do to match it. But still $$$ may not be a factor for you but it could be to others.
The 85mm GM is one of my favorite lenses ever and probably the one I use the most. I tested it against two copies of the Sigma and kept the GM but still the Sigma is a really good lens and cheaper. Sure is bigger with the built in adapter but I dont care about size. If someone does then there is the GM or the 1.8 or Batis. Plenty of 85mm options indeed.
How about 135mm 1.8 Art. That lens is simply stunning and no, the Batis does not do it for all of us performance wise.
The Zeiss 35mm 1.4...well the Sigma is sharper across the frame but I never liked the Bokeh. Still, much rather have the Samyang which so far I have yet to see a Zeiss copy that can match the much cheaper Samyang (check Fred's comparisons for example).

So sure, the 85mm GM and 50mm 1.4 are kickass lenses but the 35mm 1.4 with its quick drop of sharpness away from the center, CA and onion rings does not play at that level.
In any case...it is about options..cheaper options, some maybe superior options in some regards at least (35mm) or lenses we do not have at all from Sony like 135mm 1.8 and 105mm 1.4.
In the end, is ALWAYS better to have more options so why get bothered by it?
Regards
Fair response.

I’m offended that they basically just slapped an extra mount onto already large lenses. It’s completely mind boggling.

It would have been nice for sure to get a version made for our cameras...heck or at least dont make the extra adapter look so different from the rest. Looks like a prototype!
So the question remains..do they have better performance than the MC-11? Of course they claim performance will be better but we shall see about that..
I for now will wait and see before deciding to send mine (Canon EF mount) to be modified to Sony mount. At least the one report I have read here did not sound like AF was working too good which kind of threw me off. :/

Jun 09, 2018 at 10:05 PM
tdlavigne
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
I think people who would consider these (myself included) are probably people who either A) don't want to pay up to 2x as much for maybe 10% improvements in IQ that are likely to go unnoticed by clients, or only visible to photo-nerds on forums...or B) need something Sony doesn't make...and who knows if they'll ever get around to making one.

I have all Sony glass, but the last thing I need is a 135mm (or maybe 105mm). Sony doesn't make one, and I don't see any hints other than internet conjecture that they'll ever make one. So for me, unfortunately Sigma and their ginormous lenses are the only game in town. I'm still holding out hope that there'll be a GM 105/135 at least announced by the time the 135 ships...but I doubt it.
Jun 10, 2018 at 04:39 AM
Samuli Vahonen
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Dj R wrote:
the FE Zeiss Planar 50 f1.4 is a flawless 50mm
stunning bokeh
excellent transitions
AF is superb, AF-C/EYE AF work incredibly well
great build
for ME the extra $500 is nothing

In this side of planet Sigma 50 Art is 700EUR and Sony 50mm f/1.4 is 1850EUR. So either it's 1150EUR more (with today's exchange rate $1287.51), or you could buy 2.64x Sigma 50 Art with same price as 1x Sony. And Sigma comes with 5 year warranty, if that matters for someone.

For me personally the price is not that important, but I already did know that I do not like Sony 50mm f/1.4 rendering style, so I wanted to try something else. I like quite a lot how Sigma 24-35mm f/2 renders, and I figured why the hell not check 50 as well, specially because it's really cheap I will lose only few hundred EUR if keep it for half a year. At time of purchase I did know that 90% likelyhood that I will not like Sigma 50 Art, but one gotta try...

I agree that other Sony f/1.4 lenses are great, thou 35 could have more contrast on focus plane, just a personal preference. Specially I enjoy almost flawless boke of 85 in my nature scenes, and it also has best focus plane rendering of my 85mm lenses from f/1.7 to 2.8 (Loxia 85 is suiting better for my shooting, but only starting from f/3.2-3.5), but I don't like it at all f/1.4 and f/1.6.

-----------------------------------

BlueBomberTurbo wrote:
In regards to the OP and the soft corners on the older camera, remember that Sony has also optimized microlenses in each generation.

Microlenses do not effect how the optical system works (unless their mounting mechanism changes filter stack optical thickness). They affect how individual pixels get their colors. So field curvature and astigmatism are not affected.

I have at the moment A7, A7r, A7mkII and A7r mkII. In addition I have access to A7s and A7r mkIII. For me there is zero difference between any of these how they opically handle for example rangefinder lenses. A7r mkII and A7r mkIII do have backlit CMOS and they have less color issues with large ray angle lenses, but the field curvature and astigmatism are exactly same.

If you have measurements to show otherwise, please link.


Samuli
Jun 10, 2018 at 05:28 AM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Two new Sigma 50/1.4 FE reviews:



Jun 10, 2018 at 06:19 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
tdlavigne wrote:
I think people who would consider these (myself included) are probably people who either A) don't want to pay up to 2x as much for maybe 10% improvements in IQ that are likely to go unnoticed by clients, or only visible to photo-nerds on forums...or B) need something Sony doesn't make...and who knows if they'll ever get around to making one.

I have all Sony glass, but the last thing I need is a 135mm (or maybe 105mm). Sony doesn't make one, and I don't see any hints other than internet conjecture that they'll ever make one. So for me,
...Show more →

For myself it would come down to a need basis to buy Sigma to fill in any holes I may have that Sony or Zeiss is not providing. Sure costs would be another as well. But given the size it would really have to be a strong need. Now the 135 1.8 is one of those lenses that’s more about speed and focal length that don’t exist anywhere else. Foe me buying a 35 or 50 1.4 I’m just not that interested because we have other options. One lens that’s quite good is the 25-35 F2 and if want speed and a zoom a nice choice.
Jun 10, 2018 at 06:48 AM
tdlavigne
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
GMPhotography wrote:
tdlavigne wroteI think people who would consider these (myself included) are probably people who either A) don't want to pay up to 2x as much for maybe 10% improvements in IQ that are likely to go unnoticed by clients, or only visible to photo-nerds on forums...or B) need something Sony doesn't make...and who knows if they'll ever get around to making one.

I have all Sony glass, but the last thing I need is a 135mm (or maybe 105mm). Sony doesn't make one, and I don't see any hints other than internet conjecture that they'll ever make one. So for me, unfortunately Sigma and their ginormous lenses are the only game in town. I'm still holding out hope that there'll be a GM 105/135 at least announced by the time the 135 ships...but I doubt it.
For myself it would come down to a need basis to buy Sigma to fill in any holes I may have that Sony or Zeiss is not providing. Sure costs would be another as well. But given the size it would really have to be a strong need. Now the 135 1.8 is one of those lenses that’s more about speed and focal length that don’t exist anywhere else. Foe me buying a 35 or 50 1.4 I’m just not that interested because we have other options. One lens that’s quite good is the 25-35 F2 and if want speed
...Show more →

Pretty much exactly how I feel. I really want Sony to make more GM primes, but if they don't...I still need to get those holes in my lens lineup filled somehow.
Jun 11, 2018 at 08:20 AM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
tdlavigne wrote:
I really want Sony to make more GM primes, but if they don't...I still need to get those holes in my lens lineup filled somehow.


they will for sure. all these bodies they are selling?

let's discuss, we have
zony 35
zony 50
sony 85 GM

so sony would sell more glass, right away, if they go:
24 1.4 GM - 2018 August
105 1.4 GM - 2018 December

eventually, give us:
14 2 GM - 2019 February
135 2 GM - 2019 February
200 2 GM - 2019 April
35 1.4 GM - 2019 August
50 1.4 GM, I think this would be last, since the Zony is so good. 2020 spring?
85 1.4 GM, by this point, this lens could use a reboot? 2020 fall?

this is all speculation and just BS'ing here!
Jun 11, 2018 at 09:18 AM
tdlavigne
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Dj R wrote:
tdlavigne wroteI really want Sony to make more GM primes, but if they don't...I still need to get those holes in my lens lineup filled somehow.
they will for sure. all these bodies they are selling?

let's discuss, we have
zony 35
zony 50
sony 85 GM

so sony would sell more glass, right away, if they go:
24 1.4 GM - 2018 August
105 1.4 GM - 2018 December

eventually, give us:
14 2 GM - 2019 February
135 2 GM - 2019 February
200 2 GM - 2019 April
35 1.4 GM - 2019 August
50 1.4 GM, I think this would be last, since the Zony is so good. 2020 spring?
85 1.4 GM, by this point, this lens could use a reboot? 2020 fall?

this is all speculation and just BS'ing here!


Oh I'm sure they will eventually...but as a former Nikon user you probably know that even they're still on their 135 from like 20 years ago with no update in sight. As I understand it, it's not that popular a focal length so it's never a priority for manufacturers. 105, 135, 200...all fairly specialized...and costly, and my only worry is that because of this it might be this year...or 5 years...or who knows when.

I know I'm just being greedy, since I have all the other lenses I need so far...but I really want a fast tele lol.
Jun 11, 2018 at 10:14 PM
phototiimo
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Any more tests of field curvature or sensor stack issues?
Jun 11, 2018 at 10:24 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #15Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Samuli Vahonen wrote:
sungphoto wroteRegarding the harsh/unpleasant bokeh, I personally have found this to be the case with the sigma art 50 and 35 on canon, Nikon and adapted to Sony - I much prefer the rendering of the FE Zeiss Planar 50 f1.4 (a lens I liked enough that I often try to justify picking up another full frame Sony body)
I'm not that far in my studies that I could say about boke overall, initial feeling is boke is mostly good, but quite high contrast (not the worst, but VERY far away for example from Zeiss SLR Planars), transition zone mostly looks good. But I'll have to get out with the lens many more times, as this lens boke seems to be complicated and I find hard time understanding what some of the behaviours.

The corner boke issue I mentioned in page 1 post #2 is separate topic, it's about potential field curvature/astigmatism issue. The scene where I first noticed
...Show more →

I can see that rough bokeh on the corners with the CV40/1.2 E-mount wide open which is likely from field curvature. In the case of the Sigma 50/1.4, it could be induced field curvature but perhaps it also shows up on a Canon/Nikon as well.
Jun 11, 2018 at 10:41 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #16Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Samuli Vahonen wrote:
GMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.

Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.

GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money
...Show more →

In the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.

The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.
Jun 11, 2018 at 10:44 PM
Samuli Vahonen
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
phototiimo wrote:
Any more tests of field curvature or sensor stack issues?

For proper test I would need Canon 1D-series camera and Sigma 50 Art w/ Canon mount. I don't have neither one...

I have been few times shooting with Sigma 50 Art and my feeling is that I do not want to waste more of my time shooting standard thick sensor cover glass camera. I see way too many corner boke issues, where same content in middle of frame is completely OK. Some of it comes from the lens design for sure, but thick cover glass makes the issue worse. For majority of people this lens should be OK; if I would only shoot portraits in urban environment I would have never seen anything distracting in boke. Unfortunately for me my loved shooting environment (old evergreen forests) is just very difficult environment to shoot in what comes to boke and reveals any boke faults in no time.

Due to weak lens mount in my Kolari v2 modified cameras, I'm afraid to shoot Sigma with them, it's just too heavy. Original A7 had 2 piece lens mount; the ring which comes against the lens is metal but below that there is plastic ring with tabs, and lens actually attaches to the plastic tabs. I spent almost half an hour creating proper support mechanism, which will prevent Sigma to twist the lens mount and keeps lens & sensor aligned to same plane when I was shooting test photos in my living room - that can't be transferred to outdoors shooting... I ordered Fotodiox Tough Mount for both of my A7 Kolari v2 cameras, once they come I can take actual outdoor shots with Sigma 50 Art w/ Kolari v2 modified camera without being afraid of breaking the camera or having lens tilted compared to sensor.


Samuli
Jun 12, 2018 at 12:56 AM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Another short review with Sigma 50/1.4


Jun 12, 2018 at 02:47 AM
phototiimo
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Thanks for your insight, Samuli. I look forward to hearing any updates about your experience. As for sensor stack/field curvature issues with these lenses, does anyone know if this was also a problem with adapted Sigma lenses and the MC-11?
Jun 12, 2018 at 02:50 AM
InFocus2014
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
I received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com










Jun 12, 2018 at 02:40 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister