Sigma 50/1.4 FE from somebody who has shot Sigma 50/1.4 Art on both Nikon and Canon previously, also comparing with 55/1.8 ZA:
Sigma 50/1.4 FE vs. EF MC-11, mostly video stuff:
Sigma 105/1.4 sony+godox outdoor shoot Japanese commentary and pictures:
I compared my FE50/1.4 to the 50 At with Metabones. The Sony was sharper, had less CAs and is better sealed (I had the Sigma fog a few times aleady). Because of that we bought a second FE50/1.4 for our business.
The 35 Art wasn't as sharp as the Canon 35/1.4ii, which I now replaced with the Samyang 35/1.4. My copy is as sharp as the 35/1.4ii.
The Sigma lens I am really considering is the 20/1.4, though.
GabrielPhoto wrote: InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.
The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).
The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).
My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):
Jeff
www.gr8photography.comInteresting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:
In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.
Regards
My experience was similar. My sigma was maybe a tiny bit sharper in the center, but not at the 1/3 lines and I found the GM rendering to be much nicer. Sold the Sigma 85 and bought the Batis 85 in addition to the 85GM for travel and lightweight work.
Fred Miranda wrote: Samuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.
I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?
RoseandCharles wrote:
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I'm not a FM, but my opinion is that 100 STF has really nice bokeh when you can see it. If you are doing head-only portrait there will be plenty of the smooth bokeh visible. If you do fit-whole-person portrait, the bokeh will be quite small, so small that its quality will not be much perceived.
On the other hand my Sigma 135/1.8 has quite nice background bokeh. Examples at two different distances at f/1.8:
RoseandCharles wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?...Show more →
I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective. Personally, I don't like the 100STF rendering, it looks artificial for my taste, like iphone background bokeh rendering using computational photography algorithms.
Holger wrote: RoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective.
FE1.4/50 is very good on boke, which has low frequency (=almost everything in urban environment scenes). But it is really awful when you have high frequency and high contrast (=e.g. foliage and about everything in nature). If you only shoot head and shoulder portraits, flowers or full body portraits in urban environment, you have only seen "the good" in FE1.4/50 boke. On top of serious issues with high frequency & high contrast boke scenerios FE1.4/50 has very high contrast in boke. This makes the other boke quality issues more visible. I just can't understand why people can claim that FE1.4/50 has great boke, when it's great only in some scenarios and absolute horrendous in other scenarios. So I guess we disagree strongly on this topic.
I'm not trying to "defend" Sony 50 Art; it has also shitty rendering of background boke with high frequency & high contrast, thou little less contrast in boke compared to focus plane than FE1.4/50. Under ANY circumstances I could not make generic claim that either lens has good boke, without specifying, which kind of scene I'm referring. On boke quality, of mentioned nature scenes with high frequency&contrast, both get beaten by numerous lenses, of which none renders the focus plane as good as these two e.g. Zeiss Planar 1.4/50 ZE/ZF @ f/2.5, Rokkor 58mm f/1.2 @ f/2-2.4...
Of modern lenses I can't find many lenses, which have truly good boke. GM85 is really exceptional in this respect, as long as you forget the crappy apertures f/1.4 and f/1.6 and think the lens as "maximum aperture f/1.7"-lens.
PS. To overcome to superugly high frequency & high contrast (=e.g. foliage, forest undergroth etc.) in nature scenes I found best method to always use polarizer with Sigma 50 Art, when shooting nature scenes; I can reduce/eliminate the small highlights reflected from wax from the leaves of trees/plants/etc. which turns the boke high frequency detail from high contrast to low contrast, from which Sigma usually survives (I would assume same applies FE1.4/50). Personally this is little disappointment as over the years I have found group of Zeiss lenses with optimal apertures and shooting distances, which did not need polarizer and I have been enjoying "real colors" of scenes. So I guess it's back to polarizer colors when I want to shoot faster than ~f/2.5.
Samuli Vahonen wrote: Holger wroteRoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective.FE1.4/50 is very good on boke, which has low frequency (=almost everything in urban environment scenes). But it is really awful when you have high frequency and high contrast (=e.g. foliage and about everything in nature). If you only shoot head and shoulder portraits, flowers or full body portraits in urban environment, you have only seen "the good" in FE1.4/50 boke. On top of serious issues with high frequency & high contrast boke scenerios FE1.4/50 has very high contrast in boke. This makes the other boke quality issues more visible. I just can't understand why people can claim that FE1.4/50 has great boke, when it's great only in some scenarios and absolute horrendous in other scenarios. So I guess we disagree strongly on this topic.
I'm not trying to "defend" Sony 50 Art; it has also shitty rendering of background boke with high frequency & high contrast, thou little less contrast in boke compared to focus plane than FE1.4/50. Under ANY circumstances I could not make generic claim that either lens has good boke, without specifying, which kind of scene I'm referring. On boke quality, of mentioned nature scenes with high frequency&contrast, both get beaten by numerous lenses, of which none renders the focus plane as good as these two e.g. Zeiss Planar 1.4/50 ZE/ZF @ f/2.5, Rokkor 58mm f/1.2 @ f/2-2.4...
Of modern lenses I can't find many lenses, which have truly good boke. GM85 is really exceptional in this respect, as long as you forget the crappy apertures f/1.4 and f/1.6 and think the lens as "maximum aperture f/1.7"-lens.
PS. To overcome to superugly high frequency & high contrast (=e.g. foliage, forest undergroth etc.) in nature scenes I found best method to always use polarizer with Sigma 50 Art, when shooting nature scenes; I can reduce/eliminate the small highlights reflected from wax from the leaves of trees/plants/etc. which turns the boke high frequency detail from high contrast to low contrast, from which Sigma usually survives (I would assume same applies FE1.4/50). Personally this is little disappointment as over the years I have found group of Zeiss lenses with optimal apertures and shooting distances, which did not need polarizer and I have been enjoying "real colors" of scenes. So I guess it's back to polarizer colors when I want to shoot faster than ~f/2.5.
Samuli...Show more →
Yes, we disagree strongly in that regard. Bokeh is a very subjective thing, too, and I can't share your strong aversion at all.
Holger wrote: RoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective. Personally, I don't like the 100STF rendering, it looks artificial for my taste, like iphone background bokeh rendering using computational photography algorithms.
I used to think that the 100 STF rendering was artificial, and in some circumstances it seems that way, but most of the time the bokeh is just so creamy smooth and allows the subject to pop out in a very 3D-like manner. It works best when there's foreground and background in addition to the subject.
I would say that we shoot in foliage and mountain/nature scenes frequently enough that good rendering of the background is very important to us. I feel that it really helps separate the subject from the busy foliage of the background.
jtra wrote: RoseandCharles wroteI'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.I'm not a FM, but my opinion is that 100 STF has really nice bokeh when you can see it. If you are doing head-only portrait there will be plenty of the smooth bokeh visible. If you do fit-whole-person portrait, the bokeh will be quite small, so small that its quality will not be much perceived.
On the other hand my Sigma 135/1.8 has quite nice background bokeh. Examples at two different distances at f/1.8:
The Sigma 135mm is a great lens. It would be a tad bit smaller and lighter than the 70-200mm/2.8 GM. I assume you're using it on the adapter since the FE mount version isn't out yet?
Sigma 50 and 135 Art would be a really good portrait pair. The rumors of the Sony 135GM still haven't materialized, and would probably cost more. This is a tempting route to go for sure.
Holger wrote: RoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective. Personally, I don't like the 100STF rendering, it looks artificial for my taste, like iphone background bokeh rendering using computational photography algorithms.
I think your comments on the STF bokeh overstate the case and comparing the optical effects of the apodization filter to iphone processing to be apples and oranges (pardon the pun). I tend to agree with Rose and Charles and in most cases I find the bokeh from the STF to be quite pleasing. I did find a significant learning curve with the lens and it can look overdone/plasticky in some circumstances. However, with time I found it to be a really fine lens--sharp and well corrected with extraordinary quality of bokeh--and a great arrow to have in the quiver. I do not prefer its output in many cases to say the GM 85, but in some cases it produces images I like over any other lens I own. Have you spent much time with the lens?
Luvwine wrote: Holger wroteRoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective. Personally, I don't like the 100STF rendering, it looks artificial for my taste, like iphone background bokeh rendering using computational photography algorithms.I think your comments on the STF bokeh overstate the case and comparing the optical effects of the apodization filter to iphone processing to be apples and oranges (pardon the pun). I tend to agree with Rose and Charles and in most cases I find the bokeh from the STF to be quite pleasing. I did find a significant learning curve with the lens and it can look overdone/plasticky in some circumstances. However, with time I found it to be a really fine lens--sharp and well corrected with extraordinary quality of bokeh--and a great arrow to have in the quiver. I do not prefer its output in many cases to say the GM 85, but in some cases it produces images I like over any other lens I own. Have you spent much time with the lens? ...Show more →
You are entitled to your opinion, as I am to mine. I find it artificial.
jtra wrote: Holger wroteYes, we disagree strongly in that regard. Bokeh is a very subjective thing, too, and I can't share your strong aversion at all.Bokeh can be analyzed and described objectively.
I have analyzed its relationship to spherical aberration here: http://jtra.cz/stuff/essays/bokeh/
I think you need to be careful here. You can define a metric, of course, which _you_ think to describe Bokeh according to your understanding and analyse it. That is fine, but others might chose a different approach, different metrics, different weights, whatever. Basically you just put forward a theory, like others did and try to support it with some samples. You can analyse your defined metrics objectively only if you restrain yourself to pure mathematics. How else will you avoid personal bias?
All that doesn't change that people have different priorities and preferences regarding what people call bokeh in the final image, often meaning totally different things.
jtra wrote:
I'm not a FM, but my opinion is that 100 STF has really nice bokeh when you can see it. If you are doing head-only portrait there will be plenty of the smooth bokeh visible. If you do fit-whole-person portrait, the bokeh will be quite small, so small that its quality will not be much perceived.
On the other hand my Sigma 135/1.8 has quite nice background bokeh. Examples at two different distances at f/1.8:
RoseandCharles wrote:
The Sigma 135mm is a great lens. It would be a tad bit smaller and lighter than the 70-200mm/2.8 GM. I assume you're using it on the adapter since the FE mount version isn't out yet?
These are actually from Nikon D750 (lit by AD600BM and AD200 together).
I now have both D750 and A7III. I have got annoyed by focus issues with my D750 (worse with Sigmas, well the 24/1.4 most, 135/1.8 is okish, but not just them, Nikkors as well; my and most borrowed lenses are at +20 AF tune or beyond since shutter replacement). It is usable, but amount of pictures lost due to misfocus is not small when photographing people (landscapes are perfect though). Nikon did not fix it in first camera trip to service center claiming it is within spec (I did not include lenses as I was using them in mean time on a6000 with manual adapter and I did want them to correct body anyway, not lenses as there were issues with borrowed lenses too).
The whole session from which the two above pictures come from were focused in liveview so I thought if I'm using DSLR in its inferior liveview, I might be using real mirrorless. That is why I bought A7III. It is focusing way better (with native Sony lenses) than my D750. Ergonomy on A7III is worse in many ways, but better in some ways too. I'm interested in how E-mount Sigmas will work on A7III especially because Sigma offers paid mount conversion service which should include also conversion from F-mount to E-mount once E-mount lenses are released.
So I'm now evaluating which body (and lens system) to keep :-) But I will give D750 second chance at service center this time with lenses.
Maybe Nikon will come with amazing mirrorless in meantime that will work perfectly with my existing F-mount lenses including Sigma, that would thwart my migration to Sony, but I guess for Nikon mirrorless I would have to change lenses anyway (due to new rumored Z-mount) and chances are much higher that rumored "sophisticated F-mount lens to Z-mount body adapter" will be causing problems with Sigmas.
RoseandCharles wrote: Holger wroteRoseandCharles wroteFred Miranda wroteSamuli Vahonen wroteGMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
SamuliIn the case of the 100-400GM, I think bokeh it's pretty good or at least average compared to 'other' 100-400mm lenses. Still crap like you said.
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.I have to agree about the Tamron 28-75, Sony 50mm f1.4 and 100-400 bokeh/background rendering.
I'm curious though, what are your thoughts about the 100 STF bokeh rendering? Is it "too perfect" for your tastes? In our case we've really, really enjoyed the look, but wish there was more of it. I think the 85 or 70-200 GM might be in our future, but some samples from the Sigma Art lenses also have us intrigued.
I would love to see more side-by-side bokeh comparison between the various f1.4 lenses. It seems like the Samyang lenses are less sharp, have more CA but have more pleasing background blur, while the Sigma Art lenses are sharper, have less CA and a bit busier bokeh. Is this the case or am I imagining things?I disagree strongly about the FE50/1.4 bokeh background rendering being bad or mediocre. I like it very much and I used quite a few 50mm lenses. We have seen and taken many images I find very pleasing wrt rendering. Of course that is subjective. Personally, I don't like the 100STF rendering, it looks artificial for my taste, like iphone background bokeh rendering using computational photography algorithms.I used to think that the 100 STF rendering was artificial, and in some circumstances it seems that way, but most of the time the bokeh is just so creamy smooth and allows the subject to pop out in a very 3D-like manner. It works best when there's foreground and background in addition to the subject.
I would say that we shoot in foliage and mountain/nature scenes frequently enough that good rendering of the background is very important to us. I feel that it really helps separate the subject from the busy foliage of the background.
jtra wrote: jtra wroteI'm not a FM, but my opinion is that 100 STF has really nice bokeh when you can see it. If you are doing head-only portrait there will be plenty of the smooth bokeh visible. If you do fit-whole-person portrait, the bokeh will be quite small, so small that its quality will not be much perceived.
On the other hand my Sigma 135/1.8 has quite nice background bokeh. Examples at two different distances at f/1.8:
http://jtra.cz/foto/20180528-pavel-a-jana/preview/20180528192402_10005.medium.jpgRoseandCharles wroteThe Sigma 135mm is a great lens. It would be a tad bit smaller and lighter than the 70-200mm/2.8 GM. I assume you're using it on the adapter since the FE mount version isn't out yet?These are actually from Nikon D750 (lit by AD600BM and AD200 together).
I now have both D750 and A7III. I have got annoyed by focus issues with my D750 (worse with Sigmas, well the 24/1.4 most, 135/1.8 is okish, but not just them, Nikkors as well; my and most borrowed lenses are at +20 AF tune or beyond since shutter replacement). It is usable, but amount of pictures lost due to misfocus is not small when photographing people (landscapes are perfect though). Nikon did not fix it in first camera trip to service center claiming it is within spec (I did not include lenses as I was using them in mean time on a6000 with manual adapter and I did want them to correct body anyway, not lenses as there were issues with borrowed lenses too).
The whole session from which the two above pictures come from were focused in liveview so I thought if I'm using DSLR in its inferior liveview, I might be using real mirrorless. That is why I bought A7III. It is focusing way better (with native Sony lenses) than my D750. Ergonomy on A7III is worse in many ways, but better in some ways too. I'm interested in how E-mount Sigmas will work on A7III especially because Sigma offers paid mount conversion service which should include also conversion from F-mount to E-mount once E-mount lenses are released.
So I'm now evaluating which body (and lens system) to keep :-) But I will give D750 second chance at service center this time with lenses.
Maybe Nikon will come with amazing mirrorless in meantime that will work perfectly with my existing F-mount lenses including Sigma, that would thwart my migration to Sony, but I guess for Nikon mirrorless I would have to change lenses anyway (due to new rumored Z-mount) and chances are much higher that rumored "sophisticated F-mount lens to Z-mount body adapter" will be causing problems with Sigmas.
We came from micro focus adjustment hell, too, which is worse when shooting with zooms. It's nice to not have to worry about that these days.
I don't really pay too much attention to what "could" be in the future. Right now the continuous eye AF is really invaluable for my shooting at work and for leisure.
As an aside, I would love to see some comprehensive side-by-side comparisons between Sigma Art vs Sony, for 35mm f1.4, 50mm f1.4 and 85mm f1.4 lenses. Also, since the Sigma 85mm f1.4 is the same size and weight as the 135mm f1.8 lens, it would seem that the 135mm might be a better way to go for the extra reach.
Regarding bokeh: I think with the 35mm and 50mm focal lengths, it's the overlapping circular highlights in the background foliage that can be very distracting. On longer lenses with larger bokeh balls, it can be a very nice look.