fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.

  
 
fplstudio
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Has anyone compared AF of any Sigma FE vs Sigma EF+MC-11?
Jun 12, 2018 at 03:24 PM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Samuli Vahonen wrote
GMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.

Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.

GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.

Samuli
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.


Well you’re not going to win over any Tamron friends with that attitude

Jun 12, 2018 at 04:59 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
fotografur wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Samuli Vahonen wrote
GMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.

Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.

GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.

Samuli
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.
Well you’re not going to win over any Tamron friends with that attitude



Personally I use a zoom for convenience and if OOF rendering is important for the shot, out come my primes. I'm looking at the Tamron for a travel zoom...fairly light, good speed and a decent range...for when I just don't want to go out with primes.
Jun 12, 2018 at 05:11 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #4Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Friends don’t have to agree on everything!

fotografur wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Samuli Vahonen wrote
GMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.

Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.

GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.

Samuli
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.
Well you’re not going to win over any Tamron friends with that attitude


Jun 12, 2018 at 05:12 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
InFocus2014 wrote:
I received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight
...Show more →
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards

Jun 12, 2018 at 05:15 PM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
chez wrote:
fotografur wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Samuli Vahonen wrote
GMPhotography wroteNot a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.

Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.

GMPhotography wroteI’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.

Samuli
The Tamron 28-75's OOF rendering is horrendous. I just don't know how to be polite about this one.
Well you’re not going to win over any Tamron friends with that attitude

Personally I use a zoom for convenience and if OOF rendering is important for the shot, out come my primes. I'm looking at the Tamron for a travel zoom...fairly light, good speed and a decent range...for when I just don't want to go out with primes.


You’re right Chez. Different tools for different results.
Jun 12, 2018 at 05:28 PM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
85mm test of video

Jun 12, 2018 at 11:07 PM
InFocus2014
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
I guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote:
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards



Jun 13, 2018 at 04:31 AM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
InFocus2014 wrote:
I guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards

My theory is that they are so close in sharpness that which one comes on top will be determined by the individual copy tested.
Still in the end, the GM I have was sharper than the two copies I tested, and even without comparing, the sharpness at 1.4 is at a level that meets my needs for my work, allowing me to crop with enough detail, etc. And of course, the beautiful Bokeh, so I am happy with it even though at first my bank account was not as happy with my choice
Jun 13, 2018 at 10:48 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #10Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
InFocus2014 wrote:
I guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards


Lensrentals tests at infinity distance and perhaps Sigma does better there when wide-open.
Jun 13, 2018 at 11:28 AM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
GabrielPhoto wrote:
My theory is that they are so close in sharpness that which one comes on top will be determined by the individual copy tested.
Still in the end, the GM I have was sharper than the two copies I tested, and even without comparing, the sharpness at 1.4 is at a level that meets my needs for my work, allowing me to crop with enough detail, etc. And of course, the beautiful Bokeh, so I am happy with it even though at first my bank account was not as happy with my choice


thx for reporting your feedback, well done.
so they are close, with the GM being lighter, shorter in length,
and it has the button on the barrel!

Jun 13, 2018 at 12:34 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Fred Miranda wrote:
InFocus2014 wroteI guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards
Lensrentals tests at infinity distance and perhaps Sigma does better there when wide-open.


That is a VERY good point since my tests were portrait work only. I do recall a quick sample of a distant building where the Sigma looked sharper specially away from the center. I thought maybe I messed something up since it was a quick couple of images I took, but now what you are saying makes sense of that experience.
Jun 13, 2018 at 12:36 PM
InFocus2014
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
GabrielPhoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards
Lensrentals tests at infinity distance and perhaps Sigma does better there when wide-open.
That is a VERY good point since my tests were portrait work only. I do recall a quick sample of a distant building where the Sigma looked sharper specially away from the center. I thought maybe I messed something up since it was a quick couple of images I took, but now what you are saying makes sense of that experience.



I do not wish to argue this point. I will say that I have carefully tested two copies of the 85 ART against two copies of the GM 85 and the Sigma lenses were noticeably sharper at any distance. The following is a portrait shot I took last night wide-open on the Sigma lens, with little sharpening (the background was originally much smoother - I added a lot of contract to the background). I can tell you that neither of my GM lenses would have been this good at f1.4.

To be clear, I am still a fan of the GM 85 and will continue to use it (it beats the heck out of the Nikon 85mm f1.4 and Canon 85mm f1.2L II that I used to shoot). When I need the highest IQ, however, and in shooting situations where weight is not a factor, I will reach for the Sigma lens.

A7RIII, Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, f1.4, ISO 100, 1/200, two AD200 flashes




Jun 13, 2018 at 04:21 PM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
InFocus2014 wrote:
GabrielPhoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI guess you need to ask why your results were so different from the LensRentals tests. Of course, when any of us test just one lens, the tests will never be statistically valid.

GabrielPhoto wrote
InFocus2014 wroteI received my Sigma FE 85mm f1.4 ART, yesterday. It is clearly much sharper wide-open than my GM 85. It also focuses more reliably in low-light - particularly the Eye Focus. The sharpness out toward the edge of the frame is amazing. As a note, this is my second GM 85, which is noticeably sharper than the first one I had.

The Sigma seems slightly longer in FL than the GM lens and the bokeh is just a bit smoother (that was a surprise).

The takeaway? For travel and general street photography, I'll shoot the GM 85 due to the smaller size/weight (often stopped-down to f1.6 or f1.8). For critical work, I'll shoot the ART lens (when not shooting the 135mm ART, my favorite portrait lens).

My experience comparing the two lenses pretty much follows the LensRentals tests for the two lenses (the ART lens being the DSLR mount):

Jeff
www.gr8photography.com
Interesting. My experience was the complete opposite when I compared four 85mm lenses:


In fact, I was expecting the Sigma to be sharper and since the first copy failed to do so, I decided to try a second and once again my GM was sharper not to mention nicer Bokeh too.
Also, focusing with the GM has never been an issue for me unless I was running it without the firmware update.

Regards
Lensrentals tests at infinity distance and perhaps Sigma does better there when wide-open.
That is a VERY good point since my tests were portrait work only. I do recall a quick sample of a distant building where the Sigma looked sharper specially away from the center. I thought maybe I messed something up since it was a quick couple of images I took, but now what you are saying makes sense of that experience.
I do not wish to argue this point. I will say that I have carefully tested two copies of the 85 ART against two copies of the GM 85 and the Sigma lenses were noticeably sharper at any distance. The following is a portrait shot I took last night wide-open on the Sigma lens, with little sharpening (the background was originally much smoother - I added a lot of contract to the background). I can tell you that neither of my GM lenses would have been this good at f1.4.

To be clear, I am still a fan of the GM
...Show more →
There is nothing to argue indeed. You had your experience, I had mine (I did a video review of it). Neither of the Sigma was close to the GM for my portrait work and trust me, I WANTED them to be..first because I could have saved money and second because unlike a lot of people, I am a sucker for BIG lenses...they make me feel that less compromises were made
Jun 13, 2018 at 04:45 PM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
Initial review of 50/1.4 with promise of more comparisons:

Jun 14, 2018 at 12:17 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
That’s like me standing next to a NBA basketball player. Lol

I’m 5’7” on a good day
Jun 14, 2018 at 07:14 AM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
A new video comparing Sigma 50/1.4 Art e-mount with Sony Zeiss 50/1.4 ZA


Jun 14, 2018 at 11:56 PM
Leonberger
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
BHphoto is showing the Sigma 35mm 1.4 as being in stock!

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1393492-REG/sigma_35mm_f_1_4_dg_hsm.html

Jun 15, 2018 at 05:14 AM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
New video with Sigma 35/1.4, unboxing and short AF test:

Jun 15, 2018 at 06:17 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Sigma Art FE-mount discussion/tests/etc.
The one lens I have a little interest in is the 24 1.4. Only because it’s cheaper than the Batis 25 but size is not something I want.
Jun 15, 2018 at 06:21 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister