chez wrote: thrice wroteI just saw this and instantly lost all interest. So much for "mirrorless has no size benefit above 50mm".
https://image.ibb.co/nneW58/FB_IMG_1528372536468.jpg
Image belongs to David KilpatrickWe are comparing a 1.4 to a 1.8 lens right? Don't we get the same picture if we put the mirrorless made Sony 85 1.4 against the 1.8 lens?
KarmaKramer wrote:
How are Leica's so amazing and yet remain pretty small,excluding the Noctilux which is big I hear. Is it an autofocus thing..??
They have (had?) a very strong design constraint to keep lenses small. The majority of their lenses are wides.
The issue that arises is higher vignetting, which I never saw a huge issue unless you're doing repro work.
Due to a rangefinder having short flange-focal distance the lenses can be closer to the film plane.
In the past a telecentric design wasn't needed (film didn't really care how oblique the light was) and they could use semi-symmetrical lens designs which are simpler to correct and usually produce less distortion.
Obviously the advent of digital has changed things somewhat and some of the old Leica wides don't play so nice.
They had (somewhat inconsistently of late) very tight quality control and did all their lens element grinding/polishing/coating in-house. That degree of control also ensured higher general quality.
Oh and they charged a lot more for the lenses so they could put higher cost glass and more man-power into their production.
thrice wrote: KarmaKramer wroteHow are Leica's so amazing and yet remain pretty small,excluding the Noctilux which is big I hear. Is it an autofocus thing..??They have (had?) a very strong design constraint to keep lenses small. The majority of their lenses are wides.
The issue that arises is higher vignetting, which I never saw a huge issue unless you're doing repro work.
Due to a rangefinder having short flange-focal distance the lenses can be closer to the film plane.
In the past a telecentric design wasn't needed (film didn't really care how oblique the light was) and they could use semi-symmetrical lens designs which are simpler to correct and usually produce less distortion.
Obviously the advent of digital has changed things somewhat and some of the old Leica wides don't play so nice.
They had (somewhat inconsistently of late) very tight quality control and did all their lens element grinding/polishing/coating in-house. That degree of control also ensured higher general quality.
Oh and they charged a lot more for the lenses so they could put higher cost glass and more man-power into their production....Show more →
chez wrote: thrice wroteI just saw this and instantly lost all interest. So much for "mirrorless has no size benefit above 50mm".
https://image.ibb.co/nneW58/FB_IMG_1528372536468.jpg
Image belongs to David KilpatrickWe are comparing a 1.4 to a 1.8 lens right? Don't we get the same picture if we put the mirrorless made Sony 85 1.4 against the 1.8 lens?
I put my Zeiss ZF.2 85/1.4 up next to the Sigma (in EF mount) and saw the same sort of size differential (the Zeiss is about the same length as the FE 85/1.8, but fatter). Like the Otus, the Sigma is an absolute beast of a lens and it's far larger than a typical SLR 85/1.4
sungphoto wrote:
Regarding the harsh/unpleasant bokeh, I personally have found this to be the case with the sigma art 50 and 35 on canon, Nikon and adapted to Sony - I much prefer the rendering of the FE Zeiss Planar 50 f1.4 (a lens I liked enough that I often try to justify picking up another full frame Sony body)
I'm not that far in my studies that I could say about boke overall, initial feeling is boke is mostly good, but quite high contrast (not the worst, but VERY far away for example from Zeiss SLR Planars), transition zone mostly looks good. But I'll have to get out with the lens many more times, as this lens boke seems to be complicated and I find hard time understanding what some of the behaviours.
The corner boke issue I mentioned in page 1 post #2 is separate topic, it's about potential field curvature/astigmatism issue. The scene where I first noticed was this:
red area: the rough boke happened in top right corner
blue area: similar distance and content
I tried tiltin and rotating camera so that red area was in middle of sensor and boke was not rough anymore in the viewfinder.
Image with my normal processing in normal websize, rough boke on top right corner is visible without pixelpeeping:
Not a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder. I’m seeing this in the Tammy 28-75 I just got yesterday. I’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I am sorry but I don't see how you can compare lenses size wise unless their performance is similar. Neither of those lenses is anywhere near as sharp wide open across the frame as the Sony 50mm 1.4 so of course it is easy to make a lens smaller if you sacrifice performance to do so. fotografur wrote: thrice wroteI just saw this and instantly lost all interest. So much for "mirrorless has no size benefit above 50mm".
GMPhotography wrote:
Not a fan of the look here. I wonder if this has more to do with lens polishing. I can’t imagine at these costs they have the technology of what Sony is doing with there GM glass and there new lens polishing techniques. Makes me wonder.
Light was crappy on first day, I'll know do I like the look after I have processed today's shots as there was some light today.
Some of the Sony lenses seem to have really nice rendering style (GM85 and GM24-70, I don't like much the Sony "Zeiss" 1.4/50, way too much contrast on boke). But also some lenses have super ugly boke even they have the magical "GM"-letters, like the 100-400, really giganticly ugly boke on large subject size boke shots.
GMPhotography wrote:
I’m running out to test that lens now but a few snaps yesterday reared it’s ugly head with onion rings and really rough bokeh.
I also have noticed that many samples of Tamron 24-75 show ugly boke. Luckily I don't do photography for money so I don't have to care, for personal use f/2.8 basic zoom is just too slow for me to get interested.
To add to the lens size discussion above, just compare m mount lenses to their SL counterparts.
The m mount Lux 50 APSH weighs 335g and comes with an E46 filter. The SL version weighs three times as much and comes with an 82mm filter. Compared to that the Sony 50 1.4 (780g, 72mm) is hardly oversized or heavy.
The 75 Cron weighs 430g and has a 49mm filter. The SL version weighs 720g and comes with a 67mm filter thread. The Sony 85 1.8 weighs less than the m mount Cron, but to be fair, the SL Cron is probably playing in another league optically.
Still, even Leica is unwilling or unable to do magic with AF lenses in front of ever more demanding sensors. I guess, we either accept the size trade off or otherwise opt for lesser and/or slower lenses.
Few observations after using the lens second time.
I tried to use AF for most shots, but unfortunately I automatically focused some shots manually (using AF feels so slow and obstructive compared to normally focusing manually). I took 152 photos today and there were no missfocused frames, so the 1 frame from first shoot is only one which AF did not hit the target (and most likely it was my fault). So Sony/Sigma focusing systems seems pretty OK for still subject shooter, moving targets somebody else can test... I most likely stop torturing myself now with the AF and go back to manual focus. If somebody has some questions about AF I can try to test and answer, but please don't ask AF-C, Eyefocus etc. "moving stuff relevant", I'm not interested wasting my time to stuff I will never use.
There are bugs in the lens software or communication with camera. Both of these happened once (this far), camera A7r mkII:
1. Lens doesn't autofocus, similar error which happened in many Tamron 28-75 review videos (added embedded video to end of this post as url-tag did not work). I also happened to press button which magnifies when manual focusing and it zoomed in the screen (normally in AF-mode there is error dialog saying you can't magnify when using AF). Problem was fixed by switching camera off and then back on.
2. Lens doesn't close down before I take photo even setting "Live View Display" was set to "Setting Effect ON". I tried powering off-on camera and it did not start to work. Everyting returned to normal after I unmounted the lens and mounted it back to camera. [I cannot say 100% sure if this has happened more than one time, as I mostly shoot f/1.4-2.8 range and it would be hard to notice if camera is stuck at f/1.4. I noticed this when I was composing f/9 shot and lens was clearly "stuck" at full aperture based on out of focus highlight blur circle diameter]
Another suspicious behaviour is that when camera is turned on lens focus back and forth EVEN when AF/MF switch is at MF-position! This makes it impossible to focus, switch off camera, and when something interesting happens, e.g. sun shines to your scene between clouds, switch camera on and take photo. Instead one needs to focus after camera is switched on. And the same happens when camera goes to sleep and wakes from the sleep. So only possibility is to set "Remote Ctrl" = On if you want to maintain specific focus position for a long time. This will disable sleep mode, but if you forgot camera "on" it will empty your battery, also if you need to wait for long time your battery will run out.
You may say "but lens returns to same focus position". It may feel like it, but lens does not have that accurate focus position information that it can return exactly same focus position. It may appear it's same focus position, but I would not trust it, and when using maximum magnification before and after I can see that focus position has changed a little bit.
Wow! Now I appreciate so much more that Loxia/CV lenses have fully mechanical focus and aperture.
Samuli
Video I tried to link with url-tag, but it did not work = had to embed it:
On another not how come Canon And Nikon 50mm f1.4 are nice sized and Sony 50mm f1.4 is huge
Nikon 50/1.4 AF and Canon 50/1.4 AF, Zeiss Classic 50/1.4 (not Milvus) and Contax/Zeiss 50/1.4 are all classical 7 element double Gauss or Planar types, which explain their small size. The Sony/Zeiss 50/1.4 FE should be compared to the Sigma Art 50/1.4 and the Nikon 58/1.4 AF, all which are more advanced modern designs and bigger than the older 50/1.4 lenses. The modern and big normal lenses will perform much better at f/1.4 on digital than the older designs did. The Milvus 50/1.4 and Otus 55/1.4 are Distagons and even larger. It's all about performance at f/1.4-f/2 on digital.
I'm still confused about what sensor stack thickness the ART lenses would be designed for. The 50 Art originally came out several years back, so we should consider what manufacturers were using at that time.
"2. m4/3s cameras usually have 4mm stacks, Leica about 1.25mm. Canon, Nikon and Sony range from 1.9 to 2.4mm, so they're clustered together."
I think we're only going to see slight degradation, and only wide open, and only if the exit pupil is suitably forward. Certainly worth thinking about though, since wide apertures are the bread and butter of the FE primes Sigma is releasing.
I tried to compare Sigma 24/1.4 on Nikon D750 vs same lens on A7iii with manual adapter. I have only manual Novoflex adapter where I cannot set aperture exactly (except for wide open).
In bokeh comparison, I used my test chart from my bokeh article displayed on 55" TV but focusing on towel in front of it. Front of the lens was 47cm from towel plane, 146cm from 55" TV plane. Camera is on tripod, exposure is manual with delayed shutter in LV mode on D750, self-timer on A7iii.
Bokeh did not change significantly. Compare yourself:
I also did some outdoor comparisons (no pictures online at this time) with my lenses:
- Nikkor 50/1.8g vs. Sony 55/1.8 FE ZA: Sony destroys Nikkor wide open in sharpness and is still significantly better when both are stopped down.
- Nikkor 18-35/3.5-4.5G ED vs. Sony 16-35/4 ZA: In equivalent focal lengths both are sharp about same, the differences are small. Nikkor has excellent flare resistance, I will need to compare it.
- Sigma 24/1.4 on Nikon vs. Sigma 24/1.4 on Sony: On Nikon I used focus in LV. On Sony I used focus magnifier and focused manually. Comparing only f/1.4 as I could not set aperture exactly with adapter. In center, image from Sony is sharper (probably AA filter difference - at mid apertures I see more false color on distant water waves than on Nikon). But there could be focus difference. I see extreme corners are worse on Sony (perhaps some astigmatism), but it might be still just caused by different focus plane. Stopped down to about f/3.2 corners are ok.
T Gordon you can skip this post, b/c you know how I feel....
I really don't understand who is going to buy these lenses. I suppose folks who don't know any better? Meaning folks transitioning to Sony right now....?
Anyone who is currently shooting sony mirrorless, who has first hand experience with the FE Zeiss Planar 50 f1.4, and has shot an engagement session with an 85 GM, and has shot a few "getting ready" sessions with the 35 1.4 ZA.... I imagine they are NOT looking at any of these sigma options.
the FE Zeiss Planar 50 f1.4 is a flawless 50mm
stunning bokeh
excellent transitions
AF is superb, AF-C/EYE AF work incredibly well
great build
for ME the extra $500 is nothing
sigma has a built in adaptor, looks like a telescope attached to a toy camera,
but forget looks, which means I'm putting aside the fact that it's LOOONNNGGGG,
it's HEAVIER too!
and it's risky.
other tidbits:
- 50mm sony zeiss 1.4 - I haven't seen copy variation, but make sure you get the newer serial numbers, avoid a recalled lens here.
- the 85 GM is a stunning lens, no copy variation, no recalls. it has a button on the barrel that you can assign things to, such as EYE AF, AFC, AFS, etc.
- the 35 1.4 ZA when you get a centered copy, is INCREDIBLE. buy from someone with a good return policy.
- sony could offer us a 105mm 1.4 GM next week, who knows.. they have more money than any player in this market
- does sony offer higher discounts this summer, just to mess with sigma? they CAN, you know that.
In closing, risk reward:
Sony's technology could shift and let's get crazy, perhaps they don't share AF info with sigma (down the line) - the only reason I bring this up is.... sure this may be a long shot (this crazy idea), but I just don't see the risk/reward of a 35/50/85 sigma, when there IS A NATIVE SONY LENS, THAT KICKS ASS, with the same 1.4, and it doesn't need a diet. just to save money? I guess that is a thing. but unless you've already tried the sony version on an A7rIII or A9 or A7III, you'll always be wondering, how good is that sony glass compared with this heavy telescope.
we are not talking about the 24-70 2.8 sony vs tamron here...
but if we were, with the tamron, there is risk....
and a lot of reward.....!!!
with sigma vs. sony prime glass, there is risk, and no reward (IMO)
I come from canon and nikon land.
I have owned sigma art glass, I'm not a hater, just a realist.
I loved the 12-24. it was for things.
but when I shot people, which is what I do most, I found the sigma glass to be a bit sterile.