fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender

  
 
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #1FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
kdrk888 wroteBob, after reading your thread, I tested the 1.4TC on the 100-400 GM and A7RIII, lo and behold it has vignetting at 560mm too. I called Sony this morning to explain the issue, the rep asked me to read him the serial No. of the TC, he said the TCs with last 4 digits below (or above, I forgot) xxx5000 may have this issue. He asked me to send the TC in to get a replacement.

My 100-400mm's focus also locks up randomly once in a while on the A7RIII, say I focus on a flower, take the shot, focus it on another flower, it won't focus, the focus is locked. I have to turn off the camera to reboot. I explained this phenomenon to the rep, he said I should update the lens firmware to see if the problem still persists first.
I may send mine in. It's serial 39XX and I see strong vignetting at f/8.


Unfortunately, not so fast Fred. I don't think the problem is solved. When I first called Sony , the rep said the TC's last 4 digits in the serial number below (or above, I forgot) 5000 had vignetting issues. He asked me to send my TC to Sony for a replacement, I did, but Sony didn't have the 1.4 Tc in stock so they sent me a check for a full refund. I bought another one a month later, same problem, sent that one in, this time Sony sent me a new replacement, same problem. This is the 3rd copy I tried. My current copy ends with 0663, my first two copies end above 5000, so I am not sure if the rep was correct in saying xxx5000 is the cutoff line for bad copies. Maybe they all have this issue.

This morning I tried 560mm with the camera's lens compensation off and on, with "on", the vignetting isn't so bad, with "off", Lightroom would correct it somewhat but it never completely goes away.

First shot, camera lens compensation off, second shot on, straight JPEG out of the camera. I know, I know, I need to clean the sensor.

It would be good if more folks try it with the lens compensation on and off to see if they observe the same thing.





Lens Comp. off







Lens Comp. on

Feb 17, 2019 at 07:24 AM
dseelyjr
Offline
Details
p.4 #2FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I use Capture 1 with this combination (100-400 + 1.4x) and notice that the only Profile available for this combination is the "Manufacturer Profile". C1 has profiles for the 70-200/2.8 + 1.4x and 70-200/2.8 + 2x, but only a profile for the basic 100-400 with no TCs. I can correct all or most of the vignetting using the "Light Falloff" control ...
Feb 17, 2019 at 08:37 AM
dseelyjr
Offline
Details
p.4 #3FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
... by the way, I have NO issues with using the 100-400 with no TC; in that case, its a wonderful lens. Even with the 1.4x, its great with some "Falloff" correction for when the vignetting occurs at 560mm ...
Feb 17, 2019 at 08:39 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.4 #4FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
kdrk888 wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
kdrk888 wroteBob, after reading your thread, I tested the 1.4TC on the 100-400 GM and A7RIII, lo and behold it has vignetting at 560mm too. I called Sony this morning to explain the issue, the rep asked me to read him the serial No. of the TC, he said the TCs with last 4 digits below (or above, I forgot) xxx5000 may have this issue. He asked me to send the TC in to get a replacement.

My 100-400mm's focus also locks up randomly once in a while on the A7RIII, say I focus on a flower, take the shot, focus it on another flower, it won't focus, the focus is locked. I have to turn off the camera to reboot. I explained this phenomenon to the rep, he said I should update the lens firmware to see if the problem still persists first.
That's great news. I am sending mine in. It's about 39XX and I see strong vignetting at f/8.
It looks like the rep told you serial numbers below xxx5000.
Unfortunately, not so fast Fred. I don't think the problem is solved. When I first called Sony , the rep said the TC's last 4 digits in the serial number below (or above, I forgot) 5000 had vignetting issues. He asked me to send my TC to Sony for a replacement, I did, but Sony didn't have the 1.4 Tc in stock so they sent me a check for a full refund. I bought another one a month later, same problem, sent that one in, this time Sony sent me a new replacement, same problem. This is the 3rd copy
...Show more →

Following Douglas' suggestion, I am submitting below for my 100-400 GM with my 1.4X teleconverter (SN xxx4207. I guess this doesn't look too good compared to Douglas' teleconverter.

Images were shot with my tripod mounted 100-400mm GM plus the mentioned 1.4X teleconverter. Lens with teleconverter set at ISO 100, f8 at 1/500 sec. Camera and lens still with original firmware settings. They have not been updated. Images shot RAW and then processed in LR 6.14 (last standalone version of LR). Images processed for the images as Douglas had suggested, Images reduced to JPEG files from RAW.

First Image Lens Compensation off, and right out of camera.
Second Image Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied.
Third Image Lens Compensation off LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.

Fourth Image Lens Compensation on, and right out of camera.
Fifth Image Lens Compensation on, LR Profile applied.
Sixth Image Lens Compensation on, LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.

Rich







© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation off, and right out of camera.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation off LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation on, and right out of camera.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation on, LR Profile applied.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation on, LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.

Feb 17, 2019 at 09:34 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #5FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I tested this further today and saw what could be the reason for some seeing the vignetting at 560/8 and others not. It has to do with focus distance and therefore how close the lens' rear element is to the extender. At infinity distance the vignetting is strongest and at MFD, there is almost no mechanical vignetting.

BTW: My lens is version 02 and my extender serial is "39XX" (last 4)

No correction applied in-camera or in Lightroom CC.




Feb 17, 2019 at 11:02 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #6FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
kdrk888 wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
kdrk888 wroteBob, after reading your thread, I tested the 1.4TC on the 100-400 GM and A7RIII, lo and behold it has vignetting at 560mm too. I called Sony this morning to explain the issue, the rep asked me to read him the serial No. of the TC, he said the TCs with last 4 digits below (or above, I forgot) xxx5000 may have this issue. He asked me to send the TC in to get a replacement.

My 100-400mm's focus also locks up randomly once in a while on the A7RIII, say I focus on a flower, take the shot, focus it on another flower, it won't focus, the focus is locked. I have to turn off the camera to reboot. I explained this phenomenon to the rep, he said I should update the lens firmware to see if the problem still persists first.
That's great news. I am sending mine in. It's about 39XX and I see strong vignetting at f/8.
It looks like the rep told you serial numbers below xxx5000.
Unfortunately, not so fast Fred. I don't think the problem is solved. When I first called Sony , the rep said the TC's last 4 digits in the serial number below (or above, I forgot) 5000 had vignetting issues. He asked me to send my TC to Sony for a replacement, I did, but Sony didn't have the 1.4 Tc in stock so they sent me a check for a full refund. I bought another one a month later, same problem, sent that one in, this time Sony sent me a new replacement, same problem. This is the 3rd copy I tried. My current copy ends with 0663, my first two copies end above 5000, so I am not sure if the rep was correct in saying xxx5000 is the cutoff line for bad copies. Maybe they all have this issue.

This morning I tried 560mm with the camera's lens compensation off and on, with "on", the vignetting isn't so bad, with "off", Lightroom would correct it somewhat but it never completely goes away.

First shot, camera lens compensation off, second shot on, straight JPEG out of the camera. I know, I know, I need to clean the sensor.

It would be good if more folks try it with the lens compensation on and off to see if they observe the same thing.
Following Douglas' suggestion, I am submitting below for my 100-400 GM with my 1.4X teleconverter (SN xxx4207. I guess this doesn't look too good compared to Douglas' teleconverter.

Images were shot with my tripod mounted 100-400mm GM plus the mentioned 1.4X teleconverter. Lens with teleconverter set at ISO 100, f8 at 1/500 sec. Camera and lens still with original firmware settings. They have not been updated. Images shot RAW and then processed in LR 6.14 (last standalone version of LR). Images processed for the images as Douglas had suggested, Images reduced to JPEG files from RAW.

First Image Lens Compensation off, and
...Show more →

Thanks for the effort, Rich. There is a similar thread in DPreview. Seems to be a pretty common phenomenon.
Feb 17, 2019 at 11:02 AM
Shebco
Offline
Details
p.4 #7FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I've had consistency issues with mine since I got it in October. It's very frustrating and I have no confidence in the lens. It's been back twice to Precision and both times no change. They say it meets Sony specs. I think that's bench testing vs real world. It feels like a loose element or something. Currently Sony is evaluating and I will let you know how it goes.
Feb 17, 2019 at 11:05 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #8FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
I tested this further today and saw what could be the reason for some seeing the vignetting at 560/8 and others not. It has to do with focus distance and therefore how close the lens' rear element is to the extender. At infinity distance the vignetting is strongest and at MFD, there is almost no mechanical vignetting.

BTW: My lens is version 02 and my extender serial is "39XX" (last 4)

No correction applied in-camera or in Lightroom CC.


You are probably right, Fred. I dug out two shots from last year, I am not sure if the lens comp. in the camera was on or off, most likely off. These two were not corrected in LR.







at 560mm







at 516mm

Feb 17, 2019 at 11:13 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #9FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Download this Lightroom preset and place it in this location:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/Buzz/100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix.xmp.zip

Username > Library > Application Support > Adobe > CameraRaw > Settings > User Presets

It will fix the visible vignetting introduced by the 1.4x extender at 2m until infinity. This is even before any Profile correction in Lightroom.





Before Preset (100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix)







After Preset (100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix)

Feb 17, 2019 at 11:29 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.4 #10FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Can't open the link, Fred. I am a computer n00b.
Feb 17, 2019 at 11:51 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #11FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
kdrk888 wrote:
Can't open the link, Fred. I am a computer n00b.


Try again. I've updated it.
Remember to turn vignetting correction OFF in-camera and in-post. First use my preset and then see if the LR profile makes it even better.
Feb 17, 2019 at 11:52 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #12FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Here is a real image showing the before and after 100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix Preset.

1) No preset and no LR lens profile
2) With preset and no LR lens profile
3) With preset and with LR lens profile





No preset and no LR lens profile







With "100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix" preset and no LR lens profile







With "100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix" preset + LR lens profile

Feb 17, 2019 at 12:06 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.4 #13FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Nice that there is a fix. I just checked mine and yes, I have the vignetting also. Worth making a warranty claim? And if so, just call Sony or work through the retailer?
Feb 17, 2019 at 12:24 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #14FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Luvwine wrote:
Nice that there is a fix. I just checked mine and yes, I have the vignetting also. Worth making a warranty claim? And if so, just call Sony or work through the retailer?


I don't think there is a Sony fix. It looks like the mechanical vignetting will appear with any 1.4x extender (and possibly 2.0x as well) especially from 5m until infinity distance. At MFD there is almost no mechanical vignetting.

It looks like the best fix is to use the custom preset I posted above and use with images showing vignetting with the 1.4x extender.
Feb 17, 2019 at 12:31 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.4 #15FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
Download this Lightroom preset and place it in this location:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/Buzz/100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix.xmp.zip

Username > Library > Application Support > Adobe > CameraRaw > Settings > User Presets

It will fix the visible vignetting introduced by the 1.4x extender at 2m until infinity. This is even before any Profile correction in Lightroom.


Fred Miranda wrote:
kdrk888 wroteCan't open the link, Fred. I am a computer n00b.
Try again. I've updated it.
Remember to turn vignetting correction OFF in-camera and in-post. First use my preset and then see if the LR profile makes it even better.


Hi Fred,

I still can't open the file. It indicates that the link is invalid.

Rich


Feb 17, 2019 at 12:48 PM
pizdets17
Offline
Details
p.4 #16FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
^same
Feb 17, 2019 at 12:58 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #17FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Feb 17, 2019 at 01:03 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.4 #18FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Can this work for us that use ACR + Photoshop?
Feb 17, 2019 at 01:08 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #19FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Here is another sample image showing the before and after Lightroom "Preset". (no other correction done)

Note: The mechanical vignetting also happens at 300mm + extender (420mm) and the preset also takes care of it. (see last 2 images)





560mm (400mm+1.4x) Before the preset







560mm (400mm+1.4x) After the preset







420mm (300+1.4x) Before the preset







420mm (300mm+1.4x) After the preset

Feb 17, 2019 at 01:30 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.4 #20FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
Copy and paste it on your browser instead:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/Buzz/100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix.xmp.zip


Hi Fred,

Forgive my ignorance. I have the file that you posted and it was opened. Could you walk me through how to install/import this into my LR6.14.

Thanks for your assistance. I can not find how and where this is:

Username > Library > Application Support > Adobe > CameraRaw > Settings > User Presets.

Do I just use the + in LR for Presets to add this?

Rich


Feb 17, 2019 at 01:35 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister