Adapters have just gotten old hat to me. But yes they have come a long way. It's all about needs here especially between these two great lenses. I should have both. Lol
Fred Miranda wrote: AGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteHaving only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses.It's just my personal experience and I thought it was important to point out that "size vs speed" is not the only consideration. There are many other aspects that come into play when deciding on these lenses. I for one, own three 85mm lenses for entirely different needs. (Batis, GM and ZM)
I have used smart adapters since they first came to market and they have definitely come a long way. The thing is, Sony keeps releasing lenses like crazy and pretty soon, adapting will turn from necessity to just individual preference.
GMPhotography wrote:
Adapters have just gotten old hat to me. But yes they have come a long way. It's all about needs here especially between these two great lenses. I should have both. Lol
Fred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteHaving only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses.It's just my personal experience and I thought it was important to point out that "size vs speed" is not the only consideration. There are many other aspects that come into play when deciding on these lenses. I for one, own three 85mm lenses for entirely different needs. (Batis, GM and ZM)
I have used smart adapters since they first came to market and they have definitely come a long way. The thing is, Sony keeps releasing lenses like crazy and pretty soon, adapting will turn from necessity to just individual preference.
Guy, except for my long Canon lenses, I steered away from adapters and I have been using only native FE lenses. Then the Sigma 135mm f/1.8 Art came along and all bets are off...... Yes, you should own both!
AGeoJO wrote: GMPhotography wroteAdapters have just gotten old hat to me. But yes they have come a long way. It's all about needs here especially between these two great lenses. I should have both. Lol
Fred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses.It's just my personal experience and I thought it was important to point out that "size vs speed" is not the only consideration. There are many other aspects that come into play when deciding on these lenses. I for one, own three 85mm lenses for entirely different needs. (Batis, GM and ZM)
I have used smart adapters since they first came to market and they have definitely come a long way. The thing is, Sony keeps releasing lenses like crazy and pretty soon, adapting will turn from necessity to just individual preference.Guy, except for my long Canon lenses, I steered away from adapters and I have been using only native FE lenses. Then the Sigma 135mm f/1.8 Art came along and all bets are off...... Yes, you should own both!
Yeah I ended up selling my 70-200mm 2.8 II even though IQ was better than the GM I tested because spot AF was pretty bad when moving away from the center.
Wish I had it now to test with v57 of the Metabones since even my old 300mm 2.8 non is is amazingly good with that firmware. Then again...I prefer primes anyway
AGeoJO wrote: GMPhotography wroteAdapters have just gotten old hat to me. But yes they have come a long way. It's all about needs here especially between these two great lenses. I should have both. Lol
Fred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses.It's just my personal experience and I thought it was important to point out that "size vs speed" is not the only consideration. There are many other aspects that come into play when deciding on these lenses. I for one, own three 85mm lenses for entirely different needs. (Batis, GM and ZM)
I have used smart adapters since they first came to market and they have definitely come a long way. The thing is, Sony keeps releasing lenses like crazy and pretty soon, adapting will turn from necessity to just individual preference.Guy, except for my long Canon lenses, I steered away from adapters and I have been using only native FE lenses. Then the Sigma 135mm f/1.8 Art came along and all bets are off...... Yes, you should own both!
What about my first love, the Samyang 135/2 ? Since Batis 135 moved in, my Samie is back-of-the-cabinet. Worse, I think both Batis and Samie know I've been dreaming about F1.8 with the Sigma again. What's a guy to do ? ( no Pun intended Guy)
Fred Miranda wrote:
@GMPhotography@@,
Gabriel and Joshua felt betrayed when you traded your Sigma for the Batis. You better make up for it!
hahaha nah, I just wanted to make sure people reading understood that his comments referred to performance on A9 not on A7Rii. I may be wrong but I think I got the Sigma before Guy did even and if it sucked, it would have been gone already
LBJ2 wrote:
What about my first love, the Samyang 135/2 ? Since Batis 135 moved in, my Samie is back-of-the-cabinet. Worse, I think both Batis and Samie know I've been dreaming about F1.8 with the Sigma again. What's a guy to do ? ( no Pun intended Guy)
Just buy the Sigma and have the tri-135 setup..you know you want that
AGeoJO wrote: GMPhotography wroteI'm out of baseball helmets. I need real protection from that swinging wife bat.Buy your wife hand bags or shoes and you won't even need any helmet .
Right after buying a new lens, I take my wife to romantic location with low light pollution. I tell her we will be outside at night watching the stars...That's how I do all my astro shooting!
Actually one of the selling points of the Batis 135 is that it looks similar to the Batis 85, which I already own -- meaning that my wife is less likely to notice that I bought yet another lens.
I had a chance to do some shooting today. Definitely a keeper. The f/2.8 limitation seems to be a non-issue for, say, head and shoulders portraits, because at that distance to the subject you're going to have a great amount of background blur at f/2.8. I found that reassuring, as that's most of what I shoot anyway. To the extent that it's an issue, I'd imagine it'd be more of an issue for full-body portraits where the subject's distance is greater.
The bokeh is really lovely on this lens. I need to test it out more, but so far nothing to complain about. I think it's noticeably smoother than the 85.
Here's a close-up shot (slightly cropped). I didn't perfectly nail focus in this shot (or perhaps I should have used a faster shutter speed), but I love the bokeh and rendering.
The bokeh is as well-structured as it is appealing, front and back of the plane. I prefer it to the B85 too, not by a little. Scanning a larger number of images typical of what you might shoot works better to get a good take than identifying a one in a hundred image blemish in ugly light.
More reviews are out, and praise is well-nigh universal. One interesting report is the effectiveness of the OIS for long s/s shooting. I like the way color is preserved in bokeh as well as excellent tonal separation in low light scenes. Many representative samples here:
'..the Batis 135mm isn’t just good – it’s astonishing. Indeed in almost a decade of testing and reviewing lenses, I’ve seen few lenses that come anywhere this close to perfection.'
I just thought I'd post this shot as an example of how thin the DOF is at f/2.8, at a head-and-shoulders portrait distance. At that distance, who needs f/2?
I've been very pleased with the 135 -- it's replaced my Batis 85 as my go-to portrait lens, and it's made me question whether I even need the 85. Though I think I'll keep the 85 for indoor use, where the extra speed and/or shorter working distance can come in handy.
MrTMan wrote:
I just thought I'd post this shot as an example of how thin the DOF is at f/2.8, at a head-and-shoulders portrait distance. At that distance, who needs f/2?
I've been very pleased with the 135 -- it's replaced my Batis 85 as my go-to portrait lens, and it's made me question whether I even need the 85. Though I think I'll keep the 85 for indoor use, where the extra speed and/or shorter working distance can come in handy.
Good example! As more and more experiment/try this lens, I think many will come to the same conclusion. Once you start using the Batis 135 @ F2.8 you forget all about the fact that it's not F2.
I use both Batis 85 and 135 and find they make for very different applications. IMO, the current Batis system make for a great kit: 18, 25, 85, and 135 not going to miss much with these focal lengths. For those accustomed to the Batis 85, or 85mm in general for portrait should be prepared to step back a few times an then repeat to adjust to the very close frame you'll get with the 135mm. Worse part of the Batis system is getting used to quiet, snappy native AF, along with the light weight of these weather/dust resistant lenses is maybe too easy
peter1219 wrote:
I also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.
Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.
The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.
The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
MrTMan wrote: peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.
Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.
The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.
The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
LBJ2 wrote: MrTMan wroteI just thought I'd post this shot as an example of how thin the DOF is at f/2.8, at a head-and-shoulders portrait distance. At that distance, who needs f/2?
I've been very pleased with the 135 -- it's replaced my Batis 85 as my go-to portrait lens, and it's made me question whether I even need the 85. Though I think I'll keep the 85 for indoor use, where the extra speed and/or shorter working distance can come in handy.Good example! As more and more experiment/try this lens, I think many will come to the same conclusion. Once you start using the Batis 135 @ F2.8 you forget all about the fact that it's not F2.
I use both Batis 85 and 135 and find they make for very different applications. IMO, the current Batis system make for a great kit: 18, 25, 85, and 135 not going to miss much with these focal lengths. For those accustomed to the Batis 85, or 85mm in general for portrait should be prepared to step back a few times an then repeat to adjust to the very close frame you'll get with the 135mm. Worse part of the Batis system is getting used to quiet, snappy native AF, along with the light weight of these weather/dust resistant lenses is maybe too easy ...Show more →
I think they need to add something n the 35-45 range with an f/2 aperture. But that would then be five lenses to carry!