Steve Spencer wrote: uhoh7 wroteSteve Spencer wroteI know personally, I would never feel comfortable with taking off that epoxied cover glass. I would worry about dust on that open sensor that would be permanent and ruin the camera.What we don't know is the long-term viability of such a camera. Will it last five years? Three? Two? What happens if you take it to the dessert?It's certainly a concern, but why not wait to you understand the process before using words like "never"?
Sam Lee:
"for the dust issues, Taiwan master done at anti-dust room. All his mod camera can guarantee at F16 there is no dust. For my camera I have already tested at F32 without any dust.Basally, he resume there is no dust at F16. U can add money to ensure there is no dust at F22 or F32.
The STC thin filter is alreay have anti-dust coating, it is easy to remove the dust.
so I think remove cover glass+ stable thin filter[1mm STC Sony AWB] is good enough solution. Retro design wide lenses or 90's wide lenes will be much better."
I'm so impressed with these guys
Earlier quoteI think there is another issue as well. I don't think we can treat all RF lenses as the same. It is clear that Leica and even Zeiss with the ZM 35 f/1.4 are designing lenses with the cover glass in mind. So if you consider a lens like the Leica M 28 f/1.4 ASPH which Sean Reid finds does better on the Leica SL than the Leica M240, then we can't expect a lens like that to do best on a camera with the thinnest sensor stack possible. I have that lens and it really does quite well on an unmodified A7rII. I think it may well lose performance if you make the mod have thinner glass.Wake me when there is an entire M lens set which does better on SL than 240 or M9
Earlier quoteAnother issue that has just been raised is whether front end filters can be used as alternative to modifying the sensor cover glass.You think a simple front filter can compensate for everything that's happening from exit pupil to sensor array, like simply removing the problem at the source? First let's see the head to head vs M240 with external filter on an interesting lens. Yes, I know it's easier. I don't think it's a free lunch. But I'm happy to be wrong.
Earlier quoteI do think as thin a filter as possible makes sense with a lens designed for film.We are totally on the same page here. I never try to say everybody wants/likes this. But what an option! Not to mention it would not be hard to make a camera with an adjustable stack.
Earlier quoteI would even like to see a different version that would strike a balance between the modern Leica lenses and the native Sony lenses.The v2 is pretty close. But I know llija is very open, and thicker is easy.
Now, I have another revelation:
I've been asking what type is the coverglass made out of [this term all should know by now, means the glass below the stacks glued to the sensor]? My thought was: why not just put the IR cut right there, and forget the whole stack?
Let me quote a friend who knows [my source base is growing]:
"The cover glass itself is just clear glass[on Sony, Canikon]. I tried to convert an M246 once and it actually was set up like you say, with the cover glass itself being the IR cut filter. I think in general the clear glass is easier to manufacture for a few reasons. 1) This is the standard that CMOS/CCD factories use, 2) The clear glass can be a higher quality. The clear glass is probably a more durable variety than filter glass, which is notoriously soft. This makes it easier to polish it to a perfect surface finish before gluing it down. Along this same logic, clear glass can be made with something like synthetic quartz, which is a chrystiline structure that naturally excludes trapped internal bubbles. Filter glass on the other hand is prone to small bubble inclusions. The big ones can be screened out, but the smaller ones might only be caught in a downstream quality control step. For a factory, I would guess that a defective cover glass would be a lost sensor, while a defective cover glass is replaceable. 3) The durable cover glass cuts down repair costs. On the M246, if you break or scratch the IR filter (like I did), they have to replace the whole sensor. Nikon/Canon/Sony can replace just the glass. Funny enough those service centers charge you for a whole new sensor actually, but I am betting they send off the good sensors to the factory to refurbish with new glass."
So I have to ask: is this also true on the M240 and is this the real Leica "secret"? Put the IR cut right in the cover glass! Is there a stack at all?
replied:
"The M246 uses just that as the single sensor filter, no LPF1/2 on top. The M240 I would expect does the same thing."
Bingo!Charlie, I think we actually agree more than we disagree. I think we agree that it would be nice to see a camera with as thin of a filter as possible for lenses designed for film. I think we also probably agree a great way to do that would be to get rid of LPF1 and LPF2 and replace the cover glass with something with an IR cut filter as thin as is practical. I think we also probably agree that having a different camera mod similar to the Kolari V2 probably makes sense for the Leica M lenses designed for digital. There are a lot of these and all of them work pretty well on the Kolari V2 modded camera. Maybe not quite as well as an M240, but close.These plus the longer lenses that are less affected by the cover glass (e.g., the 90 cron AA; the 135 telyt APO, etc.) can make a great kit and some might like things like the dust shaker remaining intact. I think we agree on all that.
I think we mostly agree on a bunch of other stuff too. We both see some concern in removing the epoxied cover glass, but I am more worried about this such that I can't really see ever doing it mainly because the mistake would be irreversible and wreck the camera. I think we both also see some promise in front end filters. I probably see more promise there, but I think they might be a nice add on to your extreme mod for film. What if that extreme mod didn't filter out enough IR light--adding an IR cut filter like many people did for the M8 would be a nice patch. What if the extreme mod let in too much UV light for some situation--again you could address this with a front filter. Finally what if you are getting moire with an AA less mod--I image you could even craft a front end AA filter of sorts for those situations in which you get moire that is problematic. No a front end filter will never be a perfect solution, but it does offer a lot of flexibility in implementation that could be helpful regardless of the camera it is used on.
So let me say thanks for this thread. It has taught me a lot and I appreciate your efforts in putting all this together. We may not always agree, but I see no reason we can't be supportive of each others efforts in this forum. Best wishes and Happy Holidays....Show more →
Same to you Steve, and aside from a few little tiffs I have enjoyed many many of your posts over the years
I do get a bit excited sometimes, but I long ago learned to never hold grudges, or confuse an argument with something personal and long lasting. I've been mistaken many times about many things. But I'm a science fan, and I see those guys throw out theories all the time on better evidence. It's actually an advantage to be wrong, because people will teach you I've been wrong so often, I'm now a know it all
Now back to our topic: Here is another interesting aspect:
M10 specs are coming out. The Leica M10 Facebook Page
I think M10 is going to be a huge hit, because it will be just like the M6 in hand. But technically it is a generation behind. 24mp, No video at all or so these guys claim. I would love to have one, but that leaves quite a hole for the A7r2 "Film Special". Improved M240 level performance with RF wides, Latest BSI sensor, 42mp ISO6400 np, 4K video, and AF. AND THIS Updated Lens app!! Check the specs now!!
That is going to make a pretty sweet second body to any flavor M, and well ahead technically of Leica, or second to whatever else is your main squeeze
@ Sam Lee
Looks incredibly clean. Edge is unbelievable.
@ Fred just to make it clear to those who have not read the whole thread, that is alot more than a modded stack. It's with no coverglass and then a .7mm in LPF2. Coverglass removed in clean room. This is a unique mod.
The external filter is surprisingly good with this lens. I don't think it's at this level in a number of ways. But in time we will get some head to head shots to see if that impression is valid.
Basically with the filter we are taking too much glass in the path and adding more. Sam is down to absolute minimum glass in the path....well close.
On that note perhaps some optics enthusiasts are following this thread. I would love get some impressions about the new Schott BG 60 61 and 62, IR cut designed for BSI cell phones, thin as .21mm: Scroll to page 30 for full specs, but whole piece is interesting
most of you know I'm obsessed with the whole issue since Dec 2013. While this thread is really about modding the A7rii, the A7s is now a big favorite with many astro shooters, and they teach each other all about these sensor stacks. I think it will inform us.
Above is apparently (and ANYONE chime in to correct ANYTHING) the basic sensor stack design in all the major players. Sony Canikon etc. Note we have LPF1 and LPF2. They say we should use these names.
https://c6.staticflickr.com/1/442/30857318773_9b2a703538.jpg LPF-2 side by unoh7, on Flickr
Many thanks to Mike Malik for making and sharing these images.
Now above we DO NOT see what most in astro refer to as "COVER GLASS", which is in fact a thin layer directly on the sensor, (shown below) which I don't think anybody removes, but the same term is also used to refer to LPF1+LPF2.
OK First real serious question, Sam or anyone: How different is the A7r2 in the basic setup of LPF1 or 2?
Now when I would try to ask the Astro guys int the forums about stuff to get an idea about what would really work best for UWA RF glass, they basically rolled their eyes and ignored me so I found a tech they often used and I used "cover glass" in the generic way- including LFP1&2 (not knowing the dif)
"Are you absolutely sure that Kolari are removing the coverglass and not the thick filter stack? I've never seen a sensor with a thick window. I know for a fact the A7s has a 1.6 mm thick filter stack that includes the colour correcting filter (that we remove for astronomy). Removing this makes the camera about 4x more sensitive to h-alpha, which is of interest to astronomers.
We also reposition the sensor and properly re-align it to within +/- 0.02 mm. This is very important if you are going to be using fast lenses. I've seen more than one camera where this is not done properly, once the alignment is lost it requires specialised tools to get it back (we have those, but prefer not to need them!).
The sensor must be moved forwards to compensate the optical path. It sits on 3 points, each with a different adjustment to ensure the sensor is perfectly aligned as each camera is slightly different. Often we see that these shims are just all removed - which corrects for the back focus but loses the alignment, this will work with slower lenses but for fast lenses you really need this to be done properly.
Another solution is to fit clear glass or quartz but this just introduces glass back into the path and also is a source of halos and reflections."
He also sent a few image samples of the effects of the options on WB, which I will post later if we want them. Very nice guy, Here is his site
Armed with all this dangerous knowledge I then asked all about it to Ilija at Kolari, who has been such an asset for many of us.
"Ok let me clarify. In all of our mods, both filters are removed. Full spectrum is when that stack is replaced with a clear window that does not block any wavelengths, in that case it just helps keep focus and protect the sensor.
Removing just one of the filters will give you basically an H-alpha conversion in camera. Both stacks block IR aggresively, but only one of them blocks the H-alpha wavelength. So removing one shifts your red sensitivity up, making it perfect for astro. It isn't going to be even close to an accurate white balance, but for some of the less picky shooters if you set a custom white balance with that setup you will get a passable result. In this mod, you are reducing the thickness of glass over the sensor by about half, so it does help RF performance. What these guys fail to do, or at least I'm assuming, is move the sensor forward. They mostly shoot with telescopes or AF lenses were that doesn't show up as a problem. When we do this removal we move the sensor forward to provide good MF performance as well.
In our thin fitler, we remove both filters, and replace it with an even thinner replacement that does the closest job of approximating the transmission curve of BOTH original filters (less well at the UV end but accurately in the red portion)
Another option that probably wasn't mentioned, is removing the LPF2 filter, and then restoring proper color balance with our hot mirror filter over the lenses for regular photography.
For H-alpha photography you can just use a thin filter camera for similar performance as a stock camera, but your camera will only pick up about 15% of available light in that band without the LPF2/H-alpha mod."
This communication, and what I learned about color issues with the astro mods convinced me Kolari was really ahead of these astro guys for our purposes. But I owe them for such great explanations of whats over the sensor.
OK now we are talking about a whole new sensor and Sam has tried 2 mods: (I quote from our PM) 1. first modded at 2015 oct, mod to stc 0.7mm thin filter, silimar to Kolari v2 but with anti-smudge(water contact angle>110∘, antistatic and scratch resistant coatings,
used around 1 years there is no dust issues on thin filter, i can only use a7rii internal dust removal function to remove the dust. but still have some RF wide lenses can't use. The STC 0.7mm thin filter main problems is awb will have some red but easily tune at LR / C1 .
2. second modded at 2016 June, removed the sensor protection glass/ cover, which will reduce 0.7mm. removed the glass outcome is very very good. All the lenes become much more sharper and cleaner.
the sensor protection cover/glass is not easily to remove. This cannot be revented with the orginal sensor protection cover / glass , but the master say he can prodive third party glass to replaced, but i dont think we will revented it...
So, I am not clear on 2 exactly. Perhaps The mast actually removed the real "cover glass" which is shown above in the drawings, and which is attached directly to the sensor, and our Astro Modder said he could not believe anybody would take off
Another thing Sam mentioned to me was very interesting: "it seems that there are newest STC thin filter @0.5mm or 0.85mm with 100% sony colour /AWB profile, there will be no awb / colour problems." Sam's Link to STC glass
Sam, since this link takes us to an external filter, are you using any special filters on the lens itself? It is making me think of the "hot mirror" technique which Ilija describes. Or, is this link to show the glass you are using either 1) in LPF1 or LPF2 or the actual sensor cover?
Sam, I think you did say you were not so fond of the r2 color, and I'm just wondering was that the case before the mod. I've been talking with Ilija at Solari and he is pretty excited doing some more r2 mods. I will try to get him in here also to help us and perhaps we can chart a way forward which will give us the highest performance possible
I also can't thank Sam Lee enough for sharing his experience. He is at the tip of the spear yes, for my 2nd mod, the taiwan master removed the real "cover glass", the glass is around 0.7mm. it hard to remove like astro modder said, but finally done, so now is only lowpass filter 1 (STC 0.7mm thin filter ) + sensor only.
Since i haven't use the STC 0.5mm or 0.85mm thin filter, i needed to say again, this two filter seems to provide almost the same colour profile and awb for sony sensor.
Many thank for uhoh7 Great effort in doing such summary...
Hi, Sam. Thanks to you and Charlie for the great information. I'm a bit more impressed with your results than what I've see from Kolari. I'm weighing my options between the two, but I was hoping you could confirm this is what you ordered.
freaklikeme wrote: samlee.hk wroteuhoh7 wroteOK let's get serious
most of you know I'm obsessed with the whole issue since Dec 2013. While this thread is really about modding the A7rii, the A7s is now a big favorite with many astro shooters, and they teach each other all about these sensor stacks. I think it will inform us.
Above is apparently (and ANYONE chime in to correct ANYTHING) the basic sensor stack design in all the major players. Sony Canikon etc. Note we have LPF1 and LPF2. They say we should use these names.
https://c6.staticflickr.com/1/442/30857318773_9b2a703538.jpg LPF-2 side by unoh7, on Flickr
Many thanks to Mike Malik for making and sharing these images.
Now above we DO NOT see what most in astro refer to as "COVER GLASS", which is in fact a thin layer directly on the sensor, (shown below) which I don't think anybody removes, but the same term is also used to refer to LPF1+LPF2.
OK First real serious question, Sam or anyone: How different is the A7r2 in the basic setup of LPF1 or 2?
Now when I would try to ask the Astro guys int the forums about stuff to get an idea about what would really work best for UWA RF glass, they basically rolled their eyes and ignored me so I found a tech they often used and I used "cover glass" in the generic way- including LFP1&2 (not knowing the dif)
"Are you absolutely sure that Kolari are removing the coverglass and not the thick filter stack? I've never seen a sensor with a thick window. I know for a fact the A7s has a 1.6 mm thick filter stack that includes the colour correcting filter (that we remove for astronomy). Removing this makes the camera about 4x more sensitive to h-alpha, which is of interest to astronomers.
We also reposition the sensor and properly re-align it to within +/- 0.02 mm. This is very important if you are going to be using fast lenses. I've seen more than one camera where this is not done properly, once the alignment is lost it requires specialised tools to get it back (we have those, but prefer not to need them!).
The sensor must be moved forwards to compensate the optical path. It sits on 3 points, each with a different adjustment to ensure the sensor is perfectly aligned as each camera is slightly different. Often we see that these shims are just all removed - which corrects for the back focus but loses the alignment, this will work with slower lenses but for fast lenses you really need this to be done properly.
Another solution is to fit clear glass or quartz but this just introduces glass back into the path and also is a source of halos and reflections."
He also sent a few image samples of the effects of the options on WB, which I will post later if we want them. Very nice guy, Here is his site
Armed with all this dangerous knowledge I then asked all about it to Ilija at Kolari, who has been such an asset for many of us.
"Ok let me clarify. In all of our mods, both filters are removed. Full spectrum is when that stack is replaced with a clear window that does not block any wavelengths, in that case it just helps keep focus and protect the sensor.
Removing just one of the filters will give you basically an H-alpha conversion in camera. Both stacks block IR aggresively, but only one of them blocks the H-alpha wavelength. So removing one shifts your red sensitivity up, making it perfect for astro. It isn't going to be even close to an accurate white balance, but for some of the less picky shooters if you set a custom white balance with that setup you will get a passable result. In this mod, you are reducing the thickness of glass over the sensor by about half, so it does help RF performance. What these guys fail to do, or at least I'm assuming, is move the sensor forward. They mostly shoot with telescopes or AF lenses were that doesn't show up as a problem. When we do this removal we move the sensor forward to provide good MF performance as well.
In our thin fitler, we remove both filters, and replace it with an even thinner replacement that does the closest job of approximating the transmission curve of BOTH original filters (less well at the UV end but accurately in the red portion)
Another option that probably wasn't mentioned, is removing the LPF2 filter, and then restoring proper color balance with our hot mirror filter over the lenses for regular photography.
For H-alpha photography you can just use a thin filter camera for similar performance as a stock camera, but your camera will only pick up about 15% of available light in that band without the LPF2/H-alpha mod."
This communication, and what I learned about color issues with the astro mods convinced me Kolari was really ahead of these astro guys for our purposes. But I owe them for such great explanations of whats over the sensor.
OK now we are talking about a whole new sensor and Sam has tried 2 mods: (I quote from our PM) 1. first modded at 2015 oct, mod to stc 0.7mm thin filter, silimar to Kolari v2 but with anti-smudge(water contact angle>110∘, antistatic and scratch resistant coatings,
used around 1 years there is no dust issues on thin filter, i can only use a7rii internal dust removal function to remove the dust. but still have some RF wide lenses can't use. The STC 0.7mm thin filter main problems is awb will have some red but easily tune at LR / C1 .
2. second modded at 2016 June, removed the sensor protection glass/ cover, which will reduce 0.7mm. removed the glass outcome is very very good. All the lenes become much more sharper and cleaner.
the sensor protection cover/glass is not easily to remove. This cannot be revented with the orginal sensor protection cover / glass , but the master say he can prodive third party glass to replaced, but i dont think we will revented it...
So, I am not clear on 2 exactly. Perhaps The mast actually removed the real "cover glass" which is shown above in the drawings, and which is attached directly to the sensor, and our Astro Modder said he could not believe anybody would take off
Another thing Sam mentioned to me was very interesting: "it seems that there are newest STC thin filter @0.5mm or 0.85mm with 100% sony colour /AWB profile, there will be no awb / colour problems." Sam's Link to STC glass
Sam, since this link takes us to an external filter, are you using any special filters on the lens itself? It is making me think of the "hot mirror" technique which Ilija describes. Or, is this link to show the glass you are using either 1) in LPF1 or LPF2 or the actual sensor cover?
Sam, I think you did say you were not so fond of the r2 color, and I'm just wondering was that the case before the mod. I've been talking with Ilija at Solari and he is pretty excited doing some more r2 mods. I will try to get him in here also to help us and perhaps we can chart a way forward which will give us the highest performance possible
I also can't thank Sam Lee enough for sharing his experience. He is at the tip of the spear yes, for my 2nd mod, the taiwan master removed the real "cover glass", the glass is around 0.7mm. it hard to remove like astro modder said, but finally done, so now is only lowpass filter 1 (STC 0.7mm thin filter ) + sensor only.
Since i haven't use the STC 0.5mm or 0.85mm thin filter, i needed to say again, this two filter seems to provide almost the same colour profile and awb for sony sensor.
Many thank for uhoh7 Great effort in doing such summary...Hi, Sam. Thanks to you and Charlie for the great information. I'm a bit more impressed with your results than what I've see from Kolari. I'm weighing my options between the two, but I was hoping you could confirm this is what you ordered.
I needed to apologize about the thin filter, for the thin filter 0.5 or 0.85 are not made by STC.
if u have any problems for A7 thin filter mod, it better to ask master directly,
sorry for any inconvenience
samlee.hk wrote:
I think u better direct ask the master
freaklikeme wrotesamlee.hk wroteuhoh7 wroteOK let's get serious
most of you know I'm obsessed with the whole issue since Dec 2013. While this thread is really about modding the A7rii, the A7s is now a big favorite with many astro shooters, and they teach each other all about these sensor stacks. I think it will inform us.
Above is apparently (and ANYONE chime in to correct ANYTHING) the basic sensor stack design in all the major players. Sony Canikon etc. Note we have LPF1 and LPF2. They say we should use these names.
https://c6.staticflickr.com/1/442/30857318773_9b2a703538.jpg LPF-2 side by unoh7, on Flickr
Many thanks to Mike Malik for making and sharing these images.
Now above we DO NOT see what most in astro refer to as "COVER GLASS", which is in fact a thin layer directly on the sensor, (shown below) which I don't think anybody removes, but the same term is also used to refer to LPF1+LPF2.
OK First real serious question, Sam or anyone: How different is the A7r2 in the basic setup of LPF1 or 2?
Now when I would try to ask the Astro guys int the forums about stuff to get an idea about what would really work best for UWA RF glass, they basically rolled their eyes and ignored me so I found a tech they often used and I used "cover glass" in the generic way- including LFP1&2 (not knowing the dif)
"Are you absolutely sure that Kolari are removing the coverglass and not the thick filter stack? I've never seen a sensor with a thick window. I know for a fact the A7s has a 1.6 mm thick filter stack that includes the colour correcting filter (that we remove for astronomy). Removing this makes the camera about 4x more sensitive to h-alpha, which is of interest to astronomers.
We also reposition the sensor and properly re-align it to within +/- 0.02 mm. This is very important if you are going to be using fast lenses. I've seen more than one camera where this is not done properly, once the alignment is lost it requires specialised tools to get it back (we have those, but prefer not to need them!).
The sensor must be moved forwards to compensate the optical path. It sits on 3 points, each with a different adjustment to ensure the sensor is perfectly aligned as each camera is slightly different. Often we see that these shims are just all removed - which corrects for the back focus but loses the alignment, this will work with slower lenses but for fast lenses you really need this to be done properly.
Another solution is to fit clear glass or quartz but this just introduces glass back into the path and also is a source of halos and reflections."
He also sent a few image samples of the effects of the options on WB, which I will post later if we want them. Very nice guy, Here is his site
Armed with all this dangerous knowledge I then asked all about it to Ilija at Kolari, who has been such an asset for many of us.
"Ok let me clarify. In all of our mods, both filters are removed. Full spectrum is when that stack is replaced with a clear window that does not block any wavelengths, in that case it just helps keep focus and protect the sensor.
Removing just one of the filters will give you basically an H-alpha conversion in camera. Both stacks block IR aggresively, but only one of them blocks the H-alpha wavelength. So removing one shifts your red sensitivity up, making it perfect for astro. It isn't going to be even close to an accurate white balance, but for some of the less picky shooters if you set a custom white balance with that setup you will get a passable result. In this mod, you are reducing the thickness of glass over the sensor by about half, so it does help RF performance. What these guys fail to do, or at least I'm assuming, is move the sensor forward. They mostly shoot with telescopes or AF lenses were that doesn't show up as a problem. When we do this removal we move the sensor forward to provide good MF performance as well.
In our thin fitler, we remove both filters, and replace it with an even thinner replacement that does the closest job of approximating the transmission curve of BOTH original filters (less well at the UV end but accurately in the red portion)
Another option that probably wasn't mentioned, is removing the LPF2 filter, and then restoring proper color balance with our hot mirror filter over the lenses for regular photography.
For H-alpha photography you can just use a thin filter camera for similar performance as a stock camera, but your camera will only pick up about 15% of available light in that band without the LPF2/H-alpha mod."
This communication, and what I learned about color issues with the astro mods convinced me Kolari was really ahead of these astro guys for our purposes. But I owe them for such great explanations of whats over the sensor.
OK now we are talking about a whole new sensor and Sam has tried 2 mods: (I quote from our PM) 1. first modded at 2015 oct, mod to stc 0.7mm thin filter, silimar to Kolari v2 but with anti-smudge(water contact angle>110∘, antistatic and scratch resistant coatings,
used around 1 years there is no dust issues on thin filter, i can only use a7rii internal dust removal function to remove the dust. but still have some RF wide lenses can't use. The STC 0.7mm thin filter main problems is awb will have some red but easily tune at LR / C1 .
2. second modded at 2016 June, removed the sensor protection glass/ cover, which will reduce 0.7mm. removed the glass outcome is very very good. All the lenes become much more sharper and cleaner.
the sensor protection cover/glass is not easily to remove. This cannot be revented with the orginal sensor protection cover / glass , but the master say he can prodive third party glass to replaced, but i dont think we will revented it...
So, I am not clear on 2 exactly. Perhaps The mast actually removed the real "cover glass" which is shown above in the drawings, and which is attached directly to the sensor, and our Astro Modder said he could not believe anybody would take off
Another thing Sam mentioned to me was very interesting: "it seems that there are newest STC thin filter @0.5mm or 0.85mm with 100% sony colour /AWB profile, there will be no awb / colour problems." Sam's Link to STC glass
Sam, since this link takes us to an external filter, are you using any special filters on the lens itself? It is making me think of the "hot mirror" technique which Ilija describes. Or, is this link to show the glass you are using either 1) in LPF1 or LPF2 or the actual sensor cover?
Sam, I think you did say you were not so fond of the r2 color, and I'm just wondering was that the case before the mod. I've been talking with Ilija at Solari and he is pretty excited doing some more r2 mods. I will try to get him in here also to help us and perhaps we can chart a way forward which will give us the highest performance possible
I also can't thank Sam Lee enough for sharing his experience. He is at the tip of the spear yes, for my 2nd mod, the taiwan master removed the real "cover glass", the glass is around 0.7mm. it hard to remove like astro modder said, but finally done, so now is only lowpass filter 1 (STC 0.7mm thin filter ) + sensor only.
Since i haven't use the STC 0.5mm or 0.85mm thin filter, i needed to say again, this two filter seems to provide almost the same colour profile and awb for sony sensor.
Many thank for uhoh7 Great effort in doing such summary...Hi, Sam. Thanks to you and Charlie for the great information. I'm a bit more impressed with your results than what I've see from Kolari. I'm weighing my options between the two, but I was hoping you could confirm this is what you ordered.
Thank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions
p.3 #10First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Tmuussoni wrote:
Thank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions
The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....
p.3 #11First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Gary Clennan wrote: Tmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....
+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.
p.3 #13First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Fred Miranda wrote: Gary Clennan wroteTmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.
True, but what if the wide open performance on the Loxia could be improved with a thinner sensor stack?
p.3 #14First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
freaklikeme wrote: Fred Miranda wroteGary Clennan wroteTmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.True, but what if the wide open performance on the Loxia could be improved with a thinner sensor stack?
I doubt that will be true Brad as the Loxia was designed for the sensor stack of the Sony A7 series cameras.
p.3 #15First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Steve Spencer wrote: freaklikeme wroteFred Miranda wroteGary Clennan wroteTmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.True, but what if the wide open performance on the Loxia could be improved with a thinner sensor stack?I doubt that will be true Brad as the Loxia was designed for the sensor stack of the Sony A7 series cameras.
Designed as best they could for the sensor stack. That doesn't necessarily mean performance can't be improved, since it, to a lesser degree, exhibits some of the same FC issue wide open as the ZM Distagon 35.
You may be right about the 21. It's just a theory, but I am positive it would help the Loxia 35.
p.3 #16First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
freaklikeme wrote: Steve Spencer wrotefreaklikeme wroteFred Miranda wroteGary Clennan wroteTmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.True, but what if the wide open performance on the Loxia could be improved with a thinner sensor stack?I doubt that will be true Brad as the Loxia was designed for the sensor stack of the Sony A7 series cameras.Designed as best they could for the sensor stack. That doesn't necessarily mean performance can't be improved, since it, to a lesser degree, exhibits some of the same FC issue wide open as the ZM Distagon 35.
You may be right about the 21. It's just a theory, but I am positive it would help the Loxia 35.
I would not be surprised if a somewhat thinner stack helped the 35, but I doubt it would the 21. The Loxia 35 was tweaked (and it seems not enough) for the A7 series cameras, whereas the 21 was clearly designed from the ground up for these cameras. So, I think the 21 likely would be a bit worse on a modified camera. I am surprised nobody has done this test. It seems somebody would have.
p.3 #17First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Steve Spencer wrote: freaklikeme wroteSteve Spencer wrotefreaklikeme wroteFred Miranda wroteGary Clennan wroteThe absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.True, but what if the wide open performance on the Loxia could be improved with a thinner sensor stack?I doubt that will be true Brad as the Loxia was designed for the sensor stack of the Sony A7 series cameras.Designed as best they could for the sensor stack. That doesn't necessarily mean performance can't be improved, since it, to a lesser degree, exhibits some of the same FC issue wide open as the ZM Distagon 35.
You may be right about the 21. It's just a theory, but I am positive it would help the Loxia 35.I would not be surprised if a somewhat thinner stack helped the 35, but I doubt it would the 21. The Loxia 35 was tweaked (and it seems not enough) for the A7 series cameras, whereas the 21 was clearly designed from the ground up for these cameras. So, I think the 21 likely would be a bit worse on a modified camera. I am surprised nobody has done this test. It seems somebody would have.
I think it's probably because people who get the mod aren't interested in using native mount lenses. If I had thought about it when I owned it I could've compared it on the a7m mod, but I only use that camera as a digital back, so it didn't occur to me at the time.
p.3 #18First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
I agree that the Loxia 21 will perform best with the sensor stack for which it was designed but, at the same time, I have the suspicion that if Sony had adopted a very thin filter ( like a Leica M or Kolari mod) Zeiss might have been able to design a 21/2.8 with better performances than the current Loxia. To put it another way: the best possible 21mm lens for a thin filter stack will outperform the best possible 21mm. for a thick sensor stack, because there’s only so much they can do to overcome that intrusive thick slab of glass between lens and sensor. This is only a uneducated guess by my part but I’d be surprised If I’m not quite right in this matter.
p.3 #19First Sighting: A7rii Thin filter in action
Fred Miranda wrote: Gary Clennan wroteTmuussoni wroteThank you everyone who have contributed to this thread. Especially Charlie. There was a time when I was obsessed with Kolari mod and potential A7r II performance. But that kinda faded away while I was waiting for the M10 specs. Well, M10 is here and in some ways I am bit let down. So I think my interest for modded A7r II has resurfaced. The thing is I am invested in M glass and superb performance with SEM 21 would be crucial. Decisions, decisions The absolute best overall performance with the 21SEM (and mostly all other Leica M glass) will be on a digital Leica M body. Why not pick one up and try it out? It would save you some headache from messing around with all this Kolari stuff....+1
For the A7RII, there is an excellent native option: Loxia 21mm f/2.8.
I doubt that any adapted lens designed for a different sensor stack will beat it even with the help of modded bodies or corrective front-lenses.
Really, I think SEM 21 would easily compete on Sam's body. We don't know, but I'm not sure why anyone has the urge to pre-judge or predict. Or, Gary, to tell people they should just use M lenses on M bodies.
Especially since the best 35 available for STOCK A7r2 is ZM 35/1.4 according to Fred, AN M LENS, unless I have that wrong. So why on earth can't the SEM 21, which is a fully modern 2011 design with fantastic MTFs, meet or beat the native Zeiss 21/2.8, with a thinner filter than Kolari v2? The Sony micro lenses and sensor design is fine with the ZM 35/1.4. No reason to assume they won't be with wider lenses and Leica "glass in path" thickness.
In fact, Gary, the SEM 18 actually equals M240 performance in the Kolari v2 mod, using A7ii, according to Kasson, and on A7rii, according to lloyd, before a thinner filter is even considered. The SEM 18 is a very friendly wide angle, but the SEM 21 seems nice as well. The SEM 24 less so.
So I respectfully call BS to the negative input from Gary and Fred, both of whom I admire. You guys have made your choices, and that's fine--for you and your priorities. I would never presume to tell you to do otherwise. But there are plenty of people with a serious soft spot for M and other RF lenses. They are small, MF like a dream, there's alot more choices, many of which are very interesting. That's why many of us wanted a FF Nex in the first place. AF is now an option as well. We do not know how the SEM 18 or 21 will go up against the native Zeiss lenses on any of the mods, unless I missed some head to head testing somewhere.
What we do know is that native lenses will not perform as well on modded camera. So you don't do a mod to shoot natives. That's been obvious from the start, no?
No offense, but for me the A7 FF is more interesting as an ALT platform, than one dedicated to what Sony offers, which, let's be honest, are a mixed bag with all sorts of issues, depending on the lens, in size, handling, QC and performance. Those issues are moot for some and deal breakers for others. Quite a few have actually left sony partly over some of those issues, if you follow the Fuji forum. I don't think anyone is "wrong" to choose natives and go all Sony or part Sony. But I sure don't think anybody is "wrong" to pass on the thick filter choices and try to make the camera work better for non-natives, especially the great M/LTM lenses.
"M lenses are best on Leica Bodies" The ZM 35/1.4 on stock A7r2 puts the lie to that, before mods are even considered, since some would argue the Sony 42mp sensor is already winning at landscape apertures.
Above the 21 on Kolari v1. Below, you have a native Sony 28 at this level? Keyhole by unoh7, 28 Summicron on A7.mod Kolari v2
In fact just the normal Kolari mod, v2 takes the 475 gram plain A7 and removes the AA, giving it a new character altogether, and enabling landscape performance from M mount 18mm on up if you choose carefully. SEM 18 and 28 Lux are shooting as well as M240 according to Lloyd, ON V2 A7rii, right now. V1 completely revived the A7 for me. I have plenty of samples from before the mod with many lenses. The A7r and r2 are likely less fundamentally changed compared to the 24mp models, as they are already "R", so edges and corners will improve with M wides, but overall clarity and "look" remain similar.
Sam and his gutsy coverglass pulling Master in Taiwan have now taken A7 thin-filter M shooting to another breathtaking level, which may well already equal any M digital body. Kolari has not been asleep, and Ilija has been studying up since this thread began, inspired by new possibilities, and the quest to offer great performance with ALL M wides. To that end, he has found a new ultra-thin IR glass which may get us there without having to pull or replace the bottom coverglass.
On the right, labeled v4 is a new ultra-thin IR cut, 4x thinner than current v2 Kolari. It's now in a A7, and that camera will be in the air to Idaho tomorrow, so I can test it straight up against the M9 and A7.mod v2 with a bunch of lenses, including ones like the CV 21/4 and ZM35/2 which are better on M9 than Kolari v2 for sure.
Ilija is making no claims pending our tests, but he wants us to know he's trying. He found the new ultra-thin IR glass, got the camera, had his techs install the mod, and is sending it to me to try. I'm counting on help here from everybody to interpret and direct test shots in the coming weeks, including naysayers Fred and Gary if they are willing, so we can see if it works. llija thinks it could be very good based on very quick preliminary tests he did, but he does not know. We will all-- those willing anyway-- decide, realtime, if the "UT" or whatever we should call it......V10, in a nod to M10..will be a viable option which anyone can get. It's a reach to channel faithfully some of the greatest, sexiest, compact lenses ever made, old and new, from the 30's fledgling wide angles all the way to the latest incredible M lenses from Leica, Zeiss, CV, and that crazy guy who made the Sonnetar. Cmon, who can put that down?
We are starting with a A7 simply because it's cheap and predictive. I already have one with v2. To risk a A7rii before we get a good idea where we are at is over our budget. But once I test for a time, then we can send this camera to others. In an ideal world we would send it to Nico, who has M10 and 21/4 skopar, and that is not out of the question at all. Since the A7 is 24 mp it would be great to compare to M10.
Ideally we want to find people who have M240 or M10 (or both) and "problem" wides, of which there are quite a few, and who are willing to do some head to heads at infinity, "Fred Style"
A great M shooting A7x.mod is not to "dis" native Sony or Leica bodies. Jeez, I'd love a M10. If somebody sends me 6600, I promise to buy one straight away. But I'd still want to test this new mod for Sony. There are a ton of reasons some people would enjoy a very strong thin-filter mod on one flavor or other of A7. It might be for the 42mp files from a r2, or the affordable 24mp files from a very light A7. The mod might be somebody's only camera, or a second body with complimentary strengths to M or native Sony, or a cheap M backup body, in case the 240 goes down on a job, or the M9 goes in for a sensor. TYG I had v1 when my M9 went in for a shutter. The main thing for all these folks is to try and get the mod working really well, like at "240 Level" for more than just a few M wides like SEM 18 and 28 Lux. llija knows how important that is, so let's see
Will the IR cut be enough? How will the edges and corners be improved? Can we get the WB working right? Let's find out