DavidBM wrote:
Juha Kannisto wrote
DavidBM wrote
Charlie N wrote
DavidBM wrote
Ive just updated to version 6, and I'm not impressed.
The TAP has always had the bad habit of not working very well away from the centre.
But it seems to have got worse in this respect than the previous version on the R2 on the couple of lenses I tried it on: unless the focus point is dead centre, it hunts without much success.
And I have no use for an AF system that forces me to focus and recompose!
Are others experiencing this behaviour? I think the update was meant for a9/r3 users.
TAP has been poor in the focus area regard, still not very good, but v6 + R3 is much better than v5 + R2 IMO. Ete AF and face tracking seem to pick up outside the central areas better. Feels just as fast, maybe faster It is indeed for a9/r3 users, but I was using r3
And it seems to me worse away from the centre than firmware 5 with the r2 which is what I was using before.
I have only tried two lenses (2.8/40 CV and C-Sonnar 1.5/50) though.
Also I may have forgotten how frustrating this behaviour is (I've basically gone back to only using MF with manual lenses with the R3 so haven't used my TechArt for a while, but thought that with the new firmware I'd try it) For me the AF performance seems clearly improved on v6 + A9 vs. earlier firmware(s), no more "focus pulsing/hunting" and mostly focus is achieved very quickly and reliably in AF-C mode. In wide area mode with TAP, focus points from near centre seem to be picked most often, but it is pretty capable to focus on outer areas when I select other focus areas e.g. via touch focus, even when selecting areas near the corners (as far into corners as possible with touch focus). I mostly use TAP with CV 50/3.5 Heliar (VM) which is very sharp corner to corner at any aperture so probably that helps. It seems to focus well in near-corners here in the office (currently at work) as long as I keep the aperture wide open (f3.5) to allow enough light. Outdoors in daylight I mostly shoot this lens at f8 or f5.6 and go to f3.5 in low light.
I've been still getting many random restarts these past days I've been using TAP again though, but they don't bother me too much in casual use now. I’ve never used wide area AF, only Movable point (all three sizes). And it is fine at centre, Ok one click of the joystick In any direction, further and it gives up. Maybe it’s lens dependent. The longer the lens the better it ought work off centre I guess...
I tend to shoot a lot of cityscape / street shots with TAP where I want everything in focus and basically wide area AF-C works well for that with this lens especially at f8 or f5.6. When I shoot close-ups and want to focus on some very specific object, touch focus works nicely and there's no need to change focusing mode. I don't use touch focus much with native AF lenses though but I like it with TAP.
I also have the 40/2.8 CV Heliar. I don't have C-Sonnar 50/1.5 but I do have Nokton 50/1.5 (VM). Will try with those later to see if there are significant differences in AF performance on my A9 with TAP.
On the wider lenses (e.g. 28mm) I don't like using TAP as much since there's often a need to adjust focus to get maximum corner-to-corner sharpness depending on lens / field curvature etc. and AF is not so good for that. I no longer have wider than 28mm M/LTM lenses. And long lenses often need pre-focusing when focusing close so for me ideal focal lengths with TAP are 40-50mm.