fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
robgo2 wrote:
So far, most of the gripes have to do with price and weight. But the Loxia 85 is undoubtedly an ultra-high quality optic, at least from a technical standpoint. If it were a Leica, it would cost 50% more, and people would simply shrug their shoulders. If it were an Otus, it would weigh 50% more, and people would shrug their aching shoulders. The real question is whether the Loxia's IQ justifies its price and weight, especially in comparison to available alternatives. My guess is that once it gets into the hands of actual users, not professional testers, there will
...Show more →

It probably will sell well, the blue label and the high quality of Zeiss optics should take care of that. I don't think anybody here doubts that this is going to be a very good/excellent lens. However, just as with 35mm and 50mm, there are plenty of options in the 85/90mm range by now, native and otherwise. Going by the responses in this thread, it seems that many FM'ers prefer either slower/lighter/more affordable alt glass or faster glass or AF lenses.

Will the Loxia beat most of those lenses? Most likely. Is it worth the price? For many people, the answer is yes, for me, no. Despite suffering from GAS, I don't see myself getting this: If I want an MF lens, then I'm going to reach for my Elmarit, if I need AF, there is always the Batis.
Sep 15, 2016 at 07:52 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Jman13 wrote:
DavidBM wroteSo just had a look at the published MTF for Batis and Loxia.
It's hard to compare because Batis gives you f1.8 and f4 whereas Lox gives you f2.4 and f5.6
But it is clear that Lox is a bit better at 2.4 than Lox at 1.8; and again better at 5.6 than Lox at f4.

Judging I doubt that there's a huge difference in the Batis between f 4 and f5.6 but there might be.

Anyhow it remains for testers to determine if there is a real world difference. I think at this stage it would need to be a big difference to persuade me to pay more for more weight despite the evil guy in the back of my head saying "but you know you want to compete your set of Loxias..."
Considering how incredibly sharp the Batis is throughout the frame and throughout the aperture range, I would be hard pressed to imagine any real significant difference. Maybe, maybe...you'd see a slight advantage using the A7R II with one of them, but in photos either displayed on screen or printed at most any print size? You won't see a sharpness difference.


Jordan, let's do a test (I live in Columbus now) and I will order this right away. You and I both have the Batis and I also have the Leica M 90 f/2 AA and a Milvus 85 f/1.4 to throw in the mix. I have an A7r II and an A7s and I think you have an A7 II. I am betting based on the stellar MTFs that the Loxia will beat the Batis at infinity landscapes, but only if you blow it up big. Of course that is what some people will definitely want to do.
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:22 AM
bwcolor
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
My Leica 90mm f/2.0 APO ASPH. weighs 500 grams. I'm pretty sure that the Leica color rendering differs, the price used is a bit higher. There must be something favoring the Zeiss..maybe better micro-contrast..different..better bokeh?
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:27 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.9 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
My take is this looks like a fantastic lens. Small in size but not in weight. Comparing it to the Batis, I suspect it will be a lot like the Loxia 21 vs. the Batis 25. When my wife looked at these two lenses, she said, "wow, the AF one is so much bigger." And it is when you put them side by side, but the Batis actually weighs 70g less.

Yes, the price is hard to swallow, but it is cheaper than the Leica M 90 f/2.4 Summarit. For those who actually use it I think it will serve very well for portraits, be an excellent landscape lens, and do video extremely well. It will be a great all arounder. I am most interested to see how it compares to my Leica 90 cron AA, which is smaller and lighter (even with the adapter) and also an excellent all around performer and a half stop faster too. Despite all that going for the Leica, I expect this lens to compete with it very well. These two are similar lenses and will do much the same sort of thing. I wouldn't be surprised, however, as good as the Leica 90 AA is, if the Loxia was a bit nicer for portraits with a bit better bokeh (the Leica has underrated bokeh, but I still would not be surprised if the all spherical 85 Sonnar beats it and the samples looks fantastic). I am also confident that the Loxia's 10 aperture blades will produce a lot better sunstars than the 11 bladed Leica. The Leica will no doubt have some other advantages besides being smaller and lighter, but I think the Loxia will give it a run for it money and the Loxia is much cheaper than the 90 cron AA.

For me, this 85mm will complete my small (but not light) Zeiss kit with the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 50. I would be quite happy with this kit, but I would still love a Loxia 28 (f/2 if they can squeeze it in the form factor or another f/2.4 if they cannot).
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:42 AM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.9 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
Jman13 wrote
DavidBM wroteSo just had a look at the published MTF for Batis and Loxia.
It's hard to compare because Batis gives you f1.8 and f4 whereas Lox gives you f2.4 and f5.6
But it is clear that Lox is a bit better at 2.4 than Lox at 1.8; and again better at 5.6 than Lox at f4.

Judging I doubt that there's a huge difference in the Batis between f 4 and f5.6 but there might be.

Anyhow it remains for testers to determine if there is a real world difference. I think at this stage it would need to be a big difference to persuade me to pay more for more weight despite the evil guy in the back of my head saying "but you know you want to compete your set of Loxias..."
Considering how incredibly sharp the Batis is throughout the frame and throughout the aperture range, I would be hard pressed to imagine any real significant difference. Maybe, maybe...you'd see a slight advantage using the A7R II with one of them, but in photos either displayed on screen or printed at most any print size? You won't see a sharpness difference.
Jordan, let's do a test (I live in Columbus now) and I will order this right away. You and I both have the Batis and I also have the Leica M 90 f/2 AA and a Milvus 85 f/1.4 to throw in the mix. I have an A7r II and an A7s and I think you have an A7 II. I am betting based on the stellar MTFs that the Loxia will beat the Batis at infinity landscapes, but only if you blow it up big. Of course that is what some people will definitely want to do.


I don't have the Batis...but I'd be interested in seeing your results. I'll eventually test the Loxia for sure. When I tested the Batis, I found it outstandingly sharp across the frame...I'm not saying the Loxia couldn't improve, just that I only think you'd see a difference if you printed huge and examined side by side prints of the same subject close up. Even then, I think it'd likely be pretty close given how sharp the Batis is. If that's what's required to see a difference, then in any individual shot, you're not going to see much of a difference. Heck, I went with an adapted Canon 100/2 because while the Batis is better, it's not that much better...and it was worth saving the $700.

For some, the Loxia will make more sense, but for most people, the Batis will be the far better buy.
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:47 AM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.9 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I'm anxious to have it - it's just what I was hoping for, unlike so many others, it seems. I wasn't expecting it to be low-priced (do "Zeiss" and "low price" ever occur in the same sentence?), and maybe I have a different point of reference, but it seems reasonably light and compact to me...a featherweight compared to The Sumo, anyway, and 85mm corresponds to my favorite landscape lens in 4x5 (300mm), so it's something that I use a lot.

Now, bring on the 28mm Loxia
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:48 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
My take is this looks like a fantastic lens. Small in size but not in weight. Comparing it to the Batis, I suspect it will be a lot like the Loxia 21 vs. the Batis 25. When my wife looked at these two lenses, she said, "wow, the AF one is so much bigger." And it is when you put them side by side, but the Batis actually weighs 70g less.

Yes, the price is hard to swallow, but it is cheaper than the Leica M 90 f/2.4 Summarit. For those who actually use it I think it will
...Show more →
Steve, don't odd number of blades produce sunstars that are double of the blades?
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:49 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
mogul wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteMy take is this looks like a fantastic lens. Small in size but not in weight. Comparing it to the Batis, I suspect it will be a lot like the Loxia 21 vs. the Batis 25. When my wife looked at these two lenses, she said, "wow, the AF one is so much bigger." And it is when you put them side by side, but the Batis actually weighs 70g less.

Yes, the price is hard to swallow, but it is cheaper than the Leica M 90 f/2.4 Summarit. For those who actually use it I think it will serve very well for portraits, be an excellent landscape lens, and do video extremely well. It will be a great all arounder. I am most interested to see how it compares to my Leica 90 cron AA, which is smaller and lighter (even with the adapter) and also an excellent all around performer and a half stop faster too. Despite all that going for the Leica, I expect this lens to compete with it very well. These two are similar lenses and will do much the same sort of thing. I wouldn't be surprised, however, as good as the Leica 90 AA is, if the Loxia was a bit nicer for portraits with a bit better bokeh (the Leica has underrated bokeh, but I still would not be surprised if the all spherical 85 Sonnar beats it and the samples looks fantastic). I am also confident that the Loxia's 10 aperture blades will produce a lot better sunstars than the 11 bladed Leica. The Leica will no doubt have some other advantages besides being smaller and lighter, but I think the Loxia will give it a run for it money and the Loxia is much cheaper than the 90 cron AA.

For me, this 85mm will complete my small (but not light) Zeiss kit with the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 50. I would be quite happy with this kit, but I would still love a Loxia 28 (f/2 if they can squeeze it in the form factor or another f/2.4 if they cannot).
Steve, don't odd number of blades produce sunstars that are double of the blades?


Yep.
Sep 15, 2016 at 08:59 AM
arduluth
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Jman13 wrote:
Maybe...still, it's a really hard sell when those lenses are SO much cheaper, and the Batis is out with AF, OIS, outstanding optics, a stop faster aperture, and is shorter and lighter to boot, for $200 less. I can't see any reason I would buy this lens at this price. At $900, it becomes a potential alternative. At $1,400, it's insanity to me.


Same here. Especially given how good the Contax G 90mm f/2.8 and C/Y 85mm f/2.8 are wide open. My copy of the Contax G 90mm f/2.8 is sharp edge to edge, enough so that I don't hesitate to use it at f/2.8 if the light demands. It cleans up a bit at f/4 - slightly more contrast, less vignetting, covers up a slight misfocus, sharpness moves into the corners - but I never feel like I *have* to stop it down. It's honestly hard to see how to improve much on the G 90 for me.

The new Loxia looks nice, but it's a non-starter for me. If having a set of lenses with identical look and feel was very important to me I could imagine getting one. That's very low on my list of priorities.

Pretty surprised the Loxia 85 weighs almost 600g - sans adapter (I share one Ulata adapter for G lenses), the G 90 weighs 190g, about a third of the Loxia.

Didn't realize that the Batis was shorter *and* lighter. That's impressive.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:17 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve, I never owned a 90 Cron AA, but I did a 75 Cron AA. Clear an detailed, but also very much a "in-your-face-sharp" lens. But it left me emotionally cold, not unlike a Zeiss Z*Mp. The Loxia is on the other side of neutral. Brilliantly clear and detailed, but mild-mannered rather than athletic...
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:21 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I just merged the two threads we had on the Loxia 85/2.4.

From the MTF graph, it looks to be amazing across the entire image field wide-open at f/2.4!
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:24 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
mogul wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteMy take is this looks like a fantastic lens. Small in size but not in weight. Comparing it to the Batis, I suspect it will be a lot like the Loxia 21 vs. the Batis 25. When my wife looked at these two lenses, she said, "wow, the AF one is so much bigger." And it is when you put them side by side, but the Batis actually weighs 70g less.

Yes, the price is hard to swallow, but it is cheaper than the Leica M 90 f/2.4 Summarit. For those who actually use it I think it will serve very well for portraits, be an excellent landscape lens, and do video extremely well. It will be a great all arounder. I am most interested to see how it compares to my Leica 90 cron AA, which is smaller and lighter (even with the adapter) and also an excellent all around performer and a half stop faster too. Despite all that going for the Leica, I expect this lens to compete with it very well. These two are similar lenses and will do much the same sort of thing. I wouldn't be surprised, however, as good as the Leica 90 AA is, if the Loxia was a bit nicer for portraits with a bit better bokeh (the Leica has underrated bokeh, but I still would not be surprised if the all spherical 85 Sonnar beats it and the samples looks fantastic). I am also confident that the Loxia's 10 aperture blades will produce a lot better sunstars than the 11 bladed Leica. The Leica will no doubt have some other advantages besides being smaller and lighter, but I think the Loxia will give it a run for it money and the Loxia is much cheaper than the 90 cron AA.

For me, this 85mm will complete my small (but not light) Zeiss kit with the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 50. I would be quite happy with this kit, but I would still love a Loxia 28 (f/2 if they can squeeze it in the form factor or another f/2.4 if they cannot).
Steve, don't odd number of blades produce sunstars that are double of the blades?


Yes, the Leica 90 cron AA has 22 pointed sunstars, which are not its best feature. I much prefer the 10 pointed stars of the Leica 90 f/4 macro or presumably the 85 Loxia.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:25 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
philber wrote:
Steve, I never owned a 90 Cron AA, but I did a 75 Cron AA. Clear an detailed, but also very much a "in-your-face-sharp" lens. But it left me emotionally cold, not unlike a Zeiss Z*Mp. The Loxia is on the other side of neutral. Brilliantly clear and detailed, but mild-mannered rather than athletic...


Thanks for confirming that Phillipe. That is how it looked to me from the samples on Dear Susan as well.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:26 AM
PEKA62
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Looking at the MTF of the highly regarded 100 MP @ f/2, this new Loxia is better until close to the edge (although it's f/2.4 vs f/2)
I'll order one.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:27 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
arduluth wrote:
Jman13 wroteMaybe...still, it's a really hard sell when those lenses are SO much cheaper, and the Batis is out with AF, OIS, outstanding optics, a stop faster aperture, and is shorter and lighter to boot, for $200 less. I can't see any reason I would buy this lens at this price. At $900, it becomes a potential alternative. At $1,400, it's insanity to me.
Same here. Especially given how good the Contax G 90mm f/2.8 and C/Y 85mm f/2.8 are wide open. My copy of the Contax G 90mm f/2.8 is sharp edge to edge, enough so that I don't hesitate to use it at f/2.8 if the light demands. It cleans up a bit at f/4 - slightly more contrast, less vignetting, covers up a slight misfocus, sharpness moves into the corners - but I never feel like I *have* to stop it down. It's honestly hard to see how to improve much on the G 90 for me.

The new Loxia looks nice,
...Show more →

The shorter is not very much 92mm for the Batis without caps vs. 94.8mm for the Loxia. A little less than 3mm longer for the loxia is very little difference. The lighter will be noticeable, however. This is also true of the 25 Batis vs.21 Loxia lenses. The Batis lenses are much larger in physical size, but lighter in weight.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:32 AM
arduluth
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
I'm anxious to have it - it's just what I was hoping for, unlike so many others, it seems. I wasn't expecting it to be low-priced (do "Zeiss" and "low price" ever occur in the same sentence?), and maybe I have a different point of reference, but it seems reasonably light and compact to me...a featherweight compared to The Sumo, anyway, and 85mm corresponds to my favorite landscape lens in 4x5 (300mm), so it's something that I use a lot.

Now, bring on the 28mm Loxia


I don't think it's a bad lens. I haven't seen anyone else say that. I don't think anyone was expecting it to be $400. It's just that this is a focal length and speed combo with a lot of excellent options, and most of them are a lot cheaper, lighter, and/or smaller. That's the kicker. It doesn't make this lens stinker, but it does make it a lot less compelling than, say, the Loxia 21mm, Batis 25mm, or Batis 85mm. Another combination of price, focal length, speed, size, weight, and performance may have elicited a different reaction.

Glad that it's what you were hoping for.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:32 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

That's what it looks to me it's a softer rendition type lens which is nice. It does not scream at you per say


philber wrote:
Steve, I never owned a 90 Cron AA, but I did a 75 Cron AA. Clear an detailed, but also very much a "in-your-face-sharp" lens. But it left me emotionally cold, not unlike a Zeiss Z*Mp. The Loxia is on the other side of neutral. Brilliantly clear and detailed, but mild-mannered rather than athletic...

Sep 15, 2016 at 09:36 AM
Robin Smith
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I don't get Zeiss. Why are they producing this when they have the Batis 85/1.8 which is, faster has AF, and is lighter to boot? Is there really such a market for an MF lens like this? No wonder their prices are high as they keep on subdividing the 85mm market.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:40 AM
itai195
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I have and love the Batis 85, but its rendering looks quite different, and more over powering for sure than this new Loxia. I can totally understand why someone would prefer the Loxia. But for me, AF in this focal length and a faster aperture are too hard to give up.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:44 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Robin Smith wrote:
I don't get Zeiss. Why are they producing this when they have the Batis 85/1.8 which is, faster has AF, and is lighter to boot? Is there really such a market for an MF lens like this? No wonder their prices are high as they keep on subdividing the 85mm market.


The Loxia 85/2.4 will be better for video and part of a 52mm filter thread family.
It has mechanical manual focus which some prefer for many applications including landscape, street and video.
Although both sonnars, I can already tell from the sample pictures that this lens renders differently than the Batis.

The Batis still "looks" heavier even though it's about 100 grams lighter. I was hoping the Lox 85/2.4 was 450-500 grams instead of 600g. At this weight, my 85GM is only about 200 grams heavier..Total different beasts but you get my point.
Sep 15, 2016 at 09:46 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister