Sharp wide open across the frame, low vignetting, no ghosting, low to moderate distortion, some LoCA, lovely bokeh, nice contrast...
Sounds like my Sonnar 3.5/100, but that weighs only 285g without adapter and costs a fraction (but used of course)..
The beautiful sunstars, the electronic coupling and the more intense colours are lovely and I'd have bought this lens for 800€, but the price tag and the weight kill this lens completely for me.
I like the rendering in philbers shot, but I think that the crop is slightly blurred.
With the zm I get for about half the money about half the weight and about the same image quality, autofocus with the Techart pro, but f4 which is no big deal for landscape photography.
The sample shots look fine, but honestly, nothing is standing out for me in them at all. Certainly doesn't look any better than the Batis, and frankly doesn't look any better than the G 90 or C/Y 85, which can be had for 1/5 the cost.
I owned a Contax G 90 (and a G45 and G 28 for that matter, so I don't think my 90 was "inferior"), and the Loxia is the better lens IMHO. The very strong contrast in the Contax came at the expense of sweet colours, whereas not in the Loxia, which is both very sweet and offers the benefits of strong micro-contrast. The Loxia is also very good wide open, whereas the Contax was only really happy from f:4.0. Lastly, the Loxia bokeh doesn't have occasional rough spots like the Contax, on the contrary, it is really well behaved.
Just my $0.02
Maybe...still, it's a really hard sell when those lenses are SO much cheaper, and the Batis is out with AF, OIS, outstanding optics, a stop faster aperture, and is shorter and lighter to boot, for $200 less. I can't see any reason I would buy this lens at this price. At $900, it becomes a potential alternative. At $1,400, it's insanity to me.
I checked out some MTFs, and the only manual focus 85/90 Sonnar/Tessar that is comparable, is the ZM Sonnar 85/2. The Contax Sonnar 90/2.8, C/Y Sonnar 85/2.8 and ZM Tele-Tessar 85/4 are all beaten by the new Loxia Sonnar 85/2.4. Not surprising given the modern 7/7 elements/groups with three anomalous dispersion glasses in the new lens.
I think that the Loxia 85/2.4 looks like a good deal compared to a Leica 90/2.4 Summarit-M.
bjornthun wrote:
I checked out some MTFs, and the only manual focus 85/90 Sonnar/Tessar that is comparable, is the ZM Sonnar 85/2. The Contax Sonnar 90/2.8, C/Y Sonnar 85/2.8 and ZM Tele-Tessar 85/4 are all beaten by the new Loxia Sonnar 85/2.4. Not surprising given the modern 7/7 elements/groups with three anomalous dispersion glasses in the new lens.
I think that the Loxia 85/2.4 looks like a good deal compared to a Leica 90/2.4 Summarit-M.
Well I can tell you the the ZM 85 f4 is extremely under rated MTFs than because in practice it s sharper than the GM 85 and that's rated higher. I'll take real world
Agree, bjornthun. It's a very serious, very well built lens. MTF are a little better than the Batis 85 at f5.6 with very even performance, no astigmatism until outer frame area - near the wide edge. NO curvature. 0.8m MFD, nothing special. A simple design, 7/7 reformulated Sonnar, with what looks like three APD elements. The weight? It's built to last a long time. It's the kind of lens I thought we had seen the last of. It will be a steady seller at low volumes. If no asph, no onion rings, bet it has beautiful bokeh, done the old fashioned way. Well done. $1400 is fair.
GMPhotography wrote: bjornthun wroteI checked out some MTFs, and the only manual focus 85/90 Sonnar/Tessar that is comparable, is the ZM Sonnar 85/2. The Contax Sonnar 90/2.8, C/Y Sonnar 85/2.8 and ZM Tele-Tessar 85/4 are all beaten by the new Loxia Sonnar 85/2.4. Not surprising given the modern 7/7 elements/groups with three anomalous dispersion glasses in the new lens.
I think that the Loxia 85/2.4 looks like a good deal compared to a Leica 90/2.4 Summarit-M.Well I can tell you the the ZM 85 f4 is extremely under rated MTFs than because in practice it s sharper than the GM 85 and that's rated higher. I'll take real world
Unlike the ZM (the hood is extra and pricey) the new Loxia comes with a metal hood.
So just had a look at the published MTF for Batis and Loxia.
It's hard to compare because Batis gives you f1.8 and f4 whereas Lox gives you f2.4 and f5.6
But it is clear that Lox is a bit better at 2.4 than Lox at 1.8; and again better at 5.6 than Lox at f4.
Judging I doubt that there's a huge difference in the Batis between f 4 and f5.6 but there might be.
Anyhow it remains for testers to determine if there is a real world difference. I think at this stage it would need to be a big difference to persuade me to pay more for more weight despite the evil guy in the back of my head saying "but you know you want to compete your set of Loxias..."
Wow almost 600g?? I thought my Loxia 21 was heavy at 395g. While I am sure that is a quality lens it is not going to tempt me despite how much I like my Loxia 21.
Now am a definitely happy with my 215g Nikon 100/2.8 E lens. It's sharp, small, light and was all of $100.
The ZM is measured, and the GM is theoretical right? And the Loxia is measured as well......so the GM MTF diagram is really the odd man out for comparison purposes. Plus the ZM wouldn't have been measured on a Sony. (Or does Zeiss actual measurement use some sensor neutral approach?)
Not saying that it changes your point, just clarifying it a bit......(I think...)
-Tim
GMPhotography wrote: bjornthun wroteI checked out some MTFs, and the only manual focus 85/90 Sonnar/Tessar that is comparable, is the ZM Sonnar 85/2. The Contax Sonnar 90/2.8, C/Y Sonnar 85/2.8 and ZM Tele-Tessar 85/4 are all beaten by the new Loxia Sonnar 85/2.4. Not surprising given the modern 7/7 elements/groups with three anomalous dispersion glasses in the new lens.
I think that the Loxia 85/2.4 looks like a good deal compared to a Leica 90/2.4 Summarit-M.Well I can tell you the the ZM 85 f4 is extremely under rated MTFs than because in practice it s sharper than the GM 85 and that's rated higher. I'll take real world
Yes, Zeiss these lenses on an optical test bench of their own design, not using a camera.
tsdevine wrote:
The ZM is measured, and the GM is theoretical right? And the Loxia is measured as well......so the GM MTF diagram is really the odd man out for comparison purposes. Plus the ZM wouldn't have been measured on a Sony. (Or does Zeiss actual measurement use some sensor neutral approach?)
Not saying that it changes your point, just clarifying it a bit......(I think...)
-Tim
GMPhotography wrotebjornthun wroteI checked out some MTFs, and the only manual focus 85/90 Sonnar/Tessar that is comparable, is the ZM Sonnar 85/2. The Contax Sonnar 90/2.8, C/Y Sonnar 85/2.8 and ZM Tele-Tessar 85/4 are all beaten by the new Loxia Sonnar 85/2.4. Not surprising given the modern 7/7 elements/groups with three anomalous dispersion glasses in the new lens.
I think that the Loxia 85/2.4 looks like a good deal compared to a Leica 90/2.4 Summarit-M.Well I can tell you the the ZM 85 f4 is extremely under rated MTFs than because in practice it s sharper than the GM 85 and that's rated higher. I'll take real world
So far, most of the gripes have to do with price and weight. But the Loxia 85 is undoubtedly an ultra-high quality optic, at least from a technical standpoint. If it were a Leica, it would cost 50% more, and people would simply shrug their shoulders. If it were an Otus, it would weigh 50% more, and people would shrug their aching shoulders. The real question is whether the Loxia's IQ justifies its price and weight, especially in comparison to available alternatives. My guess is that once it gets into the hands of actual users, not professional testers, there will be a chorus of praise, as there always is with new high end glass, and it will eventually sell reasonably well. GAS has a power beyond all reckoning.
DavidBM wrote:
So just had a look at the published MTF for Batis and Loxia.
It's hard to compare because Batis gives you f1.8 and f4 whereas Lox gives you f2.4 and f5.6
But it is clear that Lox is a bit better at 2.4 than Lox at 1.8; and again better at 5.6 than Lox at f4.
Judging I doubt that there's a huge difference in the Batis between f 4 and f5.6 but there might be.
Anyhow it remains for testers to determine if there is a real world difference. I think at this stage it would need to be a big difference to persuade me to pay more for more weight despite the evil guy in the back of my head saying "but you know you want to compete your set of Loxias..."...Show more →
Considering how incredibly sharp the Batis is throughout the frame and throughout the aperture range, I would be hard pressed to imagine any real significant difference. Maybe, maybe...you'd see a slight advantage using the A7R II with one of them, but in photos either displayed on screen or printed at most any print size? You won't see a sharpness difference.