But specifically:
- The L85 is as sharp at f/2.4 anywhere in the frame as the ZM85 is at f/4
- At f/4 the L85 is a tad sharper all over than the ZM85 at f/4, but just a tad
- At f/5.6 they are identically sharp all over (center to extreme corner) at 42.5 MP (I guess diffraction is taking over)
- The L85 has similar vignetting at f/2.4 as the ZM85 does at f/4
- The L85 is less "twitchy" or sensitive to focus ring rotation at infinity than ZM85 - i.e., it's easier to achieve critical focus with the L85 because of the focus throw
- Color rendition - It appears the L85 is slightly more neutral in color, but it's slight for sure
- Contrast/pop? For the images I took it's very very close - i.e., they both look great
Caveat - I converted the L85 images from Sony ARW using ACR which is claiming that is has applied the built-in lens profile - not sure how to keep ACR from applying a lens profile.
Anyways, what you get with the L85 is basically the same performance as the ZM85, but at one stop faster plus larger, heavier, and ~2x the price.
But specifically:
- The L85 is as sharp at f/2.4 anywhere in the frame as the ZM85 is at f/4
- At f/4 the L85 is a tad sharper all over than the ZM85 at f/4, but just a tad
- At f/5.6 they are identically sharp all over (center to extreme corner) at 42.5 MP (I guess diffraction is taking over)
- The L85 has similar vignetting at f/2.4 as the ZM85 does at f/4
- The L85 is less "twitchy" or sensitive to focus ring rotation at infinity than ZM85 - i.e., it's easier to achieve critical focus with the L85 because of the focus throw
- Color rendition - It appears the L85 is slightly more neutral in color, but it's slight for sure
- Contrast/pop? For the images I took it's very very close - i.e., they both look great
Caveat - I converted the L85 images from Sony ARW using ACR which is claiming that is has applied the built-in lens profile - not sure how to keep ACR from applying a lens profile.
Anyways, what you get with the L85 is basically the same performance as the ZM85, but at one stop faster plus larger, heavier, and ~2x the price.
Excellent lens though . . . . do I need both?...Show more →
You can keep the Loxia but don't go selling the ZM. You will regret!
Yeah, for what I paid for the ZM it's a no-brainer to keep it - so small and lightweight. The question is do I want to spend the $1400 to have f/2.4? at 85mm? It's nice to have EXIF and image magnification automatically when turning the ring.
jhinkey wrote:
Yeah, for what I paid for the ZM it's a no-brainer to keep it - so small and lightweight. The question is do I want to spend the $1400 to have f/2.4? at 85mm? It's nice to have EXIF and image magnification automatically when turning the ring.
jhinkey wrote:
Yeah, for what I paid for the ZM it's a no-brainer to keep it - so small and lightweight. The question is do I want to spend the $1400 to have f/2.4? at 85mm? It's nice to have EXIF and image magnification automatically when turning the ring.
Some more gear needs to go on the B&S board.
And then there's the 35/1.4 ZM thing . . .
Thanks for that summary! One thing I would add is that TAP+85ZM is a plus for the ZM over the Loxia. You get both AF and closer focus which, at closer than mfd distances on the ZM, may make up the difference in aperture speed. I know I'm going to find this to be a tough decision. It would be more than a luxury to keep both and I'm not sure why I should other than regret for the one I let go!
I'm into panoramas for awhile now, and got the Loxia 85 for this purpose. Works wonderful.
Here a 60 picture pano of the 'Oude Kerk' in Amsterdam, consecrated in 1306. Shot at f8, A7R2. I resized the pics to 50% for the stitching process as it would just get too big. But to show the potential detail, I've added some crops of the original files.
^ Nice and incredible detail! I was just visiting your fine city. I didn't have my Loxia 85 as it was on its way but I had the Zeiss 85/4 ZM. Here's a set from Amsterdam from the past week.
Testing out the transition from the narrow focal plane to out-of-focus areas
The third one was captured last week during an epic Texas sunrise. It was facing the opposite way after the sun had risen a bit. I wanted to catch the morning light hit the buildings. If the building looks like it's leaning, it's not. It's just an optical illusion because of the shape of the left side of the Nix building.
...unless you want to wait about a year and get one for much less at the Buy and Sell board.
Yeah, it's a tough call when one owns the most excellent 85/4 ZM already. Really for $1400 I'm getting f/2.4, EXIF, weather sealing (though not really an issue with the ZM), + very very very good f/2.4 IQ and excellent f/4 IQ.
Can a man own both? Apparently the answer is yes for some. The 35/1.4 ZM though is calling my name too. May have to gradually step into the Loxia as the bank account allows.
Who knows, some local person may buy the L85, hate it, and then put it in the used case at the local pro shop for a few hundred $$ savings . . . in a year though!