fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
stevesanacore
Offline
Details
p.53 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Luvwine wrote:
stevesanacore wrote
Luvwine wrote
stevesanacore wroteI'd love a 100-135mm in E mount. 85 is just not long enough for a minimal travel kit. The more I shoot with the Sony the less tolerance I have with adapters for my personal work. Other than the 70-200 f4, there are no other compact options yet. I guess the wonderful 135 f2 would be nice, but certainly not compact.
I doubt we will see a 135/2 unless it is a GM or Batis. The Loxia line will be slower at that focal length if it comes. In the interim, I and many others like the compact and terrific Leica 135/3.4 apo. Yes, it requires an adapter, but is worth it to me.
Well a 135 f2 may just be too large anyway. I'd be happy with a 2.8. A 100 2.8 may be the best compromise. Yes the Leica 135 3.4 caught my attention too. I agree the Leica M adapter is tiny compared with the Canon adapter. I'd really like AF, so a Batis or even a Sony would suffice. Maybe the Sony 90 2.8 is the way to go until a better alternative shows up...
What Steve Spencer says, above. Check out the TAP adapter. It does well autofocusing with the Leica 135/3.4 (and many other lenses). The TAP does work use face detect AF but so far not eye AF, unfortunately.


I keep forgetting about that adapter. I just sold my Leica R lenses, (focusing manually with precision wide open was causing me grief), and picked up a few Sony Zeiss AF lenses, which are very impressive. I still have a huge set of Canon's latest and greatest as I use them for most of my work. I just don't like the bulk when I travel. I've toyed with Zeiss or Leica M optics but haven't moved yet. I may rent the adapter and lens and see how I like it. Thanks for the reminder! I would guess a Sony or Batis 100 or 135 is in the future, but who knows how long that will be.
Jan 20, 2017 at 11:59 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteIf I could only have one 85mm, it would be the GM 85/1.4 and portraits would be its main application. For landscapes, I would skip 85mm and mostly shoot with the Vario-Sonnar 100-300. -- which is heavy, superb and already in my bag.

Using the Loxia 85/2.4 for portraits is not much different than shooting with the Sony 90/2.8 Macro in terms of depth of field and background blur. It can be used for portraits but imo, it's not the best tool for the job. Not enough depth of field and too much micro-contrast. Also, your model needs to be very patient allowing you to get proper focus. Like I said, it's possible and you will end up with at lot of keepers but imo not ideal. Sony natives and EyeAF are a Godsend.

How about the Loxia 85/2.4 for landscapes? I think that currently, it's the best lens for the Sony E-mount. It handily beats the Batis 85 and GM 85 even at f/5.6. Against the Leica 90AA and ZM 85, the difference is very small but it's still a better performer at all apertures.

Should I get the Loxia or ZM for landscapes? That's a tough question. If I didn't already have the heavy Zeiss 100-300 (925g), I would probably bring the Loxia 85 to the field. However, the IQ difference between the Loxia and ZM is VERY small to almost unnoticeable in practical terms after f/6.3 making the ZM a more compact (and cheaper) alternative for landscapes without compromising anything at my mostly used apertures.

I know the Loxia MTF looks better but my infinity tests show that both lenses are indeed very close 1 1/2 stops down.
Both have a 10-blade aperture, high micro-contrast and great flair performance. I can almost identify the Loxia images from its cooler color cast.

See here: (best of 3 for each lens. Both focused at mid-field. Both lenses are perfectly centered)
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1450325/48#13878625

If you are mostly shooting landscapes with a 85mm prime, I hope the above test will help you make your own mind.
All the best,
Fred
I still cannot help but think that Fred's test, however well done, showed the ZM to its best advantage in that the best aperture for the Loxia is likely F5.6 whereas Fred's test was at 7.1 (past best for Loxia, best for ZM). Still, both are excellent no doubt with Loxia a shade ahead in that comparison. The earlier comparison can be found here:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1450325/45

It shows a greater difference and that may be explained by copy variation on the ZM tho hard to say from afar.

The bottom line is that we are spoiled for choice today. All are valid selections depending
...Show more →

The sample crop I posted previously was indeed at f/7.1. That's because that's the optimal aperture for the 85 ZM (which is only a hair better than at f/5.6 on the edges). It does not mean that f/4 (wide open) and f/5.6 are not great. -- Just like Loxia 85mm at f/2.4 and f/4 are still great.

I didn't post crops at f/5.6 but wrote on my previous post that they are very similar and that's quite amazing for the ZM considering it's only 1-stop down compared to the Loxia's 2 1/2 stops down.

I would consider all three lenses (Leica 90AA, Loxia 85 and ZM 85) superb optically. Practical differences will in color rendition and speed only. The Leica lacks the micro-contrast from the two Zeiss lenses. Different tools for different needs.

Here are crops at f/5.6 straight from the camera other than the same sharpening applied to both. (best of 3 for each). Notice the difference in color cast (Loxia: cooler, ZM: warmer).

Like I wrote before, the Loxia is technically better (Just like the MTF graph shows) but at least with my copies, the difference is insignificant in practical terms. Remember we are pixel peeping at 1:1!




Center 1:1 crop at infinity distance.






Mid-Field 1:1 crop at infinity distance






Extreme Edges 1:1 crop at infinity distance (Note the ZM is a bit wider)

Jan 20, 2017 at 12:16 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Here are the thumbs showing the entire scene:




Notice the color cast differences and very similar contrast

Jan 20, 2017 at 12:20 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.53 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Here are the thumbs showing the entire scene:


Thank you very much Fred for posting that. It does seem to me to show a bit more advantage for the Loxia than at 7.1 but as you say the differences are subtle assuming a good copy of the ZM.

Any info regarding the GM at infinity vis a vis a comparison with Loxia?



Edited on Jan 20, 2017 at 12:57 PM · View previous versions
Jan 20, 2017 at 12:54 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteHere are the thumbs showing the entire scene:
Thank you very much Fred for posting that. It does seem to me to show a bit more advantage for the Loxia that at 7.1 but as you say the differences are subtle assuming a good copy of the ZM.

Any info regarding the GM at infinity vis a vis a comparison with Loxia?


I will do a new test whenever the rain stops.
I didn't test the Loxia directly to the GM but if I remember correctly, the ZM did better than the Batis and GM starting at f/5.6. (infinity distance)
Jan 20, 2017 at 12:57 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.53 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHere are the thumbs showing the entire scene:
Thank you very much Fred for posting that. It does seem to me to show a bit more advantage for the Loxia that at 7.1 but as you say the differences are subtle assuming a good copy of the ZM.

Any info regarding the GM at infinity vis a vis a comparison with Loxia?
I will do a new test whenever the rain stops.
I didn't test the Loxia directly to the GM but if I remember correctly, the ZM was better than the Batis and GM starting at f/5.6. (infinity distance)


Yes, I recall seeing a test that Guy did where the ZM was as good or better (I think better) than the GM at infinity. It would be great to have a head to head comparison in selfish part because there is a fellow on another forum who is convinced that the GM is the better optic than i think any other lens on the planet and "clearly better" than the Loxia....Of course he has only tested at portrait distances and only in the center and even then the only advantage I can see is bokeh. Sigh.....

Edited on Jan 20, 2017 at 01:02 PM · View previous versions
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:00 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHere are the thumbs showing the entire scene:
Thank you very much Fred for posting that. It does seem to me to show a bit more advantage for the Loxia that at 7.1 but as you say the differences are subtle assuming a good copy of the ZM.

Any info regarding the GM at infinity vis a vis a comparison with Loxia?
I will do a new test whenever the rain stops.
I didn't test the Loxia directly to the GM but if I remember correctly, the ZM was better than the Batis and GM starting at f/5.6. (infinity distance)
Yes, I recall seeing a test that Guy did where the ZM was as good or better (I think better) than the GM at infinity. It would be great to have a head to head comparison in selfish part because there is a fellow on another forum who is convinced that the GM is the better optic than i think any other lens on the planet and "clearly better" than the Loxia....Of course he has only tested at portrait differences and only in the center and even then the only advantage I can see is bokeh. Sigh.....


Stay away from 'mine is better than yours' forum fights!
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:01 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.53 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHere are the thumbs showing the entire scene:
Thank you very much Fred for posting that. It does seem to me to show a bit more advantage for the Loxia that at 7.1 but as you say the differences are subtle assuming a good copy of the ZM.

Any info regarding the GM at infinity vis a vis a comparison with Loxia?
I will do a new test whenever the rain stops.
I didn't test the Loxia directly to the GM but if I remember correctly, the ZM was better than the Batis and GM starting at f/5.6. (infinity distance)
Yes, I recall seeing a test that Guy did where the ZM was as good or better (I think better) than the GM at infinity. It would be great to have a head to head comparison in selfish part because there is a fellow on another forum who is convinced that the GM is the better optic than i think any other lens on the planet and "clearly better" than the Loxia....Of course he has only tested at portrait differences and only in the center and even then the only advantage I can see is bokeh. Sigh.....
Stay away from 'mine is better than yours' forum fights!


Understood. Thing is, I agree that for portrait the logical best choice would be the GM. I mean who would not want great center resolution, speed, excellent bokeh, and Eye AF for that application? It is not a matter of "mine is better than yours" so much as knowing what tools are the best for any given application. Ignoring the "know it alls" is challenging at times, however. .....

Edt: Another comment. One thing that annoys me about Sony is that their MTF graphs are well nigh useless. For the GM lenses they say the MTF 50 is what they are shooting for, but only provide MTF 30 in their graphs for the GM. Huh? And then, to make things worse, the MTF's are computed and not measured and ignore diffraction effects. The MTF for the GM 85 at F8 is simply not possible and therefore tells us little about the optical merits compared to something like the Loxia (which has a measured MTF including MTF 40). That is another reason getting a great comparison like you provide is so helpful as it let's others get a sense of the optical merits of each lens and means more than the published MTFs.

Thanks again, Fred.
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:05 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I posted infinity crops from the 85 GM from f/1.4 until f/11 (center, mid and edge) at infinity. It was quite impressive from wide-open! I can't find it right now but it was posted on this forum.
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:13 PM
rji2goleez
Offline
Details
p.53 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Yet another option not mentioned in this discussion is the Contax G 90/2.8. It's also small, inexpensive and renders nicely. A Techart AF adapter also exists for Contax G to NEX which works well but not quite as fast as TAP. When I get my Loxia, I plan to test these together.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/2016#13887068
Note: The skyline image was shot wide open at f/2.8

I should have posted these here vs the FE Image thread.
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:16 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.53 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Found the 85/1.4 GM comparison from f/1.4 until f/13.
It's great starting at f/4 but wider apertures are still good throughout the frame.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1423407/3#13503296
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:18 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.53 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Found the 85/1.4 GM comparison from f/1.4 until f/13.
It's great starting at f/4 but wider apertures are still good throughout the frame.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1423407/3#13503296


It looks like the contrast isn't as good in the far corners wide open, but it sure seems pretty darned sharp!

Does one need
85/4 ZM
85/2.4 Lox
85/1.4 GM

if you do, then you pretty much have all uses at 85mm taken care of
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:35 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.53 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Found the 85/1.4 GM comparison from f/1.4 until f/13.
It's great starting at f/4 but wider apertures are still good throughout the frame.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1423407/3#13503296


Thanks Fred. It does look good, but hard to know how good without a comparison test. Your follow up comments on the next page indicate you thought 85 Batis might be better for landscape due to greater contrast.
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:38 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.53 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
jhinkey wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteFound the 85/1.4 GM comparison from f/1.4 until f/13.
It's great starting at f/4 but wider apertures are still good throughout the frame.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1423407/3#13503296
It looks like the contrast isn't as good in the far corners wide open, but it sure seems pretty darned sharp!

Does one need
85/4 ZM
85/2.4 Lox
85/1.4 GM

if you do, then you pretty much have all uses at 85mm taken care of


No doubt, but what do you use for which tasks? ZM for lightest weight and smallest size, GM for portraits and ?? Loxia for best landscape? And ?
Jan 20, 2017 at 01:39 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.53 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I am looking for a ZM 85 so just PM me if you decide on the Loxia
Jan 20, 2017 at 03:23 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.53 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
I am looking for a ZM 85 so just PM me if you decide on the Loxia


Hi Guy,

You crack me up. You are the Poster Child for:

http://www.caginkapi.com/_y/data/storage/attachments/625e8a4605b7b257019fe6e8d07dc352.gif



Rich
Jan 20, 2017 at 03:39 PM
tzhang4284
Offline
Details
p.53 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
rji2goleez wrote:
Yet another option not mentioned in this discussion is the Contax G 90/2.8. It's also small, inexpensive and renders nicely. A Techart AF adapter also exists for Contax G to NEX which works well but not quite as fast as TAP. When I get my Loxia, I plan to test these together.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/2016#13887068
Note: The skyline image was shot wide open at f/2.8

I should have posted these here vs the FE Image thread.


I had the G90 and sold it in anticipation of the Loxia 85. Based on the photos I took with it (using the TA-GA3 adapter), the Loxia 85 is a much stronger lens all around especially if you care about corner to corner sharpness. low CA and usable manual focus ergonomics. The AF wasn't particularly great either with the adapter and this setup wasn't cheap at all when you factor in the cost of the adapter.

The L85 also has a higher contrast and more vibrant color cast like the other Loxia lenses relative to the G90's rendering, which had lower contrast. That said, the g90 was a great travel portrait lens though - just the right amount of sharpness in good light wide open without editing although the bokeh was a little harsh, as they say.
Jan 20, 2017 at 03:49 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.53 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
I am looking for a ZM 85 so just PM me if you decide on the Loxia


Hah!

I just pointed Bob to a used 85ZM for sale at PopFlash that I happened to run across last week - which he apparently quickly grabbed and already has pictures from.

Glad I happened to find a pristine used *5ZM at the local pro shop some time ago! I had my 75/2.5 Summarit-M with me and it was immediately obvious that the ZM blew it away in just about every way except f/2.5. So I grabbed it and the rest is history.

Now I'm just waiting for that used L85 to show up at the local pro shop - - maybe in a couple of years when someone who bought it on a whim finally decides to trade it in for a big loss

I kid you not - I've bought some used, but incredibly pristine lenses at the local pro shop (135/3.4 APO, 180/3.4 APO, 85ZM, etc, etc.) that appeared to be unused and were a great price. The story is always that someone bought it, let it sit for a couple of years, then traded it in on something else. Handy to live in a large metropolitan area with folks willing to freely spend their cash on expensive stuff
Jan 20, 2017 at 05:38 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.53 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I saw that on eBay and if I had the money . Bob would have not got it. Lol

I had my shot at it. Great price. Now Bob looks to try the Loxia. See what he decides to do but I'll buy that ZM.
Jan 20, 2017 at 05:47 PM
photomadnz
Offline
Details
p.53 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
When I look at Fred's test of the ZM v Loxia above it looks like the ZM has more depth to it? More, (for lack of a better word), 3D'ness to it.... Is it just me?

Ive noticed with my files off the Loxia that they are crazy good technically but are they lacking something? Your shots above again look a little 1 dimensional off the Loxia in comparison..
Jan 20, 2017 at 06:59 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister