Luvwine wrote: stevesanacore wroteI'd love a 100-135mm in E mount. 85 is just not long enough for a minimal travel kit. The more I shoot with the Sony the less tolerance I have with adapters for my personal work. Other than the 70-200 f4, there are no other compact options yet. I guess the wonderful 135 f2 would be nice, but certainly not compact.I doubt we will see a 135/2 unless it is a GM or Batis. The Loxia line will be slower at that focal length if it comes. In the interim, I and many others like the compact and terrific Leica 135/3.4 apo. Yes, it requires an adapter, but is worth it to me.
Well a 135 f2 may just be too large anyway. I'd be happy with a 2.8. A 100 2.8 may be the best compromise. Yes the Leica 135 3.4 caught my attention too. I agree the Leica M adapter is tiny compared with the Canon adapter. I'd really like AF, so a Batis or even a Sony would suffice. Maybe the Sony 90 2.8 is the way to go until a better alternative shows up...
stevesanacore wrote: Luvwine wrotestevesanacore wroteI'd love a 100-135mm in E mount. 85 is just not long enough for a minimal travel kit. The more I shoot with the Sony the less tolerance I have with adapters for my personal work. Other than the 70-200 f4, there are no other compact options yet. I guess the wonderful 135 f2 would be nice, but certainly not compact.I doubt we will see a 135/2 unless it is a GM or Batis. The Loxia line will be slower at that focal length if it comes. In the interim, I and many others like the compact and terrific Leica 135/3.4 apo. Yes, it requires an adapter, but is worth it to me.Well a 135 f2 may just be too large anyway. I'd be happy with a 2.8. A 100 2.8 may be the best compromise. Yes the Leica 135 3.4 caught my attention too. I agree the Leica M adapter is tiny compared with the Canon adapter. I'd really like AF, so a Batis or even a Sony would suffice. Maybe the Sony 90 2.8 is the way to go until a better alternative shows up...
You do know there is an adapter for Leica M lenses that has autofocus. So, if you want autofocus you can go with Leica M and have autofocus too. It is call the TAP (Tech Art Pro) and you will find a couple of threads on it in the Alt lens forum.
stevesanacore wrote: Luvwine wrotestevesanacore wroteI'd love a 100-135mm in E mount. 85 is just not long enough for a minimal travel kit. The more I shoot with the Sony the less tolerance I have with adapters for my personal work. Other than the 70-200 f4, there are no other compact options yet. I guess the wonderful 135 f2 would be nice, but certainly not compact.I doubt we will see a 135/2 unless it is a GM or Batis. The Loxia line will be slower at that focal length if it comes. In the interim, I and many others like the compact and terrific Leica 135/3.4 apo. Yes, it requires an adapter, but is worth it to me.Well a 135 f2 may just be too large anyway. I'd be happy with a 2.8. A 100 2.8 may be the best compromise. Yes the Leica 135 3.4 caught my attention too. I agree the Leica M adapter is tiny compared with the Canon adapter. I'd really like AF, so a Batis or even a Sony would suffice. Maybe the Sony 90 2.8 is the way to go until a better alternative shows up...
What Steve Spencer says, above. Check out the TAP adapter. It does well autofocusing with the Leica 135/3.4 (and many other lenses). The TAP does work use face detect AF but so far not eye AF, unfortunately.
A progression of 50/2 - 85/2.4 - 100/2.8 - 135/3.4 (half stop decreases in maximum aperture) will make good sense to some segment of the market. It certainly does to many of us here, and I'm sure it does to Zeiss as well, as they are half way there already, with two stunning lenses.
But - without sounding too elitist - the broader user base sees the optical world very differently. To them the ideal lens specs are what they grew up with, from mainstream camera systems, with a smattering of exotica.
A sample of n=10,000 at SAR voted for a 135/1.8 as their second preference for upcoming a7x system lenses. The top ten 'featured' seven zooms of Canon/Nikon/A mount configurations as well. Top lens desired was a 24-105/4, a lens type (4x zoom) that might seem at odds with ever-increasing resolution and potential image quality. But user wishes are fragmented too, dreams like the 50/0.95 and 85/1.2 made the top eleven as well - expensive dreams that seem either already catered for, or which are nightmares in disguise when used on small 40+ Mp cameras.
philip_pj wrote:
A progression of 50/2 - 85/2.4 - 100/2.8 - 135/3.4 (half stop decreases in maximum aperture) will make good sense to some segment of the market. It certainly does to many of us here, and I'm sure it does to Zeiss as well, as they are half way there already, with two stunning lenses.
But - without sounding too elitist - the broader user base sees the optical world very differently. To them the ideal lens specs are what they grew up with, from mainstream camera systems, with a smattering of exotica.
A sample of n=10,000 at SAR voted for a 135/1.8 as their second preference for upcoming a7x system lenses. The top ten 'featured' seven zooms of Canon/Nikon/A mount configurations as well. Top lens desired was a 24-105/4, a lens type (4x zoom) that might seem at odds with ever-increasing resolution and potential image quality. But user wishes are fragmented too, dreams like the 50/0.95 and 85/1.2 made the top eleven as well - expensive dreams that seem either already catered for, or which are nightmares in disguise when used on small 40+ Mp cameras.
...Show more →
+1
I like that progression. I'd love to have a 135/1.8, but not in a Loxia - a 135/3.4 as good as my Leica would be killer to have.
A 135/1.8 would be more of a specialist lens for ME since it would be AF and quite large/heavy and only would be used on special occasions like my 135/2 APO Zeis is.
I decided against the Loxia (for now) in preference for the Tele-Tessar 85/4 ZM. It's so tiny and with TAP, one can create a nice bokeh effect at less than MFD.
rji2goleez wrote:
I decided against the Loxia (for now) in preference for the Tele-Tessar 85/4 ZM. It's so tiny and with TAP, one can create a nice bokeh effect at less than MFD.
jhinkey wrote: rji2goleez wroteI decided against the Loxia (for now) in preference for the Tele-Tessar 85/4 ZM. It's so tiny and with TAP, one can create a nice bokeh effect at less than MFD.
photomadnz wrote:
Has anyone with both the ZM 85mm F4 and now the Loxia 85mm formed any strong opinions either way?
Look earlier in the thread. There have been two comparisons. Both favor Loxia but one by more than the other. Fred's comparison shows a small advantage over his excellent copy of the ZM. My take is that the Loxia is a small amount better than a good copy of the ZM 85 and a fair amount better than a less than stellar copy. Where the ZM wins is in the size/weight department and in TAP compatibility. The Loxia is faster and is somewhat sharper with less CA. If size is a priority, the ZM is a great choice. If you want the best glass, the Loxia is hard to beat. Others will doubtless chime in if my summary is somehow inaccurate.
Thanks, yeah Ive seen that but there more to the process then 1 test comparison. Id be more interested to how Fred and others are finding the overall experience after spending quite a bit of time with the ZM previously.
I have a test sample of the Loxia myself but theres something about the contrast in the ZM line that gives a unique look of its own. Interested to hear what users are experiencing.....
rji2goleez wrote: jhinkey wroterji2goleez wroteI decided against the Loxia (for now) in preference for the Tele-Tessar 85/4 ZM. It's so tiny and with TAP, one can create a nice bokeh effect at less than MFD.
I've been looking around more re the L85, and stick with my views upthread that it's a true (therefore rare) multi-purpose optic. Users of the ZM85 who are happy with it in use largely/purely as a landscape/nature lens (and who would not be), the Loxia is one step forward ('sharpness') and one step back (weight/size/cost). I would not class the gain in sharpness as small (either quantitatively (MTF), or qualitatively (image assessment), but opinions will differ.
Zeiss went to plenty of trouble to make it the sound compromise it is, and one reference point was the ZM85/4. From Victor (VBL):
"VBL: Would you say that compactness is the key selling proposition of the Loxia lenses?
Mr. Cristophe Casenave: Definitely. But without compromising build or image quality. This is why Loxia 85 is “only” f/2.4. We have this 85/4 lens in M mount (Tele-Tessar) and people always said – it might be a bit slow but its size is miraculous, it’s superb. So we tried to make a compromise, to keep the size compact while adding a bit more light. We were *opening it more and more* and then we said stop, that’s it – f/2.4, that’s a perfect balance between size and speed."
Which gives us an insight into the development process: 'we were opening it more and more' almost certainly refers to prototype design contenders, of different sizes and weights.
Many users do not see color as a primary factor in image assessment, instead all the focus is on 'sharpness'. To some extent, this is due to the strong emphasis on selected lens metrics by the industry, rather than what we might call 'learned characteristics' - color being a key example of these. Catering to more experienced users, Zeiss are very involved with color right now:
"We should also think of a new coatings which ensure better flare protection and *color rendition stability* across the recent Zeiss lens line. We are investing a lot in the effort to keep that distinguished *Zeiss color interpretation and look* across all Zeiss lenses.." [asterisks are all mine]
In terms of 'how good is the L85?', you can take a close look at the 'same subject' images comparing Otus85-Milvus85-ZEF 85-Batis85-Loxia85, all at ~f2.4:
[the ZEF is essentially a repackaged CY 85/1.4 with new coatings, same design]. At 'best aperture' at infinity (f4 or f5.6), Loxia has the least curvature and the best corners of all of them (MTF).
Great followup Phillip, cheers. The Loxia I have is sublime and Ill be interested to see how DxO and the likes rate it. I cant imagine anything being better once stopped down. I like to see how much of a scare it gives the Otus.....
philip_pj wrote:
I've been looking around more re the L85, and stick with my views upthread that it's a true (therefore rare) multi-purpose optic. Users of the ZM85 who are happy with it in use largely/purely as a landscape/nature lens (and who would not be), the Loxia is one step forward ('sharpness') and one step back (weight/size/cost). I would not class the gain in sharpness as small (either quantitatively (MTF), or qualitatively (image assessment), but opinions will differ.
Zeiss went to plenty of trouble to make it the sound compromise it is, and one reference point was the ZM85/4. From Victor (VBL):
"VBL: Would you say that compactness is the key selling proposition of the Loxia lenses?
Mr. Cristophe Casenave: Definitely. But without compromising build or image quality. This is why Loxia 85 is “only” f/2.4. We have this 85/4 lens in M mount (Tele-Tessar) and people always said – it might be a bit slow but its size is miraculous, it’s superb. So we tried to make a compromise, to keep the size compact while adding a bit more light. We were *opening it more and more* and then we said stop, that’s it – f/2.4, that’s a perfect balance between size and speed."
Which gives us an insight into the development process: 'we were opening it more and more' almost certainly refers to prototype design contenders, of different sizes and weights.
Many users do not see color as a primary factor in image assessment, instead all the focus is on 'sharpness'. To some extent, this is due to the strong emphasis on selected lens metrics by the industry, rather than what we might call 'learned characteristics' - color being a key example of these. Catering to more experienced users, Zeiss are very involved with color right now:
"We should also think of a new coatings which ensure better flare protection and *color rendition stability* across the recent Zeiss lens line. We are investing a lot in the effort to keep that distinguished *Zeiss color interpretation and look* across all Zeiss lenses.." [asterisks are all mine]
In terms of 'how good is the L85?', you can take a close look at the 'same subject' images comparing Otus85-Milvus85-ZEF 85-Batis85-Loxia85, all at ~f2.4:
[the ZEF is essentially a repackaged CY 85/1.4 with new coatings, same design]. At 'best aperture' at infinity (f4 or f5.6), Loxia has the least curvature and the best corners of all of them (MTF). ...Show more →
I'll be buying my 3rd ZM 85 again soon. Having the GM 85 and it's performance more wide open than having the ZM is the perfect compliment lens. Plus I'll have 3 ZM lenses that pretty much match each other. So come February 8th when I get my smugmug money I'll be buying it again. So I'm looking for a great copy again. Unless I steal mine back from Fred.
The Loxia looks to be great and if I only wanted one 85 this would be number 1 choice. But I need a AF lens here too. Now if there was a great 135 F2 in E mount than I'd sell my GM 85 and buy the Loxia to replace it but until that point than I feel my best option is having two 85s
philip_pj wrote:
A progression of 50/2 - 85/2.4 - 100/2.8 - 135/3.4 (half stop decreases in maximum aperture) will make good sense to some segment of the market. It certainly does to many of us here, and I'm sure it does to Zeiss as well, as they are half way there already, with two stunning lenses.
But - without sounding too elitist - the broader user base sees the optical world very differently. To them the ideal lens specs are what they grew up with, from mainstream camera systems, with a smattering of exotica.
A sample of n=10,000 at SAR voted for a 135/1.8 as their second preference for upcoming a7x system lenses. The top ten 'featured' seven zooms of Canon/Nikon/A mount configurations as well. Top lens desired was a 24-105/4, a lens type (4x zoom) that might seem at odds with ever-increasing resolution and potential image quality. But user wishes are fragmented too, dreams like the 50/0.95 and 85/1.2 made the top eleven as well - expensive dreams that seem either already catered for, or which are nightmares in disguise when used on small 40+ Mp cameras.
I think this progression is close, but I think that 85 and 100 are a bit too close in focal length. I think a progression of 50 f/2, 85 f/2.4, and 135 f/2.8 would make more sense. This would also help video people, who are an obvious target audience for the Loxia lenses, as they don't like lenses with a narrower max aperture than f/2.8. I see a nice balance with a potential Loxia lineup of 21 f/2.8, 28 f/2.4, 35 f/2, 50 f/2, 85 f/2.4, and 135 f/2.8. I hope we get at least these last two lenses, but I think that will depend on sales of the 85. I think the Loxia 21 has sold pretty well so a 28 is hopefully in the works and if the 85 sells well I think we will get a 135.
If I could only have one 85mm, it would be the GM 85/1.4 and portraits would be its main application. For landscapes, I would skip 85mm and mostly shoot with the Vario-Sonnar 100-300. -- which is heavy, superb and already in my bag.
Using the Loxia 85/2.4 for portraits is not much different than shooting with the Sony 90/2.8 Macro in terms of depth of field and background blur. It can be used for portraits but imo, it's not the best tool for the job. Not enough depth of field and too much micro-contrast. Also, your model needs to be very patient allowing you to get proper focus. Like I said, it's possible and you will end up with at lot of keepers but imo not ideal. Sony natives and EyeAF are a Godsend.
How about the Loxia 85/2.4 for landscapes? I think that currently, it's the best lens for the Sony E-mount. It handily beats the Batis 85 and GM 85 even at f/5.6. Against the Leica 90AA and ZM 85, the difference is very small but it's still a better performer at all apertures.
Should I get the Loxia or ZM for landscapes? That's a tough question. If I didn't already have the heavy Zeiss 100-300 (925g), I would probably bring the Loxia 85 to the field. However, the IQ difference between the Loxia and ZM is VERY small to almost unnoticeable in practical terms after f/6.3 making the ZM a more compact (and cheaper) alternative for landscapes without compromising anything at my mostly used apertures.
I know the Loxia MTF looks better but my infinity tests show that both lenses are indeed very close 1 1/2 stops down.
Both have a 10-blade aperture, high micro-contrast and great flair performance. I can almost identify the Loxia images from its cooler color cast.
^That being said, and while my initial shots with the 85 ZM are wonderful, I just snagged a LNIB Loxia 85 to try out and compare. At the end of the day, I'll likely sell one of them but finding a barely used Loxia 85 for less than MSRP was too good to pass up. I'll be traveling for the next week so won't be able to compare until after that!
GAS - it's a terrible thing! I have a lot of glass that I will have to begin unloading . . .
Fred Miranda wrote:
If I could only have one 85mm, it would be the GM 85/1.4 and portraits would be its main application. For landscapes, I would skip 85mm and mostly shoot with the Vario-Sonnar 100-300. -- which is heavy, superb and already in my bag.
Using the Loxia 85/2.4 for portraits is not much different than shooting with the Sony 90/2.8 Macro in terms of depth of field and background blur. It can be used for portraits but imo, it's not the best tool for the job. Not enough depth of field and too much micro-contrast. Also, your model needs to be very patient allowing you to get proper focus. Like I said, it's possible and you will end up with at lot of keepers but imo not ideal. Sony natives and EyeAF are a Godsend.
How about the Loxia 85/2.4 for landscapes? I think that currently, it's the best lens for the Sony E-mount. It handily beats the Batis 85 and GM 85 even at f/5.6. Against the Leica 90AA and ZM 85, the difference is very small but it's still a better performer at all apertures.
Should I get the Loxia or ZM for landscapes? That's a tough question. If I didn't already have the heavy Zeiss 100-300 (925g), I would probably bring the Loxia 85 to the field. However, the IQ difference between the Loxia and ZM is VERY small to almost unnoticeable in practical terms after f/6.3 making the ZM a more compact (and cheaper) alternative for landscapes without compromising anything at my mostly used apertures.
I know the Loxia MTF looks better but my infinity tests show that both lenses are indeed very close 1 1/2 stops down.
Both have a 10-blade aperture, high micro-contrast and great flair performance. I can almost identify the Loxia images from its cooler color cast.
If you are mostly shooting landscapes with a 85mm prime, I hope the above test will help you make your own mind.
All the best,
Fred...Show more →
I still cannot help but think that Fred's test, however well done, showed the ZM to its best advantage in that the best aperture for the Loxia is likely F5.6 whereas Fred's test was at 7.1 (past best for Loxia, best for ZM). Still, both are excellent no doubt with Loxia a shade ahead in that comparison. The earlier comparison can be found here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1450325/45
It shows a greater difference and that may be explained by copy variation on the ZM tho hard to say from afar.
The bottom line is that we are spoiled for choice today. All are valid selections depending upon how one prioritizes optical excellence, size, and speed.
I also think that any differences between these lenses may become more significant only upon the development of a future higher MP sensor. It may be that the Loxia is designed with that in mind perhaps more than M mount glass would be. That is, the Loxia might be a bit more future proof, tho obviously this is speculative.
Lastly Fred, have you or anyone else compared the GM 85 at infinity versus the Loxia? I know you indicated that the Loxia handily beats it and the Batis, but I have not seen such testing and would be very interested in seeing it.