fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.37 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
alba63 wrote
digital_AM wroteThe other lens I'm considering is the Canon 24 TSE.
If you shoot lots of architecture, then TSE would be the one, however my tests of this lens (24 TS-E II) yielded quite so...so results, as opposed to the Canon DSLR where it was a stellar lens.Might the the adapter solution, might be my sample, no idea.
It's the adapter. They differ in flange distance and that introduces unwanted field curvature. (That goes for any EF lens as well - not just TS-Es)
I have a Metabones and a Fotodiox adapter. The Metabones has the TS-E 17/4 infinity distance at around 3m and field curvature at infinity is very apparent even stepping the lens down. The Fotodiox on the other hand has infinity at the lens infinity mark and does not introduces any field curvature. You have to try a few adapters and see which one has the correct registry. This drove me nuts for a while.
I'm confused: how can the flange distance induce field curvature in the EF lenses that unit focus? Once you have focused the effective optical distance will be the same on any adapter that allows you to focus at that distance at all. If there are floating elements, of course, it's different...or am I missing something?
If the adapter gives imperfect flange distance, infinity focus will not be accurate in the lens. There may also be a severe field curvature effect depending on how off the adapter is.

I've tested this with numerous adapters and have two EF to E adapters that confirms my findings. One gives a very flat field for my EF and TS-E lenses (while giving the lens perfect infinity hard stop) and the other a very noticeable field curvature for all my lenses (center and edges are never in the same plane of field)

I don't know the technical explanation for this but
...Show more →

I'm not doubting your findings; I"m just puzzled what the explanation is for unit focussing lenses. Because infinity focus being off in the lens doesn't matter if the lens is unit focussing, as long as total distance from the rear element to the sensor is correct (the lens is just changing extension, and it doesn't matter what the ratio of extension from the lens and extension from the adapter is). The Canon TSE is not, though, unit focusing: it has some kind of internal focus, so I can easily see how you could end up with a curved field is the adapter is the wrong length (the elements will be in the wrong configuration for the focussed distance, if you are using the internal focus to compensate for incorrect flange distance.

But have you observed this behaviour (the field curvature) in any unit focussing lenses? I think the 50mm EF ones unit focus, for example. Of course even in the unit focussing lenses if the flange distance is off then the infinity mark will incorrect: but I don't see how this can matter in a unit focussing lens except as an inconvenience (or if the adapter is too long, in which case you won't be able to get infinity).
Dec 22, 2016 at 04:15 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.37 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
alba63 wrote
digital_AM wroteThe other lens I'm considering is the Canon 24 TSE.
If you shoot lots of architecture, then TSE would be the one, however my tests of this lens (24 TS-E II) yielded quite so...so results, as opposed to the Canon DSLR where it was a stellar lens.Might the the adapter solution, might be my sample, no idea.
It's the adapter. They differ in flange distance and that introduces unwanted field curvature. (That goes for any EF lens as well - not just TS-Es)
I have a Metabones and a Fotodiox adapter. The Metabones has the TS-E 17/4 infinity distance at around 3m and field curvature at infinity is very apparent even stepping the lens down. The Fotodiox on the other hand has infinity at the lens infinity mark and does not introduces any field curvature. You have to try a few adapters and see which one has the correct registry. This drove me nuts for a while.
I'm confused: how can the flange distance induce field curvature in the EF lenses that unit focus? Once you have focused the effective optical distance will be the same on any adapter that allows you to focus at that distance at all. If there are floating elements, of course, it's different...or am I missing something?
If the adapter gives imperfect flange distance, infinity focus will not be accurate in the lens. There may also be a severe field curvature effect depending on how off the adapter is.

I've tested this with numerous adapters and have two EF to E adapters that confirms my findings. One gives a very flat field for my EF and TS-E lenses (while giving the lens perfect infinity hard stop) and the other a very noticeable field curvature for all my lenses (center and edges are never in the same plane of field)

I don't know the technical explanation for this but it happens. It took me a while to realize this.

@MJKoski@@ posted exactly what happens when using an adapter yielding an imprecise flange distance:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1464618/0#13836163
I'm not doubting your findings; I"m just puzzled what the explanation is for unit focussing lenses. Because infinity focus being off in the lens doesn't matter if the lens is unit focussing, as long as total distance from the rear element to the sensor is correct (the lens is just changing extension, and it doesn't matter what the ratio of extension from the lens and extension from the adapter is). The Canon TSE is not, though, unit focusing: it has some kind of internal focus, so I can easily see how you could end up with a curved field is
...Show more →

I see. Yes, perhaps the lenses I tried are not unit focusing. This behavior happens with all my TS-Es, 24-70L II and 16-35/4L lenses. (All using MF and checking the distance scale)
Dec 22, 2016 at 04:22 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.37 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
This is interesting...I've read the previous posts before, which triggered me to do some testing of various lenses on Canon (5DSR) and Sony (A7RII with Metabones IV adapter).

The Canon 17 t/s is very soft at distance (corners), at all apertures, when focused close. Focus far, stop down to f/8-11, and it's a huge improvement, and has very good DOF into the near foreground. However...this is the same on either the Canon or the Sony! I couldn't see a difference between them. I didn't check far focus away from corners, and perhaps there would be some difference there. I believe I saw the same results as the 17, to a lesser extent, on the 24 t/s, but I'd have to check my notes and test shots to refresh my memory.

The Zeiss 15/2.8 Distagon has somewhat similar behavior. On the 5DSR, it's also best focused at distance and stopped down. On the Sony, when focused close, distance is unacceptably soft regardless of aperture; focused far, it's much better, but still suffers in resolution compared to using it on the 5DSR. (The Voigtlander 15/4.5 beats it very slightly on the Sony, but the Zeiss is the clear winner when I compare shots from it using the Canon.) I noticed that infinity on the Sony is quite a bit before the hard stop, whereas it's at or very close to the hard stop on Canon.

I've tested Canon 16-35/4 on both cameras too. It also needs far focus for best overall results at the wide end, but again, I can see no difference between using it on Canon vs Sony.

Odd that differences seem all over the map from one user to another. I repeated the tests several times, always with the same result. Variance in Metabones, perhaps?

Edited on Dec 22, 2016 at 04:40 PM · View previous versions
Dec 22, 2016 at 04:38 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.37 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
alba63 wroteIf you shoot lots of architecture, then TSE would be the one, however my tests of this lens (24 TS-E II) yielded quite so...so results, as opposed to the Canon DSLR where it was a stellar lens.Might the the adapter solution, might be my sample, no idea.
It's the adapter. They differ in flange distance and that introduces unwanted field curvature. (That goes for any EF lens as well - not just TS-Es)
I have a Metabones and a Fotodiox adapter. The Metabones has the TS-E 17/4 infinity distance at around 3m and field curvature at infinity is very apparent even stepping the lens down. The Fotodiox on the other hand has infinity at the lens infinity mark and does not introduces any field curvature. You have to try a few adapters and see which one has the correct registry. This drove me nuts for a while.
I'm confused: how can the flange distance induce field curvature in the EF lenses that unit focus? Once you have focused the effective optical distance will be the same on any adapter that allows you to focus at that distance at all. If there are floating elements, of course, it's different...or am I missing something?
If the adapter gives imperfect flange distance, infinity focus will not be accurate in the lens. There may also be a severe field curvature effect depending on how off the adapter is.

I've tested this with numerous adapters and have two EF to E adapters that confirms my findings. One gives a very flat field for my EF and TS-E lenses (while giving the lens perfect infinity hard stop) and the other a very noticeable field curvature for all my lenses (center and edges are never in the same plane of field)

I don't know the technical explanation for this but it happens. It took me a while to realize this.

@MJKoski@@@ posted exactly what happens when using an adapter yielding an imprecise flange distance:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1464618/0#13836163
I'm not doubting your findings; I"m just puzzled what the explanation is for unit focussing lenses. Because infinity focus being off in the lens doesn't matter if the lens is unit focussing, as long as total distance from the rear element to the sensor is correct (the lens is just changing extension, and it doesn't matter what the ratio of extension from the lens and extension from the adapter is). The Canon TSE is not, though, unit focusing: it has some kind of internal focus, so I can easily see how you could end up with a curved field is the adapter is the wrong length (the elements will be in the wrong configuration for the focussed distance, if you are using the internal focus to compensate for incorrect flange distance.

But have you observed this behaviour (the field curvature) in any unit focussing lenses? I think the 50mm EF ones unit focus, for example. Of course even in the unit focussing lenses if the flange distance is off then the infinity mark will incorrect: but I don't see how this can matter in a unit focussing lens except as an inconvenience (or if the adapter is too long, in which case you won't be able to get infinity).
I see. Yes, perhaps the lenses I tried are not unit focusing. This behavior happens with all my TS-Es, 24-70L II and 16-35/4L lenses. (All using MF and checking the distance scale)


From what I can tell, all of those have FLEs.
Dec 22, 2016 at 04:38 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.37 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
This is interesting...I've read the previous posts before, which triggered me to do some testing of various lenses on Canon (5DSR) and Sony (A7RII with Metabones IV adapter).

The Canon 17 t/s is very soft at distance (corners), at all apertures, when focused close. Focus far, stop down to f/8-11, and it's a huge improvement, and has very good DOF into the near foreground. However...this is the same on either the Canon or the Sony! I couldn't see a difference between them. I didn't check far focus away from corners, and perhaps there would be some difference there. I believe I
...Show more →

The adapter brand (or even variability within a brand) will make a difference in your results. The best test is to see if the adapter lets you focus at infinity at the lens hard stop (in the case of Canon it's the infinity stop symbol -- see image). If you manual focus your subject at infinity distance and the marking on the lens shows less than infinity (like 3m for example), the adapter is not up to specs and will cause issues. Metabones is the worse I've tried.




Dec 22, 2016 at 05:04 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.37 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
alba63 wroteIf you shoot lots of architecture, then TSE would be the one, however my tests of this lens (24 TS-E II) yielded quite so...so results, as opposed to the Canon DSLR where it was a stellar lens.Might the the adapter solution, might be my sample, no idea.
It's the adapter. They differ in flange distance and that introduces unwanted field curvature. (That goes for any EF lens as well - not just TS-Es)
I have a Metabones and a Fotodiox adapter. The Metabones has the TS-E 17/4 infinity distance at around 3m and field curvature at infinity is very apparent even stepping the lens down. The Fotodiox on the other hand has infinity at the lens infinity mark and does not introduces any field curvature. You have to try a few adapters and see which one has the correct registry. This drove me nuts for a while.
I'm confused: how can the flange distance induce field curvature in the EF lenses that unit focus? Once you have focused the effective optical distance will be the same on any adapter that allows you to focus at that distance at all. If there are floating elements, of course, it's different...or am I missing something?
If the adapter gives imperfect flange distance, infinity focus will not be accurate in the lens. There may also be a severe field curvature effect depending on how off the adapter is.

I've tested this with numerous adapters and have two EF to E adapters that confirms my findings. One gives a very flat field for my EF and TS-E lenses (while giving the lens perfect infinity hard stop) and the other a very noticeable field curvature for all my lenses (center and edges are never in the same plane of field)

I don't know the technical explanation for this but it happens. It took me a while to realize this.

@MJKoski@@@ posted exactly what happens when using an adapter yielding an imprecise flange distance:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1464618/0#13836163
I'm not doubting your findings; I"m just puzzled what the explanation is for unit focussing lenses. Because infinity focus being off in the lens doesn't matter if the lens is unit focussing, as long as total distance from the rear element to the sensor is correct (the lens is just changing extension, and it doesn't matter what the ratio of extension from the lens and extension from the adapter is). The Canon TSE is not, though, unit focusing: it has some kind of internal focus, so I can easily see how you could end up with a curved field is the adapter is the wrong length (the elements will be in the wrong configuration for the focussed distance, if you are using the internal focus to compensate for incorrect flange distance.

But have you observed this behaviour (the field curvature) in any unit focussing lenses? I think the 50mm EF ones unit focus, for example. Of course even in the unit focussing lenses if the flange distance is off then the infinity mark will incorrect: but I don't see how this can matter in a unit focussing lens except as an inconvenience (or if the adapter is too long, in which case you won't be able to get infinity).
I see. Yes, perhaps the lenses I tried are not unit focusing. This behavior happens with all my TS-Es, 24-70L II and 16-35/4L lenses. (All using MF and checking the distance scale)


Yep; AFAIK all of those have at least some internal focus. Some modern lenses that extend when you focus *also* have some internal focus: I think the new Sony 2.8/50 macro is like that. It extends when you focus; but it doesn't extend enough to be unit focus to 1:1 so as far as I can tell it must be also doing some internal focus....
Dec 22, 2016 at 05:46 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.37 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
alba63 wrote
digital_AM wroteThe other lens I'm considering is the Canon 24 TSE.
If you shoot lots of architecture, then TSE would be the one, however my tests of this lens (24 TS-E II) yielded quite so...so results, as opposed to the Canon DSLR where it was a stellar lens.Might the the adapter solution, might be my sample, no idea.
It's the adapter. They differ in flange distance and that introduces unwanted field curvature. (That goes for any EF lens as well - not just TS-Es)
I have a Metabones and a Fotodiox adapter. The Metabones has the TS-E 17/4 infinity distance at around 3m and field curvature at infinity is very apparent even stepping the lens down. The Fotodiox on the other hand has infinity at the lens infinity mark and does not introduces any field curvature. You have to try a few adapters and see which one has the correct registry. This drove me nuts for a while.
I'm confused: how can the flange distance induce field curvature in the EF lenses that unit focus? Once you have focused the effective optical distance will be the same on any adapter that allows you to focus at that distance at all. If there are floating elements, of course, it's different...or am I missing something?
If the adapter gives imperfect flange distance, infinity focus will not be accurate in the lens. There may also be a severe field curvature effect depending on how off the adapter is.

I've tested this with numerous adapters and have two EF to E adapters that confirms my findings. One gives a very flat field for my EF and TS-E lenses (while giving the lens perfect infinity hard stop) and the other a very noticeable field curvature for all my lenses (center and edges are never in the same plane of field)

I don't know the technical explanation for this but
...Show more →

I second what Fred says here. I have the 17TSE, 24TSE II, 45TSE and 90TSE, as well as the Hartblei 65 Super Rotator and the Mamiya 645 35/3.5 on Kipon shift adapter, and the adapter makes a big difference. My favorite adapter for these lenses is the Sigma MC-11, which seems machined to proper tolerances. Otherwise, it is a crap-shoot how well these lenses focus on Fotodiox and Commlite -- some okay, but others with strong field curvature.

It isn't limited to field curvature on TSE type lenses -- seems to affect wide angle lenses with retro-focus designs most, including some zooms.

It's like the Wild West with lenses and adapters -- until you try them, you never know if its an outlaw or a settler!

From what I've read, it seems there is a good amount of unit variation in the Metabones, while the Sigma seems to be very consistent (as you might expect from a major lens manufacturer). Fotodiox seems pretty consistent too. The Commlite seems somewhat questionable, and doesn't work well with as many lenses in my stable when it comes to AF accuracy and speed. These are for EF mount, or other lenses with intermediate adapter to EF, such as Nikon, etc.
Dec 22, 2016 at 05:52 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.37 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
If you manual focus your subject at infinity distance and the marking on the lens shows less than infinity (like 3m for example), the adapter is not up to specs and will cause issues. Metabones is the worse I've tried.

Sounds just like my Metabones. I haven't tried any other adapters; I didn't know that one brand varies so much from another. (I figured on a little individual variation, but not brand-dependent.)
Dec 22, 2016 at 06:07 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.37 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Pretty much why I gave up on most adapters. I do have the TAP though
Dec 22, 2016 at 06:42 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.37 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
Pretty much why I gave up on most adapters. I do have the TAP though


Most lenses you use on TAP are unit focusing and have no floating element. So no adapter problem if it's straight.

An exception though is the ZM 1.4/35. It may pay to prefocus before using TAP not to get in range, but to be sure the floating element is in the right position. Using the OptoSigma it's *possible* that pre focussing to somewhere slightly out of focus before focusing with TAP would give best results: but if so I have no idea where! Something for hardy early adopters to find out!
Dec 22, 2016 at 06:52 PM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.37 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I noticed on my Novoflex Nikon to Sony adapter that the infinity position of my lenses has changed. On my Voigtlander 90mm on the D810 infinity was always at the hard stop; on my Novoflex it appears to be a little before the hard stop although still over the infinity symbol. On my Zeiss 50mm even on my D810 the hard stop was not accurate - you needed to pull it back a smidge - and on the Novoflex I had to pull it back a little further again.

I have not done proper extensive testing however a brick wall shot at 50mm looked OK without any obvious sign of field curvature.
Dec 22, 2016 at 07:20 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.37 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wrotePretty much why I gave up on most adapters. I do have the TAP though
Most lenses you use on TAP are unit focusing and have no floating element. So no adapter problem if it's straight.

An exception though is the ZM 1.4/35. It may pay to prefocus before using TAP not to get in range, but to be sure the floating element is in the right position. Using the OptoSigma it's *possible* that pre focussing to somewhere slightly out of focus before focusing with TAP would give best results: but if so I have no idea where! Something for hardy early adopters to find out!


Exactly David , we willl see where we are on that wth the filter. I had my issues with Metabones and it got to be annoying playing that game. The TAP for me is a bonus it does not stop me from shooting like a metabones would. I carry a spare M to E adapter anyway if all fails.
Dec 22, 2016 at 07:47 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.37 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
If you using M mount, the Voigtlander VM/E Close Focus Adapter was great. I found with lenses like the 35 Lux FLE which was excellent on the A7rII you could vary the curvature marginally by changing the infinity stop to suit.

Of course having TAP has resolved a lot these issues
Dec 22, 2016 at 07:56 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.37 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
We totally derailed this thread.
Someone please, post some Loxia 85 images. Fast!
Dec 22, 2016 at 08:10 PM
rji2goleez
Offline
Details
p.37 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
We totally derailed this thread.
Someone please, post some Loxia 85 images. Fast!


If Zeiss would only deliver, I would be happy to oblige . . .
Dec 22, 2016 at 08:26 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.37 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I wonder what's holding up the shipments. I've had e-mails from every European and Canadian dealer I've worked with letting me know they'll sell the lens for the US price or less with free expedited shipping. Are we low priority for the Loxias?
Dec 22, 2016 at 08:47 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.37 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Like little kids waiting for Santa to deliver. And you thought that went away.
Dec 22, 2016 at 09:00 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.37 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I'm not waiting for one. I'm just hoping we haven't found ourselves on Zeiss' sh*t list for whatever reason.
Dec 22, 2016 at 09:18 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.37 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Me either at least for now. Want to see some tests
Dec 22, 2016 at 09:28 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.37 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Hopefully they won't be made of coal lumps when we finally get them.
Dec 22, 2016 at 09:49 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister