I was in a Berlin store today and asked the salesman there to show me both the Batis and the Loxia (85). He looked at me as if I had asked a quite absurd question - he thought (what many reviews say) that the Loxia is too heavy, not very fast and therefore way too expensive. I nevertheless asked him to let me shoot with both on my a7rII. I went outside and snapped 2 dozens of shots with each. After a while I thought he is really right, Batis also very good + AF + almost 1 stop faster + cheaper + slightly lighter.
I checked the images at home, here is what I saw - first Batis:
1. Batis is very good in the center, but not that great in the outer third.
2. Despite the stabilizer I had several shots (with the Batis) with camera shake or OOF.
3. As said by others, the distortion in the Batis is quite high (3%), luckily switchable on and off with LR - obviously compromises sharpness further.
Then the Loxia:
Eehhh....
Wow!!!
I mean - wow.
1. Almost every single shot exactly in focus, and where is that Batis veil gone (I hadn't noticed was there before)?
2. So evenly sharp over the frame.
3. That is - wait - oh! @ f2.4!!
Now light was already at dawn, therefore crappy, and yet, that should have - if anything - played in favor of the AF & stabilized Batis. Except that it didn't. I am sure the Batis with some practice (better to always know well your equipment) can yield very good results too, in the Lloyd Chambers review they were pretty close, maybe there is more sample variation?
But that Loxia is something else... An understatement lens at first sight, but an amazing over- performer at second.
My conclusion: I personally would judge the Batis as a bit too expensive for what it is, the Loxia is expensive, but seems to offer exceptional (!) performance at all apertures. I have never seen anything that performs like that lens...
Sorry for my highly enthousiast quick and dirty review - I am rarely impressed by a lens. Here I was!
Will attach sample photo or crop later...
alba63 wrote:
I was in a Berlin store today and asked the salesman there to show me both the Batis and the Loxia (85). He looked at me as if I had asked a quite absurd question - he thought (what many reviews say) that the Loxia is too heavy, not very fast and therefore way too expensive. I nevertheless asked him to let me shoot with both on my a7rII. I went outside and snapped 2 dozens of shots with each. After a while I thought he is really right, Batis also very good + AF + almost 1 stop faster + cheaper + slightly lighter.
I checked the images at home, here is what I saw - first Batis:
1. Batis is very good in the center, but not that great in the outer third.
2. Despite the stabilizer I had several shots (with the Batis) with camera shake or OOF.
3. As said by others, the distortion in the Batis is quite high (3%), luckily switchable on and off with LR - obviously compromises sharpness further.
Then the Loxia:
Eehhh....
Wow!!!
I mean - wow.
1. Almost every single shot exactly in focus, and where is that Batis veil gone (I didn't notice first was there)?
2. So evenly sharp over the frame.
3. That is - wait - oh! @ f2.4!!
Now light was already at dawn, therefore crappy, and yet, that should have - if anything - played in favor of the AF- stabilized Batis. Except that it didn't. I am sure the Batis with some practice (better to always know well your equipment) can yield very good results too, in the Lloyd Chambers review they were pretty close, maybe there is more sample variation?
But that Loxia is something else... An understatement lens at first sight, but an over- performer at second.
My conclusion: I personally would judge the Batis as a bit too expensive for what it is, the Loxia is expensive, but seems to offer exceptional (!) performance at all apertures. I have never seen anything that performs like that lens...
Sorry for my highly enthousiast quick and dirty review - I am rarely impressed by a lens. Here I was!
Will attach sample photo or crop later......Show more →
jhinkey wrote: alba63 wroteI was in a Berlin store today and asked the salesman there to show me both the Batis and the Loxia (85). He looked at me as if I had asked a quite absurd question - he thought (what many reviews say) that the Loxia is too heavy, not very fast and therefore way too expensive. I nevertheless asked him to let me shoot with both on my a7rII. I went outside and snapped 2 dozens of shots with each. After a while I thought he is really right, Batis also very good + AF + almost 1 stop faster + cheaper + slightly lighter.
I checked the images at home, here is what I saw - first Batis:
1. Batis is very good in the center, but not that great in the outer third.
2. Despite the stabilizer I had several shots (with the Batis) with camera shake or OOF.
3. As said by others, the distortion in the Batis is quite high (3%), luckily switchable on and off with LR - obviously compromises sharpness further.
Then the Loxia:
Eehhh....
Wow!!!
I mean - wow.
1. Almost every single shot exactly in focus, and where is that Batis veil gone (I didn't notice first was there)?
2. So evenly sharp over the frame.
3. That is - wait - oh! @ f2.4!!
Now light was already at dawn, therefore crappy, and yet, that should have - if anything - played in favor of the AF- stabilized Batis. Except that it didn't. I am sure the Batis with some practice (better to always know well your equipment) can yield very good results too, in the Lloyd Chambers review they were pretty close, maybe there is more sample variation?
But that Loxia is something else... An understatement lens at first sight, but an over- performer at second.
My conclusion: I personally would judge the Batis as a bit too expensive for what it is, the Loxia is expensive, but seems to offer exceptional (!) performance at all apertures. I have never seen anything that performs like that lens...
Sorry for my highly enthousiast quick and dirty review - I am rarely impressed by a lens. Here I was!
Will attach sample photo or crop later...That's not helping my bank account
The local pro shop has no idea when they'll even get a display model in let alone stock.
Have a bunch of gear piled up to potentially trade in on this baby!
Fred Miranda wrote: GMPhotography wroteI better pick up knitting my ski mask in time. ðŸ˜As great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.
I couldn't wait anymore so I got a ... Zeiss 135 f2 Apo Sonar instead of it. I wish we had a comparabale native 135 for the FE mount (for weight and cost reasons), since I personally prefer it over the 85, but the big bulky 135 Apo Sonnar can capture images now so that's all that matters. I hope the trade off will be worth it - higher cost, greater weight vs better IQ and more useful FL.
Fred Miranda wrote:
As great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.
Yes I'm not sure either; I'm guessing from the MTF that's it's a little better than the ZM; but the ZM is so good at what it does that a little better is probably not worth it (and maybe not visible in quite large prints) for the extra weight as a hiking and landscape lens. And the extra speed is nice; but then for portraits most of us use a GM or Batis or something with a red dot on TAP. So it could be a compromise one lens does everything option without the speed and AF of our portrait lenses, or the compactness of the ZM. Or it could be a fourth short tele for most of us (Fast AF, Macro, Hiking landscape, then this!
So I'll need to be amazed at the image level to either get an nth short tele, or replace the ZM and take one lens fewer on hikes to make up the weight.
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteAs great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.Yes I'm not sure either; I'm guessing from the MTF that's it's a little better than the ZM; but the ZM is so good at what it does that a little better is probably not worth it (and maybe not visible in quite large prints) for the extra weight as a hiking and landscape lens. And the extra speed is nice; but then for portraits most of us use a GM or Batis or something with a red dot on TAP. So it could be a compromise one lens does everything option without the speed and AF of our portrait lenses, or the compactness of the ZM. Or it could be a fourth short tele for most of us (Fast AF, Macro, Hiking landscape, then this!
So I'll need to be amazed at the image level to either get an nth short tele, or replace the ZM and take one lens fewer on hikes to make up the weight....Show more →
That's how I see it as well. The ZM 85 is my landscape lens and for everything else including portraits the GM 85 is my go-to lens. I can't see myself replacing the GM for the Loxia as I prefer AF and the faster speed for these applications.
So, for landscapes, the new Loxia 85/2.4 has to be way better than the ZM 85 at f/5.6 and f/8 for me to make the switch.
So down here is a link to the central 12MP crop (100% size) of a file I made today wide open, at ISO2500 befor the camera store. This kind of clarity is quite impressive to me. I don't know the ZM85/4.
However as my budget for lenses etc for this year is already exhausted, I went for a Contax 85/2,8 for the time being that I found on Ebay for a fraction of the price of a Loxia 85. If I am not happy with it, I will probably get nervous again -
Here is the link that hopefully doesn't embed the pic directly... (too big)
I think at 5.6 and F8 you will not see a advantage maybe even at F4. Obviously at 2.4 it will have the advantage. For me if it beats the ZM at 5.6 and a big if than I'll get the Loxia. I'll buy a third ZM if it don't
For me wide open I'll grab the GM at 1.7 to 2.8 it's brilliant
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteAs great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.Yes I'm not sure either; I'm guessing from the MTF that's it's a little better than the ZM; but the ZM is so good at what it does that a little better is probably not worth it (and maybe not visible in quite large prints) for the extra weight as a hiking and landscape lens. And the extra speed is nice; but then for portraits most of us use a GM or Batis or something with a red dot on TAP. So it could be a compromise one lens does everything option without the speed and AF of our portrait lenses, or the compactness of the ZM. Or it could be a fourth short tele for most of us (Fast AF, Macro, Hiking landscape, then this!
So I'll need to be amazed at the image level to either get an nth short tele, or replace the ZM and take one lens fewer on hikes to make up the weight.That's how I see it as well. The ZM 85 is my landscape lens and for everything else including portraits the GM 85 is my go-to lens. I can't see myself replacing the GM for the Loxia as I prefer AF and the faster speed for these applications.
So, for landscapes, the new Loxia 85/2.4 has to be way better than the ZM 85 at f/5.6 and f/8 for me to make the switch.
GMPhotography wrote:
I think at 5.6 and F8 you will not see a advantage maybe even at F4. Obviously at 2.4 it will have the advantage. For me if it beats the ZM at 5.6 and a big if than I'll get the Loxia. I'll buy a third ZM if it don't
For me wide open I'll grab the GM at 1.7 to 2.8 it's brilliant
Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteAs great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.Yes I'm not sure either; I'm guessing from the MTF that's it's a little better than the ZM; but the ZM is so good at what it does that a little better is probably not worth it (and maybe not visible in quite large prints) for the extra weight as a hiking and landscape lens. And the extra speed is nice; but then for portraits most of us use a GM or Batis or something with a red dot on TAP. So it could be a compromise one lens does everything option without the speed and AF of our portrait lenses, or the compactness of the ZM. Or it could be a fourth short tele for most of us (Fast AF, Macro, Hiking landscape, then this!
So I'll need to be amazed at the image level to either get an nth short tele, or replace the ZM and take one lens fewer on hikes to make up the weight.That's how I see it as well. The ZM 85 is my landscape lens and for everything else including portraits the GM 85 is my go-to lens. I can't see myself replacing the GM for the Loxia as I prefer AF and the faster speed for these applications.
So, for landscapes, the new Loxia 85/2.4 has to be way better than the ZM 85 at f/5.6 and f/8 for me to make the switch.
Guy when you say you'll get the Lox if it beats the ZM at f5.6 do you mean if it beats it just visibly in 100% crops (I think it will, just, from the the MTF) or will you need it to significantly (visible in a big but not wall covering print) beat it?
One of my personal tests on a 42MP sensor for a *resolution* difference (other differences matter of course) that is 'worth it' is visible at 50% without any humming an hawing (you know, "*maybe* A is better than B") and instantly striking at 100%.
That's not to say that GAS hasn't caused me sometimes to buy things because they are better but don't pass my "worth it" test....
Here is the thing the darn ZM is so nice today and even beats the GM 85 and I love the ZM so for me it needs to beat it's pants off the ZM. If it's slightly better I'm not so sure I want bigger , heavier and more cost at a slight advantage. I was very happy with the ZM 85 it just got caught up in being a selling chip for other glass. I'm not embarrassed to say I would buy it for the third time either. I'm a lens whore with a lot of GAS.
DavidBM wrote: GMPhotography wroteI think at 5.6 and F8 you will not see a advantage maybe even at F4. Obviously at 2.4 it will have the advantage. For me if it beats the ZM at 5.6 and a big if than I'll get the Loxia. I'll buy a third ZM if it don't
For me wide open I'll grab the GM at 1.7 to 2.8 it's brilliant
Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteAs great as the Loxia 85 looks, I'm not yet convinced it will replace my ZM 85.Yes I'm not sure either; I'm guessing from the MTF that's it's a little better than the ZM; but the ZM is so good at what it does that a little better is probably not worth it (and maybe not visible in quite large prints) for the extra weight as a hiking and landscape lens. And the extra speed is nice; but then for portraits most of us use a GM or Batis or something with a red dot on TAP. So it could be a compromise one lens does everything option without the speed and AF of our portrait lenses, or the compactness of the ZM. Or it could be a fourth short tele for most of us (Fast AF, Macro, Hiking landscape, then this!
So I'll need to be amazed at the image level to either get an nth short tele, or replace the ZM and take one lens fewer on hikes to make up the weight.That's how I see it as well. The ZM 85 is my landscape lens and for everything else including portraits the GM 85 is my go-to lens. I can't see myself replacing the GM for the Loxia as I prefer AF and the faster speed for these applications.
So, for landscapes, the new Loxia 85/2.4 has to be way better than the ZM 85 at f/5.6 and f/8 for me to make the switch.Guy when you say you'll get the Lox if it beats the ZM at f5.6 do you mean if it beats it just visibly in 100% crops (I think it will, just, from the the MTF) or will you need it to significantly (visible in a big but not wall covering print) beat it?
One of my personal tests on a 42MP sensor for a *resolution* difference (other differences matter of course) that is 'worth it' is visible at 50% without any humming an hawing (you know, "*maybe* A is better than B") and instantly striking at 100%.
That's not to say that GAS hasn't caused me sometimes to buy things because they are better but don't pass my "worth it" test....
GMPhotography wrote:
I still have to buy a 18mm so I'm being really careful on another 85
Yup fair enough! I would have said Batis; but I wonder how the ZM f4 compares with a correction filter? I had written it off but now we might have solutions for rangefinder lenses....