Luvwine wrote: Steve Spencer wroteBastianK wroteGMPhotography wroteIf there was a FE 135mm f2 AF I would sell the GM 85 and have the Loxia 85 as my choice. That would be a better fit for a lot of folks I would think.Funny thing you say that. I am using the Canon EF 135mm 2.0L via Sigma MC-11 and also think it suits me better than an 85mm 1.4.
I actually thought as soon as the Loxia arrives I will immediatley sell my Leica Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asph,
after having done the comparison I am not so sure anymore...
Regarding Bokeh I will also do a comparison against the Jupiter-9 85mm 2.0, which is also a Sonnar design,
and another comparison with the Summicron pre-Asph where the subject size is kept constant, not the camera position.
But to be honest, I don't think this lens will appeal to as many as the 21mm.
In 85mm land there is much competition, the Batis has AF, is lighter and faster and
for the price of a new Loxia 85 you might even find a GM 85mm 1.4 on the used market.Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian. It looks good with some interesting character, but I would prefer less of the cat's eye shapes. For me I really don't need another 85/90. I have the 85 Milvus, the 85 Batis, the Leica M 90 f/2 AA, the Leica R 80 f/1.4, and the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro, so where would this fit in? I have a great modern portrait lens (the Milvus). I have a great AF portrait lens (the Batis 85). I have a great character portrait lens (the 80 lux). I have a great landscape lens (the 90 cron AA), and I have a great portable lens that also does nice landscapes and macro too (the 90 elmar macro). Still this lens is interesting to me in that it has what looks like an interesting dual character. At f/2.4 and f/2.8 it looks to be a quite decent portrait lens and that is fast enough for me (look at micro 4/3rds shooters as an example and how they lust over the 42.5 Nocitron--this lens will have very similar depth of field at f/2.4). It also looks like a fantastic landscape lens stopped down. So, it is much more portable than the Milvus. I am pretty sure it will beat the Batis for landscapes and it won't be too much worse for portraits the way I shoot. It won't have the character of the the 80 lux, but it will be cleaner (i.e., fewer aberrations) and a bit better stopped down, and a bit smaller and lighter. It will be way better for portraits and probably a bit better for landscapes than the 90 elmar macro. The big question for me is whether it will be better than the 90 cron AA at anything. It is a bit heavier and bigger. It may, however, be better at portraits even though the 90 cron AA is just a bit longer and faster. The loxia might have better bokeh, although I think the bokeh of the 90 cron AA is much better than its reputation. My guess is it will be close with slightly different character for the two lenses. I will be interested in that comparison. It might be better than the 90 cron AA for landscapes too, but the 90 cron AA is amazingly sharp across the frame with excellent micro contrast, and almost no coma or CA. The Loxia looks really good from f/4, however, and it definitely has better sunstars (although the 90 elmar macro competes well there). From the examples I expect the 90 cron AA to be better wider than f/4, but from that point on the Loxia will be a great competitor.
So, all that is to say I think it can have a place in my bag despite my large collection of 85/90s. When I want a versatile 3 lens kit with a similar look, great performance and still compact, I think the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 85 will work very well together. This kit would allow decent portraits, excellent landscapes performance, and very good fairly close in performance. All with a very Zeiss look. I also will use the lens for video. Yes, 85/90mm is crowded especially in my bag, but I think this looks like a very nice option to fill an interesting niche. I have had my pre-order in for awhile and I won't cancel it, but if it doesn't compete well with the 90 cron AA for portraits and it doesn't best the 90 elmar macro for landscapes then I will probably return it.I have some dough in my PayPal account so I preordered one. I do also have the 90/AA. If it beats the Leica, I will sell the Leica as I like that it shares a filter thread with the other two Loxia lenses I own. The flip side is that the Leica works with the TAP and is a bit lighter, smaller, and faster. Tough choice. We will see.
When I get my Loxia I will try to do a shootout with my other 85/90s and I will pay particularly close attention to the comparison of the Loxia to the 90 AA. For me these lenses hit a sweet spot in performance and size, but I am not sure I need both, but I think I want both. These are difficult decisions indeed.
The Loxia looks very nice so far. To me it has some nice punch to it and acutity and right now looks cleaner than the Batis as far as aberrations. Am I seeing some fringing in the Batis.
GMPhotography wrote:
The Loxia looks very nice so far. To me it has some nice punch to it and acutity and right now looks cleaner than the Batis as far as aberrations. Am I seeing some fringing in the Batis.
I agree, at f/2.4 the Loxia looks a bit cleaner than the Batis at f/2.5, when looking at Renee's images. I can see ever so slight purple fringes even in the Loxia at f/2.4 in the 100% crops of the fence, yet it appears cleaner than the Batis, in the images of the fence.
In the landscape shots the Loxia looks to have bit more saturated colours at f/2.4 than the Batis at f/2.5. At f/4 I'm hard pressed to see a difference between the two, so I think the experts here will have to judge the comparison at f/4.
BastianK wrote: Fred Miranda wroteBastian,
Thanks for your objective review!
It was a good move to add the "same size of subject" bokeh test. Seems to be the fair approach and bokeh looks just as expected.Thanks Fred!
PS: I still have to get my hands on the ZM 35mm 1.4 and compare it to my Loxia 35mm 2.0...
Bastian,
I've managed to get superb copies of both lenses (Loxia 35/2 and Zeiss 35/1.4 ZM). Here is how they compare at infinity distances (Extreme edges, Mid-field and Center)
xwing15 wrote:
And for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8
Thanks for the samples xwing15!
After equalizing exposure (one shot was 1/3 over and the other 2/3), they look VERY similar at long distance f/2.5 (I consider that more mid-field than extreme edge though). At f/4, the Loxia pulls ahead showing more resolution.
I give the edge to the Loxia for the close distance sample but we need to be sure focus was identical.
As far as LoCA they are also very similar from your samples with the Loxia performing only slightly better.
Fred Miranda wrote: xwing15 wroteAnd for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8Thanks for the samples xwing15!
After equalizing exposure (one shot was 1/3 over and the other 2/3), they look VERY similar at long distance f/2.5 (I consider that more mid-field than extreme edge though). At f/4, the Loxia pulls ahead showing more resolution.
I give the edge to the Loxia for the close distance sample but we need to be sure focus was identical.
As far as LoCA they are also very similar from your samples with the Loxia performing slightly better.
Thanks Fred. Focus was also made with the Batis manuel. Should be correct. And your observations I would sign.
But as I said, I am far away from a lab student.
Fred Miranda wrote:
I've managed to get superb copies of both lenses (Loxia 35/2 and Zeiss 35/1.4 ZM). Here is how they compare at infinity distances (Extreme edges, Mid-field and Center)
Thanks, I already came across that one. I am just not so sure about Bokeh yet.
The Loxia is definetly not great here, but I have seen a few samples (here) where the ZM didn't really shine as well.
Bokeh would pretty much be the only reason to switch for me, as I am quite happy with the 35 Loxia stopped down for landscape and architecture.
Steve Spencer wrote:
When I get my Loxia I will try to do a shootout with my other 85/90s and I will pay particularly close attention to the comparison of the Loxia to the 90 AA. For me these lenses hit a sweet spot in performance and size, but I am not sure I need both, but I think I want both. These are difficult decisions indeed.
I am sure interested in the comparison to the 90 AA.
Edit:
I just forgot, is hard infinity stop working on your samples wide open? On mine it isn't. Contrary to my 35 and 21.
klasGelinder wrote:
Here is a comparison taken at f4 of the Otus, Leica Elmarit and Loxia. Looking at the building furthest back the Loxia looks pretty good.
Fred Miranda wrote: klasGelinder wroteHere is a comparison taken at f4 of the Otus, Leica Elmarit and Loxia. Looking at the building furthest back the Loxia looks pretty good.
From this test, the new Loxia did noticeably better than the Otus all over the frame and way better than the Elmarit towards the edges.
I felt the Otus and Loxia were pretty close, but the case for the Otus just got tougher. You can get the Loxia, Milvus, and Batis 85s--all of them together--for less than the price of the Otus and those other three Zeiss lenses are all pretty fantastic. At 85mm I went with the strategy of several lenses instead of the Otus super lens, so I might be biased, but I think there are so many good 85/90s that it is hard to go with just one, even one as good as the Otus.
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteklasGelinder wroteHere is a comparison taken at f4 of the Otus, Leica Elmarit and Loxia. Looking at the building furthest back the Loxia looks pretty good.
From this test, the new Loxia did noticeably better than the Otus all over the frame and way better than the Elmarit towards the edges.I felt the Otus and Loxia were pretty close, but the case for the Otus just got tougher. You can get the Loxia, Milvus, and Batis 85s--all of them--for less than the price of the Otus and those other three Zeiss lenses are all pretty fantastic. At 85mm I went with the strategy of several lenses instead of the Otus super lens, so I might be biased, but I think there are so many good 85/90s that it is hard to go with just one, even one as good as the Otus.
To me the Otus still excels in areas outside resolution/contrast like aberration and flare control.
However, the Loxia does not have aspherical elements which will surely translates to cleaner bokeh balls...and let's not forget the 10-blade aperture sweet sunstars..
We have so many great options right now!
Fred Miranda wrote:
These Imatest results tells us the new Loxia is also great at close distances.
My observation as well, stellar sharpness even at MFD. The Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asp struggles here a lot and is very soft wide open (much better at f/2.8 though).
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteklasGelinder wroteHere is a comparison taken at f4 of the Otus, Leica Elmarit and Loxia. Looking at the building furthest back the Loxia looks pretty good.
From this test, the new Loxia did noticeably better than the Otus all over the frame and way better than the Elmarit towards the edges.I felt the Otus and Loxia were pretty close, but the case for the Otus just got tougher. You can get the Loxia, Milvus, and Batis 85s--all of them--for less than the price of the Otus and those other three Zeiss lenses are all pretty fantastic. At 85mm I went with the strategy of several lenses instead of the Otus super lens, so I might be biased, but I think there are so many good 85/90s that it is hard to go with just one, even one as good as the Otus.To me the Otus still excels in areas outside resolution/contrast like aberration and flare control.
However, the Loxia does not have aspherical elements which will surely translates to cleaner bokeh balls...and let's not forget the 10-blade aperture sweet sunstars..
We have so many great options right now!
How it behaves when pointed into the sun is what I'm interested in and what kind of sun stars it makes (with the sun or lights at night) - these are the only real weaknesses of the 85/4 ZM (besides no CPU), though at that price for the Loxia it better be absolutely stellar in these two areas for that kind of price jump.
I got an excellent deal on my 85/4ZM so perhaps I should wait to find someone with buyers remorse on the 85/2.4 Loxia to try to get a good deal. This happens every once in a while at the local Pro shop - I'll find a very expensive lens for a really good price because someone traded it in after hardly using it. May have to wait quite a while for this to happen with the 85/2.4 though . . .