fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
Fred any timeline when your 85 shows up


Hopefully sometime in December...I may not be in the first batch of pre-orders depending on demand.
I took too long to pull the trigger on this one.
Nov 19, 2016 at 03:58 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.24 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
My ZM 85f4 is on its way to Fred. Now one wonders if I'll be buying a third one. Actually this maybe a new record. Fred bought both of mine.

Crazy

But seriously this is a great comparison between the two. Anyone wanna bet donuts here


Well, I'm about to put my ZM 85/4 on the Buy-Sell board...
Nov 19, 2016 at 08:44 PM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.24 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
BastianK wrote:
GMPhotography wroteIf there was a FE 135mm f2 AF I would sell the GM 85 and have the Loxia 85 as my choice. That would be a better fit for a lot of folks I would think.
Funny thing you say that. I am using the Canon EF 135mm 2.0L via Sigma MC-11 and also think it suits me better than an 85mm 1.4.

I actually thought as soon as the Loxia arrives I will immediatley sell my Leica Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asph,
after having done the comparison I am not so sure anymore...

Two very different lenses, the strength of one is the weakness of the other.
For some shots I love the color rendition of the Summicron, but it is also the reason I tend to avoid it when shooting events or weddings, as it does not match my
...Show more →

Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian. It looks good with some interesting character, but I would prefer less of the cat's eye shapes. For me I really don't need another 85/90. I have the 85 Milvus, the 85 Batis, the Leica M 90 f/2 AA, the Leica R 80 f/1.4, and the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro, so where would this fit in? I have a great modern portrait lens (the Milvus). I have a great AF portrait lens (the Batis 85). I have a great character portrait lens (the 80 lux). I have a great landscape lens (the 90 cron AA), and I have a great portable lens that also does nice landscapes and macro too (the 90 elmar macro). Still this lens is interesting to me in that it has what looks like an interesting dual character. At f/2.4 and f/2.8 it looks to be a quite decent portrait lens and that is fast enough for me (look at micro 4/3rds shooters as an example and how they lust over the 42.5 Nocitron--this lens will have very similar depth of field at f/2.4). It also looks like a fantastic landscape lens stopped down. So, it is much more portable than the Milvus. I am pretty sure it will beat the Batis for landscapes and it won't be too much worse for portraits the way I shoot. It won't have the character of the the 80 lux, but it will be cleaner (i.e., fewer aberrations) and a bit better stopped down, and a bit smaller and lighter. It will be way better for portraits and probably a bit better for landscapes than the 90 elmar macro. The big question for me is whether it will be better than the 90 cron AA at anything. It is a bit heavier and bigger. It may, however, be better at portraits even though the 90 cron AA is just a bit longer and faster. The loxia might have better bokeh, although I think the bokeh of the 90 cron AA is much better than its reputation. My guess is it will be close with slightly different character for the two lenses. I will be interested in that comparison. It might be better than the 90 cron AA for landscapes too, but the 90 cron AA is amazingly sharp across the frame with excellent micro contrast, and almost no coma or CA. The Loxia looks really good from f/4, however, and it definitely has better sunstars (although the 90 elmar macro competes well there). From the examples I expect the 90 cron AA to be better wider than f/4, but from that point on the Loxia will be a great competitor.
So, all that is to say I think it can have a place in my bag despite my large collection of 85/90s. When I want a versatile 3 lens kit with a similar look, great performance and still compact, I think the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 85 will work very well together. This kit would allow decent portraits, excellent landscapes performance, and very good fairly close in performance. All with a very Zeiss look. I also will use the lens for video. Yes, 85/90mm is crowded especially in my bag, but I think this looks like a very nice option to fill an interesting niche. I have had my pre-order in for awhile and I won't cancel it, but if it doesn't compete well with the 90 cron AA for portraits and it doesn't best the 90 elmar macro for landscapes then I will probably return it.
Nov 19, 2016 at 08:55 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.24 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
BastianK wrote
GMPhotography wroteIf there was a FE 135mm f2 AF I would sell the GM 85 and have the Loxia 85 as my choice. That would be a better fit for a lot of folks I would think.
Funny thing you say that. I am using the Canon EF 135mm 2.0L via Sigma MC-11 and also think it suits me better than an 85mm 1.4.

I actually thought as soon as the Loxia arrives I will immediatley sell my Leica Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asph,
after having done the comparison I am not so sure anymore...

Two very different lenses, the strength of one is the weakness of the other.
For some shots I love the color rendition of the Summicron, but it is also the reason I tend to avoid it when shooting events or weddings, as it does not match my other lenses in this regard.
Loxia produces wonderful sunstars, Leica not so much.
Corner to corner sharpness and sharpness near MFD the Loxia wins hands down.
Even at f/2.4 I can easily produce moiré on the border of the frame on the A7rII's 42mp with the Loxia

Regarding Bokeh I will also do a comparison against the Jupiter-9 85mm 2.0, which is also a Sonnar design,
and another comparison with the Summicron pre-Asph where the subject size is kept constant, not the camera position.

But to be honest, I don't think this lens will appeal to as many as the 21mm.
In 85mm land there is much competition, the Batis has AF, is lighter and faster and
for the price of a new Loxia 85 you might even find a GM 85mm 1.4 on the used market.
Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian. It looks good with some interesting character, but I would prefer less of the cat's eye shapes. For me I really don't need another 85/90. I have the 85 Milvus, the 85 Batis, the Leica M 90 f/2 AA, the Leica R 80 f/1.4, and the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro, so where would this fit in? I have a great modern portrait lens (the Milvus). I have a great AF portrait lens (the Batis 85). I have a great character portrait lens (the 80 lux). I have a great landscape lens (the
...Show more →

I have some dough in my PayPal account so I preordered one. I do also have the 90/AA. If it beats the Leica, I will sell the Leica as I like that it shares a filter thread with the other two Loxia lenses I own. The flip side is that the Leica works with the TAP and is a bit lighter, smaller, and faster. Tough choice. We will see.
Nov 19, 2016 at 09:09 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
BastianK wrote
GMPhotography wroteIf there was a FE 135mm f2 AF I would sell the GM 85 and have the Loxia 85 as my choice. That would be a better fit for a lot of folks I would think.
Funny thing you say that. I am using the Canon EF 135mm 2.0L via Sigma MC-11 and also think it suits me better than an 85mm 1.4.

I actually thought as soon as the Loxia arrives I will immediatley sell my Leica Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asph,
after having done the comparison I am not so sure anymore...

Two very different lenses, the strength of one is the weakness of the other.
For some shots I love the color rendition of the Summicron, but it is also the reason I tend to avoid it when shooting events or weddings, as it does not match my other lenses in this regard.
Loxia produces wonderful sunstars, Leica not so much.
Corner to corner sharpness and sharpness near MFD the Loxia wins hands down.
Even at f/2.4 I can easily produce moiré on the border of the frame on the A7rII's 42mp with the Loxia

Regarding Bokeh I will also do a comparison against the Jupiter-9 85mm 2.0, which is also a Sonnar design,
and another comparison with the Summicron pre-Asph where the subject size is kept constant, not the camera position.

But to be honest, I don't think this lens will appeal to as many as the 21mm.
In 85mm land there is much competition, the Batis has AF, is lighter and faster and
for the price of a new Loxia 85 you might even find a GM 85mm 1.4 on the used market.
Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian. It looks good with some interesting character, but I would prefer less of the cat's eye shapes. For me I really don't need another 85/90. I have the 85 Milvus, the 85 Batis, the Leica M 90 f/2 AA, the Leica R 80 f/1.4, and the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro, so where would this fit in? I have a great modern portrait lens (the Milvus). I have a great AF portrait lens (the Batis 85). I have a great character portrait lens (the 80 lux). I have a great landscape lens (the
...Show more →

Steve, I've tested the Batis 85/1.8 at infinity distances and it's very good at f/5.6 but worse than the Zeiss 85/4 ZM and even more so than the 90 cron AA. From the lenses I tested for landscapes, I would rate resolution/contrast in this order:

1) 90 cron AA
2) Zeiss 85/4 ZM
3) Sony 85/1.4GM
4) Batis 85/1.8

The new Loxia has the potential to be the very best of the bunch at f/4 and f/5.6. From the MTF graph, I suspect it will do better than the 85/4ZM wide-open and at f/5.6 and at these apertures, it could potentially dethrone the Leica.

I was not a fan of the Leica bokeh at close distances and I understand this is very subjective. I saw too much onion ring, outlining "structures" and as Bastian pointed out “crown cork” shaped balls between f2.8 and f8.

I'm hoping the new Loxia 85/2.4 will have a much cleaner bokeh and from the initial reviews, it's looking good.
Nov 19, 2016 at 09:19 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.24 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Geez I got one 85 and feeling like a chump. Lol

Really be interesting to see some of these comparisons. This is a really crowded focal length . I'll get the Loxia at least that is my plan in the New Year but I want to see those comparisons and honestly my ZM 85 was not something I really wanted to sell. I like that lens a lot
Nov 19, 2016 at 09:20 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve, you must be the king of 85/90 lenses I guess I won't feel too guilty about getting a second 85mm! I do have a Canon t/s 90 too, but that's more of a specialty thing.

I'm mainly getting the Loxia 85 in the interest of cutting down the bag weight for longer walks/hikes. The overly heavy bag got old fast this year. I've slimmed it down nicely to 10 Voigt, 15 Voigt, 21 Loxia, 28/2 ZE, 35 Loxia, 50 Loxia, 85 Otus (Loxia to be substituted when it arrives), A7RII body, and A7R infrared body with Canon 16-35/4. A wide variety with reasonable weight in a midsized shoulder bag (about 12 pounds, I think, which is featherweight compared to all the large format stuff I used to lug), and when the 85 Loxia comes, that will give me a slot to add one lens of my choice, as appropriate for what I'm doing. So, I can add the 100 makro-planar, or the 24 t/s, or the 135/2 ZE, depending on the situation, and weight will still be reasonable. If I'm close to the car or have a specific need, then I can pull out the heavier, faster ZE lenses as needed.
Nov 19, 2016 at 10:30 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.24 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
Steve, you must be the king of 85/90 lenses I guess I won't feel too guilty about getting a second 85mm! I do have a Canon t/s 90 too, but that's more of a specialty thing.

I'm mainly getting the Loxia 85 in the interest of cutting down the bag weight for longer walks/hikes. The overly heavy bag got old fast this year. I've slimmed it down nicely to 10 Voigt, 15 Voigt, 21 Loxia, 28/2 ZE, 35 Loxia, 50 Loxia, 85 Otus (Loxia to be substituted when it arrives), A7RII body, and A7R infrared body with Canon 16-35/4. A
...Show more →

Whoah that's your slimmed down kit! When you say longer hikes you mean one day hikes, right? I'm in awe if you can carry all that and tent/food/sleeping bag etc!
Nov 19, 2016 at 10:50 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
Whoah that's your slimmed down kit! When you say longer hikes you mean one day hikes, right? I'm in awe if you can carry all that and tent/food/sleeping bag etc!


Oh no, I'm not THAT ambitious! By "longer", I mean 2-3 miles over a couple of hours. All I carry is the shoulder bag, tripod, and often a small pair of binoculars for birding while I'm out.

I was carrying a much bigger shoulder bag with 5DSR and a pile of ZE-mount lenses. All big and heavy. Then I got the A7RII and gradually got a few E-mount lenses. A couple months ago, I decided that the weight reduction had to go further, and I slimmed it down to the list I posted above. I'm keeping the big ZE lenses, except the 21 Distagon, but they won't go on a regular basis.

Edited on Nov 19, 2016 at 10:55 PM · View previous versions
Nov 19, 2016 at 10:52 PM
photomadnz
Offline
Details
p.24 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Snupi wrote:
Lloyd Chambers has posted the first pics and comments on the Lox 85. This lens is outstanding regarding sharpness and resolving power. As things stand now - a must have!


Agreed. He's just posted some landscape shots in the last couple of days at higher res and it looks to be the sharpest lens in this category bar none.... Absolutely stellar..
Nov 19, 2016 at 10:52 PM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.24 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Bastian,
Thanks for your objective review!
It was a good move to add the "same size of subject" bokeh test. Seems to be the fair approach and bokeh looks just as expected.

Thanks Fred!

Steve Spencer wrote:
Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian.

So, all that is to say I think it can have a place in my bag despite my large collection of 85/90s. When I want a versatile 3 lens kit with a similar look, great performance and still compact, I think the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 85 will work very well together.

Dear Steven, I am with you in pretty much everything you have written.
As I see things regarding corner to corner sharpness it might be one of the best 85mm lenses available.
Microcontrast is also as high as on the other Loxia lenses (maybe not as biting as the 35mm 2.0 stopped down, but definetly in the league of the 21mm 2.8). But you still get very smooth bokeh wide open without any deteoriations like onion rings (as can be seen on the 90mm cron apo).

PS: I still have to get my hands on the ZM 35mm 1.4 and compare it to my Loxia 35mm 2.0...

I have shot a concert and a few portraits with this lens yesterday, I will update the review within the day.
Nov 20, 2016 at 02:38 AM
xwing15
Offline
Details
p.24 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Some comparative pictures between Loxia and Batis

René





Loxia 2.4







Loxia 2.4 crop







Batis 2.5







Batis 2.5 crop

Nov 20, 2016 at 04:19 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.24 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
xwing15 wrote:
Some comparative pictures between Loxia and Batis

René


Thanks for posting those shots, Rene. I had no idea that the Loxia was already available. May be it's just me, but the Loxia crop seems to have a bit more pop/acuity. Or is this the result of slightly different lighting conditions?
Nov 20, 2016 at 04:26 AM
xwing15
Offline
Details
p.24 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Chris_88 wrote:
xwing15 wroteSome comparative pictures between Loxia and Batis

René
Thanks for posting those shots, Rene. I had no idea that the Loxia was already available. May be it's just me, but the Loxia crop seems to have a bit more pop/acuity. Or is this the result of slightly different lighting conditions?


Thanks Chris. Light conditions are the same. Of course not in the laboratory. But I noticed also in other pictures. But I'm not a real 'tester'.

still some. Focus on the crop

René





Loxia 2.4







Loxia 2.4 crop







Batis 2.5







Batis 2.5 crop

Nov 20, 2016 at 04:36 AM
xwing15
Offline
Details
p.24 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
-All images only Raw conversion. Remainder 'neutral' if possible. Therefore with the harsh sunlight certainly not optimal.

Will do today what is more to me. Make normal photos in the real world.

René





Loxia 4.0







Loxia 4.0 crop







Batis 4.0







Batis 4.0

Nov 20, 2016 at 04:41 AM
xwing15
Offline
Details
p.24 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
And for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8





Batis 1.8







Loxia 2.4

Nov 20, 2016 at 04:54 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.24 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
xwing15 wrote:
And for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8


Interesting. Do you think, it's fair to say that the Loxia is more Zeiss-y (as in classic Zeiss rendering) than the Batis, Rene?
Nov 20, 2016 at 05:08 AM
xwing15
Offline
Details
p.24 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Chris_88 wrote:
xwing15 wroteAnd for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8
Interesting. Do you think, it's fair to say that the Loxia is more Zeiss-y (as in classic Zeiss rendering) than the Batis, Rene?


Think the Loxia is closer to the Zeiss like MP 50 100 and 135. so rather in the classic Zeiss rendering. It is too early to form an opinion. Have the Loxia only since 2 days and today I come finally to go out with it. Look forward.

cheers René
Nov 20, 2016 at 05:14 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.24 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
xwing15 wrote:
Chris_88 wrote
xwing15 wroteAnd for comparison Loxia 2.4 with Batis 1.8
Interesting. Do you think, it's fair to say that the Loxia is more Zeiss-y (as in classic Zeiss rendering) than the Batis, Rene?
Think the Loxia is closer to the Zeiss like MP 50 100 and 135. so rather in the classic Zeiss rendering. It is too early to form an opinion. Have the Loxia only since 2 days and today I come finally to go out with it. Look forward.

cheers René


Thanks, that's the impression I got looking at this thread. Looking forward to hearing/reading further comments from you, once you have been able to test drive the lens some more. Have a great Sunday afternoon.
Nov 20, 2016 at 05:21 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.24 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
BastianK wrote
GMPhotography wroteIf there was a FE 135mm f2 AF I would sell the GM 85 and have the Loxia 85 as my choice. That would be a better fit for a lot of folks I would think.
Funny thing you say that. I am using the Canon EF 135mm 2.0L via Sigma MC-11 and also think it suits me better than an 85mm 1.4.

I actually thought as soon as the Loxia arrives I will immediatley sell my Leica Summicron 90mm 2.0 pre-Asph,
after having done the comparison I am not so sure anymore...

Two very different lenses, the strength of one is the weakness of the other.
For some shots I love the color rendition of the Summicron, but it is also the reason I tend to avoid it when shooting events or weddings, as it does not match my other lenses in this regard.
Loxia produces wonderful sunstars, Leica not so much.
Corner to corner sharpness and sharpness near MFD the Loxia wins hands down.
Even at f/2.4 I can easily produce moiré on the border of the frame on the A7rII's 42mp with the Loxia

Regarding Bokeh I will also do a comparison against the Jupiter-9 85mm 2.0, which is also a Sonnar design,
and another comparison with the Summicron pre-Asph where the subject size is kept constant, not the camera position.

But to be honest, I don't think this lens will appeal to as many as the 21mm.
In 85mm land there is much competition, the Batis has AF, is lighter and faster and
for the price of a new Loxia 85 you might even find a GM 85mm 1.4 on the used market.
Thanks for the Bokeh comparison Bastian. It looks good with some interesting character, but I would prefer less of the cat's eye shapes. For me I really don't need another 85/90. I have the 85 Milvus, the 85 Batis, the Leica M 90 f/2 AA, the Leica R 80 f/1.4, and the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro, so where would this fit in? I have a great modern portrait lens (the Milvus). I have a great AF portrait lens (the Batis 85). I have a great character portrait lens (the 80 lux). I have a great landscape lens (the 90 cron AA), and I have a great portable lens that also does nice landscapes and macro too (the 90 elmar macro). Still this lens is interesting to me in that it has what looks like an interesting dual character. At f/2.4 and f/2.8 it looks to be a quite decent portrait lens and that is fast enough for me (look at micro 4/3rds shooters as an example and how they lust over the 42.5 Nocitron--this lens will have very similar depth of field at f/2.4). It also looks like a fantastic landscape lens stopped down. So, it is much more portable than the Milvus. I am pretty sure it will beat the Batis for landscapes and it won't be too much worse for portraits the way I shoot. It won't have the character of the the 80 lux, but it will be cleaner (i.e., fewer aberrations) and a bit better stopped down, and a bit smaller and lighter. It will be way better for portraits and probably a bit better for landscapes than the 90 elmar macro. The big question for me is whether it will be better than the 90 cron AA at anything. It is a bit heavier and bigger. It may, however, be better at portraits even though the 90 cron AA is just a bit longer and faster. The loxia might have better bokeh, although I think the bokeh of the 90 cron AA is much better than its reputation. My guess is it will be close with slightly different character for the two lenses. I will be interested in that comparison. It might be better than the 90 cron AA for landscapes too, but the 90 cron AA is amazingly sharp across the frame with excellent micro contrast, and almost no coma or CA. The Loxia looks really good from f/4, however, and it definitely has better sunstars (although the 90 elmar macro competes well there). From the examples I expect the 90 cron AA to be better wider than f/4, but from that point on the Loxia will be a great competitor.
So, all that is to say I think it can have a place in my bag despite my large collection of 85/90s. When I want a versatile 3 lens kit with a similar look, great performance and still compact, I think the Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, and Loxia 85 will work very well together. This kit would allow decent portraits, excellent landscapes performance, and very good fairly close in performance. All with a very Zeiss look. I also will use the lens for video. Yes, 85/90mm is crowded especially in my bag, but I think this looks like a very nice option to fill an interesting niche. I have had my pre-order in for awhile and I won't cancel it, but if it doesn't compete well with the 90 cron AA for portraits and it doesn't best the 90 elmar macro for landscapes then I will probably return it.
Steve, I've tested the Batis 85/1.8 at infinity distances and it's very good at f/5.6 but worse than the Zeiss 85/4 ZM and even more so than the 90 cron AA. From the lenses I tested for landscapes, I would rate resolution/contrast in this order:

1) 90 cron AA
2) Zeiss 85/4 ZM
3) Sony 85/1.4GM
4) Batis 85/1.8

The new Loxia has the potential to be the very best of the bunch at f/4 and f/5.6. From the MTF graph, I suspect it will do better than the 85/4ZM wide-open and at f/5.6 and at these apertures, it could potentially dethrone the Leica.

I
...Show more →

Thanks Fred, I don't have the 85 f/4 ZM or the 85 GM, but I agree on the assessment of the Batis. I have tried to find onion rings in the bokeh, but they are rare and hard to produce. I do find a bit of outlining to be common, which bothers me less, but again that is subjective. If I care about bokeh, I almost always shoot this lens wide open--it is so good wide open--so I haven't really looked for the crown cork shaped balls or noticed them. One other point is I use the lens with the Hawk's helicoid and it does very well up close with the helicoid, and reduces the minimal focal distance to .6m or so. At this new MFD the amount of bokeh with the lens is really improved and that makes a big difference for close backgrounds in my experience.
Nov 20, 2016 at 06:57 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister