HKFEVER wrote: MDJAK wroteWhy did some come with 128 gb cfast and others 64? Mine came with 64.
While I haven't had any problems thus far and hope you get that worked out, I did have corrupted files on a Lexar 64gb card in the past with my 1Dx. My solution? I stepped on the foot pedal of my garbage can and dumped the card right in it. No way I was going to take that chance again.In HK, Canon only come with 128GB.
64GB has a much slower writing speed.
Now, I have 3 CFast cards, all in 128GB:
1. Replacement 128 Sandisk from Canon, more corrupt files.
2. I bought another 128 Sandisk on the street, so far only 1 corrupt file, in my memory.
3. I bought 3600X 128 Lexar from B&H, arrived this afternoon, so far so good only 105 files. Will try to open them again tmr.
the fact that they are "ok" when first downloaded would suggest that they are written correctly, but something happens afterwards. Have you tried a different computer to download them?
Iwas joeking wrote: HKFEVER wroteI just have another raw file turn bad right in front of my face (Open with Sandisk Reader).
It was GOOD this morning.Have you tried using a different computer?
I tired on:
- 2013 iMac with all updated software and OS.
- 2015 mini Mac with all updated software and OS.
- Win10 PC with Br and DPP4 installed.
- Brand new iMac with all updated software and OS.
Software:
- DPP4 thumbnail with embeded jpg in Raw, so show OK in preview. Once you double click the file, it will render a little bit different in corrupt area.
- Br preview raw file, do not preview the embeded jpg, so it will show no good right in the thumbnail preview.
- PS preview raw file, do not preview the embeded jpg, so it will show no good right in the raw adjustment screen.
- Lightroom shows OK in preview, I guest it preview the embeded jpg. But once you double click the file, thumbnail turn bad, show the same as PS.
I would also try shooting
1) jpg only(see if problem occurs BEFORE writing to card)
2) jpg plus Raw
3) shoot Raw, but shoot to the regular CF card.
If it's ok on other machines then it does seem like there's something strange going on. It is very weird that the first read is ok, but then afterwards the file is corrupt on the card(Is this instantaneous or does it have to "sit" for a period of time?). Maybe someone knows about the process of reading the file, maybe it's more involved than just reading it??
I am now shooting RAW + L jpg in both cards.
Sandisk CF Extreme Pro 32GB + Lexar 3600X 128GB
And will see the out come in couple days.
Canon told me that there is no different to plug or unplug the card with or without turn off the camera, as long as the red light is off. I knew this since the first day with 1DS
Maybe you turned on the "self-destruct" option somewhere in the C. Fn. menu
All jokes aside, if you don't have corrupted files written to CF card, problem must be somewhere in the CFast slot. Either software or hardware issue. Your test of multiple CFast cards excludes the issue with a CFast card.
Very surprising is the fact that the files show up corrupted after a while. Maybe there is to much power going to the card and camera "destroys" it?
When the same card is reading a good file one try then bad the next, is it being inserted back into the camera at any point in between? If not then then it seems most likely a card issue. I've read a lot of this at potn and it seems to happen when the cards are in the camera and in the readers. The only constant seems to be the cards themselves.
Sounds like OP is putting the card back in the camera, then previously good files are corrupted.
I wonder if the camera is doing a card validation of some kind when powered up that is writing something to the card and corrupting files? Or on reinsertion, is for some reason not properly seeing previously written blocks?
Are these CFast cards MLC flash as opposed to SLC?
Back in the mid-2000s during the 1DII period, there was a problem with Lexar CF cards and the camera resulting in lost images. I.e. not written to the card. IIRC, the red write light might have stayed on indefinitely, rather than normally flashing while writing before going off. It was eventually resolved. Hopefully also the case here, as I will take delivery of a 1DXII once Canon Canada gets more stock (apparently end of June).
FWIW, I've been told I'm only getting a 64GB card with the camera... I thought it was 128GB??
Just use Mac's Terminal and ran MD5 the result for the _X2_0431.cr2 are:
good file with 6b1873ddcb8268b3739436925d4d4ce5
bad file with f2dbdce652c274f3b66838b54a2dfb28
kosin wrote: HKFEVER wroteI am using Lexar 3600X 128GB with Lexar reader, so far so good after 100 pictures,
I don't have fingers to cross any more
kosin wroteShutterbug2006 wroteTry a different Cfast card reader?I was under impression that the OP used different card readers...
If not, it would be the obvious next step. Different card reader or simply connecting connecting the camera via USB.Are you using just one card reader for all your tests?
I have 3 different CFast card readers:
All the previous random corrupted files were read by Sandisk reader with Sandisk CFast card.
Transcend, did not use it yet.
Lexar 3600X + its thunderbolt reader is the fastest, no issue yet, finger crossed
Just a long shot but are the Cfast cards ejected properly from the Mac once copied to the HDD? The reason why I ask is that once files are copied to the Mac and then copied again to another Mac, the corruption seems to occur. If the Cfast card is just removed from the reader and not ejected properly by dragging the CFast icon to the trash, data could be lost and could be the cause of the corruption problem.
HKFEVER wrote: kosin wroteHKFEVER wroteI am using Lexar 3600X 128GB with Lexar reader, so far so good after 100 pictures,
I don't have fingers to cross any more
kosin wroteShutterbug2006 wroteTry a different Cfast card reader?I was under impression that the OP used different card readers...
If not, it would be the obvious next step. Different card reader or simply connecting connecting the camera via USB.Are you using just one card reader for all your tests?I have 3 different CFast card readers: http://www.pbase.com/hkfever/image/163429045/large.jpg
All the previous random corrupted files were read by Sandisk reader with Sandisk CFast card.
Transcend, did not use it yet.
Lexar 3600X + its thunderbolt reader is the fastest, no issue yet, finger crossed
Keep us posted if you encounter any problems.
Did you have any corrupted files, question marked images, in camera before downloading them to the computer?
There is a thread on DPR that lists a Canon phone number to call for 1DX2 problems especially with freeze ups and hanging. You might want to call to report your issues with corrupt files. It's in the 1D forum. I'd post the link but I'm not sure about forum etiquette here at FM.com on such cross links to competitors. I'm sure you can find it.
It has definitely made me glad that I was not an early adopter of the 1DX2. Hopefully Canon can sort it out in time for the Olympics as that would be pretty bad publicity to have bodies locking up at key moments during events.