p.3 #1Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I own the 150-600 Sport and tried out the 200-500.
- The focus speed is about the same on my D300
- The Nikon is lighter, if you want a walk around hand hold get the 200-500
- Sharpness is about the same
- There are times when you want 600mm and also times when you want 150mm (I'd rather have even wider as I had on my 80-400 VR)
- As I do shoot on the beach and in crappy weather it's nice to have water sealing. I've shot the 80-400 VR which is not sealed in rain and snow and it did not matter.
I used to like to walk around hand holding my 80-400 VR and now that I'm using the heavier 150-600 Sport I've learned the advantages of shooting on a tripod. I can always pop the quick release and shoot handheld when it is called for.
p.3 #3Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I returned my copy of the Sport lens as it has two serious design flaws relating to the permanently attached collar and its straight foot design that made it impractical to use either hand held or with a gimbal support.
I cannot remove the collar and foot for hand held shooting and the gap between the barrel of the lens and the foot is too narrow to get my hand around the lens.
The lens foot blocks the right side of my camera grip and function and preview buttons completely when I use the foot at the 3 o'clock position to attach it to a Wimberley Sidekick on my ballhead to have a gimbal support. No such problems with my 80-400mm, 200-400mm, and 200-500mm Nikon lenses, and no such problems with the Sigma Contemporary and the Tamron 150-600mm lenses.
For me any possible advantages of the Sigma Sport lens are completely negated when it is not comfortable for hand held use and cannot be mounted on my tripod with the Sidekick gimbal.
You cannot compare a cropped 500mm shot to one taken with a 600mm lens. The 600mm produces an image with the subject area that is 44% larger than one from a 500mm lens. A file from a D810 with the 500mm might be close to that of one from the D750 using a 600mm lens but that seems like an odd comparison to be making for all practical purposes. The smaller the image area the greater the reduction of cropping options and print enlargement capability and this is already often a concern much of the time when photographing wildlife.
p.3 #4Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I'm conflicted, and doing some searching (hence the bumping of an old thread)...I have my 500mm F4 for sale, and potentially sold, I'm thinking of going to a 150-600 or 200-500 for size's sake, I've just never seen samples from the 150-600 that really blow me away, I've seen some from the 200-500 that are quite impressive.
That being said, the extra reach would be good...
My main concern is that I'm going to sell my 500mm and sink this money in to a new lens and regret it, and be unable to get a 500 again for what mine might go for. I know there's not much that's going to touch the 500mm in terms of IQ...someone steer me in the right direction?
I'll be using a D810 and eventually a D500 when my pre-order arrives.
p.3 #5Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
No doubt those that own the zooms will back them solidly. But realistically, no zoom will equal the sharpness and detail rendered by a fixed long lens. Anything over 200mm, I use fixed lenses. So I would not have a tough decision, I'd keep that big 500. Good luck with the zoom if you go that way.
p.3 #6Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Steve, I had the Sportma and the 200-500 at the same time. The preferred set-up
was the 200-500 on the D810 and the Sportma on my D7200. I turned the 200-500
into a 500 f4 VR with a trade and some dead presidents and couldn't be happier...
especially early/late letting in ALL that light. The Sportma will live on my D500. I
feel I have the best of both worlds. My 300 f2.8/200 f2 now relegated to portraits.
p.3 #7Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Steve, I'm the one who got Will's dead presidents and 200-500 . He walked away with my baby, the 500 f/4 VR
There was great angst in this decision. It was not a quick decision either as I had been thinking about it for over a year. I had the same fear as you , that I would greatly regret it and never be able to replace the 500 f/4VR. However, once I had the opportunity to shoot the 200-500, my decision was made.
For me the decision came down to one thing - weight . I could not handhold the 500 f/4VR. It always had to be on a tripod or monopod. The pure joy of being out in nature, walking around and shooting was being lost to all the setting up , futzing around with tripods and lugging all that weight around and missing shots .
While I may have given up a bit of IQ, the joy is back . Nothing beats being able to just grab, handhold and have fun.
As Will, I couldn't be happier. The 200-500 is a wonderful lens and I am quite happy with the IQ even with the 1.4 TC .
Your reasons are probably completely different than mine. I hope you can have peace with your decision, as I know it is not an easy one.
Here are a couple of recent shots with the 200-500.
p.3 #8Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
My problem is that my goals are contradictory, and I just can't figure out which way to come down on it.
I'm doing a once in a lifetime trip to Europe in July. I'm hitting an airshow at the start of the trip, and a bunch of touring Europe after that...while the portability of the 150-600mm would definitely come in handy, I would worry that for a once in a lifetime trip the optical quality of it would simply make me regret the decision.
I truly do love the 500mm, but there's a lot of factors to it that make me want to consider going a different route, not the least of which being size and cost...
I'm also running in to the issue with the Europe trip of wanting to transport a full range of lenses and do it all in a package that fits the international carry on requirements.
Currently the kit would consist of D810, D500, 500mm F4, 300mm 2.8, 70-200mm 2.8, 24-70mm 2.8, 14-24...that's a pretty tight squeeze...if possible at all.
If I go to the 150-600mm I could change the kit to 150-600mm, 70-200mm, 24-70, 14-24.
The third option would be to skip the 300 2.8, but then I leave a pretty long focal range not covered...Put the 70-200 on the D500 and I'm close, but my original plan was to put the 70-200 on the D810 with the 150-600mm on the D500 so I'd have everything covered from 70mm to 900mm of effective focal length with the exception of 200-225mm.
p.3 #10Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
birdied wrote:
Steve, I'm the one who got Will's dead presidents and 200-500 . He walked away with my baby, the 500 f/4 VR
There was great angst in this decision. It was not a quick decision either as I had been thinking about it for over a year. I had the same fear as you , that I would greatly regret it and never be able to replace the 500 f/4VR. However, once I had the opportunity to shoot the 200-500, my decision was made.
For me the decision came down to one thing - weight . I could not handhold the 500 f/4VR. It always had to be on a tripod or monopod. The pure joy of being out in nature, walking around and shooting was being lost to all the setting up , futzing around with tripods and lugging all that weight around and missing shots .
While I may have given up a bit of IQ, the joy is back . Nothing beats being able to just grab, handhold and have fun.
As Will, I couldn't be happier. The 200-500 is a wonderful lens and I am quite happy with the IQ even with the 1.4 TC .
Your reasons are probably completely different than mine. I hope you can have peace with your decision, as I know it is not an easy one.
Here are a couple of recent shots with the 200-500.
p.3 #11Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Always puzzled at that query, Fred. Kids out West learn to ride before they can walk.
Covering rodeo the last 6 yrs I'd say < 5% are so attired. Now, roughstock on the other
hand...requires helmet/kevlar vest if under age 13.
I think it is all based on where you grew up. I know from my time in the southwest helmets were reserved for rodeo events with dangerous bulls and even then there was no guarantee that the rider would wear one lol.
But living on the east coast these days when I take my kids out to a stable or farm most horse riding is taught for dressage or in English saddle and a helmet is required equipment.
p.3 #12Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
trenchmonkey wrote:
Over 50 yrs of lens
purchases and I've never scratched an element. Congrats on the lens, work it
You'll wan't more SS handholdin' 900mm FOV I started out 1/2000th then went to 1/1600th
After 2 weeks use I'm down to 1/1250th with ~90% in focus humpin' this gem. GL
Lucky you or just very meticulous you... I had a Canon 17-55 for less than 6 months and put 2 deep gouges into the front element... how? Took camera out of bag in the early morning to photograph daughter at soccer game and lens fogged up... so I lightly wiped it with a lens cloth... apparently either the cloth or the lens had something on it that created two nasty gashes across the front element...
p.3 #13Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Go4Long wrote:
I'm conflicted, and doing some searching (hence the bumping of an old thread)...I have my 500mm F4 for sale, and potentially sold, I'm thinking of going to a 150-600 or 200-500 for size's sake, I've just never seen samples from the 150-600 that really blow me away, I've seen some from the 200-500 that are quite impressive.
That being said, the extra reach would be good...
My main concern is that I'm going to sell my 500mm and sink this money in to a new lens and regret it, and be unable to get a 500 again for what mine might go for. I know there's not much that's going to touch the 500mm in terms of IQ...someone steer me in the right direction?
I'll be using a D810 and eventually a D500 when my pre-order arrives....Show more →
Steve, currently I have both the Sigma 150-600mm S and the Nikon 200-500. I will keep one of them. I am really having a hard time deciding which one to keep. I tried them on my D810. I just can't make up my mind. Here are the Pros and Cons of each, for ME:
Sigma:
Pros: obviously, the range, the push/pull feature (this really helps if I want to zoom in and out quickly, especially for airshows which you and I love), the built, the loop(?) on the lens to attach a strap, like your 500mm f/4, more customization with the Sigma USB dock.
Cons: the weight (that comes with the built), lens foot not removable, when it's extended to 600mm, the lens is pretty long and it will take some effort for my left arm to support the lens for more than 6 or 7 minutes.
Nikon:
Pros: relatively lighter, easier to put the hood on and off
Cons: Obvious, the range, not weather sealed. There is no place on the lens that you can attach a strap to without some sort of add-on fastener/Black Rapid setup. To zoom from 200 to 500 or 500 to 200, it's a pretty big turn that I can't do it in one turn,
AF: I haven't used both lenses extensively on moving subjects so I can't really comment on this, not an expert anyway. But many reviews say the Nikon's AF is not that good when the light goes down.
Sharpness: I took some shots of cars' tags with both lenses at 500mm from a distance of about 40 feet, on tripod, VR off, and look at the the numbers on that little annual sticker on the tag, the Nikon seems sharper and more contrasty. The Nikon at 500mm is even sharper than the Sigma at 600m at the same size when I looked the numbers. I have not done any AF tuning to the lenses. I had never done lens comparison before and it's quite likely that I didn't do the comparison properly. I also took some handheld pictures of sea gulls and geese at different time, to my eyes the Nikon is sharper.
Price: B&H and Adorama have10% reward on the $1799 price for the Sigma S, plus a free USB dock, so the lens basically costs about $1550, vs $1400 for the Nikon, for me the price difference doesn't come into my decision making process.
I think copy variation may play a role in the results too. It's a very tough decision. Good luck.
p.3 #14Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
tntcorp wrote: birdied wroteSteve, I'm the one who got Will's dead presidents and 200-500 . He walked away with my baby, the 500 f/4 VR
There was great angst in this decision. It was not a quick decision either as I had been thinking about it for over a year. I had the same fear as you , that I would greatly regret it and never be able to replace the 500 f/4VR. However, once I had the opportunity to shoot the 200-500, my decision was made.
For me the decision came down to one thing - weight . I could not handhold the 500 f/4VR. It always had to be on a tripod or monopod. The pure joy of being out in nature, walking around and shooting was being lost to all the setting up , futzing around with tripods and lugging all that weight around and missing shots .
While I may have given up a bit of IQ, the joy is back . Nothing beats being able to just grab, handhold and have fun.
As Will, I couldn't be happier. The 200-500 is a wonderful lens and I am quite happy with the IQ even with the 1.4 TC .
Your reasons are probably completely different than mine. I hope you can have peace with your decision, as I know it is not an easy one.
Here are a couple of recent shots with the 200-500.
Birdiebirdied - have you thought of trying out the new 500e, i.e. fl version? it shaved off nearly 2 lbs, so can be comfortably handheld.
of course it will require lots of dead presidents... :-)
p.3 #15Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I've never had an issue with the weight. Before the 500 I used a 400 2.8...so the 500 is practically a featherweight by comparison and is significantly easier to hand hold as it's much better balanced than the 400 (while the 500 is only around a pound lighter, the 400 is extremely front end heavy, so I found it exhausting to hold up).
It's really just boiling down to me trying to convince myself that I can do without the 500, which I love.
p.3 #19Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I think it is safe to say from many reports that the Tamron, Sigma C & S and the Nikon 200-500mm are all really close in terms of sharpness. I haven't been absolutely wowed by any of them but they do provide fantastic image quality at a fraction of the cost of the exotic primes. Pretty nice for us!
p.3 #20Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Will I thought you had the new nikon and preferred the sport? Now you are going back again?
I'm thinking about trying out the sport (maybe a canada purchase since it is about $1550 up north), but would never consider selling my 500vr...it is just too good, can't imagine anything being better (except maybe the new 600vr which I will never afford)...I handhold the 500vr almost 100% of the time, just never find myself in spots where I can use my tripod/gimbal. I am hoping that the sport is the equal in terms of sharpness to the 200-500 at their respective longest focal length, and hopefully faster to focus. If I can manage the 500vr, the sport will seem like a toy lens to me!