fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?

  
 
ImagePass
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Hi all,

if we consider that both have nearly the same optical quality and general performances ( AF, VR..), we can conclude that the main difference is the weight!

So, everyone has to choose between high build quality or ease of use!

I chose the Nikon because I thought it was more versatile according to the weight and size.
I can carry it in a standard size bag, like a Lowepro flipside sport 15L . Secondly, I can use it handheld quite easily.
Fabien.
Jan 29, 2016 at 11:32 PM
TightLines
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
kdrk888 wrote:
Steve, currently I have both the Sigma 150-600mm S and the Nikon 200-500. I will keep one of them. I am really having a hard time deciding which one to keep. I tried them on my D810. I just can't make up my mind. Here are the Pros and Cons of each, for ME:

Sigma:

Pros: obviously, the range, the push/pull feature (this really helps if I want to zoom in and out quickly, especially for airshows which you and I love), the built, the loop(?) on the lens to attach a strap, like your 500mm f/4, more customization with the
...Show more →

Doug - any update on your decision. I'm currently wrestling with the same decision/pricing from Adorama and rewards.
Jan 31, 2016 at 09:20 PM
mannusingh
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
What is the aperture on the Sigma sport at 500mm? Is it also F5.6? I recently used my 200-500 in the deserts of Rajasthan and more I use this lens the more I am convinced that it is an awesome lens that can be shot all day wide open with the best VR in Nikon land. I also own the 400 2.8 and the 600 4.0 and believe me I don't find my 200-500 a distant third in comparison. It likes FX sensors more than DX sensors but it is unbelievably good for the price it is available in India.

Here is a recent shot taken with my 200-500 F5.6 on my D7200 shot wide open.

Feb 01, 2016 at 02:20 AM
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
It depends on you need. The sports is sharper , faster af and the push pull is a big advantage! Way faster and you can keep the same handholding position.

Picture I took with the 150-600 sport

Northern saw wet owl






Edited on Feb 01, 2016 at 07:17 AM · View previous versions
Feb 01, 2016 at 06:22 AM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
TightLines wrote:
kdrk888 wroteSteve, currently I have both the Sigma 150-600mm S and the Nikon 200-500. I will keep one of them. I am really having a hard time deciding which one to keep. I tried them on my D810. I just can't make up my mind. Here are the Pros and Cons of each, for ME:

Sigma:

Pros: obviously, the range, the push/pull feature (this really helps if I want to zoom in and out quickly, especially for airshows which you and I love), the built, the loop(?) on the lens to attach a strap, like your 500mm f/4, more customization with the Sigma USB dock.

Cons: the weight (that comes with the built), lens foot not removable, when it's extended to 600mm, the lens is pretty long and it will take some effort for my left arm to support the lens for more than 6 or 7 minutes.

Nikon:

Pros: relatively lighter, easier to put the hood on and off

Cons: Obvious, the range, not weather sealed. There is no place on the lens that you can attach a strap to without some sort of add-on fastener/Black Rapid setup. To zoom from 200 to 500 or 500 to 200, it's a pretty big turn that I can't do it in one turn,

AF: I haven't used both lenses extensively on moving subjects so I can't really comment on this, not an expert anyway. But many reviews say the Nikon's AF is not that good when the light goes down.

Sharpness: I took some shots of cars' tags with both lenses at 500mm from a distance of about 40 feet, on tripod, VR off, and look at the the numbers on that little annual sticker on the tag, the Nikon seems sharper and more contrasty. The Nikon at 500mm is even sharper than the Sigma at 600m at the same size when I looked the numbers. I have not done any AF tuning to the lenses. I had never done lens comparison before and it's quite likely that I didn't do the comparison properly. I also took some handheld pictures of sea gulls and geese at different time, to my eyes the Nikon is sharper.

Price: B&H and Adorama have10% reward on the $1799 price for the Sigma S, plus a free USB dock, so the lens basically costs about $1550, vs $1400 for the Nikon, for me the price difference doesn't come into my decision making process.

I think copy variation may play a role in the results too. It's a very tough decision. Good luck.

Douglas
Doug - any update on your decision. I'm currently wrestling with the same decision/pricing from Adorama and rewards.



Basically I flipped a coin. I am keeping the Nikon because to my eyes, it shows a bit more details in the pictures.But I will miss the wider range of the Sigma. I changed my decision 3 or 4 times and finally made up my mind last night after I took the Sigma out to try one more time yesterday. I didn't do any AF tuning to the lenses.

Good luck.

Douglas


Feb 01, 2016 at 06:25 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
cohenfive wrote:
Will I thought you had the new nikon and preferred the sport? Now you are going back again?

I'm thinking about trying out the sport (maybe a canada purchase since it is about $1550 up north), but would never consider selling my 500vr...it is just too good, can't imagine anything being better (except maybe the new 600vr which I will never afford)...I handhold the 500vr almost 100% of the time, just never find myself in spots where I can use my tripod/gimbal. I am hoping that the sport is the equal in terms of sharpness to the 200-500 at their respective
...Show more →

Richard, I do prefer the Sport. Traded the 200-500 towards a 500 f4 VR. Love the D7200/Sportma combo...
can't wait for my D500. Best thing I can say about the 200-500, I'll own one again. Great light zoom onna
D810/800...sweet bokeh wide open and stellar VR make it a steal of a deal.
Feb 01, 2016 at 06:38 AM
TightLines
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Thanks all for your further input. This will be paired for a D800E and will make for my wildlife setup. I do most of my shooting underwater so I'm trying to find a go to setup for topside shooting.

I went to bed last night thinking the 200-500 was the ticket after reviewing the images from the Cameralabs review.

In their tests the Nikon is certainly a bit sharper, and handles the 1.4x teleconverter quite well. The TC helps hit the long end the Sigma has but certainly doesn't help on the wider end and it comes at a cost.

Looking around here it seems the photos out of the Sigma are a bit sharper. Tough to tell on smaller photos being shot by different people in very different conditions but thats my feel.

Feb 01, 2016 at 06:48 AM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
TightLines wrote:
Thanks all for your further input. This will be paired for a D800E and will make for my wildlife setup. I do most of my shooting underwater so I'm trying to find a go to setup for topside shooting.

I went to bed last night thinking the 200-500 was the ticket after reviewing the images from the Cameralabs review.

In their tests the Nikon is certainly a bit sharper, and handles the 1.4x teleconverter quite well. The TC helps hit the long end the Sigma has but certainly doesn't help on the wider end and it comes at a cost.

Looking around
...Show more →

Copy variation can play a role too.
Feb 01, 2016 at 06:53 AM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
TightLines wrote:
Thanks all for your further input. This will be paired for a D800E and will make for my wildlife setup.


I loved my D800E, but when I used it for wildlife, the shutter release was so loud I'd often just get one shot off and the animal or bird would be gone. So I jumped for the D810 when it came out. But where I shoot, it's always difficult to find wildlife, and also it's dead quiet. Of course, if you are in Yellowstone or a place where the critters are accustomed to people and noise that may not be a factor.

To stick with the subject, there's plenty of hack comparisons on you tube...
Feb 01, 2016 at 07:49 AM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Having owned both I held onto the Nikon 200-500mm and it was primarily due to the awkwardness of shooting with the Sport lens hand held. Not being able to remove the collar and the dumb design for the foot that blocks access to the controls on the camera body I knew that regardless of image quality or autofocus performance that I did not want the lens. The Sigma Contemporary lens is quite different from the Sport as it does have a removable mounting collar and the foot angles away from the camera (as does the Nikon 200-500mm) and so does accommodate hand held shooting.
Feb 01, 2016 at 12:51 PM
jyo1
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I am enjoying all the back and forth on this subject---clearly the 200-500 and the 150-600 are great lenses for the price---I think there are pros and cons for each and many posters here are adamant about their choice and others seem more willing to go either way---it's all good to have these choices and at not much $$$ at that! Personally, I am using the 80-400 AFS lens on my D7100 for motor racing pics---my subjects are much larger than the birds a lot of people here are shooting. I also usually have a photo pass, so I am closer to the action and I am liking the lighter weight of the 80-400 as there is a lot of walking involved in motor racing photography---still always temped by new gear especially at the price...
Feb 01, 2016 at 01:55 PM
bhermz
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Is $1399 (shipped) a good price for a mint used Sigma 150-600 Sport? Not purchasing from this forum, so don't have to worry about stepping on any toes. Thanks in advance.

Edited on Feb 02, 2016 at 12:38 PM · View previous versions
Feb 02, 2016 at 11:15 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Yup
Feb 02, 2016 at 11:19 AM
Craig Gillette
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
kdrk888 wrote:
Basically I flipped a coin. I am keeping the Nikon because to my eyes, it shows a bit more details in the pictures.But I will miss the wider range of the Sigma. I changed my decision 3 or 4 times and finally made up my mind last night after I took the Sigma out to try one more time yesterday. I didn't do any AF tuning to the lenses.

Good luck.

Douglas



I was in a systems engineering program aimed at the "future of the company" and our government program office customers, etc. before the program was terminated and we were all laid off. The question being discussed was how to make a decision when there were multiple competing yet equally valid objectives. Only half jokingly, the "flipping a coin" was offered as a possible solution. The idea is to remember the immediate emotional response to the flip, not the actual outcome. It doesn't give any technical validity to the decision but it tells you what choice you "wanted."
Feb 02, 2016 at 11:36 AM
wizzard0003
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Craig Gillette wrote:
I was in a systems engineering program aimed at the "future of the company" and our government program office customers, etc. before the program was terminated and we were all laid off. The question being discussed was how to make a decision when there were multiple competing yet equally valid objectives. Only half jokingly, the "flipping a coin" was offered as a possible solution. The idea is to remember the immediate emotional response to the flip, not the actual outcome. It doesn't give any technical validity to the decision but it tells you what choice you "wanted."


Very interesting and makes perfect sense...
Feb 02, 2016 at 12:50 PM
bhermz
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
wizzard0003 wrote:
Craig Gillette wroteI was in a systems engineering program aimed at the "future of the company" and our government program office customers, etc. before the program was terminated and we were all laid off. The question being discussed was how to make a decision when there were multiple competing yet equally valid objectives. Only half jokingly, the "flipping a coin" was offered as a possible solution. The idea is to remember the immediate emotional response to the flip, not the actual outcome. It doesn't give any technical validity to the decision but it tells you what choice you "wanted."
Very interesting and makes perfect sense...


+1

Makes perfect cents! Sorry had to!
Feb 02, 2016 at 01:16 PM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Craig Gillette wrote:
kdrk888 wroteBasically I flipped a coin. I am keeping the Nikon because to my eyes, it shows a bit more details in the pictures.But I will miss the wider range of the Sigma. I changed my decision 3 or 4 times and finally made up my mind last night after I took the Sigma out to try one more time yesterday. I didn't do any AF tuning to the lenses.

Good luck.

Douglas

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/coin-toss-broke-6-clinton-sanders-deadlocks-in-iowa-and-hillary-won-each-time-2016-02-02
I was in a systems engineering program aimed at the "future of the company" and our government program office customers, etc. before the program was terminated and we were all laid off. The question being discussed was how to make a decision when there were multiple competing yet equally valid objectives. Only half jokingly, the "flipping a coin" was offered as a possible solution. The idea is to remember the immediate emotional response to the flip, not the actual outcome. It doesn't give any technical validity to the decision but it tells you what choice you "wanted."


OT OT, I read that 6 precincts in Iowa last night had to flip a coin to decide whether Hillary or Bernie won since they had equal numbers of votes, all 6 flips went for Hillary.

Not to get political, since we were talking coin flipping here....
Feb 02, 2016 at 01:19 PM
Go4Long
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
FWIW, after much mental anguish I've decided I can't give up the 500 F4. I'd hate to think I sacrificed quality in the pursuit of portability.
Feb 02, 2016 at 01:22 PM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Go4Long wrote:
FWIW, after much mental anguish I've decided I can't give up the 500 F4. I'd hate to think I sacrificed quality in the pursuit of portability.


I think that is a good call on your part!
Feb 02, 2016 at 02:18 PM
sanjayg
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
What I find surprising is that a consumer grade lens like 200-500 gets talked about in the same discussions as an exotic 500f4. It baffles me.
Feb 02, 2016 at 03:26 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister