fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?

  
 
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
If I already had the 500 F4 I don't think I would have bought the sigma 150-600 sport

Mate a D500 with your 500 f4 and you will have a Killer combo!!
Feb 02, 2016 at 03:27 PM
Christian H
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
sanjayg wrote:
What I find surprising is that a consumer grade lens like 200-500 gets talked about in the same discussions as an exotic 500f4. It baffles me.


They're fairly close in quality in the ways that matter to many hobbyists. If you're a fair-weather shooter or you don't shoot a lot of backlit scenes at f/4 the two lenses are effectively interchangeable.

Exhibit A
2015 @ the John Heinz National Wildlife Refuge by Christian Hunold, on Flickr

Exhibit B
Blaumeise by Christian Hunold, on Flickr

There are things you can do with an f/4 prime that you can't do with an f/5.6 zoom, but those things don't happen on the Sunday morning birding walk or in the Conowingo Dam parking lot.
Feb 02, 2016 at 04:07 PM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
So what's the bottom line here?

Does it really just boil down to focal length? Both are essentially equivalent in IQ?
The Sigma is a steel tube you can drive a car over?
Feb 03, 2016 at 02:50 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
sanjayg wrote:
What I find surprising is that a consumer grade lens like 200-500 gets talked about in the same discussions as an exotic 500f4. It baffles me.


You obviously are easily baffled.
Feb 03, 2016 at 03:22 PM
Christian H
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Trying to distinguish these two really pretty good consumer zooms in terms of image quality is a bit of a fool's errand. The 200-500 is lightweight and, for most adults, easy to handhold for extended periods. Bokeh and rendering of color are fairly consistent with other Nikon glass in this focal range, which is nice (as well as a subjective judgment on my part). I've said something like this before: If you are used to shooting Nikon primes in this focal range, the performance of the zoom in good light will not make you throw up in your mouth. If consistency across lenses of the way your files "look" doesn't matter to you, or if one of the Sigma's features is helpful to you (such as the longer focal length), you can't go wrong with the Sigma. Whatever measurable differences in image quality may exist between these two zooms are so minor as to be irrelevant to the target audience.
Feb 03, 2016 at 03:43 PM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Thanks!
Feb 03, 2016 at 03:53 PM
sanjayg
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Imagemaster,

I have the 200-500 zoom btw and it is a very nice lens.

I get baffled because of the price differential between the 200-500 zoom and 500f4 prime. If the zoom and the prime are talked about in the same vein, you expect them to be in the same or similar price range and obviously they are not.

Imagemaster wrote:
sanjayg wroteWhat I find surprising is that a consumer grade lens like 200-500 gets talked about in the same discussions as an exotic 500f4. It baffles me.
You obviously are easily baffled.


Feb 04, 2016 at 07:38 AM
TightLines
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
At this point (Sigma available for $1800 with dock) my decision will be based on whether the longer focal length is worth the additional 1.2lbs. I'm not keen on shooting from a tripod/monopod. Decisions, decisions.
Feb 04, 2016 at 08:17 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
sanjayg wrote:
I get baffled because of the price differential between the 200-500 zoom and 500f4 prime. If the zoom and the prime are talked about in the same vein, you expect them to be in the same or similar price range and obviously they are not.


When a thread is about a specific lens or lenses, other lenses always get dragged into the discussions. That is the way it is on these forums.

I would never expect an f5.6 lens (zoom or prime) to be in the same price range of an f4 lens.
Feb 04, 2016 at 10:26 AM
cohenfive
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I have been thinking of adding the sport to my quivver, alongside the 80-400 and the 500vr. To me, since I handhold the 500vr, the sport will seem pretty small and lightweight even though it is quite a bit bigger than the new nikon 200-500. I like the longer focal length if it focuses quickly and produces pretty sharp images. You can get the sigma sport even cheaper if you know where to look also....For a while you could get one in canada for about $1550 (not there now), and I've been offered a usa model for about the same. I am heading up to Klamath this weekend, and one of the others going just got the sport so I will get a chance to see how it performs shooting birds. I'll decide from there.

You pay a huge premium to get the marginal improvement of the long primes, that has always been the case. The new lenses are just narrowing that gap further for a lot of people...but there is still a performance gap.
Feb 04, 2016 at 11:39 AM
cohenfive
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I was up in Klamath this past weekend, and one of my buddies had the sport. I didn't play with it a lot, but to my arms it didn't feel much lighter than my 500...I think it has to do with the balance point of the lens especially when zoomed out. It seemed to focus pretty well, and my buddy's pictures came out well. I was hoping it would 'feel' lighter than it did, but I could manage it since I manage the 500vr handheld ok.
Feb 11, 2016 at 04:28 PM
Pixphatic
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Till about end of February'2016,I was going through the several forums in order to learn more about these two lenses i.e. Nikon 200-500 and Sigma 150-600 Sports.Never thought I would be able to test them side by side,using the same camera body,on the same subject.It was a great experience doing a great comparison.
I am presenting here four images,two of which taken with Sigma 150-600-Sports and two with Nikon 200-500+1.4X TCII.I loved them both and very true it is very difficult to select any one.Wish I could test the 200-500 bare,but unfortunately that was not done. It would have been great if I could own them both,but alas I have to choose any one .....
Can the lenses be identified from the images....??

1. http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/y513/PIXPHATIC/DSC_2314_filtered_zps0y7f5xf2.jpg?t=1457878822

2. http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/y513/PIXPHATIC/DSC_2383_filtered_zps5wcd2bc4.jpg?t=1457878826

3. http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/y513/PIXPHATIC/DSC_2386_filtered_zpspvdmjqkj.jpg?t=1457878826

4 .http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/y513/PIXPHATIC/DSC_2300_filtered_zpsrtusopef.jpg?t=1457878826

All four with Nikon D7100 body.

Thanks for viewing.
Mar 14, 2016 at 08:10 AM
AvianScott
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
PIXPHATIC wrote:
Can the lenses be identified from the images....?? .


My guess is 1 & 4 are from the 150-600, and 2 & 3 from the 200-500 + TC.

Mar 14, 2016 at 12:31 PM
egd5
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I'm not sure which, but I also group 1&4 and 2&3 together. If I had to guess though I'd say 1&4 were the ones with a TC.
Mar 14, 2016 at 06:22 PM
twistacatz
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
AvianScott wrote:
PIXPHATIC wroteCan the lenses be identified from the images....?? .
My guess is 1 & 4 are from the 150-600, and 2 & 3 from the 200-500 + TC.



I agree, to me it looks like 1 and 4 have more feather detail.
Mar 14, 2016 at 06:30 PM
Pixphatic
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
AvianScott wrote:
PIXPHATIC wroteCan the lenses be identified from the images....?? .
My guess is 1 & 4 are from the 150-600, and 2 & 3 from the 200-500 + TC.



---------------------------------------------

egd5 wrote:
I'm not sure which, but I also group 1&4 and 2&3 together. If I had to guess though I'd say 1&4 were the ones with a TC.


---------------------------------------------

twistacatz wrote:
AvianScott wrote
PIXPHATIC wroteCan the lenses be identified from the images....?? .
My guess is 1 & 4 are from the 150-600, and 2 & 3 from the 200-500 + TC.
I agree, to me it looks like 1 and 4 have more feather detail.


absolutely correct....it seems obvious here with the greater amount of details.But one thing must be kept in mind that the Nikon was used with six (6) more elements/glasses.Five (5) for the 1.4X TCII and one(1) for the front protector.Still it AFed just great and the IQ was excellent imho.

Thanks

Mar 15, 2016 at 07:51 AM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
So,
In the end this doesn't tell me anything. Other than a TC degrades some detail. I would have liked to see the Nikon vs. Sigma both with their best respective TC's, and both without. Seems that a comparison based solely on matching the focal lengths by hook or by crook, isn't that useful. At least to me. Others may disagree.
Mar 15, 2016 at 08:03 AM
Pixphatic
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
ckcarr wrote:
So,
In the end this doesn't tell me anything. Other than a TC degrades some detail. I would have liked to see the Nikon vs. Sigma both with their best respective TC's, and both without. Seems that a comparison based solely on matching the focal lengths by hook or by crook, isn't that useful. At least to me. Others may disagree.

...nothing to disagree upon.Its only logical that the bare lenses should have been compared side by side.Will surely give a try nxt time,if get a chance.
I tried to use the 200-500 with most nos of glasses I might just use,and see what was the result.I was glad with it.
Although I will be using it @f5.6 most of the time in my upcoming trip to the Himalayas.


Mar 15, 2016 at 08:20 AM
Mark K
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Photgraphy Life's Review of 200-500
Where you can find the numbers of MTF with regard of these two lenses. Obviously at 500mm f6.3, both are more or less the same but at 600mm, it is a completely different story. There must be a reason why Sport costs a bit much more. The only thing is weather you can tolerate its weight
Mar 15, 2016 at 08:49 AM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Mark K wrote:
Photgraphy Life's Review of 200-500
Where you can find the numbers of MTF with regard of these two lenses. Obviously at 500mm f6.3, both are more or less the same but at 600mm, it is a completely different story. There must be a reason why Sport costs a bit much more. The only thing is weather you can tolerate its weight


These guys got quite a few bad copies- that they state that the 200-500 is noticeably better than the Sigma C, yet the Tamron competes well, and the Sport "obliterates" the 200-500 is a bit off. They're implying that there's a very large difference between these lenses, when there really isn't, all good copies concerned (which cannot be guaranteed regardless of brand).

Further, claiming that the Sigma lenses do not work with TCs, when they were literally released with compatible TCs...
Mar 15, 2016 at 09:38 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister