fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015landscape gear

  
 
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #1landscape gear
alundeb wrote:
dhphoto wroteThe 5D2 has perfectly good dynamic range for anything, unless you want to manipulate the file a lot
Nope, banding can show up, even in downrezzed images, after even slight manipulation like lifting shadows 1 - 2 stops. I know you will dispute that, but my data point is as valid as yours and I am not alone. I do not have a bad copy of the 5DII.


Lifting shadows 1-2 stops is a lot.

Don't do that, get round the problem in other ways Like I did for many years and banding is a complete non-issue.

It's far too easy to just dismiss the 5D2, which in skilled hands is an excellent camera.
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:29 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #2landscape gear
With that budget, you can't really go wrong with either the 5DS R, D810 or A7rII. They have different strengths and weaknesses. Buying into a new system now with that as a base is really a world of great possibilities. It is a so complex and personal decision that I think I will just recommend gathering information from more than one place. Good luck!
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:33 PM
kabraxcis
Offline
Details
p.2 #3landscape gear
15k? that's quite a bit
Depends on how long/expensive of a trip you are looking at I guess
I'd probably get an a7r2 and some lenses, and take 3~4 trips with that budget.

No reason to get Canon for landscape 1really unless you already have lenses/bodies
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:35 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #4landscape gear
bradf35 wrote:
Thanks for the replies so far. I have $15K right now, and would like to spend it on equipment plus a trip. I've already made the tripod mistake, and now have a good tripod. Right now I print at 16x20 with my 5Dc. I'd probably print larger from time to time if I could.


A little thought the comes up from time to time...

I often feel that many people who have a sum like that to spend on, say, a "landscape" setup but who are asking very, very general questions (like "what should I get") might not be doing the most effective thing if they go out and spend that money on the basis of what others say.

If you are at a point where having such expensive equipment will make a difference to your work, in most cases you would take a look at how and what you shoot, what you do with the photographs, and the available gear... and soon begin to come to some pretty concrete conclusions based on your experience.

All of which is one way of saying, "go slow on spending the 15k too quickly." Perhaps better to research and slowly acquire necessary gear, piece by piece.

alundeb wrote:
With that budget, you can't really go wrong with either the 5DS R, D810 or A7rII. They have different strengths and weaknesses. Buying into a new system now with that as a base is really a world of great possibilities. It is a so complex and personal decision that I think I will just recommend gathering information from more than one place. Good luck!


Indeed, you can make excellent photograph with any of those bodies and appropriate lenses. Each has a set of pluses and minuses, and the key issue is to see that those intersect with your needs and preferences.

I live in a world of photographers who use all three, and some use more than one.

Dan
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:35 PM
bradf35
Offline
Details
p.2 #5landscape gear


rw11 wrote:
will you carry it on your back?

use it in harsh (cold, icy, snowy conditions)?

in any event, you'll want a quality CF tripod & ballhead - is your leg set CF? will it deploy & collapse time after time in the env.s you will work in in the future?

Luckily you have a fat budget.

I think use of an ultra-wide lens for landscape is an age-related issue - personally, I never touch the things - bad for my liver.

I'd also want a camera with lots of DR, but you posted in a Canon forum, so...


I will carry it on my back, but I'm a big guy and weight generally doesn't bother me unless I go on long overnight hikes. I'll use it in any condition that's worth shooting in.
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:38 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.2 #6landscape gear
bradf35 wrote:
Thanks for the replies so far. I have $15K right now, and would like to spend it on equipment plus a trip. I've already made the tripod mistake, and now have a good tripod. Right now I print at 16x20 with my 5Dc. I'd probably print larger from time to time if I could.


For $15K + already owning a "good tripod", I'd get Dan's kit plus some trips or workshop or bigger printer or landscape photography books (see Freeman Patterson as well as the usual suspects). I suggest the 5DS rather than the 5DsR but around here that seems to be a minority viewpoint.

Definitely get a macro, ex. 100 mm L IS macro or the non-IS. Get at least the 40 mm f/2.8 STM and 50 mm f/1.8 STM as lovely lenses in their own right for extremely little money (a good case can be made for the 50 mm being Canon's sharpest at f/7.1 or f/8) and very little weight. Think about a 17 or 24 mm Tilt-Shift, for Depth of Field from nearby foreground to infinity.

Spend $200 on a good backpack bag and some more on a second (stealthy) "walking around" bag for less arduous expeditions. Don't neglect fully upgraded software for that money too. Dan's suggestion on filters is good too: CPs and a couple of NDs (say 4x/0.6/2-stops and 64x/1.6/6-stops in sizes to cover all lenses). Remote release. High quality pocket computer (with cell phone app and GPS). Extra batteries.



Edited on Oct 06, 2015 at 01:46 PM · View previous versions
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:41 PM
kemo681
Offline
Details
p.2 #7landscape gear
Been using a 40D with a 45mm t/s lens for panoramas. If it is an old barn that has "posted no trespassing" signs everywhere then the 70-200mm comes into play. Also, have a 17-40mm that I picked up used and do use. I do use a tripod with a RRS BH-55 head. Love it.

I like to do multiple row panoramas, which, so far, I can not get Photoshop CS to do so I use PTGui 9.(?) for stitching.

Seen some very interesting stuff shot with a 500mm.

Just my take,
Mike

Edited on Oct 06, 2015 at 01:49 PM · View previous versions
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:41 PM
bradf35
Offline
Details
p.2 #8landscape gear


gdanmitchell wrote:
bradf35 wroteThanks for the replies so far. I have $15K right now, and would like to spend it on equipment plus a trip. I've already made the tripod mistake, and now have a good tripod. Right now I print at 16x20 with my 5Dc. I'd probably print larger from time to time if I could.
A little thought the comes up from time to time...

I often feel that many people who have a sum like that to spend on, say, a "landscape" setup but who are asking very, very general questions (like "what should I get") might not be doing the most effective thing if they go out and spend that money on the basis of what others say.

If you are at a point where having such expensive equipment will make a difference to your work, in most cases you would take a look at how and what you shoot, what you do with the
...Show more →
alundeb wroteWith that budget, you can't really go wrong with either the 5DS R, D810 or A7rII. They have different strengths and weaknesses. Buying into a new system now with that as a base is really a world of great possibilities. It is a so complex and personal decision that I think I will just recommend gathering information from more than one place. Good luck!


Thanks for the replies. I haven't been in a position to be able to justify spending the money until now. I've always just rented nicer equipment when I've had more time to shoot. However, I now have all the time in the world. My biggest problem right now is that I've tried Sony, Nikon, and Canon and am struggling on which way to go. I'm leaning canon at the moment for the 24mm TS-E lens. I tried it out for a week in Charleston, and I loved it. I asked it more general hoping someone would come in and absolutely just love a lens that I hadn't thought about, but I see my mistake.
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:44 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.2 #9landscape gear
Lightroom 6 is not bad with 3-5 panel 5DS panos, but I have for a few years now used Hugin (related to PT-gui) for critical work with panorama stitching. I did a 12 wide x 2 high x 3 (hi-lo-mid) panorama from 72 5D classic shots with Hugin.
Oct 06, 2015 at 01:53 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.2 #10landscape gear
If choosing the cleanest/widest DR in a Canon body is important then the 6D tops all of the current 5Ds. That said the new 5DS and 5DS/R are very close to the 6D; from what I've read the 6D has 11.4 stops of DR while the two new 5Ds top out at about 11.1...at low ISOs.

Of the Canon; non 1D, FF bodies, the 6D has the 'most' sensitive center AF point, it is the lightest weight, has both GPS and WiFi built-in; with remote access available for smartphone/tablet use via WiFi and an App. Negatives for some are it's 11 point AF, a shutter speed that tops out at 1/4000th, somewhat less of a robust body, video that has a bit more morie and lastly it has a combo quick control dial that adds AF point selection instead of the separate thumb button. Also it has no built-in PC Sync port that helps use non-ttl flash.

Note, the 5D2's AF system; center point, is not as sensitive as the 6D, but it's body is a bit tougher and has much the same control layout of your 5D. I has 1/8000th, a PC Sync port, it's viewfinder has 98% coverage vs. the 6D's 97%, also the 5D2's frame rate is a bit slower than the 6D. Lastly, when pushing DR the 5D2/5D3 do have banding in the shadows, whereas the 6D/5DS/5DSR do not...

Other than DR/banding issues and a slowish SD card drive, the 5D3 is a 22mp workhorse, with 6 FPS it can manage most any kind of shooting; the best all around camera in the Canon family; so far. There are many huge pluses with the 5D3, silent shutter like the 6D; well very quiet, it has useable native ISO above 6400 if you need it, something the new 5DS and 5DS/R are limited to. And many, many more excellent features for shooting video; several that are lacking on the 6D and the two new 5DSs.

As for the new 50mp beasts, for landscapes, making large prints it seems the 5DS and 5DS/R have given photographers quite the high-res 'studio' level tool. You not only get the 61pt AF of the 5D3/1DX, but there is a new mirror/box to help dampen vibration even further than with the mirror locked up. For some it's 5 FPS are enough for some action shooting.

Then, as others have mentioned, you've got the FF alternatives with both Nikon and Sony sporting various versions of the Sony EXMOR sensor; 24, 36 and now 42mp with Sony's A7RII monster. From what I've read these have the widest DR, all with 14 stops or more, which is pretty darn impressive.

Personally my budget isn't huge and although an L lens snob of sorts, I tend to like somewhat lighter gear, so a 6D is in my near future Along with a few f4L zooms, 100L macro and a few fast/smallish primes I'm golden. I've found the f4L zooms to be much lighter than their f2.8 big brothers and it's the lighter weight that's most appealing. It is slower glass, doesn't have as smooth bokeh as f2.8 but is acceptable vs. bigger/heavier. Lastly, if budget permitted I'd no doubt grab one of the new 50mp bodies, it would be great to have all that cropability

I've seriously thought on getting one of the Sony bodies; an A7, mainly because I've a large stable of older FD and newer EF/EF-S glass. Being able to use my current lenses and some of Sony's lenses, not to mention most Nikon and other lenses would be wonderful, plus their noted 14 stops of DR; without banding, makes them highly usable. And if you have or are going to get a variety of lenses for different manufactures, personally I don't think you can have a better solution; with adapters available for so many lenses the Sony's just can't be beat IMHO.

As for a kit, I'm moving slowly to lenses with IS because I like to hand-hold for most of my imaging. I'm currently shooting with four lenses for my landscape work, they include a 17-40L, 70-200 f4L IS, 100L IS Macro and a 50 f1.4. If I was 'starting out fresh' I'd go for Canon's trio of f4L IS zooms; 16-35/24-70/70-200, and think on adding the 100-400L if I was shooting more wildlife.

Last,, if you stick with Canon gear, don't forget you can buy a refurbished or used body and lenses. The 6D has recently been at $1100 and the 5D3 at $2200; they are higher at the moment, you just have to keep an eye on the Canon refurb pages You can also get Canon primes and zooms as refurbs, and remember refurb bodies and lenses both come with a 1yr warranty, something you don't usually get when buying new.

Whatever gear you do choose, have fun shooting
Cheers,
Jerry
Oct 06, 2015 at 04:43 PM
Dark Slider
Offline
Details
p.2 #11landscape gear
Monito wrote:
It is often said that you can spend $1700 on a tripod & ballhead by buying mediocre one first and then a good one or spend $1200 by buying a good one in the first place.


1700 bucks is enough only if you limit yourself to one mediocre tripod before buying the good one. Just sayin'.
Oct 06, 2015 at 05:19 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #12landscape gear


alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wroteOn the other hand, the 5D MkII cannot compete in DR with newer sensor-based cameras like the D810 or the A7R/A7R II. Since I find more DR especially useful in landscape photography, I would neither choose the 5D MkII nor the 6D for it at this point.
Can you please explain that to Chez


No need explaining, I understand that. But I've shot over 5 years worth of landscapes with my 5d2 and have printed very large to the satisfaction of many. That my friend is where the rubber hits the road...not on some bench looking at test images blown up to pixel level on a monitor.

Now if your goal is test images...you might have a point.
Oct 06, 2015 at 06:30 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #13landscape gear
bradf35 wrote:
My biggest problem right now is that I've tried Sony, Nikon, and Canon and am struggling on which way to go. I'm leaning canon at the moment for the 24mm TS-E lens. I tried it out for a week in Charleston, and I loved it. I asked it more general hoping someone would come in and absolutely just love a lens that I hadn't thought about, but I see my mistake.


I'll make a little brand generalization. (Note: generalization) If you are already familiar with one of the major brands that you mentioned and you are on the fence... in most cases it probably makes the most sense to simply stick with the brand you are currently using — whether that is currently Sony, Canon, or Nikon.

If you are a serious landscape photographer who is looking for a new state-of-the art full frame digital camera, you'll likely go with Sony A7rII, Nikon D810, or Canon 5Ds/5DsR. All of them are used by folks who are extremely serious about this, and all of them can produce excellent work. In the end, aside from functional preferences you might have, I wouldn't sweat the differences all that much. In your case, unless you have a very strong reason to switch, I'd just stick with the brand you are using. (I'd give — and have given — the same advice to users of all three brands.)

Dan
Oct 06, 2015 at 07:55 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.2 #14landscape gear
Just a quick thought, Brad, you might want to start another topic, cross-post it here in the Canon forum as well as the Sony forum and ask for images using the 24 TS-E v1 and v2 lenses. You might ask for a few RAW samples; or download RAWs from the web, to make IQ comparisons.

You can also look through, search, the EXIF Gallery here on FM, it's a menu option at the top of each FM page

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/exifgallery.php

Cheers,
Jerry
Oct 06, 2015 at 08:18 PM
RobDickinson
Offline
Details
p.2 #15landscape gear
I would probably pick 5dsr, 16-35f4L, 24tse, sigma 50 art ( or schnieder 50 ts)

I am used to working round the limited dynamic range and I like canon lenses and handling.
Oct 06, 2015 at 08:22 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #16landscape gear
chez wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wroteOn the other hand, the 5D MkII cannot compete in DR with newer sensor-based cameras like the D810 or the A7R/A7R II. Since I find more DR especially useful in landscape photography, I would neither choose the 5D MkII nor the 6D for it at this point.
Can you please explain that to Chez
No need explaining, I understand that. But I've shot over 5 years worth of landscapes with my 5d2 and have printed very large to the satisfaction of many. That my friend is where the rubber hits the road...not on some bench looking at test images blown up to pixel level on a monitor.

Now if your goal is test images...you might have a point.


So what was the point of your countless posts like these:

"When the dynamic range of the scene exceeds the sensors abilities, I don't care how you expose the scene, you'll either get blown highlights or dark muddy shadows. The more capable the sensor, the more you can salvage the blown highlights or the muddy shadows. Proper exposure has squat to do with the sensors dynamic range abilities."
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1247661/81&year=2013#11988683

"I just pointed out the 5d3 has some short comings of it's own if you compare it to the 6d, namely the low iso dynamic range ."
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1310255/2&year=2014#12504337

"The information I'm trying to provide here is that the Sony A7R is a great option for your landscapes as it does get you more DR and it does allow you to still use all your Canon lenses"
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1355280/21#12941355

"Comes into play with cityscapes as well were there are many occasions of dark alleys and bright sunlit buildings. Also internal residential photography require a high dynamic range to handle bright window light coming into a darker inside room."
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1379418/5#13136546

Also, hasn't Canon cut off the high ISO abilities of the camera to get the gains in the low iso? Seems to me they were heading in the high ISO arena with the 6d...now they've abandoned that direction to focus on low iso DR.
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380998/1#13154765
Oct 06, 2015 at 11:51 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #17landscape gear

alundeb wrote:
chez wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wroteOn the other hand, the 5D MkII cannot compete in DR with newer sensor-based cameras like the D810 or the A7R/A7R II. Since I find more DR especially useful in landscape photography, I would neither choose the 5D MkII nor the 6D for it at this point.
Can you please explain that to Chez
No need explaining, I understand that. But I've shot over 5 years worth of landscapes with my 5d2 and have printed very large to the satisfaction of many. That my friend is where the rubber hits the road...not on some bench looking at test images blown up to pixel level on a monitor.

Now if your goal is test images...you might have a point.
So what was the point of your countless posts like these:

"When the dynamic range of the scene exceeds the sensors abilities, I don't care how you expose the scene, you'll either get blown highlights or dark muddy shadows. The more capable the sensor, the more you can salvage the blown highlights or the muddy shadows. Proper exposure has squat to do with the sensors dynamic range abilities."
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1247661/81&year=2013#11988683

"I just pointed out the 5d3 has some short comings of it's own if you compare it to the 6d, namely the low iso dynamic range ."
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1310255/2&year=2014#12504337

"The information I'm trying to provide here is
...Show more →

Yes, I welcome more dynamic range as it simplifies my workflow...but that does not mean I did not produce some amazing prints from the 5d2. It just required a more complex workflow involving GND filters and/or merging multiple exposed images. The end result with the 5d2 still was great...it only involved a more complex and tedious workflow.
Bottom line, if you cannot make great landscapes with a 6d or 5d2...then it's time for some photography classes as those cameras are very capable of delivering outstanding landscape prints.
I updated to a higher pixel camera to allow for larger prints. The extra dynamic range of the Sony sensor was a welcome addition as was the ease of manual focus.
Now what was the point of your post again?
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:20 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #18landscape gear
chez wrote:
Now what was the point of your post again?


If I was to buy a landscape camera from scratch now, and bought the 5DII in good beleief that it has excellent dynamic range for landsacape after advice from you and dhphoto, and later discover that it is more limited than any of the other cameras under consideration, and that you in fact have rcommended other cameras in other threads for exactly the dynamic range, and that dhphoto knew that you can't push shadows more that 1 stop with the 5DII, I would be pissed.
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:42 AM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.2 #19landscape gear
bradf35 wrote:
I'm leaning canon at the moment for the 24mm TS-E lens. I tried it out for a week in Charleston, and I loved it. I asked it more general hoping someone would come in and absolutely just love a lens that I hadn't thought about, but I see my mistake.


I regard that lens (the Mk II version) as my most important for landscapes, but it has some weaknesses and I could not manage with it as my only 24mm:

1. It has a problem with flare resistance.
2. Not only is it (very obviously) not weather sealed, but the knobs and controls that stick out make it very inconvenient in the field when you need to get it quickly in and out of a case in bad weather.

I do use the lens for landscape photography when hiking, but if I think those things will be a problem I take either the 16-35mm f/2.8 Mk II or the 24-70 f/4 IS instead. The 24-70 in particular I find ideal as a bad weather lens, or as my only lens if I need to travel quickly without much weight.

I’m not suggesting you don’t get the 24 TS-E Mk II. You have the budget, and it is a wonderful lens. I’m suggesting you get another lens, probably a zoom, that duplicates that focal length, which sounds like it’s a favourite of yours.

Choice of focal length is personal, but for me 24/50/100/180 is a good set. Because I’m also interested in botany, I often carry one of the longer focal lengths as a macro lens. If I know those subjects won’t be around, I take the 70-200mm f/4 IS.

Some suggestions for lens kits which include only lenses which most people consider excellent:

1. 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; 24-70mm f/4 IS; 70-200mm f/4 IS.
2. 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; Zeiss 50mm f/2 Makro Planar Milvus; Zeiss 100mm f/2 Makro Planar Milvus.
3. 16-35mm f/4 IS; 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; 70-200mm f/4 IS.
4. Zeiss 21mm f/2.8 Milvus; Zeiss 50mm f/2 MP Milvus; Zeiss 100mm f.2 MP Milvus.

Although I haven’t used the Milvus versions of the Zeiss (I have one of the earlier ZE models), I’m suggesting those because they’re weather sealed - although they are substantially heavier than the old models.

You didn’t say whether you’d be able to carry a tripod. I’m not a large guy and I find I’m unable to on an overnight hike. I have no trouble hand holding the tilt-shift lens for shifting, but tilt is another thing. However, I find I very rarely use the tilt. Think about having a zoom with IS available at 24mm for this situation.

As for the body, I’m just finishing up processing my photos from a couple of hikes in Central Australia. Both days, more so the second, when it was overcast, were pretty difficult with respect to dynamic range, but my Canon 1Ds Mk III coped (the multispot meter and a lot of experience shooting in the desert helped). I only HDR bracketed one shot, and it turned out I didn’t need to use the second frame in post. I did need to do some fairly advanced Photoshop work on the raws. The poorer dynamic range of Canon compared to Sony is real (I have a full-frame Sony Exmor, so I know), but is mainly a problem for certain styles of landscape photography - lurid sunsets maybe being one of them. I think online commentary has become distorted by the fashion for that style in gear forums. If that’s what you shoot a lot of, and you’re not a whizz in Photoshop, you do need to consider Canon’s dynamic range.

But also think about the fact that I flew from Melbourne to Central Australia, hired a 4WD, and took neither charger nor spare batteries, because I knew I wouldn’t need them. And my shooting included some long exposure tripod work within the 400 or so shots I took.
Oct 07, 2015 at 02:43 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #20landscape gear
I just have to say that the majority (by far) of the established landscape photographers I know who use full frame digital cameras for their work... are almost exclusively using zoom lenses these days.

One friend who has moved along a trajectory from LF BW film to LF color film to scanned LF color film to digital MF now also uses a full frame DSLR for a portion of his work. Because of his particular background and connection to a very famous and iconic American landscape photographer from a few decades ago, he often gives well-attended public talks to large groups of folks who know him and his work, and for the former reason a number of the attendees presume that he works in the old ways. He loves to tweak them by waiting for the inevitable "film versus digital" (classic versus modern) question and then answering more or less as follows: "Today I shoot entirely digital. And with a zoom lens!" ;-)

Notice that I wrote "almost exclusively." I do have some friends who are using adapted MF lenses and tilt/shift adapters for some work. Oh, wait, they are using MF zoom lenses! ;-)
Oct 07, 2015 at 07:09 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister