bradf35 wrote:
I'm leaning canon at the moment for the 24mm TS-E lens. I tried it out for a week in Charleston, and I loved it. I asked it more general hoping someone would come in and absolutely just love a lens that I hadn't thought about, but I see my mistake.
I regard that lens (the Mk II version) as my most important for landscapes, but it has some weaknesses and I could not manage with it as my only 24mm:
1. It has a problem with flare resistance.
2. Not only is it (very obviously) not weather sealed, but the knobs and controls that stick out make it very inconvenient in the field when you need to get it quickly in and out of a case in bad weather.
I do use the lens for landscape photography when hiking, but if I think those things will be a problem I take either the 16-35mm f/2.8 Mk II or the 24-70 f/4 IS instead. The 24-70 in particular I find ideal as a bad weather lens, or as my only lens if I need to travel quickly without much weight.
I’m not suggesting you don’t get the 24 TS-E Mk II. You have the budget, and it is a wonderful lens. I’m suggesting you get another lens, probably a zoom, that duplicates that focal length, which sounds like it’s a favourite of yours.
Choice of focal length is personal, but for me 24/50/100/180 is a good set. Because I’m also interested in botany, I often carry one of the longer focal lengths as a macro lens. If I know those subjects won’t be around, I take the 70-200mm f/4 IS.
Some suggestions for lens kits which include only lenses which most people consider excellent:
1. 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; 24-70mm f/4 IS; 70-200mm f/4 IS.
2. 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; Zeiss 50mm f/2 Makro Planar Milvus; Zeiss 100mm f/2 Makro Planar Milvus.
3. 16-35mm f/4 IS; 24mm f/3.5 TS-E Mk II; 70-200mm f/4 IS.
4. Zeiss 21mm f/2.8 Milvus; Zeiss 50mm f/2 MP Milvus; Zeiss 100mm f.2 MP Milvus.
Although I haven’t used the Milvus versions of the Zeiss (I have one of the earlier ZE models), I’m suggesting those because they’re weather sealed - although they are substantially heavier than the old models.
You didn’t say whether you’d be able to carry a tripod. I’m not a large guy and I find I’m unable to on an overnight hike. I have no trouble hand holding the tilt-shift lens for shifting, but tilt is another thing. However, I find I very rarely use the tilt. Think about having a zoom with IS available at 24mm for this situation.
As for the body, I’m just finishing up processing my photos from a couple of hikes in Central Australia. Both days, more so the second, when it was overcast, were pretty difficult with respect to dynamic range, but my Canon 1Ds Mk III coped (the multispot meter and a lot of experience shooting in the desert helped). I only HDR bracketed one shot, and it turned out I didn’t need to use the second frame in post. I did need to do some fairly advanced Photoshop work on the raws. The poorer dynamic range of Canon compared to Sony is real (I have a full-frame Sony Exmor, so I know), but is mainly a problem for certain styles of landscape photography - lurid sunsets maybe being one of them. I think online commentary has become distorted by the fashion for that style in gear forums. If that’s what you shoot a lot of, and you’re not a whizz in Photoshop, you do need to consider Canon’s dynamic range.
But also think about the fact that I flew from Melbourne to Central Australia, hired a 4WD, and took neither charger nor spare batteries, because I knew I wouldn’t need them. And my shooting included some long exposure tripod work within the 400 or so shots I took.