fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015landscape gear

  
 
RobDickinson
Offline
Details
p.3 #1landscape gear
gdanmitchell wrote:
I just have to say that the majority (by far) of the established landscape photographers I know who use full frame digital cameras for their work... are almost exclusively using zoom lenses these days.


From those I know I would say almost all of them are using primes. Most people I know are also shooting panoramics a lot too and primes are much better there.

I myself have a mix, typically shooting a 16-35, 14/2.8, 24tsemk2, 50/1.4 and 70-200. Tho I have other primes too I only have 2 zooms.

The 24tse got a lot more use when I had the 17-40L, the 16-35 changed that
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:33 PM
rw11
Offline
Details
p.3 #2landscape gear
the OP (and others) can rent a super quality prime and test it vs. whatever they now use

Oct 07, 2015 at 12:34 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #3landscape gear
RobDickinson wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteI just have to say that the majority (by far) of the established landscape photographers I know who use full frame digital cameras for their work... are almost exclusively using zoom lenses these days.
From those I know I would say almost all of them are using primes. Most people I know are also shooting panoramics a lot too and primes are much better there.

I myself have a mix, typically shooting a 16-35, 14/2.8, 24tsemk2, 50/1.4 and 70-200. Tho I have other primes too I only have 2 zooms.

The 24tse got a lot more use when I had the 17-40L, the 16-35 changed that


Hmmm...

I'm going down my little list of "California landscape photographers" who shoot full frame and cropped sensor DSLRs. I'm coming up with...

1 who likes to use alt primes on one of two mirrorless bodies

1 who uses one 24mm prime for certain kinds of night photography

and, hmmm, that's it

I'm thinking of 3 who sometimes use MF zooms on tilt/shift adapters on full frame digital cameras

Then all the others use zooms almost exclusively for this kind of work.

These are mostly all folks whose names and work you would likely recognize if you know the folks from this part of the world.

My own prime experience is, briefly...

I used to use more primes than zooms when I did landscape, but as zooms continued to improve I found no IQ advantage, even in very large prints, for this kind of work and I gradually just stopped using the primes. I sold all of them except for two — I still have a 24mm f/1.4L II (for sale) and a 50mm f/1.4 that I keep, perhaps out of habit.

On the other hand, I also use a small mirrorless camera for street and night street and travel photography... and I almost always use primes on that. Go figure.

I do know some folks who like to occasionally use a tilt/shift lens, but those I know have universally moved to adapted MF zooms on a tilt/shift adapter.

YMMV,

Dan
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:45 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #4landscape gear


RobDickinson wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteI just have to say that the majority (by far) of the established landscape photographers I know who use full frame digital cameras for their work... are almost exclusively using zoom lenses these days.
From those I know I would say almost all of them are using primes. Most people I know are also shooting panoramics a lot too and primes are much better there.

I myself have a mix, typically shooting a 16-35, 14/2.8, 24tsemk2, 50/1.4 and 70-200. Tho I have other primes too I only have 2 zooms.

The 24tse got a lot more use when I had the 17-40L, the 16-35 changed that


Most of the landscape photographers I go out with also predominately use primes. I typically carry the 16-35 zoom and my trio of Zeiss primes 21,35,100.
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:45 PM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.3 #5landscape gear
It probably depends on your budget and what you want to carry. Honestly, I rarely shoot landscapes much wider than 24mm. But I know others that shoot 11mm. If I were going on a once in a lifetime shooting trip, my gear would be:

17mm TSE
24mm TSE
16-35 f4 IS
24-70mm 2.8 II
70-200 f4 IS
1.4x

If I was going on a trip were I may want to shoot some wildlife too (e.g. Iceland), I'd probably do a 100-400 II instead of the 70-200.

I'd take a 5ds R and a sony a7r with the metabones.

Chris
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:47 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #6landscape gear
bradf35 wrote:
If you were starting over today, what landscape gear would you buy?


If we're talking strictly landscapes, I would probably go for a Pentax 645Z kit. For your budget, you could pick up a body and one or two lenses. It would give you more resolution and DR than any of the small-format systems.
Oct 07, 2015 at 02:09 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.3 #8landscape gear
gdanmitchell wrote:
alundeb wrote
dhphoto wroteThe 5D2 has perfectly good dynamic range for anything, unless you want to manipulate the file a lot
Nope, banding can show up, even in downrezzed images, after even slight manipulation like lifting shadows 1 - 2 stops. I know you will dispute that, but my data point is as valid as yours and I am not alone. I do not have a bad copy of the 5DII.
See my example above. There is the potential for banding in 5DII files, but it is often grossly overstated, for reasons that still elude me.

Dan



the 6D and 5Dii hover around the same price. The 6D has considerable improvements for landscapes, and is easily the more preferable camera. 5Dii is simply no longer a good recommendation for landscapes since it's similarly priced to the 6D.

It does landscapes fine, and does the 5Dc, but if you're deciding between the 6D and 5Dii for landscapes, it's really not even debatable. The 6D is head and shoulders better.
Oct 07, 2015 at 02:57 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #9landscape gear
molson wrote:
bradf35 wroteIf you were starting over today, what landscape gear would you buy?
If we're talking strictly landscapes, I would probably go for a Pentax 645Z kit. For your budget, you could pick up a body and one or two lenses. It would give you more resolution and DR than any of the small-format systems.


That is a beautiful system. Although the number of photo sites is the same, the potential system resolution is high by a bit.

I thought about moving to the Pentax "mini MF" system, but in the end I decided that the quality from current high end full frame DSLRs is so good (in fact, I know MF digital shooters who are switching to them), that I didn't want to build an entirely new lens collection, and that long lenses are problematic — so I stuck with FF.

YMMV,

Dan
Oct 07, 2015 at 04:40 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #10landscape gear
dhphoto wrote:
The 5D2 has perfectly good dynamic range for anything, unless you want to manipulate the file a lot

alundeb wrote:
Nope, banding can show up, even in downrezzed images, after even slight manipulation like lifting shadows 1 - 2 stops. I know you will dispute that, but my data point is as valid as yours and I am not alone. I do not have a bad copy of the 5DII.

gdanmitchell wrote:
See my example above. There is the potential for banding in 5DII files, but it is often grossly overstated, for reasons that still elude me.

Dan

Charlie N wrote:
the 6D and 5Dii hover around the same price. The 6D has considerable improvements for landscapes, and is easily the more preferable camera. 5Dii is simply no longer a good recommendation for landscapes since it's similarly priced to the 6D.

It does landscapes fine, and does the 5Dc, but if you're deciding between the 6D and 5Dii for landscapes, it's really not even debatable. The 6D is head and shoulders better.


Which is why I earlier wrote in this thread...

gdanmitchell wrote:
I think that the 6D is a better value for most folks looking for a new camera with a sensor of this type today. A 5DII could be a good option used at the right price for some folks.

Dan


;-)
Oct 07, 2015 at 04:42 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.3 #11landscape gear
gdanmitchell wrote:
I do know some folks who like to occasionally use a tilt/shift lens, but those I know have universally moved to adapted MF zooms on a tilt/shift adapter.


That loses them auto aperture. I assume they're shooting from a tripod.

Then all the others use zooms almost exclusively for this kind of work.

These are mostly all folks whose names and work you would likely recognize if you know the folks from this part of the world.


Your experiences sound like they're deep but narrow. As soon as one gets away from pure, traditional, tripod-bound, landscape shooting one starts to want specialised lenses which are either not available as zooms or when in zoom form unsatisfactory in some way such as weight or lens speed.

For example, I took a 1kg macro lens with me to Central Australia in order to shoot insects and flowers. I was not also going to hike with my 70-200mm f/4 IS, and I couldn't have fitted it in my carry-on allowance anyway. (I did actually have a 70-200 macro zoom for my film kit, but Canon don't do one.)

If I liked 15mm much as a focal length for landscape, which I don't, I'd be seriously thinking about the Zeiss ZE instead of Canon's 11-24 zoom, because it's 30% lighter and 10% cheaper.

If I were shooting for someone else to postprocess, which I don't, and I wanted one of the Zeiss Milvuses (for example, the 100 as a macro lens) I'd be seriously considering using an all-Milvus set for foolproof colour consistency.

Until very recently, I didn't have a lens suitable for wildlife other than a fixed focal length 300mm on a teleconverter. So if I were also planning to shoot wildlife I'd take that, and if I wanted a landscape shot at longer than 70mm worked within the limitations of 300mm or 420mm.

You can say cropping from a superwide zoom on a high resolution camera can substitute for a 24mm shift lens. Maybe. I haven't done the calculations, because I know it wouldn't be the way I like to work. You also have to buy and carry that superwide. Only if you don't work with a 24-70 zoom does that make sense.

Back to the OP's original question, and what would I buy if starting again with Canon for landscape and only that. It would be option 1 of the four I gave in my earlier answer (24 TS-E, 24-70 f/4 IS, 70-200 f/4 IS). But he also asked whether there were other "hero" lenses he hadn't heard about, and I tried to name some and show how they would fit into a lens kit.
Oct 08, 2015 at 03:08 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.3 #12landscape gear
There are some small and inexpensive prime lenses with unusually high value for landscape shooting, if for some reason a lens kit for a special occasion has a gap in the 35-70 mm focal length range, like if you want to carry a 16-35mm and a 70-200 mm.

The Canon 50 mm f/1.8 STM has exceptional sharpness across the frame stopped down to f/4 or more. It has zero chromatic aberrations and higher contrast than the previous Canon 50mm f/1.8 II.

The Canon 40 mm f/2.8 STM pancake needs to be stopped down to f/8 for maximal sharpness across the frame, and is then very little behind the 50 STM.

The Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 58 mm f/1.4 SL is also exceptional stopped down. It is a little bit heavier (270g) than the others, and is manual focus and aperture. It will have to be used with an adapter for Nikon mount.
Oct 08, 2015 at 04:50 AM
trajtemberg
Offline
Details
p.3 #13landscape gear
Search for user Samuli Vahonen to see what he has done with a 5D2.

Imho a 6D would sufice. Spend the time, research and money on lenses and travel.
Oct 08, 2015 at 04:53 AM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #14landscape gear
trajtemberg wrote:
Search for user Samuli Vahonen to see what he has done with a 5D2.

Imho a 6D would sufice. Spend the time, research and money on lenses and travel.


A couple of years back the 5D2 was getting pilloried here, then the winners of that years' Reuters Photographer of the Year came out and about 80% of the pics were taken with the 5D2. Fantastic images all.

There is NOTHING wrong with the 5D2, if you know how to use it.
Oct 08, 2015 at 05:04 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.3 #15landscape gear
Nothing wrong with a 40D either. I have seen some stunning work made with it. Much cheaper than the 5DII and no banding in the shadows.
Oct 08, 2015 at 05:24 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #16landscape gear
melcat wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteI do know some folks who like to occasionally use a tilt/shift lens, but those I know have universally moved to adapted MF zooms on a tilt/shift adapter.
That loses them auto aperture. I assume they're shooting from a tripod.


Then all the others use zooms almost exclusively for this kind of work.

These are mostly all folks whose names and work you would likely recognize if you know the folks from this part of the world.


Your experiences sound like they're deep but narrow. As soon as one gets away from pure, traditional, tripod-bound, landscape shooting one starts to want specialised lenses which are either not available as zooms or when in zoom form unsatisfactory in some way such as weight or lens speed.

That's pretty ironic, given the range of subjects I photograph. Doubly ironic is the fact that for some of those other genres I prefer primes. Just not for landscape photography any more. ;-)

On the other hand, since the subject of this thread is "landscape" photography, a "deep (and narrow?)" focus on issues related to that particular genre seems appropriate in this post.

Or, as you noted: "Back to the OP's original question, and what would I buy if starting again with Canon for landscape and only that." (Emphasis added)

Finally, I'm not speculating about what I might or would do. I'm simply reporting what I (and some other well-regarded landscape photographers I know) actually do — the specific kinds of equipment that are used to make a very high percentage to the "landscape" photography that perhaps some folks here are interested in creating.

I can't say (and am not saying) that no one uses the brands, models, and types of lenses you lust for when doing landscape. (Nor that everyone does or should use the gear the I use.) But I can say with certainty that the use of such equipment is relatively rare (or, in some cases, highly specialized) by comparison to the use of more prosaic gear like zoom lenses.

You can say cropping from a superwide zoom on a high resolution camera can substitute for a 24mm shift lens.

What? I didn't write that.

As always, YMMV,

Dan

Edited on Oct 08, 2015 at 01:21 PM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2015 at 06:59 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #17landscape gear
alundeb wrote:
Nothing wrong with a 40D either. I have seen some stunning work made with it. Much cheaper than the 5DII and no banding in the shadows.


In all of the thousands of images I made with a 5D Mark II, I never once ran across a situation where banding in the shadows was discernible. The only camera so far where shadow banding caused problems in an image was my Sony A7R.
Oct 08, 2015 at 10:48 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #18landscape gear
molson wrote:
alundeb wroteNothing wrong with a 40D either. I have seen some stunning work made with it. Much cheaper than the 5DII and no banding in the shadows.
In all of the thousands of images I made with a 5D Mark II, I never once ran across a situation where banding in the shadows was discernible. The only camera so far where shadow banding caused problems in an image was my Sony A7R.


I can recall exactly two in which banding was remotely a concern in the final image. (I've written before that if I went looking for it at 100% magnification, I could sometimes find it.)

One was a photograph of a very dark subject that was largely monochromatic, in this case in the green channel. The other was an scene with an exceptionally large dynamic range, and a scene that was not easily adaptable to exposure bracketing.

In the first case, I only discovered the issue in post, where I resolved it to the point of invisibility with some basic techniques. In the second case, I did make some attempt at bracketing, but in the end I decided to see what I could do with a single exposure. There was s small area of slightly visible noise banding where the image was nearly completely black but where I had pushed the exposure back up to try to get back just a hint of detail. A combination of NR and adding a tiny bit of noise in post to just that area resolved it, and the print looked great.

That's it. Two photographs. Both solved using basic post processing techniques.

Not that everyone will believe me... ;-)

Dan
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:25 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.3 #19landscape gear
Maybe I'm just extra sensitive to that banding thing. I remember in a discussion some years back, I linked to a flower image with green OOF area, where the banding was easily visible in the web sized image, in most of the image area. It didn't seem to have been heavily processed. Other people said that the banding didn't exactly jump out at them, but after I mentioned it, they could see it too.

I routinely have to run horizontal and vertical debanding tool on 5DII files with even normal processing and contrast enhancement, not even heavy shadow lifting. And I don't have a bad copy. It was tested with a common method to determine the fixed pattern noise and behaved like every other 5DII.
Oct 08, 2015 at 01:39 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #20landscape gear
alundeb wrote:
Maybe I'm just extra sensitive to that banding thing. I remember in a discussion some years back, I linked to a flower image with green OOF area, where the banding was easily visible in the web sized image, in most of the image area. It didn't seem to have been heavily processed. Other people said that the banding didn't exactly jump out at them, but after I mentioned it, they could see it too.

I routinely have to run horizontal and vertical debanding tool on 5DII files with even normal processing and contrast enhancement, not even heavy shadow lifting. And I
...Show more →

I too have come across banding issues with the 5d2...mostly shooting sunset images where some foreground object is in dark shadows. The banding appears when I try to retrieve just the slightest details in those shadows. I don't try to correct these images...either they are ok to print with featureless shadows or they end up in the culling bin.
Oct 08, 2015 at 07:17 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister